Oathbringer
28. Another Option
by Sanderson, BrandonThe chapter opens with a candid reflection on human nature, as the narrator admits to being labeled a monster and acknowledges the fears that many of us harbor about the potential for darkness within. This introspective preface sets a tone of vulnerability and self-awareness, suggesting that the true monster may be not an external force but an aspect of human capacity for both good and evil. This acknowledgment frames the broader themes of moral ambiguity and inner conflict that permeate the story, emphasizing that even those who seek righteousness can harbor fears and flaws, making the struggle for virtue complex and ongoing.
The narrative then shifts to a political and strategic context, where Dalinar Kholin faces a setback as Azir’s decision to seal off the Oathgate signifies a major diplomatic failure. The rejection from Azir underscores the fragile nature of alliances and the delicate balance of power in this world. Despite the disappointment, Dalinar remains resolute, focusing on forging alliances with other nations like Thaylenah and Kharbranth. His strategic efforts aim to unite the Eastern states into a coalition, hoping to create enough strength to influence Western nations later. The chapter highlights the importance of diplomacy, persistence, and adaptability in the face of diplomatic rejection.
Amidst the political turmoil, the story explores the mysterious underground tunnels within Urithiru, which are filled with strange phenomena and potential dangers. Dalinar’s curiosity about these tunnels, especially the strange hole at the ceiling, hints at hidden threats lurking beneath the surface of the city. His attempt to investigate using Stormlight demonstrates both his resourcefulness and the uncertainty of what lies within the tunnels. The presence of a creature like a mink and the circulating air suggest complex, possibly supernatural or fabrial-related, mechanisms at work. This subplot adds a layer of intrigue and foreshadows potential threats that could challenge the city’s stability.
The chapter concludes with Dalinar receiving a tense and final communication from Queen Fen of Thaylenah, who firmly rejects his overtures for alliance. Her stark refusal and the tone of finality reveal the deep-rooted mistrust and political complexities that hinder unity. Dalinar’s frustration and sense of helplessness are palpable as he reflects on the barriers to diplomacy and the personal toll of leadership. His internal struggle is compounded by the realization that in this fractured world, alliances are fragile, and the path forward remains uncertain. The chapter ends with Dalinar retreating into the corridors, contemplating his next move amid the ongoing chaos and the weight of leadership.
FAQs
1. What emotional or philosophical confession does the narrator make in the preface of Oathbringer, and what does it reveal about their perspective on humanity?
Answer:
The narrator admits to being called a monster and openly confesses their own humanity, stating, “I am the monster that I fear we all can become.” This confession reveals a deep self-awareness and acknowledgment of human flaws, suggesting that the narrator sees the capacity for monstrosity—whether through actions or internal struggles—as intrinsic to human nature. It highlights a theme of shared fallibility and the idea that the line between heroism and monstrosity is thin, emphasizing the complexity of moral judgment and the importance of understanding one’s own imperfections.2. How does the political situation in the chapter—specifically Azir’s decision—impact Dalinar’s strategic options, and what does this reveal about the larger conflict?
Answer:
Azir’s decision to seal off the Oathgate and refuse to open it, citing the danger of a magical portal, effectively cuts off Azir from Dalinar’s alliance-building efforts. This decision signifies a setback for Dalinar’s plans to unite the Eastern states and forge a coalition that could challenge external threats. It underscores the fragility of political alliances and highlights the challenges Dalinar faces in diplomacy, especially when dealing with nations that prioritize their own sovereignty and security. This moment reveals the broader conflict as one of mounting resistance to Dalinar’s efforts for unity, illustrating how political mistrust and fear can impede collective action against common enemies.3. Analyze Dalinar’s approach to investigating the mysterious tunnels and holes within Urithiru. What does his method reveal about his leadership style and problem-solving approach?
Answer:
Dalinar’s decision to personally investigate the tunnels by using Stormlight to levitate a chair and examine the hole demonstrates his proactive and hands-on leadership style. Rather than relying solely on reports or subordinates’ assessments, he seeks direct evidence, showing a willingness to confront unknown threats head-on. His use of Stormlight to climb and explore indicates resourcefulness and a practical mindset, valuing empirical investigation. This approach reflects a leader who is deeply involved in understanding the issues affecting his people and demonstrates a blend of courage, curiosity, and determination to find solutions, even in the face of uncertainty and potential danger.4. What does the chapter suggest about the complexities of communication and diplomacy, especially in the exchange with Queen Fen of Thaylenah?
