Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Insurgent
    Adventure FictionScience FictionYoung Adult

    Insurgent

    by Veronica, Roth
    “Insurgent” by Veronica Roth is the second installment in the Divergent trilogy, a dystopian young adult series set in a post-apocalyptic Chicago. The novel follows protagonist Tris Prior as she navigates the aftermath of a faction-based society’s collapse, grappling with grief, identity, and loyalty. Amidst escalating conflict, Tris and her allies uncover dark secrets about their world while facing moral dilemmas and personal betrayals. The story explores themes of revolution, societal control, and the consequences of choices. As a sequel to the bestselling “Divergent,” “Insurgent” expands the series’ dystopian framework and sets the stage for the trilogy’s conclusion.
    PreviousNext
    Insurgent

    Chapter Nine

    by Veronica, Roth

    The chap­ter opens with Tris and the fac­tion­less gath­er­ing around a fire to share a com­mu­nal meal. The makeshift din­ing arrange­ment high­lights the harsh real­i­ties of fac­tion­less life, where resources are scarce and hygiene is com­pro­mised. As they eat, Tris con­vers­es with Edward, a for­mer Daunt­less mem­ber, who probes her about her fam­i­ly and fac­tion trans­fer. Their exchange reveals under­ly­ing ten­sions, par­tic­u­lar­ly when Edward crit­i­cizes her deci­sion to leave Abne­ga­tion. Therese, a for­mer Eru­dite, joins the con­ver­sa­tion, shar­ing her own sto­ry of fail­ing ini­ti­a­tion and being forced to leave. This dia­logue under­scores the rigid and unfor­giv­ing nature of fac­tion soci­ety.

    The dis­cus­sion shifts to the ori­gins of the fac­tion­less, with Therese explain­ing that most are failed Daunt­less ini­ti­ates, fol­lowed by Eru­dite and Can­dor out­casts. Tris learns about the “old-age thing” in Daunt­less, where mem­bers are expelled once they can no longer meet phys­i­cal demands, often choos­ing death over fac­tion­less­ness. This rev­e­la­tion shocks Tris, as she recalls nev­er see­ing elder­ly Daunt­less mem­bers. Tobias adds a grim per­spec­tive, hint­ing at the bru­tal real­i­ties of fac­tion life. Edward’s bit­ter­ness over los­ing an eye dur­ing Daunt­less ini­ti­a­tion fur­ther expos­es the fac­tion’s vio­lent under­bel­ly, while Tris grap­ples with her own actions, such as shoot­ing Peter.

    Tobias inquires about the cur­rent state of the fac­tions, and Edward reveals that Daunt­less is split between Eru­dite and Can­dor head­quar­ters, with Abne­ga­tion sur­vivors join­ing the fac­tion­less. This news brings Tris some relief, know­ing not all Daunt­less have betrayed their val­ues. The chap­ter then tran­si­tions to a qui­eter moment between Tris and Tobias as they pre­pare to sleep. Their inti­mate exchange, filled with unspo­ken emo­tions and phys­i­cal touch, con­trasts sharply with the ear­li­er ten­sion. Tris traces Tobias’s tat­toos, sym­bol­iz­ing their shared his­to­ry and the com­plex­i­ties of their iden­ti­ties across fac­tions.

    The chap­ter clos­es with Tris falling asleep amidst the mur­murs of the fac­tion­less, find­ing solace in the noise that drowns out her guilt and grief. She wakes lat­er to a dim­ming fire, sym­bol­iz­ing the fleet­ing moments of peace in their tur­bu­lent world. This chap­ter high­lights the strug­gles of the fac­tion­less, the harsh truths of fac­tion life, and the frag­ile com­fort Tris and Tobias find in each oth­er amid chaos. The themes of iden­ti­ty, sur­vival, and loy­al­ty are woven through­out, paint­ing a poignant pic­ture of their frac­tured soci­ety.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. What does the conversation about Dauntless initiation reveal about the faction’s values and practices?

      Answer:
      The discussion between Tris, Tobias, and Edward reveals disturbing truths about Dauntless initiation and aging. Tobias explains that once Dauntless members reach a certain level of physical deterioration, they are forced to leave the faction—with the implication that some choose death over factionlessness. This highlights Dauntless’s extreme emphasis on physical capability and youth, valuing strength over wisdom or experience. The revelation about initiation failures (like Edward’s eye injury during a conflict with Peter) further underscores the faction’s brutal, survival-of-the-fittest mentality. These practices contrast sharply with the faction’s idealized image of bravery, showing how its culture prioritizes performance over compassion.

