Oathbringer
40. Questions, Peeks, and Inferences
by Sanderson, BrandonThe chapter begins by highlighting the complex political and mystical landscape on Roshar, emphasizing the presence of secretive groups involved in the resurgence of ancient threats. It introduces Uli Da as a problematic figure and discusses the broader implications of her actions, setting a tone of intrigue and suspicion. The narrative explores the existence of two major institutions—the Sons of Honor and the Skybreakers—that are linked to the potential return of the Voidbringers and Desolations. These groups have different motivations: while the Sons of Honor seek the Desolations to revive the Knights Radiant and restore power, the Skybreakers, led by Nalan’Elin, remain loyal to their oaths and are wary of the return of chaos.
The chapter delves into the historical and ideological differences between these groups, revealing their secret agendas. The Sons of Honor, under Gavilar’s influence, are believed to have worked towards rekindling Desolations, potentially leading to chaos and chaos that could serve their ends. Conversely, the Skybreakers have maintained their oaths through the ages and are suspicious of any activity that might hasten the return of the Voidbringers. Nale, a Herald, is particularly cautious and believes that any breach of oaths, such as speaking the Words of other Radiant orders, could accelerate destructive forces. These groups’ covert operations, including Nale’s dispatching of agents like Helaran, are central to understanding the ongoing conflict and hidden alliances.
The narrative shifts to focus on Shallan’s internal reflections and her discovery of a dangerous letter. She contemplates the implications of the information it contains, questioning the involvement of her family and the possible connections to Gavilar’s death. Pattern, the spren, warns her about the lies within the letter, emphasizing the danger of exposing such secrets. Shallan recognizes that the letter hints at a Surgebinder within Amaram’s army and suspects that powerful forces are manipulating events from behind the scenes. Her cautious approach to the information underscores the peril of uncovering truths that could threaten her life and the fragile peace on Roshar.
The chapter concludes with scenes of Veil, who is undercover and engaging with soldiers amidst the chaos. Her interactions reveal the tense atmosphere among the troops and hint at underlying dissatisfaction and unrest. Veil’s observations about Shallan’s erratic behavior and her own struggles provide insight into the personal toll of the ongoing conflicts. The soldiers’ conversations about their promises, medals, and the sense of purpose they seek reflect the broader theme of loyalty and disillusionment. Overall, the chapter weaves together political intrigue, secret societies, and personal struggles, illustrating the complex web of deception, loyalty, and hidden agendas shaping the fate of Roshar.
FAQs
1. Question 1
What are the two major institutions on Roshar that are associated with the return of the Voidbringers and the Desolations, and what are their respective beliefs or actions related to this threat?
Answer:
The two major institutions on Roshar associated with the potential return of the Voidbringers and the Desolations are the Sons of Honor and the Skybreakers. The Sons of Honor, led by Gavilar Kholin, worked toward the return of the Desolations, believing that only the Voidbringers’ appearance would force the Heralds to reveal themselves and that a Desolation would restore the Knights Radiant and strengthen the Vorin church. Conversely, the Skybreakers, led by the Herald Nalan’Elin, did not betray their oaths during the Recreance and have maintained a secret line of Radiants. Nale believed that men speaking the Words of other Radiant orders could hasten the Voidbringers’ return, and he took active measures, including dispatching minions like Helaran, to prevent this from happening.2. Question 2
Based on the chapter, what can be inferred about Helaran’s potential role and significance in the larger conflict involving the Radiants, the Skybreakers, and the return of the Desolations?
Answer:
Helaran appears to be a significant figure because Nale, the Herald of the Skybreakers, was impressed with him and recruited him, possibly due to his proximity to bonding a spren. The chapter suggests that Helaran’s actions—such as possibly being sent to kill Amaram or proving himself through dangerous tests—are part of a broader effort by the Skybreakers to control or influence the return of the Desolations. Given Nale’s interest and the mention that Helaran might be the one they wanted, Helaran could play a pivotal role in the unfolding events that threaten to bring back the Voidbringers, making him a key character in the conflict between the Radiant orders and the forces seeking to rekindle the Desolations.3. Question 3
How does Shallan’s handling of the secret letter illustrate the themes of secrecy and danger in the chapter?
Answer:
Shallan’s decision to hide the letter by washing off the ink, shredding it, and then destroying it in water underscores the dangerous nature of the information it contains. The chapter highlights the prevalence of secrets and lies, as Pattern notes that “there are lies in this letter,” emphasizing that such knowledge is perilous. Shallan’s awareness that the letter could reveal sensitive alliances or truths about Gavilar’s death and the return of the Desolations reflects the broader theme that knowledge can be power but also a source of danger. Her cautious approach illustrates her understanding that revealing this information could have serious repercussions, reinforcing the chapter’s motif of secrecy as a protective measure in a world filled with political intrigue and hidden threats.4. Question 4
In what ways does the chapter explore the contrast between the public perception of the soldiers and the underlying realities of their experiences?
