Chapter 1 of All the Colors of the Dark introduces us to Patch, a thirteen-year-old boy living in the quiet town of Monta Clare, nestled in the shadow of the St. Francois Mountains. From the flat roof of his kitchen, Patch gazes out at the expansive oak and pine trees, dreaming of a life beyond the Ozark Plateau. He envisions a brighter world, filled with opportunities and treasures, believing that something greater awaits him just outside his reach. His vivid imagination drives him to dream of a future where his life is full of adventure, far removed from the limited horizons of his small-town existence. This youthful idealism stands in stark contrast to the reality of his life, creating a tension that runs throughout the chapter.

The narrative soon takes a turn, shifting from Patch’s innocent daydreams to a moment of foreboding tragedy. He envisions this day as one that will remain etched in his memory, a beautiful day that will one day serve as a cherished recollection, even though he cannot anticipate the disaster that will soon unfold. After returning to his bedroom, Patch dresses up in elaborate attire, choosing a tricorne and waistcoat, transforming his navy slacks into makeshift breeches. With a small dagger tucked at his side, he immerses himself in his pirate fantasy world, a refuge from his everyday struggles. His imagination serves as a sanctuary from the harshness of his life, which is shaped by his unique circumstances, including the challenges he faces from being born with only one eye.

In Patch’s bedroom, details of his life emerge, offering a deeper understanding of his character. A black flag is used to cover a hole in the drywall, and the closet stands bare, missing doors, reflecting the neglected, yet adventurous nature of his existence. His room is filled with relics of his imagination—treasures from pirate stories, like a treasure chest and movie props, that connect him to the world he wishes to inhabit. Later, a police investigation into the events surrounding Patch reveals the significance of these items, showing how his love for fantasy and his peculiar possessions provide a window into his desires for a different life. These objects, representing both escape and neglect, hint at the gap between Patch’s fantasies and his reality, a gap that will be further explored as the story progresses.

Patch’s fondness for eye patches, particularly one made of purple satin by his mother, symbolizes his longing for acceptance and his desire to be part of something bigger than himself. He reflects on his mother’s struggles, noting the sun-damaged skin that tells of her exhausting night shifts. Their relationship is filled with warmth despite their hardships, and Patch appreciates the laughter they share, even in the face of adversity. His mother’s influence on him is undeniable, and through their moments together, the deep bond between them is revealed, showing the love that persists despite their difficult circumstances. This relationship is central to Patch’s development, providing both comfort and a sense of connection to the world he desperately wants to be part of.

The chapter concludes with Patch expressing his unwavering optimism, declaring that today will be the best day of his life. His hopeful attitude contrasts sharply with the darker reality that is about to unfold, hinting at the tragedy that looms on the horizon. Patch’s naivety makes this moment all the more poignant, as he remains unaware of the events that will soon disrupt his world. His belief in the possibility of a better future, despite the circumstances he faces, adds an emotional depth to his character. This optimism, which sustains him in the face of adversity, serves as both a strength and a vulnerability, foreshadowing the challenges he will face as his story unfolds. The chapter leaves readers anticipating the eventual collision between Patch’s idealistic dreams and the harsh realities that lie ahead, setting the stage for the chaos and emotional turmoil that will shape his journey.