Oathbringer
33. A Lecture
by Sanderson, BrandonThe chapter begins with an exchange of correspondence, revealing that Jasnah Kholin is alive, a fact that profoundly impacts Shallan. This news shifts her emotional state, bringing a mix of relief and urgency. Despite her recent trauma and the chaos surrounding her, she is consumed with questions about Jasnah’s survival and her mysterious absence. Shallan reflects on her own ordeal with the Unmade, noting her attempt to understand and analyze her experiences through her sketches. The chapter emphasizes the importance of Jasnah’s return, which signifies a turning point, altering the course of her investigations and her understanding of the unfolding events.
As Shallan seeks out Jasnah in Urithiru, her feelings are conflicted—she is both eager and anxious to see her. The narrative details her journey through the tower, describing the atmosphere and her internal struggles. She notices the change in her own emotional state, feeling a sense of liberation from fear and wrongness that had haunted her. Her cautious approach underscores her admiration and insecurity toward Jasnah, highlighting the complex dynamics of their relationship. The chapter also hints at the tower’s mysterious and oppressive aura, which dissipates once the source of darkness is confronted, symbolizing her growing confidence.
Upon finding Jasnah, Shallan observes her in her element—confident, composed, and strikingly beautiful. The scene captures Jasnah’s physical and intellectual strength, emphasizing her resilience after her apparent ordeal. Their interaction reveals Jasnah’s scientific curiosity about the unusual phenomena and her interest in the ancient technology behind the magical artifacts, such as fabrials and Shardblades. Jasnah’s explanations about spren and fabrial creation deepen the reader’s understanding of the lore, and her pragmatic, yet somewhat dramatic, manner of discourse underscores her character’s brilliance and flair. This moment also underscores the contrast between Jasnah’s composed exterior and the dangerous situations she endures.
The chapter concludes with Jasnah’s instructive attitude toward Shallan, urging her to document her observations and sketches accurately. Their exchange reveals underlying tensions—Shallan’s initial sense of subservience clashes with her desire for independence. Jasnah’s apology for past mistakes and her recognition of Shallan’s progress serve as a catalyst for the younger woman’s growth. The narrative ends on a note of mutual respect, with Jasnah’s leadership and wisdom inspiring Shallan. The chapter portrays a pivotal moment of revelation, intellectual curiosity, and the strengthening of their bond amid the larger mysteries of their world.
FAQs
1. What is the significance of Jasnah being alive in the context of Shallan’s emotional state and the story’s development?
Answer:
Jasnah’s survival is a pivotal revelation for Shallan, dramatically altering her emotional landscape and the story’s trajectory. Up until this point, Shallan believed Jasnah was dead, which had caused her grief, guilt, and a sense of loss. Learning that Jasnah is alive sparks a mixture of relief, hope, and a renewed sense of purpose. It also shifts the story’s focus, as Shallan now has the chance to reconnect with her mentor and understand how Jasnah survived. This revelation underscores the importance of hope and resilience, and it sets the stage for further revelations about Jasnah’s experiences and the broader conflict. In essence, Jasnah’s survival redefines the stakes for Shallan and provides a catalyst for her growth and the unfolding narrative.2. How does Jasnah explain the nature of fabrials, and what ethical considerations does Shallan raise about them?
Answer:
Jasnah explains that fabrials are created by capturing a spren inside a gemstone and then provoking specific responses through stimuli, such as heat or other effects. For example, she describes how flamespren can be used to manipulate heat by imprisoning them in a gemstone and then activating the stimuli to produce desired responses. Shallan reacts with horror to this explanation, questioning the morality of imprisoning spren, comparing it to locking a chull in a box to make it pull a wagon. She perceives it as a form of imprisonment and exploitation, raising ethical concerns about the treatment of sentient-like beings (spren). This highlights a core moral dilemma in the world of the story: the balance between technological advancement and respect for the natural spirits involved, prompting readers to consider the ethical implications of using such powerful and potentially harmful magic.3. In what ways does Shallan’s perception of Jasnah’s appearance and demeanor reflect her internal feelings and her view of Jasnah’s character?