Answer:
The chapter contrasts the soldiers’ outward appearance of camaraderie and normalcy with the underlying hardships they face. Veil observes that the common room is dark, unadorned, and filled with unpleasant smells, reflecting a stark, utilitarian environment. The soldiers’ casual conversations about their experiences—such as helping find a hidden mess or receiving medals—highlight a façade of pride and accomplishment. However, Veil’s commentary about Shallan being a “pain” and her description of the soldiers’ desire for meaning and recognition reveal that beneath their rough exteriors, they are seeking purpose, respect, and perhaps a sense of belonging. This contrast emphasizes the theme that appearances can be deceiving, and the soldiers’ true struggles are hidden behind their tough exteriors.5. Question 5
Considering the chapter’s content, how might the themes of suspicion and hidden agendas influence the characters’ actions and decisions?
Answer:
The chapter illustrates that suspicion and hidden agendas are central to the characters’ actions. Shallan’s secretive handling of the letter demonstrates her awareness of the dangerous knowledge it contains and her need to protect herself and others. Similarly, Nale’s recruitment of Helaran and the Skybreakers’ covert operations suggest that these organizations operate in secrecy to influence or prevent catastrophic events like the return of the Desolations. Veil’s observations about the soldiers’ desire for recognition and the underlying political tensions highlight that characters are often motivated by hidden motives, alliances, and fears. These themes create a tense atmosphere where trust is fragile, and decisions are made with caution, knowing that revealing too much could lead to betrayal or disaster.
Quotes
1. “You are familiar with the first of these, the men who call themselves the Sons of Honor. The old king of Alethkar—the Blackthorn’s brother, Gavilar Kholin—was a driving force in their expansion. He brought Meridas Amaram into their fold.”
This quote underscores the complex political and clandestine alliances that threaten the return of the Desolations, revealing how Gavilar’s actions and associations with groups like the Sons of Honor and Amaram are intertwined with larger, dangerous plans.
2. “They believed that only the Voidbringers would cause the Heralds to show themselves—and they believed that a Desolation would restore both the Knights Radiant and the classical strength of the Vorin church.”
This statement highlights the radical beliefs of the Sons of Honor, emphasizing their desire to provoke the Voidbringers’ return as a means to restore ancient powers and religious authority, which is central to understanding the chapter’s exploration of hidden motivations and dangerous ideologies.
3. “Secrets,” Pattern said. “There are lies in this letter.”
This brief but powerful line captures the chapter’s theme of deception and hidden truths, illustrating how the characters’ pursuit of information is fraught with uncertainty and the risk of uncovering dangerous lies, thus framing the narrative’s tension around trust and betrayal.
4. “Veil found Vathah and some of his men playing at pieces in their barracks common room… Though this was for Sebarial’s soldiers, she saw men in blue uniforms as well—Dalinar had ordered his men to spend time with the soldiers of his allies, to help foster a sense of camaraderie.”
This quote emphasizes the importance of unity and camaraderie among different factions, revealing the chapter’s subtle exploration of alliance-building amidst underlying tensions and the importance of social bonds in wartime.
5. “It’s like she can’t decide who she is, you know? One moment she’s cracking jokes like she’s sitting in a knitting circle with old ladies—the next she’s staring at you with that hollow gaze. The one that makes you think her soul has gone vacant…”
This passage vividly depicts Shallan’s psychological struggles, illustrating her internal conflict and the chapter’s focus on the fragility of identity and mental resilience amid chaos and danger.
Quotes
1. “You are familiar with the first of these, the men who call themselves the Sons of Honor. The old king of Alethkar — the Blackthorn’s brother, Gavilar Kholin—was a driving force in their expansion. He brought Meridas Amaram into their fold.”
This quote underscores the complex political and clandestine alliances that threaten the return of the Desolations, revealing how Gavilar’s actions and associations with groups like the Sons of Honor and Amaram are intertwined with larger, dangerous plans.
2. “They believed that only the Voidbringers would cause the Heralds to show themselves—and they believed that a Desolation would restore both the Knights Radiant and the classical strength of the Vorin church.”
This statement highlights the radical beliefs of the Sons of Honor, emphasizing their desire to provoke the Voidbringers’ return as a means to restore ancient powers and religious authority, which is central to understanding the chapter’s exploration of hidden motivations and dangerous ideologies.
3. “Secrets,” Pattern said. “There are lies in this letter.”
This brief but powerful line captures the chapter’s theme of deception and hidden truths, illustrating how the characters’ pursuit of information is fraught with uncertainty and the risk of uncovering dangerous lies, thus framing the narrative’s tension around trust and betrayal.
