If These Wings Could Fly
Chapter Fifty-Seven
by McCauley, KyrieThe chapter opens with Erin, Campbell, and Juniper returning late to Auburn by bus, where they face a tense and hostile atmosphere upon arriving home. Their attempt to reach out by phone results in a delayed pickup, signaling a strained relationship. The home environment is immediately unsettling, marked by the loud stereo and the father’s aggressive behavior, setting a tone of conflict and emotional turmoil. His anger is palpable, and the family dynamic is fraught with tension as he confronts Erin harshly for what he perceives as an embarrassment.
As the scene unfolds, the physical damage in the house reflects the fractured relationships within it. The father’s destructive actions—tearing a coat closet off its hinges, scattering shoes, and breaking picture frames—symbolize deeper emotional fractures. The broken homecoming photo, with obscured faces, poignantly represents the loss and disruption experienced by the family. Erin’s protective instincts surface as she directs her siblings away from the chaos, highlighting her role as a caretaker amidst the turmoil.
The father’s outburst reveals his frustration with his life circumstances, particularly his inability to find work and the failure of his business, which he believes defines his current despair. His anger towards Erin and the family is intertwined with his own feelings of failure, exacerbated by reminders of past mistakes. The mother’s response, marked by an unexpected display of anger, challenges his authority and demands change, culminating in a confrontation where she insists that he must leave the house, signaling a critical turning point in their relationship.
The chapter closes with a chilling power struggle, as the father physically blocks the mother and exerts control by taking her car keys, symbolizing his dominance and the family’s entrapment. Despite his threats and provocations, the mother remains resolute, yet the silence that follows is heavy with unspoken fear and uncertainty. Erin retreats upstairs, seeking refuge, while the family grapples with the aftermath of the confrontation, underscoring the chapter’s themes of conflict, control, and the fragile bonds holding the family together.
FAQs
1. How does the chapter depict the family’s emotional and physical state upon returning to the house, and what does this reveal about their relationships?
Answer:
The chapter portrays a tense and volatile atmosphere when the family returns home late. The father’s anger is immediately evident as he yells at Erin, accusing her of embarrassing him. The physical destruction in the house—torn coat closet, scattered shoes, broken picture frames, and a dented wall—symbolizes the fractured relationships and emotional turmoil within the family. The homecoming picture, shattered and obscured, poignantly reflects the broken family bonds. This environment reveals deep-seated resentment, frustration, and a lack of communication, highlighting the father’s inability to cope with his failures and the emotional distance between family members.2. What role does the father’s frustration with the town and his personal failures play in the conflict presented in the chapter?
Answer:
The father’s frustration acts as a catalyst for the conflict. He explicitly states his hatred for the town and his perceived failures, including the loss of his business and the stigma of a past failure from twenty years ago. His anger is not only directed at external circumstances but also projected onto his family, especially Erin. This resentment fuels his aggressive behavior, such as destroying household items and controlling actions like taking the car keys. His inability to move past his disappointments traps the family in a cycle of tension and fear, underscoring how unresolved personal and economic struggles can deeply impact family dynamics.3. Analyze how the mother’s response to the father’s aggression evolves throughout the chapter and what it signifies about her character.
Answer:
Initially, the mother’s anger is noticeable but restrained. As the father’s outbursts escalate, she asserts herself by telling him “You have to go” and later “You need to leave,” marking a significant shift from passivity to confrontation. This evolution signifies her growing courage and refusal to tolerate abuse, prioritizing the safety and well-being of her children. However, when physically trapped by the father, she complies with his command to go upstairs, indicating the complexity of her situation—she is both resisting and constrained by fear or power dynamics. Her actions reflect a protective yet vulnerable figure caught in a difficult, abusive environment.4. How does the author use symbolism in the description of the broken homecoming picture and the damaged living space to deepen the reader’s understanding of the family’s situation?
Answer:
The broken homecoming picture and the damaged living space serve as powerful symbols of the family’s fractured state. The homecoming photo, traditionally a symbol of celebration and unity, is shattered with faces obscured, representing lost innocence, broken relationships, and the erasure of happy memories. The torn coat closet, scattered shoes, and broken frames emphasize chaos and destruction within what should be a safe space. These symbols deepen the reader’s understanding by visually manifesting the emotional and psychological damage endured by the family, making the internal conflict tangible and highlighting the theme of disintegration.5. Considering the chapter’s events, what might be some practical steps the family could take to address the ongoing conflict and improve their situation?
Answer:
To address the conflict, the family might consider seeking professional help such as family counseling or individual therapy to manage anger and trauma. Establishing safe communication channels could help them express feelings without violence. The mother and children might explore support services for domestic abuse to ensure their safety and consider legal options if necessary. Addressing the father’s economic frustrations through career counseling or community resources might alleviate some stressors contributing to his aggression. Overall, creating a plan for safety, emotional healing, and practical support would be critical steps toward improving their situation and breaking the cycle of abuse.
Quotes
1. “How could you embarrass me like that, Erin?”
This quote reveals the immediate tension and confrontation upon returning home, highlighting the emotional volatility and underlying conflicts within the family dynamic. It sets the tone for the chapter’s exploration of anger and frustration.
2. “I hate this town,” he says. “I can’t get work. The business is done, Erin. Done. And we try to get away from it all for one night—one goddamn night—and all anyone can talk about is my other major failure, even though it was twenty years ago. Enough!”
Here, the character expresses deep resentment and despair about his circumstances, capturing themes of failure, stagnation, and the burden of past mistakes. It is a key emotional outburst that explains his destructive behavior and sense of entrapment.
