Oathbringer
58. Burdens
by Sanderson, BrandonThe chapter opens with a reflection on burdens and self-sacrifice, highlighting a Stoneward’s internal conflict about whether their lifelong willingness to sacrifice is truly noble or perhaps a form of cowardice. This introspection sets a contemplative tone, emphasizing the emotional and psychological weight carried by those sworn to serve. The narrative then shifts to Dalinar’s perspective as he observes the landscape from Urithiru, grappling with the difficulty of visualizing their altitude and the mysteries of the mountain range. His curiosity about the environment underscores his desire for concrete understanding amidst the uncertainties of their situation and the divine visions that continue to trouble him.
Dalinar’s internal dialogue reveals his deep concern about Odium, the dark god, and the unsettling interactions he experienced during a vision. While the Stormfather seems confident, Dalinar remains troubled by the reality of his encounter, especially the feeling that Odium’s presence was tangible and menacing. Navani and Jasnah’s curiosity about his vision contrasts with his own cautious approach, leading to a discussion about the nature of divine interactions and the potential risks involved. Dalinar’s fears about exposing others to Odium’s influence cause them to suspend the use of visions, though he remains haunted by the possibility that Odium can touch the world in ways beyond their understanding.
The narrative then describes a strategic visit to the control platform of the Oathgates, which are crucial for transportation across their world. The scene highlights the technological and mystical intricacies of these gateways, with Navani and her team working carefully on the mechanisms. The successful activation of a gate to Thaylen City signifies progress, and the characters’ relief and excitement are palpable. Kaladin and Shallan’s arrival signifies the importance of these developments, with Kaladin’s pragmatic approach contrasting with Shallan’s eagerness. Dalinar’s leadership is reinforced as he plans further operations, emphasizing the significance of these gateways in their ongoing struggle and mobility.
Finally, Dalinar discusses strategic military and political matters with Kaladin, including the upcoming highstorm and the importance of maintaining control over Kholinar. Dalinar’s decision to grant Kaladin land along the river reflects a recognition of his leadership and the burdens he bears. The conversation underscores the theme of duty and sacrifice, illustrating that burdens are an intrinsic part of leadership and service. Dalinar’s advice to Kaladin about managing his new responsibilities encapsulates the chapter’s core message: that burdens can be a source of strength when accepted with resolve, and that true leadership involves making difficult choices for the greater good.
FAQs
1. What internal conflict does Dalinar experience regarding his role as a Stoneward and his sense of cowardice?
Answer:
Dalinar reflects on his lifelong dedication as a Stoneward, a role centered around sacrifice. He secretly worries that this devotion might be a form of cowardice or an easy way out, suggesting an internal struggle with the true nature of heroism and self-sacrifice. This conflict highlights his ongoing self-doubt and desire to understand whether his sacrifices are genuinely noble or motivated by fear of facing his own limitations. It adds depth to his character, illustrating the psychological burdens he carries, and raises questions about the nature of duty versus self-preservation.2. How does Dalinar’s perception of the heights of Urithiru and the surrounding mountains reflect his desire for clarity and understanding?
Answer:
Dalinar’s difficulty visualizing the height of the mountains and the clouds exemplifies his longing for concrete understanding amid uncertainty. Although Navani’s scribes can measure altitude, Dalinar prefers to see and feel the scale himself, indicating his need for direct perception to truly grasp the magnitude of his environment. This craving for clarity symbolizes his broader quest for truth and comprehension of the world’s divine and physical realities, especially in the context of the spiritual visions and divine interactions he experiences.3. What are the implications of Dalinar’s interaction with Odium and his decision to suspend the use of visions?
Answer:
Dalinar’s encounter with Odium, which felt profoundly real, raises concerns about the risks of spiritual and mental exposure to malevolent forces. His decision to suspend the use of visions reflects caution and awareness of potential dangers, such as exposing minds to Odium’s influence or corrupting thoughts. This choice underscores the ongoing struggle to balance gaining divine insight with protecting oneself and others from spiritual harm. It also emphasizes the chapter’s theme of burdens—both spiritual and mental—that come with seeking divine truths.4. How does the scene involving the control building and the teleportation mechanism illustrate the technological advancements in Urithiru?
Answer:
The control building’s glyphs and the keyhole mechanism demonstrate sophisticated engineering and magical integration, allowing for rapid transportation across vast distances. Navani’s manipulation of the control mechanism, similar to the one at the Shattered Plains, shows an understanding of complex systems that can be used strategically to connect different cities through the Oathgates. This technological progress signifies a pivotal step in unifying the realms and enhancing military and logistical capabilities, reflecting the chapter’s theme of burdens and responsibilities tied to such advancements.5. In what ways does Dalinar’s conversation with Kaladin about landownership and burdens reflect broader themes of leadership and duty?
Answer:
Dalinar’s decision to grant Kaladin land along the Deathbend River underscores the theme that leadership involves bearing responsibilities and burdens, often beyond personal desires. Dalinar emphasizes that Kaladin, as a Shardbearer, has a duty to oversee and protect these lands, and that burdens such as titles and responsibilities are integral to leadership. This conversation highlights that true leadership involves accepting and managing burdens, not avoiding them. It also illustrates Dalinar’s belief that burdens can be a form of honor and duty, shaping individuals into capable leaders who serve others.
Quotes
-
1. “As a Stoneward, I spent my entire life looking to sacrifice myself. I secretly worry that is the cowardly way. The easy way out.”
This quote reveals the internal conflict of a character who perceives self-sacrifice as both noble and potentially cowardly, highlighting themes of burden and moral struggle that permeate the chapter.
2. “Odium felt real. I truly interacted with him.”
Dalinar’s account of his vision underscores the chapter’s exploration of confronting divine and malevolent forces, emphasizing the tangible threat Odium represents and the gravity of his encounter.
3. “We don’t get to choose things like this, son. Just make sure you have a good steward, wise scribes, and some solid men of the fifth and sixth dahns to lead the towns.”
This statement encapsulates the chapter’s reflection on burdens of leadership and responsibility, illustrating Dalinar’s acceptance of duty and the practical steps necessary to bear it.