Oathbringer
65. Verdict
by Sanderson, BrandonIn this chapter, Dalinar navigates a tense diplomatic encounter outside the Azish control building near the Oathgate in Azimir. Frustrated by the restrictions and rules of the place, he reflects on his dislike for the bureaucracy and the complexities of the political landscape. The scene opens with Dalinar approaching a guarded room, where Azish soldiers and officials, including viziers and ardents, prepare to engage with him. His goal is to forge alliances or at least secure a meeting with the emperor, using subtle tactics rather than force, as he recognizes the importance of diplomacy in this high-stakes environment.
Dalinar’s approach involves strategic use of language and cultural understanding. He presents written messages in Azish, which initially shock the officials, hinting at his effort to communicate beyond mere words. Using Stormlight and a connection of Spiritual Adhesion, Dalinar manages to subtly understand and speak the Azish language, demonstrating his adaptability and determination. His interactions with the soldiers, especially the young guard, reveal his skill in building rapport even in hostile settings, aiming to gather intelligence and influence the outcome of the negotiations.
The core of the chapter revolves around Dalinar’s diplomatic strategy, which hinges on presenting a compelling argument through written communication. He offers an essay from Queen Fen advocating for the economic benefits of the Oathgates, emphasizing trade and political alliances. This move signifies his shift from traditional warfare to a more nuanced approach, leveraging written diplomacy to achieve his objectives. The Azish officials’ reactions highlight the importance of cultural respect and intellectual persuasion in their political dealings, contrasting with Dalinar’s usual martial approach.
In the final moments, Dalinar introduces additional documents, including a treatise from Navani, signaling his preparedness to negotiate on multiple fronts. His willingness to adapt and employ written diplomacy reflects his broader strategy to secure alliances and influence in Azir. The chapter ends with the officials huddling to consider his proposals, illustrating the delicate balance of power, trust, and negotiation that Dalinar must master to realize his vision. This scene underscores the importance of intelligence, cultural sensitivity, and strategic communication in his efforts to unify and strengthen his position.
FAQs
1. Question 1
What strategic approach does Dalinar employ during his interactions with the Azish officials, and how does this reflect his understanding of diplomacy in unfamiliar cultural contexts?
Answer:
Dalinar adopts a non-violent, respectful approach, emphasizing openness and intelligence rather than force. He arrives unarmed, presents written documents, and demonstrates a willingness to understand their language and customs. His use of a physical connection through Stormlight to understand Azish speech exemplifies his adaptive strategy. This approach reflects his recognition that diplomacy often requires patience, cultural sensitivity, and clever use of non-combative tools—like written arguments and language—especially when dealing with unfamiliar societies. Dalinar’s tactics show his understanding that building trust and alliances in foreign contexts hinges on respect, communication, and strategic non-aggression.2. Question 2
How does Dalinar’s perception of the Azish ardents and viziers differ from his previous understanding of religious figures, and what does this reveal about political power structures in Azir?
Answer:
Dalinar initially perceives the ardents as primarily religious figures, but he quickly recognizes that they are deeply involved in the political government, with viziers and scions playing significant roles. Unlike Alethi ardents, who are more religiously oriented, the Azish ardents here are engaged in state affairs, indicating a blending of religious authority with political power. This suggests that in Azir, religious figures are also political actors, wielding influence through their involvement in governance rather than solely spiritual matters. Dalinar’s realization reveals a complex power structure where religion and politics are intertwined, and understanding this dynamic is crucial for diplomatic success.3. Question 3
What does Dalinar’s use of a written essay from Queen Fen and subsequent documents reveal about his strategy for establishing alliances with Azir?
Answer:
Dalinar’s reliance on written documents, especially the essay from Queen Fen, indicates a strategic shift from direct confrontation to diplomatic negotiation. By presenting well-crafted arguments about the economic benefits of the Oathgates and proposing trade deals, Dalinar aims to persuade Azir through diplomacy and rational discourse rather than force. This approach demonstrates his understanding that alliances can be built on mutual interest, especially economic, and that formal communication can serve as a powerful tool in establishing trust and cooperation. It also shows his adaptability in using written word as a weapon—an intellectual weapon—to complement his military strength.4. Question 4
In what ways does Dalinar’s interaction with the Stormfather during the language barrier highlight the challenges and possibilities of communication through spiritual or supernatural means?