Answer:
Shallan’s perception of Jasnah’s appearance and demeanor reveals her admiration, envy, and feelings of insecurity. She describes Jasnah as “perfect,” highlighting her beauty—tan skin, violet eyes, and elegant attire—attributes that seem almost unfair to Shallan. Her feelings of insecurity and overwhelm suggest she views Jasnah as both a role model and someone she aspires to emulate, yet also feels envious of her poise and resilience. The contrast between Jasnah’s composed, unscathed appearance after her ordeal and Shallan’s own insecurities underscores her admiration and the pressure she feels to measure up. This perception reflects the complex emotions underlying their relationship, blending respect with personal self-doubt and a desire for validation.4. How does the chapter explore the theme of perception versus reality through the discussion of Jasnah’s survival and the nature of her injuries?
Answer:
The chapter juxtaposes Jasnah’s seemingly flawless appearance with the reality of her recent trauma, illustrating how perception can differ from reality. Jasnah appears perfect—beautiful, composed, and unaffected—yet her injuries, which once seemed severe enough to be fatal, are now not visibly apparent. Shallan’s initial shock and envy stem from her perception of Jasnah’s invincibility, but the reality is that Jasnah endured significant hardship and danger. This contrast explores how appearances can mask inner struggles and how perception influences our understanding of others. It also emphasizes that resilience and strength are often internal qualities that aren’t immediately visible, encouraging a deeper appreciation of the complexities behind external appearances.5. How might the knowledge of fabrials and their creation influence the characters’ strategies in the ongoing conflict, and what ethical dilemmas could this knowledge pose?
Answer:
Understanding fabrials’ creation and function provides characters with powerful technological tools that could be used strategically in the ongoing conflict. Jasnah’s explanation reveals that they can manipulate spren and harness magical responses, potentially giving armies or individuals significant advantages. However, this knowledge also raises ethical dilemmas—such as whether it is right to imprison and manipulate sentient spirits for the sake of warfare or personal gain. The moral questions about exploiting spren challenge the characters to consider the consequences of their technological advancements. They must balance the benefits of such power against the potential harm, moral corruption, and loss of natural harmony. This knowledge could lead to debates about the ethical limits of magic use, shaping future decisions and alliances.
Quotes
1. “Jasnah’s return sparked something in her. Shallan had once been more analytical in her drawing, including notes and explanations with the sketches. Lately she’d only been doing pages and pages of twisted images.”
This quote highlights the emotional and psychological impact of Jasnah’s presumed death and her subsequent return, serving as a catalyst for Shallan’s renewed focus on understanding her experiences and the significance of her drawings.
2. “Storms… Jasnah was alive. That changed everything.”
This powerful statement underscores the chapter’s central turning point—Jasnah’s survival radically alters the narrative and Shallan’s perspective, emphasizing how critical this revelation is to her understanding of her world.
3. “You capture a spren, and imprison it inside a gemstone crafted for the purpose. Artifabrians have found that specific stimuli will provoke certain responses in the spren… Flamespren give off heat—and by pressing metal against a ruby with a flamespren trapped inside, you can increase or decrease that heat.”
This passage introduces the concept of fabrials, explaining their basis in capturing and manipulating spren. It is crucial for understanding the technological and magical framework of the world, as well as the ethical implications discussed.
4. “No worse than hitching a wagon to a chull.”
Jasnah’s comparison reveals her pragmatic view of fabrials, framing them as a necessary, if morally complex, means of harnessing spren for technological purposes. It encapsulates her rational approach and the nuanced ethical debate surrounding these devices.
5. “There are spren and there are spren, child.”
This statement reflects the complexity of spren in the narrative—distinguishing between different kinds and their significance—highlighting that not all spren are equal and that their manipulation involves understanding their true nature.
Quotes
1. “Jasnah’s return sparked something in her. Shallan had once been more analytical in her drawing, including notes and explanations with the sketches. Lately she’d only been doing pages and pages of twisted images.”
This quote highlights the emotional and psychological impact of Jasnah’s presumed death and her subsequent return, serving as a catalyst for Shallan’s renewed focus on understanding her experiences and the significance of her drawings.
2. “Storms… Jasnah was alive. That changed everything.”
This powerful statement underscores the chapter’s central turning point
— Jasnah’s survival radically alters the narrative and Shallan’s perspective, emphasizing how critical this revelation is to her understanding of her world.3. “You capture a spren, and imprison it inside a gemstone crafted for the purpose. Artifabrians have found that specific stimuli will provoke certain responses in the spren… Flamespren give off heat—and by pressing metal against a ruby with a flamespren trapped inside, you can increase or decrease that heat.”
This passage introduces the concept of fabrials, explaining their basis in capturing and manipulating spren. It is crucial for understanding the technological and magical framework of the world, as well as the ethical implications discussed.
