Crown of Midnight (Throne of Glass Book 2)
Chapter 9
by J, Maas, SarahIn Chapter 9 of “Crown of Midnight,” Celaena visits Kaltain in the dungeon, where she is confined in harsh conditions with minimal provisions. Kaltain, weakened and disheveled, reveals her despair and hints at deeper schemes, suggesting she feels used by those in power. Their interaction is tense, with Kaltain providing cryptic comments about the influence of others and her own fractured memories, implying she is caught in a web of manipulation. Celaena’s concern grows as she observes Kaltain’s fragile state and the apparent injustice of her treatment, fueling her resolve to uncover the truth behind her imprisonment.
The chapter delves into the complex relationship between Celaena and Kaltain, emphasizing the girl’s mental and physical deterioration. Kaltain’s mention of her bruises and her admission that she is being kept in the dark about her purpose highlight her vulnerability and the sinister environment she endures. Celaena’s empathy is evident as she considers the cruelty inflicted upon Kaltain and reflects on the broader corruption within the court. The conversation underscores themes of betrayal and the loss of innocence amidst political machinations.
As Kaltain speaks of her fractured memories and her suspicion that she is being used for unknown purposes, Celaena begins to grasp the extent of the court’s manipulations. Kaltain hints at a looming threat, suggesting that something significant is approaching and that she is meant to “greet” it, adding a layer of foreboding to the narrative. Celaena’s decision to leave her cloak as a gesture of compassion underscores her internal conflict—she recognizes the girl’s suffering but also understands the danger of getting involved in court intrigues.
The chapter concludes with a reflection on the injustice faced by Kaltain and the broader implications of the court’s cruelty. Nehemia’s outrage about the guards’ neglect and the treatment of court members like Kaltain highlights the widespread corruption. The storm outside symbolizes the chaos and upheaval within the court and Celaena’s world. The chapter ends with a sense of impending change, as Kaltain’s cryptic warning about something coming hints at future conflicts and revelations that will challenge Celaena’s understanding of her enemies and allies alike.
FAQs
1. What does Celaena’s interaction with Kaltain reveal about her character and her motivations in this chapter?
Answer:
Celaena’s interaction with Kaltain demonstrates her complex sense of compassion and moral ambiguity. Despite Kaltain’s suffering and her own desire for justice, Celaena shows empathy by offering her cloak and engaging in a conversation that could potentially expose dangerous information. Her decision to listen and offer help indicates her internal conflict—she is driven by a desire to uncover truths and protect those she cares about, even if it means risking her own safety or challenging her perceptions of justice. This interaction also highlights her resourcefulness and her willingness to use her influence to aid someone in distress, revealing her layered personality as both a fighter and someone capable of empathy.2. How does the depiction of Kaltain’s imprisonment and her mental state contribute to the overall tension and themes of the chapter?
Answer:
The portrayal of Kaltain’s imprisonment—her cold, squalid cell, her physical bruises, and her fractured mental state—intensifies the chapter’s mood of despair and injustice. Her fragile mental condition, evidenced by her hallucinations and fragmented thoughts about being used, underscores themes of powerlessness and corruption within the court and the justice system. The mention of her bruises and her madness evoke a sense of cruelty and neglect, highlighting how those in power manipulate or mistreat weaker individuals. This depiction heightens the moral stakes for Celaena, emphasizing her role as an agent seeking truth and justice amidst a corrupt environment, and builds tension by revealing the extent of the court’s brutality.3. In what ways does the chapter hint at larger political or supernatural threats, and how might these influence the story’s direction?
Answer:
The chapter hints at larger threats through Kaltain’s cryptic remark that “something is coming, and I am to greet it,” suggesting an impending supernatural or political upheaval. Her mention of being used and her fragmented memories imply clandestine schemes and manipulations at court, possibly involving dark magic or dangerous alliances. These clues foreshadow that greater forces—beyond individual characters—are at play, which could influence the story’s direction by introducing new conflicts, such as the arrival of a supernatural entity or a political coup. This sense of an ominous, unseen threat adds suspense and suggests that the narrative will explore themes of power, magic, and destiny.4. How does Celaena’s decision to give her cloak to Kaltain reflect her moral priorities and her approach to justice?
