Header Image
    Cover of Buttered Side Down
    Fiction

    Buttered Side Down

    by

    Part VIII begins in a dim hotel room where silence feels heav­ier than the cur­tains and lone­li­ness creeps in with­out apol­o­gy. The lead­ing lady of a small the­ater troupe, once radi­ant under stage lights, now sits hunched in a chair that scratch­es the wall­pa­per each time she shifts. Her make­up, once applied with pre­ci­sion, now smudges qui­et­ly as tears fall—not those the­atri­cal sobs that win ova­tions, but the qui­et kind that mark exhaus­tion. The scent of pow­der and fad­ed per­fume mix­es with the stale air of the room. This space isn’t grand—it is ser­vice­able, gener­ic, and far from the applause she’s used to. In her iso­la­tion, the glow of the the­ater is noth­ing but a mem­o­ry dimmed by dust.

    A wall plac­ard catch­es her eye. It’s not pro­found, just a reminder of the ser­vices offered to guests. Yet in that dull sig­nage, she sees oppor­tu­ni­ty: a chance for brief com­pan­ion­ship. When she press­es the buzzer, she doesn’t expect much. Cer­tain­ly not Pearlie Schultz. Pearlie arrives not in satin or silk, but in sim­ple cot­ton, her face open and free from pre­ten­sion. There’s noth­ing star-struck about her demeanor. Instead, she brings calm with every step, as if she had long since befriend­ed silence and knew how to tame it.

    They talk. Not of roles, cur­tain calls, or headlines—but of corset cov­ers and fam­i­ly recipes, of sewing pat­terns and the virtue of ging­ham. Pearlie doesn’t mar­vel at the lead­ing lady’s fame, nor does she fawn over her past per­for­mances. She treats her like some­one who need­ed a friend and noth­ing more. It is pre­cise­ly this absence of admi­ra­tion that offers relief. For once, the lead­ing lady isn’t cast as a role. She’s just a woman, bone-tired, long­ing to be seen out­side of cos­tume.

    Pearlie offers her more than kind words—she offers her an escape. A straw­ber­ry social, tucked in the folds of local rou­tine, promis­es fresh air and friend­ly chat­ter. For the actress, the idea is for­eign and deli­cious­ly absurd. But she agrees, drawn to the sim­plic­i­ty of it all. And there, among ging­ham table­cloths and paper lanterns, she finds what city lights and stage calls failed to give her—ease. Chil­dren tug at her hand, old ladies offer lemon­ade, and men nod as if they’ve seen her every Sun­day of the year.

    Intro­duced as Pearlie’s friend, she is giv­en a name instead of a title. There’s no pre­tense, no per­for­mance. Just her, free to laugh with­out script or motive. The crowd accepts her with warmth not because of who she is on stage, but because she showed up. That warmth does more to repair her spir­it than any review ever has. And Pearlie, who had offered noth­ing more than her­self, becomes the qui­et hero­ine of the tale.

    As night falls and the music winds down, the lead­ing lady clutch­es a paper cup, not wine but punch, and feels some­thing close to peace. Her feet hurt from stand­ing, her face aches from smiling—both gen­uine pains after a day well lived. She does­n’t promise to return to that life for­ev­er, but she knows now what she’s missed. That some­times com­fort isn’t a vel­vet cur­tain draw­ing to a close—it’s some­one ask­ing how you take your tea.

    This sto­ry, sub­tle as it is, holds more than a tale of strangers turned com­pan­ions. It reminds us that beneath every pol­ished role lies a per­son crav­ing sin­cer­i­ty. And often, it’s in the most unex­pect­ed places—a hotel plac­ard, a com­mon roof, a back­yard social—where the rich­est con­nec­tions are made. The mes­sage lingers: the need to be known not for our rep­u­ta­tions but for our qui­et, unper­formed selves.

    When Pearlie leaves that room, she does­n’t change the world. But she changes some­thing in the lead­ing lady—a small, last­ing shift. She reminds her that the­ater is not the only place to feel alive. That laugh­ter shared over pie or the trust exchanged in a smile can mean as much as applause. And that maybe, just maybe, real life is where the best per­for­mances happen—without an audi­ence at all.

    Quotes

    FAQs

    Note