3. “It is enough,” Mom says. “You have to go.”
This moment marks a pivotal turning point where the mother asserts herself, demanding change and drawing a boundary in an abusive and toxic situation. It signifies a shift in power dynamics and the family’s refusal to tolerate further harm.
4. “You want your keys, come get them.” … “Get them!” he screams. When she doesn’t move, he laughs. “That’s what I thought.”
This exchange encapsulates the controlling and menacing behavior exhibited, illustrating the intimidation tactics used to dominate and instill fear. It highlights the emotional imprisonment and helplessness experienced by the family members.
5. None of us says a word when she climbs into bed next to Campbell, Juniper, and me.
The quiet, shared moment at the chapter’s end underscores the collective trauma and the fragile safety the family seeks in each other. It closes the chapter on a somber, reflective note emphasizing endurance amid turmoil.
Quotes
1. “How could you embarrass me like that, Erin?”
This quote reveals the immediate tension and confrontation upon returning home, highlighting the emotional volatility and underlying conflicts within the family dynamic. It sets the tone for the chapter’s exploration of anger and frustration.
2. “I hate this town,” he says. “I can’t get work. The business is done, Erin. Done. And we try to get away from it all for one night — one goddamn night—and all anyone can talk about is my other major failure, even though it was twenty years ago. Enough!”
Here, the character expresses deep resentment and despair about his circumstances, capturing themes of failure, stagnation, and the burden of past mistakes. It is a key emotional outburst that explains his destructive behavior and sense of entrapment.
3. “It is enough,” Mom says. “You have to go.”
This moment marks a pivotal turning point where the mother asserts herself, demanding change and drawing a boundary in an abusive and toxic situation. It signifies a shift in power dynamics and the family’s refusal to tolerate further harm.
4. “You want your keys, come get them.” … “Get them!” he screams. When she doesn’t move, he laughs. “That’s what I thought.”
This exchange encapsulates the controlling and menacing behavior exhibited, illustrating the intimidation tactics used to dominate and instill fear. It highlights the emotional imprisonment and helplessness experienced by the family members.
5. None of us says a word when she climbs into bed next to Campbell, Juniper, and me.
The quiet, shared moment at the chapter’s end underscores the collective trauma and the fragile safety the family seeks in each other. It closes the chapter on a somber, reflective note emphasizing endurance amid turmoil.
FAQs
1. How does the chapter depict the family’s emotional and physical state upon returning to the house, and what does this reveal about their relationships?
Answer:
The chapter portrays a tense and volatile atmosphere when the family returns home late. The father’s anger is immediately evident as he yells at Erin, accusing her of embarrassing him. The physical destruction in the house—torn coat closet, scattered shoes, broken picture frames, and a dented wall—symbolizes the fractured relationships and emotional turmoil within the family. The homecoming picture, shattered and obscured, poignantly reflects the broken family bonds. This environment reveals deep-seated resentment, frustration, and a lack of communication, highlighting the father’s inability to cope with his failures and the emotional distance between family members.
2. What role does the father’s frustration with the town and his personal failures play in the conflict presented in the chapter?
Answer:
The father’s frustration acts as a catalyst for the conflict. He explicitly states his hatred for the town and his perceived failures, including the loss of his business and the stigma of a past failure from twenty years ago. His anger is not only directed at external circumstances but also projected onto his family, especially Erin. This resentment fuels his aggressive behavior, such as destroying household items and controlling actions like taking the car keys. His inability to move past his disappointments traps the family in a cycle of tension and fear, underscoring how unresolved personal and economic struggles can deeply impact family dynamics.
3. Analyze how the mother’s response to the father’s aggression evolves throughout the chapter and what it signifies about her character.
Answer:
Initially, the mother’s anger is noticeable but restrained. As the father’s outbursts escalate, she asserts herself by telling him “You have to go” and later “You need to leave,” marking a significant shift from passivity to confrontation. This evolution signifies her growing courage and refusal to tolerate abuse, prioritizing the safety and well-being of her children. However, when physically trapped by the father, she complies with his command to go upstairs, indicating the complexity of her situation—she is both resisting and constrained by fear or power dynamics. Her actions reflect a protective yet vulnerable figure caught in a difficult, abusive environment.
4. How does the author use symbolism in the description of the broken homecoming picture and the damaged living space to deepen the reader’s understanding of the family’s situation?
Answer:
The broken homecoming picture and the damaged living space serve as powerful symbols of the family’s fractured state. The homecoming photo, traditionally a symbol of celebration and unity, is shattered with faces obscured, representing lost innocence, broken relationships, and the erasure of happy memories. The torn coat closet, scattered shoes, and broken frames emphasize chaos and destruction within what should be a safe space. These symbols deepen the reader’s understanding by visually manifesting the emotional and psychological damage endured by the family, making the internal conflict tangible and highlighting the theme of disintegration.
5. Considering the chapter’s events, what might be some practical steps the family could take to address the ongoing conflict and improve their situation?
Answer:
To address the conflict, the family might consider seeking professional help such as family counseling or individual therapy to manage anger and trauma. Establishing safe communication channels could help them express feelings without violence. The mother and children might explore support services for domestic abuse to ensure their safety and consider legal options if necessary. Addressing the father’s economic frustrations through career counseling or community resources might alleviate some stressors contributing to his aggression. Overall, creating a plan for safety, emotional healing, and practical support would be critical steps toward improving their situation and breaking the cycle of abuse.
0 Comments