Answer:
Celaena’s choice to give her cloak to Kaltain demonstrates her compassion and her desire to mitigate suffering, even in difficult circumstances. It indicates that she values mercy and recognizes the importance of small acts of kindness, which contrast with the cruelty of Kaltain’s imprisonment. This act also reveals her pragmatic approach to justice—she seeks to gather information and aid those who are wronged, rather than simply punishing or ignoring them. Her decision underscores her complex moral code, balancing strength with empathy, and her willingness to act against injustice, even if it involves risking her own safety or challenging authority.5. What does the chapter suggest about the nature of trust and deception within the court, particularly in relation to Roland Havilliard and the other characters?
Answer:
The chapter portrays a court rife with suspicion, secrets, and potential deception. Kaltain’s wary response about Roland Havilliard and her warning that “none of us can be trusted” underscore the atmosphere of distrust among courtiers and officials. Her cryptic comments about being used and her fragmented memories suggest manipulation and hidden agendas. Celaena’s probing questions reveal her suspicion of the political machinations at play, and her recognition that appearances are deceiving. This environment of distrust foreshadows that characters like Roland may have hidden motives, and that alliances are fragile—adding layers of complexity to the narrative and emphasizing the theme that trust must be earned in a treacherous political landscape.
Quotes
1. “They encourage the crows to fly past here,” Kaltain murmured, more to herself than to Celaena. “And my headaches are worse every day. Worse and worse, and full of all of those flapping wings.”
This haunting metaphor reveals Kaltain’s deteriorating mental state and introduces a sense of foreboding about her perception of her surroundings and her own mind. It underscores her fragility and the chapter’s overarching theme of confinement and unseen threats.
2. “Sometimes, I think they brought me here. Not to marry Perrington, but for another purpose. They want to use me.”
This line exposes Kaltain’s suspicion that her imprisonment is part of a larger, sinister plan beyond her understanding. It hints at manipulation and schemes within the court, emphasizing the chapter’s exploration of power, control, and betrayal.
3. “She should let Kaltain freeze to death for what she’d tried to do to her. She should walk out of the dungeons smiling, because for once the right person was locked away.”
This internal conflict highlights Celaena’s moral dilemma and the theme of justice versus mercy. It encapsulates her complex feelings about vengeance, power, and the moral gray areas she navigates.
4. “She was mad. Celaena clamped down the urge to make a cutting remark, the memory of Kaltain’s bruises staying her tongue. ‘Thank you for your help.’”
This moment illustrates Celaena’s recognition of Kaltain’s mental instability and her restraint in the face of provocation. It reflects her moral restraint and the subtlety with which she handles difficult situations, reinforcing her character’s depth.
5. “Something is coming, and I am to greet it.”
Kaltain’s cryptic statement signifies an impending event or threat, functioning as a foreshadowing device. It encapsulates the chapter’s tension and the sense that darker forces are at play, ready to unfold.
Quotes
1. “They encourage the crows to fly past here,” Kaltain murmured, more to herself than to Celaena. “And my headaches are worse every day. Worse and worse, and full of all of those flapping wings.”
This haunting metaphor reveals Kaltain’s deteriorating mental state and introduces a sense of foreboding about her perception of her surroundings and her own mind. It underscores her fragility and the chapter’s overarching theme of confinement and unseen threats.
2. “Sometimes, I think they brought me here. Not to marry Perrington, but for another purpose. They want to use me.”
This line exposes Kaltain’s suspicion that her imprisonment is part of a larger, sinister plan beyond her understanding. It hints at manipulation and schemes within the court, emphasizing the chapter’s exploration of power, control, and betrayal.
3. “She should let Kaltain freeze to death for what she’d tried to do to her. She should walk out of the dungeons smiling, because for once the right person was locked away.”
This internal conflict highlights Celaena’s moral dilemma and the theme of justice versus mercy. It encapsulates her complex feelings about vengeance, power, and the moral gray areas she navigates.