      2. How does Therese’s backstory reflect the flaws in Erudite’s faction system?

      Answer:
      Therese, a former Erudite, explains she was expelled for scoring too low on an initiation intelligence test and given the demeaning choice to either clean labs or leave. Her experience exposes Erudite’s rigid elitism and lack of tolerance for diverse abilities. The faction’s hyperfocus on intellectual superiority creates a hierarchy where those deemed “not smart enough” are discarded, mirroring the cruelty Tris later observes in Dauntless. This systemic exclusion demonstrates how factions fail to accommodate individual differences, forcing people like Therese into factionlessness. It also foreshadows the broader critique of faction divisions that Tris grapples with throughout the series.

      3. Analyze the significance of Tobias’s tattoos in this chapter. What do they symbolize?

      Answer:
      Tris notices Tobias’s tattoos—including Amity’s tree and the other faction symbols—as markers of his complex identity. The tattoos represent his rejection of faction absolutism; they embody his divergence and his empathy for multiple perspectives. When Tris touches them, the moment underscores their shared resistance to faction dogma. The Amity symbol on his spine, paired with Dauntless flames over his ribs, visually reconciles traits the factions consider opposites (peace and bravery). This physical mapping of ideologies mirrors Tris’s own internal conflict, making the tattoos a metaphor for the series’ central theme: that human beings cannot be confined to single virtues.

      4. What does Edward’s attitude toward his injury and factionlessness reveal about power dynamics in this society?

      Answer:
      Edward’s bitter humor about his “fortunate” one-eyed state critiques the brutality of faction life. His sarcasm (“I’d rather be factionless than Dauntless”) rejects Dauntless’s glorified violence, yet his pride in provoking Peter shows he internalized its competitive ethos. His story reveals how factions breed cycles of aggression: Edward’s retaliation led to his mutilation, which then fueled his disdain for the system. His factionless status grants him ironic clarity—he sees through Tobias’s Dauntless loyalty—but also leaves him marginalized. This highlights the lose-lose nature of the faction structure, where even “winners” like Edward become casualties.

      5. How does the chapter use the fire as a symbolic device?

      Answer:
      The fire serves as both a literal and metaphorical centerpiece. Physically, it provides warmth and communal meals, reflecting the factionless’s resourcefulness. Symbolically, its dwindling flames mirror Tris’s fading naivety about factions (e.g., her shock about Dauntless’s aging practices). The firelight also obscures intimate moments, like Tris touching Tobias’s tattoos, suggesting how their relationship thrives in shadows away from societal scrutiny. Later, as Tris falls asleep to its glow, the fire represents temporary refuge—its eventual fading parallels her awareness that safety is fleeting in their fractured world. The imagery reinforces the novel’s tension between destruction (fire’s danger) and renewal (its warmth).

    Quotes

    • 1. “Once the Dauntless reach a certain level of physical deterioration, they are asked to leave. In one way or another.”

      This quote reveals the harsh reality of the Dauntless faction’s treatment of aging members, exposing a dark underbelly of their society where physical capability determines worth. It marks a key moment of realization for Tris about her faction’s hidden cruelty.

      2. “Let’s just say that for some, death is preferable to factionlessness.”

      Tobias’s ominous statement underscores the extreme stigma attached to being factionless in this society, suggesting some Dauntless would rather die than lose their faction identity. This highlights the deep psychological impact of the faction system.

      3. “Noise and activity are the refuges of the bereaved and the guilty.”

      This poignant observation from Tris’s perspective reveals her emotional state and coping mechanisms after traumatic events. The lyrical phrasing captures a universal human truth about avoiding painful introspection through distraction.

      4. “I wish we were alone. I almost always wish that.”

      This intimate exchange between Tris and Tobias shows their constant yearning for privacy and connection amidst chaos. It humanizes them amidst the larger faction conflicts and represents one of their few moments of vulnerability.

    Quotes

    1. “Once the Dauntless reach a certain level of physical deterioration, they are asked to leave. In one way or another.”

    This quote reveals the harsh reality of the Dauntless faction’s treatment of aging members, exposing a dark underbelly of their society where physical capability determines worth. It marks a key moment of realization for Tris about her faction’s hidden cruelty.

