Mistborn: The Final Empire
35
by Sanderson, BrandonVin grapples with profound grief and betrayal following Kelsier’s death, suspended in the mists as she reflects on his broken promise to catch her. The mists, indifferent to her pain, mirror her desire to escape her suffering. She questions Kelsier’s integrity, comparing his abandonment to Reen’s honesty, and feels the weight of his failure against the Lord Ruler. Her emotional turmoil is compounded by the recent massacre of skaa, leaving her disillusioned and questioning the purpose of Kelsier’s sacrifice.
Sazed finds Vin on the rooftop and attempts to console her, offering a perspective on faith that endures despite failure. He argues that true belief is tested in moments of despair, not just in success. Vin, however, remains bitter, insisting Kelsier was unworthy of their trust and never had a viable plan to defeat the Lord Ruler. Sazed’s calm demeanor contrasts with Vin’s anger, as he subtly defends Kelsier’s legacy and the skaa’s growing reverence for him.
The conversation shifts to the skaa’s perception of Kelsier as a religious figure, which Vin dismisses as absurd given her personal knowledge of his flaws. Sazed, ever the scholar, sees value in documenting these emerging legends as part of his study of religions. Their exchange highlights the tension between Vin’s raw grief and Sazed’s measured wisdom, as well as the broader theme of how figures are mythologized after death.
The chapter closes with Vin and Sazed standing in silence, the city shrouded in mist and sorrow. Vin’s emotional wounds remain open, but Sazed’s steadfast belief hints at the possibility of eventual healing. The night’s quietness underscores the unresolved tension between despair and hope, leaving Vin’s path forward uncertain but not entirely devoid of light.
FAQs
1. How does Vin’s emotional state reflect her feelings of betrayal after Kelsier’s death?
Answer:
Vin experiences profound grief and disillusionment, feeling that Kelsier betrayed her trust by dying and leaving her vulnerable. The text shows her comparing this abandonment to Reen’s departure, but with added bitterness because Kelsier had promised to “catch her.” Her wish to dissolve into the mist symbolizes her desire to escape the pain of betrayal and loss. This emotional turmoil is central to her character development in this chapter, as she questions the meaning of Kelsier’s sacrifice and struggles with her faith in him.2. What philosophical debate about good and evil arises in Vin’s conversation with Sazed?
Answer:
The chapter revisits Ham’s ongoing question about whether evil truly exists, contrasting it with Sazed’s firm belief in the existence of both good and evil men. Sazed argues that evil is real and that the skaa massacred by the Lord Ruler’s forces were victims of evil actions. This dialogue deepens the moral complexity of the narrative, challenging Vin’s cynical perspective after Kelsier’s death and reinforcing the thematic struggle between hope and despair in the face of oppression.3. How does Sazed defend his continued belief in Kelsier despite his failure?
Answer:
Sazed argues that true faith is tested by failure, not success. He suggests that believing in someone only when they succeed is easy, but maintaining faith after disappointment holds greater value. This perspective contrasts sharply with Vin’s anger and sense of betrayal. Sazed’s stance introduces a key thematic element about the nature of belief and legacy, hinting that Kelsier’s impact may extend beyond his death, as seen in the growing skaa legends about him.4. What significance does the bent coin hold in this chapter?
Answer:
The bent coin, which Vin retrieves after her time in the mists, is the same one she and Kelsier used during their early Allomancy training. It serves as a tangible reminder of their bond and his broken promises. The damaged state of the coin mirrors Vin’s fractured trust and the irreversible change in her relationship with Kelsier. This small detail carries emotional weight, symbolizing how their past connection now feels distorted and unreliable to her.5. How does the chapter explore the beginnings of Kelsier’s transformation into a religious figure?
Answer:
Sazed mentions collecting the emerging skaa legends about Kelsier, treating him as a nascent religious icon despite Vin’s protests that he was just a man. This conversation foreshadows Kelsier’s lasting influence on the skaa rebellion and introduces the idea that his death may have been part of a larger, unseen plan. The discussion challenges Vin’s literal understanding of Kelsier’s failure by suggesting that his legacy could hold spiritual significance beyond practical outcomes.
Quotes
1. “I know what will happen if I make the wrong choice. I must be strong; I must not take the power for myself. For I have seen what will happen if I do.”
This opening epigraph hints at a profound internal struggle and foreshadows the chapter’s themes of trust, betrayal, and the corrupting nature of power. It sets a contemplative tone for Vin’s later reflections.
2. “Belief isn’t simply a thing for fair times and bright days, I think. What is belief—what is faith—if you don’t continue in it after failure?”
Sazed delivers this powerful statement about the nature of faith during Vin’s crisis of trust following Kelsier’s death. It represents the chapter’s core philosophical exploration of belief in the face of disappointment.
3. “Anyone can believe in someone, or something, that always succeeds, Mistress. But failure… ah, now, that is hard to believe in, certainly and truly. Difficult enough to have value, I think.”
Sazed expands on his earlier point, offering a profound perspective on the true test of faith. This quote captures the chapter’s examination of how we respond when our heroes fail us.
4. “So many of them are, I think,” Sazed said quietly.
This brief but impactful response to Vin’s assertion that Kelsier was “just a man” encapsulates the chapter’s meditation on how ordinary people become religious figures. It suggests the transformative power of belief and legend.
5. “He was no prophet or god. He was just a man.”
Vin’s bitter declaration represents her shattered trust in Kelsier and serves as the emotional climax of the chapter. This quote powerfully conveys her disillusionment and the painful transition from idealization to reality.