Answer:
Dalinar’s attempt to understand Azish language with the Stormfather’s help underscores both the difficulty and potential of supernatural aid in communication. While the Stormfather admits that Dalinar is capable of making connections and understanding through spiritual adhesion, it emphasizes that the initiative and effort originate from Dalinar himself. This interaction illustrates that supernatural means can bridge gaps in understanding, but they require the user’s intent and skill. It highlights the possibility of overcoming language barriers with spiritual tools, yet also acknowledges the limitations—such as the need for personal effort and the importance of context—making it a nuanced form of communication.5. Question 5
Critically evaluate Dalinar’s decision to use a written essay as a weapon in diplomacy instead of traditional military or forceful tactics. What are the potential advantages and risks of this approach?
Answer:
Dalinar’s choice to employ a written essay as a diplomatic tool offers several advantages: it allows him to present a well-reasoned, non-threatening case for alliance, appealing to rationality and shared economic interests. This method can foster trust and demonstrate respect for Azir’s sovereignty, potentially leading to longer-lasting alliances. However, the risks include misinterpretation or rejection of the written argument if the Azish officials are skeptical or distrustful of foreign motives. It also assumes that the Azish value diplomacy and rational discourse over force, which may not always be the case. While non-violent, this approach requires patience and the ability to follow up effectively—if the diplomatic effort fails, Dalinar might need to revert to more aggressive tactics or face diplomatic setbacks.
Quotes
1. “Now that we abandon the tower, can I finally admit that I hate this place? Too many rules.”
This quote, spoken by Amethyst, encapsulates a sense of frustration and longing for freedom, setting a tone of rebellion against restrictive authority that resonates through the chapter.
2. “I’ve spoken new languages in the visions. You can make me speak Azish.”
This statement highlights Dalinar’s unique connection to the Stormfather and hints at his growing ability to bridge language and understanding, which becomes a key element in diplomatic negotiations and insight into Azish culture.
3. “You insist on thinking of them as ardents, because they can read, both male and female. But he was no longer in Alethkar.”
This remark underscores the cultural differences in Azir, where religious figures hold more political power and have a different role than in Alethkar, illustrating the chapter’s exploration of political and religious dynamics.
4. “Instead, he had brought a different kind of weapon. An essay.”
This line emphasizes Dalinar’s strategic approach to diplomacy—using words, reason, and written arguments as tools of influence rather than violence, marking a shift in his methods of negotiation.
5. “Fen argued that Dalinar’s desperation to forge an alliance made for the perfect opportunity to secure beneficial and lasting trade deals through Urithiru.”
This quote encapsulates the core argument of Queen Fen’s diplomatic strategy, highlighting the importance of trade and political alliances as vital to Dalinar’s broader goals, and reflects the chapter’s focus on diplomacy over conflict.
Quotes
1. “Now that we abandon the tower, can I finally admit that I hate this place? Too many rules.”
This quote, spoken by Amethyst, encapsulates a sense of frustration and longing for freedom, setting a tone of rebellion against restrictive authority that resonates through the chapter.
2. “I’ve spoken new languages in the visions. You can make me speak Azish.”
This statement highlights Dalinar’s unique connection to the Stormfather and hints at his growing ability to bridge language and understanding, which becomes a key element in diplomatic negotiations and insight into Azish culture.
3. “You insist on thinking of them as ardents, because they can read, both male and female. But he was no longer in Alethkar.”
This remark underscores the cultural differences in Azir, where religious figures hold more political power and have a different role than in Alethkar, illustrating the chapter’s exploration of political and religious dynamics.
4. “Instead, he had brought a different kind of weapon. An essay.”
This line emphasizes Dalinar’s strategic approach to diplomacy
— using words, reason, and written arguments as tools of influence rather than violence, marking a shift in his methods of negotiation.5. “Fen argued that Dalinar’s desperation to forge an alliance made for the perfect opportunity to secure beneficial and lasting trade deals through Urithiru.”