    2. “Let’s just say that for some, death is preferable to factionlessness.”

    Tobias’s ominous statement underscores the extreme stigma attached to being factionless in this society, suggesting some Dauntless would rather die than lose their faction identity. This highlights the deep psychological impact of the faction system.

    3. “Noise and activity are the refuges of the bereaved and the guilty.”

    This poignant observation from Tris’s perspective reveals her emotional state and coping mechanisms after traumatic events. The lyrical phrasing captures a universal human truth about avoiding painful introspection through distraction.

    4. “I wish we were alone. I almost always wish that.”

    This intimate exchange between Tris and Tobias shows their constant yearning for privacy and connection amidst chaos. It humanizes them amidst the larger faction conflicts and represents one of their few moments of vulnerability.

    FAQs

    1. What does the conversation about Dauntless initiation reveal about the faction’s values and practices?

    Answer:
    The discussion between Tris, Tobias, and Edward reveals disturbing truths about Dauntless initiation and aging. Tobias explains that once Dauntless members reach a certain level of physical deterioration, they are forced to leave the faction—with the implication that some choose death over factionlessness. This highlights Dauntless’s extreme emphasis on physical capability and youth, valuing strength over wisdom or experience. The revelation about initiation failures (like Edward’s eye injury during a conflict with Peter) further underscores the faction’s brutal, survival-of-the-fittest mentality. These practices contrast sharply with the faction’s idealized image of bravery, showing how its culture prioritizes performance over compassion.

    2. How does Therese’s backstory reflect the flaws in Erudite’s faction system?

    Answer:
    Therese, a former Erudite, explains she was expelled for scoring too low on an initiation intelligence test and given the demeaning choice to either clean labs or leave. Her experience exposes Erudite’s rigid elitism and lack of tolerance for diverse abilities. The faction’s hyperfocus on intellectual superiority creates a hierarchy where those deemed “not smart enough” are discarded, mirroring the cruelty Tris later observes in Dauntless. This systemic exclusion demonstrates how factions fail to accommodate individual differences, forcing people like Therese into factionlessness. It also foreshadows the broader critique of faction divisions that Tris grapples with throughout the series.

    3. Analyze the significance of Tobias’s tattoos in this chapter. What do they symbolize?

    Answer:
    Tris notices Tobias’s tattoos—including Amity’s tree and the other faction symbols—as markers of his complex identity. The tattoos represent his rejection of faction absolutism; they embody his divergence and his empathy for multiple perspectives. When Tris touches them, the moment underscores their shared resistance to faction dogma. The Amity symbol on his spine, paired with Dauntless flames over his ribs, visually reconciles traits the factions consider opposites (peace and bravery). This physical mapping of ideologies mirrors Tris’s own internal conflict, making the tattoos a metaphor for the series’ central theme: that human beings cannot be confined to single virtues.

    4. What does Edward’s attitude toward his injury and factionlessness reveal about power dynamics in this society?

    Answer:
    Edward’s bitter humor about his “fortunate” one-eyed state critiques the brutality of faction life. His sarcasm (“I’d rather be factionless than Dauntless”) rejects Dauntless’s glorified violence, yet his pride in provoking Peter shows he internalized its competitive ethos. His story reveals how factions breed cycles of aggression: Edward’s retaliation led to his mutilation, which then fueled his disdain for the system. His factionless status grants him ironic clarity—he sees through Tobias’s Dauntless loyalty—but also leaves him marginalized. This highlights the lose-lose nature of the faction structure, where even “winners” like Edward become casualties.

    5. How does the chapter use the fire as a symbolic device?

    Answer:
    The fire serves as both a literal and metaphorical centerpiece. Physically, it provides warmth and communal meals, reflecting the factionless’s resourcefulness. Symbolically, its dwindling flames mirror Tris’s fading naivety about factions (e.g., her shock about Dauntless’s aging practices). The firelight also obscures intimate moments, like Tris touching Tobias’s tattoos, suggesting how their relationship thrives in shadows away from societal scrutiny. Later, as Tris falls asleep to its glow, the fire represents temporary refuge—its eventual fading parallels her awareness that safety is fleeting in their fractured world. The imagery reinforces the novel’s tension between destruction (fire’s danger) and renewal (its warmth).

    Note