Chapter 9 begins with the charismatic and physically impressive Errol Gardner making his entrance. With his tall, muscular frame and signature polished style, Errol exudes an air of confidence that is immediately felt by those around him. When he meets Frank Szatowski, he joyously pronounces Frank’s last name in a theatrical manner, adding an extra touch of flair to their introduction. Errol then eagerly inquires about Frank’s drive to Osprey Lodge, demonstrating genuine interest in his guest’s journey. Frank, taken aback by the grandeur of the lodge, is soon hurried upstairs by Aidan, Errol’s son. The office where Frank is led is a striking testament to Errol’s refined tastes, filled with exquisite woodwork that not only enhances the space but also gives a clear sense of Errol’s sophisticated personality.

As the conversation settles into a more congenial rhythm, Frank presents Errol with a bottle of bourbon, referencing Errol’s well-known fondness for the drink, which had previously been featured in New England Living. The two exchange stories as they enjoy their drinks, with Errol being refreshingly honest about a prior interview he had been a part of, one he hadn’t particularly enjoyed. Despite this, he admits he did appreciate the attention the bourbon received in the publication. The warm, welcoming environment is further enhanced by the appearance of Gerry Levinson, an older friend of Errol’s. As they pour their drinks, Errol raises a toast to the occasion of the wedding and takes a moment to praise Maggie, referring to her as an intelligent and rare talent. This commendation shows the admiration Errol holds for Maggie, setting a positive tone for the gathering.

In the midst of the jovial conversation, Frank finds himself reflecting on the fond memories he shared with his late wife, Colleen. He speaks openly about their early years together while he was serving in the army, allowing the bourbon to ease his nerves and allowing him to delve into more personal matters. This leads to a heartfelt discussion about Catherine, Errol’s wife, who has been suffering from debilitating migraines for quite some time. Frank and Errol both acknowledge the profound impact her condition has had on their lives, with Catherine’s inability to attend the wedding being a poignant reminder of her ongoing struggle. Despite Errol’s hope for her recovery, it becomes clear that her participation in the event would remain out of reach for the time being.

The conversation takes an unexpected turn when the name Dawn Taggart is mentioned, causing an immediate and noticeable shift in the atmosphere. A tense silence falls over the room as Gerry, sensing the unease, inquires about a piece of mail Frank has received. Frank, who has been trying to make sense of everything, pulls out an envelope that sparks an intense discussion. Inside, they find a photo that immediately grabs the group’s attention, triggering a mixture of curiosity and suspicion. Aidan’s reaction is swift and alarming as he declares the photo to be a fake, adding a layer of urgency to the conversation. As they begin to discuss the implications of the photo, the group also reflects on Aidan’s past encounters with Dawn, a brief and somewhat awkward meeting that had been clouded by unanswered questions and lingering doubts.

Aidan begins to recount his meeting with Dawn, describing it as a chance encounter after a flat tire left him stranded. Their brief interaction, which consisted of vague and unmemorable references to pop culture, left both parties feeling disconnected. They shared one dinner date, but after that, Aidan and Dawn parted ways, never to cross paths again. Now, as they examine the photo and its potential significance, the group begins to dig deeper into the motives of those involved. Gerry suggests that a financial angle may be at play, drawing comparisons to the O. J. Simpson case and hinting at the possibility of a civil lawsuit. The tension in the room grows as Aidan, who is already under pressure, tries to clarify his position and defend his innocence. This complex situation, involving legal complications and family dynamics, leaves the group on edge, particularly as they try to piece together the connection between Dawn’s disappearance and Aidan’s involvement.

As the chapter unfolds, the narrative continues to intertwine personal struggles with legal uncertainty. The characters’ lives are increasingly dominated by these complex, unresolved issues, and the protagonist is left to navigate the murky waters of familial expectations, personal accountability, and the trials of love. What initially seemed like a simple gathering at the wedding soon evolves into a web of intrigue, with each individual harboring secrets that, once revealed, could shake the foundations of their relationships. The mixture of family loyalty, legal threats, and emotional turmoil leaves everyone questioning their place in the family and their connection to the events unfolding. This chapter marks a pivotal moment in the story, as the protagonist begins to realize that the stakes are much higher than they initially believed.