This quote encapsulates the core argument of Queen Fen’s diplomatic strategy, highlighting the importance of trade and political alliances as vital to Dalinar’s broader goals, and reflects the chapter’s focus on diplomacy over conflict.
FAQs
1. Question 1
What strategic approach does Dalinar employ during his interactions with the Azish officials, and how does this reflect his understanding of diplomacy in unfamiliar cultural contexts?
Answer:
Dalinar adopts a non-violent, respectful approach, emphasizing openness and intelligence rather than force. He arrives unarmed, presents written documents, and demonstrates a willingness to understand their language and customs. His use of a physical connection through Stormlight to understand Azish speech exemplifies his adaptive strategy. This approach reflects his recognition that diplomacy often requires patience, cultural sensitivity, and clever use of non-combative tools—like written arguments and language—especially when dealing with unfamiliar societies. Dalinar’s tactics show his understanding that building trust and alliances in foreign contexts hinges on respect, communication, and strategic non-aggression.
2. Question 2
How does Dalinar’s perception of the Azish ardents and viziers differ from his previous understanding of religious figures, and what does this reveal about political power structures in Azir?
Answer:
Dalinar initially perceives the ardents as primarily religious figures, but he quickly recognizes that they are deeply involved in the political government, with viziers and scions playing significant roles. Unlike Alethi ardents, who are more religiously oriented, the Azish ardents here are engaged in state affairs, indicating a blending of religious authority with political power. This suggests that in Azir, religious figures are also political actors, wielding influence through their involvement in governance rather than solely spiritual matters. Dalinar’s realization reveals a complex power structure where religion and politics are intertwined, and understanding this dynamic is crucial for diplomatic success.
3. Question 3
What does Dalinar’s use of a written essay from Queen Fen and subsequent documents reveal about his strategy for establishing alliances with Azir?
Answer:
Dalinar’s reliance on written documents, especially the essay from Queen Fen, indicates a strategic shift from direct confrontation to diplomatic negotiation. By presenting well-crafted arguments about the economic benefits of the Oathgates and proposing trade deals, Dalinar aims to persuade Azir through diplomacy and rational discourse rather than force. This approach demonstrates his understanding that alliances can be built on mutual interest, especially economic, and that formal communication can serve as a powerful tool in establishing trust and cooperation. It also shows his adaptability in using written word as a weapon—an intellectual weapon—to complement his military strength.
4. Question 4
In what ways does Dalinar’s interaction with the Stormfather during the language barrier highlight the challenges and possibilities of communication through spiritual or supernatural means?
Answer:
Dalinar’s attempt to understand Azish language with the Stormfather’s help underscores both the difficulty and potential of supernatural aid in communication. While the Stormfather admits that Dalinar is capable of making connections and understanding through spiritual adhesion, it emphasizes that the initiative and effort originate from Dalinar himself. This interaction illustrates that supernatural means can bridge gaps in understanding, but they require the user’s intent and skill. It highlights the possibility of overcoming language barriers with spiritual tools, yet also acknowledges the limitations—such as the need for personal effort and the importance of context—making it a nuanced form of communication.
5. Question 5
Critically evaluate Dalinar’s decision to use a written essay as a weapon in diplomacy instead of traditional military or forceful tactics. What are the potential advantages and risks of this approach?
Answer:
Dalinar’s choice to employ a written essay as a diplomatic tool offers several advantages: it allows him to present a well-reasoned, non-threatening case for alliance, appealing to rationality and shared economic interests. This method can foster trust and demonstrate respect for Azir’s sovereignty, potentially leading to longer-lasting alliances. However, the risks include misinterpretation or rejection of the written argument if the Azish officials are skeptical or distrustful of foreign motives. It also assumes that the Azish value diplomacy and rational discourse over force, which may not always be the case. While non-violent, this approach requires patience and the ability to follow up effectively—if the diplomatic effort fails, Dalinar might need to revert to more aggressive tactics or face diplomatic setbacks.
0 Comments