Answer:
The chapter highlights the difficulties of diplomacy through the tense and ultimately unsuccessful communication with Queen Fen. Dalinar’s repeated efforts to forge alliances are met with stubbornness and finality from Fen, who explicitly states she will not allow Thaylenah to fall into Dalinar’s hands and dismisses his offers as naive or desperate. The written exchanges underscore the importance of personal dialogue—something that Dalinar recognizes might be more effective if he could speak with her directly. The chapter illustrates how political negotiations are complicated by mistrust, differing priorities, and the risk of miscommunication, emphasizing that diplomacy often involves patience, understanding, and the challenge of overcoming entrenched positions.5. Consider Dalinar’s reflections at the end of the chapter, where he feels ignored and frustrated. What does this reveal about the emotional toll of leadership in times of crisis?
Answer:
Dalinar’s feelings of being ignored and his desire for open skies and fresh air reveal the emotional strain that leadership entails, especially during crises. Despite his efforts and strategic thinking, he faces indifference from those around him, which can foster feelings of isolation and frustration. His internal struggle shows that leadership is not only about making decisions but also about managing personal emotions and the loneliness that can accompany responsibility. It underscores the human side of leadership—the desire for connection, acknowledgment, and a moment of respite amidst relentless pressure—highlighting that even strong leaders are vulnerable and need moments to process their emotional burdens.
Quotes
1. “Finally, I will confess my humanity. I have been named a monster, and do not deny those claims. I am the monster that I fear we all can become.”
This poignant quote from the preface of Oathbringer encapsulates the chapter’s exploration of self-identity, fear, and the universal potential for darkness within. It sets a reflective tone on the nature of monstrosity and human fallibility.
2. “‘The decision has been made,’ … ‘to seal off this Oathgate until we can destroy it. We realize this is not the path you wished for us to take, Dalinar Kholin. Know that the Prime of Azir considers you fondly, and looks forward to the mutual benefit of trade agreements and new treaties between our nations.”
This passage highlights the political tensions and difficult decisions faced by Dalinar, illustrating the theme of diplomatic conflict and the sacrifices made in pursuit of larger goals.
3. “It was nearly enough to make him pull out of the place. But where would they go? Abandon the Oathgates? For now, he’d quadrupled patrols and sent Navani’s researchers searching for a possible explanation.”
This quote emphasizes Dalinar’s determination to face the mysterious threats within Urithiru despite the uncertainty, reflecting his leadership resolve and the chapter’s focus on confronting unseen dangers.
4. “Miles upon miles of even smaller tunnels threaded through the walls and ceilings of an already daunting system. And hiding in them somewhere, the thing that Shallan had drawn…”
This description underscores the chapter’s exploration of hidden dangers and the mysterious, possibly malevolent forces lurking beneath the surface of Urithiru, heightening the tension and sense of mystery.
5. “I’m fine,” he lied. “I just need time to think.”
This simple yet powerful line captures Dalinar’s internal struggle and the emotional toll of leadership, illustrating the chapter’s theme of personal sacrifice and the burden of command.
Quotes
1. “Finally, I will confess my humanity. I have been named a monster, and do not deny those claims. I am the monster that I fear we all can become.”
This poignant quote from the preface of Oathbringer encapsulates the chapter’s exploration of self-identity, fear, and the universal potential for darkness within. It sets a reflective tone on the nature of monstrosity and human fallibility.
2. “‘The decision has been made,’ … ‘to seal off this Oathgate until we can destroy it. We realize this is not the path you wished for us to take, Dalinar Kholin. Know that the Prime of Azir considers you fondly, and looks forward to the mutual benefit of trade agreements and new treaties between our nations.”
This passage highlights the political tensions and difficult decisions faced by Dalinar, illustrating the theme of diplomatic conflict and the sacrifices made in pursuit of larger goals.
3. “It was nearly enough to make him pull out of the place. But where would they go? Abandon the Oathgates? For now, he’d quadrupled patrols and sent Navani’s researchers searching for a possible explanation.”