4. “Veil found Vathah and some of his men playing at pieces in their barracks common room… Though this was for Sebarial’s soldiers, she saw men in blue uniforms as well—Dalinar had ordered his men to spend time with the soldiers of his allies, to help foster a sense of camaraderie.”
This quote emphasizes the importance of unity and camaraderie among different factions, revealing the chapter’s subtle exploration of alliance-building amidst underlying tensions and the importance of social bonds in wartime.
5. “It’s like she can’t decide who she is, you know? One moment she’s cracking jokes like she’s sitting in a knitting circle with old ladies—the next she’s staring at you with that hollow gaze. The one that makes you think her soul has gone vacant…”
This passage vividly depicts Shallan’s psychological struggles, illustrating her internal conflict and the chapter’s focus on the fragility of identity and mental resilience amid chaos and danger.
FAQs
1. Question 1
What are the two major institutions on Roshar that are associated with the return of the Voidbringers and the Desolations, and what are their respective beliefs or actions related to this threat?
Answer:
The two major institutions on Roshar associated with the potential return of the Voidbringers and the Desolations are the Sons of Honor and the Skybreakers. The Sons of Honor, led by Gavilar Kholin, worked toward the return of the Desolations, believing that only the Voidbringers’ appearance would force the Heralds to reveal themselves and that a Desolation would restore the Knights Radiant and strengthen the Vorin church. Conversely, the Skybreakers, led by the Herald Nalan’Elin, did not betray their oaths during the Recreance and have maintained a secret line of Radiants. Nale believed that men speaking the Words of other Radiant orders could hasten the Voidbringers’ return, and he took active measures, including dispatching minions like Helaran, to prevent this from happening.
2. Question 2
Based on the chapter, what can be inferred about Helaran’s potential role and significance in the larger conflict involving the Radiants, the Skybreakers, and the return of the Desolations?
Answer:
Helaran appears to be a significant figure because Nale, the Herald of the Skybreakers, was impressed with him and recruited him, possibly due to his proximity to bonding a spren. The chapter suggests that Helaran’s actions—such as possibly being sent to kill Amaram or proving himself through dangerous tests—are part of a broader effort by the Skybreakers to control or influence the return of the Desolations. Given Nale’s interest and the mention that Helaran might be the one they wanted, Helaran could play a pivotal role in the unfolding events that threaten to bring back the Voidbringers, making him a key character in the conflict between the Radiant orders and the forces seeking to rekindle the Desolations.
3. Question 3
How does Shallan’s handling of the secret letter illustrate the themes of secrecy and danger in the chapter?
Answer:
Shallan’s decision to hide the letter by washing off the ink, shredding it, and then destroying it in water underscores the dangerous nature of the information it contains. The chapter highlights the prevalence of secrets and lies, as Pattern notes that “there are lies in this letter,” emphasizing that such knowledge is perilous. Shallan’s awareness that the letter could reveal sensitive alliances or truths about Gavilar’s death and the return of the Desolations reflects the broader theme that knowledge can be power but also a source of danger. Her cautious approach illustrates her understanding that revealing this information could have serious repercussions, reinforcing the chapter’s motif of secrecy as a protective measure in a world filled with political intrigue and hidden threats.
4. Question 4
In what ways does the chapter explore the contrast between the public perception of the soldiers and the underlying realities of their experiences?
Answer:
The chapter contrasts the soldiers’ outward appearance of camaraderie and normalcy with the underlying hardships they face. Veil observes that the common room is dark, unadorned, and filled with unpleasant smells, reflecting a stark, utilitarian environment. The soldiers’ casual conversations about their experiences—such as helping find a hidden mess or receiving medals—highlight a façade of pride and accomplishment. However, Veil’s commentary about Shallan being a “pain” and her description of the soldiers’ desire for meaning and recognition reveal that beneath their rough exteriors, they are seeking purpose, respect, and perhaps a sense of belonging. This contrast emphasizes the theme that appearances can be deceiving, and the soldiers’ true struggles are hidden behind their tough exteriors.
5. Question 5
Considering the chapter’s content, how might the themes of suspicion and hidden agendas influence the characters’ actions and decisions?
Answer:
The chapter illustrates that suspicion and hidden agendas are central to the characters’ actions. Shallan’s secretive handling of the letter demonstrates her awareness of the dangerous knowledge it contains and her need to protect herself and others. Similarly, Nale’s recruitment of Helaran and the Skybreakers’ covert operations suggest that these organizations operate in secrecy to influence or prevent catastrophic events like the return of the Desolations. Veil’s observations about the soldiers’ desire for recognition and the underlying political tensions highlight that characters are often motivated by hidden motives, alliances, and fears. These themes create a tense atmosphere where trust is fragile, and decisions are made with caution, knowing that revealing too much could lead to betrayal or disaster.
0 Comments