4. “No worse than hitching a wagon to a chull.”
Jasnah’s comparison reveals her pragmatic view of fabrials, framing them as a necessary, if morally complex, means of harnessing spren for technological purposes. It encapsulates her rational approach and the nuanced ethical debate surrounding these devices.
5. “There are spren and there are spren, child.”
This statement reflects the complexity of spren in the narrative—distinguishing between different kinds and their significance—highlighting that not all spren are equal and that their manipulation involves understanding their true nature.
FAQs
1. What is the significance of Jasnah being alive in the context of Shallan’s emotional state and the story’s development?
Answer:
Jasnah’s survival is a pivotal revelation for Shallan, dramatically altering her emotional landscape and the story’s trajectory. Up until this point, Shallan believed Jasnah was dead, which had caused her grief, guilt, and a sense of loss. Learning that Jasnah is alive sparks a mixture of relief, hope, and a renewed sense of purpose. It also shifts the story’s focus, as Shallan now has the chance to reconnect with her mentor and understand how Jasnah survived. This revelation underscores the importance of hope and resilience, and it sets the stage for further revelations about Jasnah’s experiences and the broader conflict. In essence, Jasnah’s survival redefines the stakes for Shallan and provides a catalyst for her growth and the unfolding narrative.
2. How does Jasnah explain the nature of fabrials, and what ethical considerations does Shallan raise about them?
Answer:
Jasnah explains that fabrials are created by capturing a spren inside a gemstone and then provoking specific responses through stimuli, such as heat or other effects. For example, she describes how flamespren can be used to manipulate heat by imprisoning them in a gemstone and then activating the stimuli to produce desired responses. Shallan reacts with horror to this explanation, questioning the morality of imprisoning spren, comparing it to locking a chull in a box to make it pull a wagon. She perceives it as a form of imprisonment and exploitation, raising ethical concerns about the treatment of sentient-like beings (spren). This highlights a core moral dilemma in the world of the story: the balance between technological advancement and respect for the natural spirits involved, prompting readers to consider the ethical implications of using such powerful and potentially harmful magic.
3. In what ways does Shallan’s perception of Jasnah’s appearance and demeanor reflect her internal feelings and her view of Jasnah’s character?
Answer:
Shallan’s perception of Jasnah’s appearance and demeanor reveals her admiration, envy, and feelings of insecurity. She describes Jasnah as “perfect,” highlighting her beauty—tan skin, violet eyes, and elegant attire—attributes that seem almost unfair to Shallan. Her feelings of insecurity and overwhelm suggest she views Jasnah as both a role model and someone she aspires to emulate, yet also feels envious of her poise and resilience. The contrast between Jasnah’s composed, unscathed appearance after her ordeal and Shallan’s own insecurities underscores her admiration and the pressure she feels to measure up. This perception reflects the complex emotions underlying their relationship, blending respect with personal self-doubt and a desire for validation.
4. How does the chapter explore the theme of perception versus reality through the discussion of Jasnah’s survival and the nature of her injuries?
Answer:
The chapter juxtaposes Jasnah’s seemingly flawless appearance with the reality of her recent trauma, illustrating how perception can differ from reality. Jasnah appears perfect—beautiful, composed, and unaffected—yet her injuries, which once seemed severe enough to be fatal, are now not visibly apparent. Shallan’s initial shock and envy stem from her perception of Jasnah’s invincibility, but the reality is that Jasnah endured significant hardship and danger. This contrast explores how appearances can mask inner struggles and how perception influences our understanding of others. It also emphasizes that resilience and strength are often internal qualities that aren’t immediately visible, encouraging a deeper appreciation of the complexities behind external appearances.
5. How might the knowledge of fabrials and their creation influence the characters’ strategies in the ongoing conflict, and what ethical dilemmas could this knowledge pose?
Answer:
Understanding fabrials’ creation and function provides characters with powerful technological tools that could be used strategically in the ongoing conflict. Jasnah’s explanation reveals that they can manipulate spren and harness magical responses, potentially giving armies or individuals significant advantages. However, this knowledge also raises ethical dilemmas—such as whether it is right to imprison and manipulate sentient spirits for the sake of warfare or personal gain. The moral questions about exploiting spren challenge the characters to consider the consequences of their technological advancements. They must balance the benefits of such power against the potential harm, moral corruption, and loss of natural harmony. This knowledge could lead to debates about the ethical limits of magic use, shaping future decisions and alliances.
0 Comments