This quote emphasizes Dalinar’s determination to face the mysterious threats within Urithiru despite the uncertainty, reflecting his leadership resolve and the chapter’s focus on confronting unseen dangers.
4. “Miles upon miles of even smaller tunnels threaded through the walls and ceilings of an already daunting system. And hiding in them somewhere, the thing that Shallan had drawn…”
This description underscores the chapter’s exploration of hidden dangers and the mysterious, possibly malevolent forces lurking beneath the surface of Urithiru, heightening the tension and sense of mystery.
5. “I’m fine,” he lied. “I just need time to think.”
This simple yet powerful line captures Dalinar’s internal struggle and the emotional toll of leadership, illustrating the chapter’s theme of personal sacrifice and the burden of command.
— Unknown
FAQs
1. What emotional or philosophical confession does the narrator make in the preface of Oathbringer, and what does it reveal about their perspective on humanity?
Answer:
The narrator admits to being called a monster and openly confesses their own humanity, stating, “I am the monster that I fear we all can become.” This confession reveals a deep self-awareness and acknowledgment of human flaws, suggesting that the narrator sees the capacity for monstrosity—whether through actions or internal struggles—as intrinsic to human nature. It highlights a theme of shared fallibility and the idea that the line between heroism and monstrosity is thin, emphasizing the complexity of moral judgment and the importance of understanding one’s own imperfections.
2. How does the political situation in the chapter—specifically Azir’s decision—impact Dalinar’s strategic options, and what does this reveal about the larger conflict?
Answer:
Azir’s decision to seal off the Oathgate and refuse to open it, citing the danger of a magical portal, effectively cuts off Azir from Dalinar’s alliance-building efforts. This decision signifies a setback for Dalinar’s plans to unite the Eastern states and forge a coalition that could challenge external threats. It underscores the fragility of political alliances and highlights the challenges Dalinar faces in diplomacy, especially when dealing with nations that prioritize their own sovereignty and security. This moment reveals the broader conflict as one of mounting resistance to Dalinar’s efforts for unity, illustrating how political mistrust and fear can impede collective action against common enemies.
3. Analyze Dalinar’s approach to investigating the mysterious tunnels and holes within Urithiru. What does his method reveal about his leadership style and problem-solving approach?
Answer:
Dalinar’s decision to personally investigate the tunnels by using Stormlight to levitate a chair and examine the hole demonstrates his proactive and hands-on leadership style. Rather than relying solely on reports or subordinates’ assessments, he seeks direct evidence, showing a willingness to confront unknown threats head-on. His use of Stormlight to climb and explore indicates resourcefulness and a practical mindset, valuing empirical investigation. This approach reflects a leader who is deeply involved in understanding the issues affecting his people and demonstrates a blend of courage, curiosity, and determination to find solutions, even in the face of uncertainty and potential danger.
4. What does the chapter suggest about the complexities of communication and diplomacy, especially in the exchange with Queen Fen of Thaylenah?
Answer:
The chapter highlights the difficulties of diplomacy through the tense and ultimately unsuccessful communication with Queen Fen. Dalinar’s repeated efforts to forge alliances are met with stubbornness and finality from Fen, who explicitly states she will not allow Thaylenah to fall into Dalinar’s hands and dismisses his offers as naive or desperate. The written exchanges underscore the importance of personal dialogue—something that Dalinar recognizes might be more effective if he could speak with her directly. The chapter illustrates how political negotiations are complicated by mistrust, differing priorities, and the risk of miscommunication, emphasizing that diplomacy often involves patience, understanding, and the challenge of overcoming entrenched positions.
5. Consider Dalinar’s reflections at the end of the chapter, where he feels ignored and frustrated. What does this reveal about the emotional toll of leadership in times of crisis?
Answer:
Dalinar’s feelings of being ignored and his desire for open skies and fresh air reveal the emotional strain that leadership entails, especially during crises. Despite his efforts and strategic thinking, he faces indifference from those around him, which can foster feelings of isolation and frustration. His internal struggle shows that leadership is not only about making decisions but also about managing personal emotions and the loneliness that can accompany responsibility. It underscores the human side of leadership—the desire for connection, acknowledgment, and a moment of respite amidst relentless pressure—highlighting that even strong leaders are vulnerable and need moments to process their emotional burdens.
0 Comments