4. “She was mad. Celaena clamped down the urge to make a cutting remark, the memory of Kaltain’s bruises staying her tongue. ‘Thank you for your help.’”
This moment illustrates Celaena’s recognition of Kaltain’s mental instability and her restraint in the face of provocation. It reflects her moral restraint and the subtlety with which she handles difficult situations, reinforcing her character’s depth.
5. “Something is coming, and I am to greet it.”
Kaltain’s cryptic statement signifies an impending event or threat, functioning as a foreshadowing device. It encapsulates the chapter’s tension and the sense that darker forces are at play, ready to unfold.
— Unknown
FAQs
1. What does Celaena’s interaction with Kaltain reveal about her character and her motivations in this chapter?
Answer:
Celaena’s interaction with Kaltain demonstrates her complex sense of compassion and moral ambiguity. Despite Kaltain’s suffering and her own desire for justice, Celaena shows empathy by offering her cloak and engaging in a conversation that could potentially expose dangerous information. Her decision to listen and offer help indicates her internal conflict—she is driven by a desire to uncover truths and protect those she cares about, even if it means risking her own safety or challenging her perceptions of justice. This interaction also highlights her resourcefulness and her willingness to use her influence to aid someone in distress, revealing her layered personality as both a fighter and someone capable of empathy.
2. How does the depiction of Kaltain’s imprisonment and her mental state contribute to the overall tension and themes of the chapter?
Answer:
The portrayal of Kaltain’s imprisonment—her cold, squalid cell, her physical bruises, and her fractured mental state—intensifies the chapter’s mood of despair and injustice. Her fragile mental condition, evidenced by her hallucinations and fragmented thoughts about being used, underscores themes of powerlessness and corruption within the court and the justice system. The mention of her bruises and her madness evoke a sense of cruelty and neglect, highlighting how those in power manipulate or mistreat weaker individuals. This depiction heightens the moral stakes for Celaena, emphasizing her role as an agent seeking truth and justice amidst a corrupt environment, and builds tension by revealing the extent of the court’s brutality.
3. In what ways does the chapter hint at larger political or supernatural threats, and how might these influence the story’s direction?
Answer:
The chapter hints at larger threats through Kaltain’s cryptic remark that “something is coming, and I am to greet it,” suggesting an impending supernatural or political upheaval. Her mention of being used and her fragmented memories imply clandestine schemes and manipulations at court, possibly involving dark magic or dangerous alliances. These clues foreshadow that greater forces—beyond individual characters—are at play, which could influence the story’s direction by introducing new conflicts, such as the arrival of a supernatural entity or a political coup. This sense of an ominous, unseen threat adds suspense and suggests that the narrative will explore themes of power, magic, and destiny.
4. How does Celaena’s decision to give her cloak to Kaltain reflect her moral priorities and her approach to justice?
Answer:
Celaena’s choice to give her cloak to Kaltain demonstrates her compassion and her desire to mitigate suffering, even in difficult circumstances. It indicates that she values mercy and recognizes the importance of small acts of kindness, which contrast with the cruelty of Kaltain’s imprisonment. This act also reveals her pragmatic approach to justice—she seeks to gather information and aid those who are wronged, rather than simply punishing or ignoring them. Her decision underscores her complex moral code, balancing strength with empathy, and her willingness to act against injustice, even if it involves risking her own safety or challenging authority.
5. What does the chapter suggest about the nature of trust and deception within the court, particularly in relation to Roland Havilliard and the other characters?
Answer:
The chapter portrays a court rife with suspicion, secrets, and potential deception. Kaltain’s wary response about Roland Havilliard and her warning that “none of us can be trusted” underscore the atmosphere of distrust among courtiers and officials. Her cryptic comments about being used and her fragmented memories suggest manipulation and hidden agendas. Celaena’s probing questions reveal her suspicion of the political machinations at play, and her recognition that appearances are deceiving. This environment of distrust foreshadows that characters like Roland may have hidden motives, and that alliances are fragile—adding layers of complexity to the narrative and emphasizing the theme that trust must be earned in a treacherous political landscape.
0 Comments