
Allegiant
Chapter Twenty-Nine
by Roth, VeronicaTobias, restrained with plastic ties, reflects on his injuries and the chaotic aftermath of his arrest. Despite enduring worse pain before, the wild anger in the soldier’s eyes unsettles him. Nearby, Mary and Rafi sit wounded, separated by guards, with Rafi nodding approvingly at Tobias. Yet, Tobias feels a gnawing guilt, questioning the success of their mission. Reggie reassures him that Nita and the fringe group will take the blame, but Tobias remains uneasy about the prolonged silence from their captors and the absence of Nita, suspecting their actions may have caused fatalities.
The uncertainty deepens as Tobias confronts Reggie about Nita’s true intentions, realizing Tris was right—they were deceived about stealing memory serum. A guard interrupts their conversation, reinforcing the tense atmosphere. Tris arrives, bandaged and bloodied, delivering updates about David’s critical condition and other injuries. Tobias’s guilt intensifies as he grapples with the destruction caused by their actions, realizing he participated in something far more sinister without knowing the full truth.
Tris confronts Tobias with the harsh reality: his allies sought poison to assassinate government officials and incite war. Her voice trembles with anger as she reveals Uriah’s grave condition, injured by one of their diversionary explosives. The news strikes Tobias like a physical blow, flooding him with memories of Uriah’s vibrant personality and his broken promise to protect him. Tris’s words underscore the irreversible damage done, leaving Tobias shattered by the consequences of his blind trust.
The chapter closes with Tris expressing her devastation, unsure if she can ever reconcile with Tobias. His remorse is palpable as he faces the weight of his actions—betrayal, unintended casualties, and the potential loss of a dear friend. The emotional confrontation leaves Tobias questioning his judgment and the irreversible fractures in his relationships, marking a pivotal moment of reckoning in the narrative.
FAQs
1. What was Tobias’s physical and emotional state at the beginning of the chapter, and what do these details reveal about his character?
Answer:
Tobias begins the chapter with stinging wrists from plastic ties and a sore jaw from being struck by a guard’s gun. While he downplays these injuries as minor compared to past experiences, his emotional state is more complex. He feels sick to his stomach despite Rafi’s approving nod, showing his growing unease about the mission’s morality. This reveals key aspects of his character: physical resilience (dismissing pain) but deep moral sensitivity (questioning consequences). His later realization about Nita’s lies and the attack’s true purpose intensifies this internal conflict, showing his capacity for remorse when principles are violated.2. How does Tris’s arrival and revelation about the attack’s true purpose serve as a turning point in the chapter?
Answer:
Tris’s appearance with news about David’s injuries and Uriah’s critical condition forces Tobias to confront the devastating reality of the attack. Her revelation that Nita’s group sought deadly poison (not memory serum) to assassinate government officials reframes the entire mission as an act of terrorism rather than rebellion. This moment is pivotal because it: 1) confirms Tris was right about Nita’s deception, 2) exposes the human cost (David paralyzed, Uriah possibly dying), and 3) shatters Tobias’s trust in his allies. The “blow to the head” metaphor underscores how this truth fundamentally alters his understanding of events.3. Analyze how the guards’ treatment of Tris contrasts with their treatment of the prisoners, and what this reveals about power dynamics in their society.
Answer:
The guards initially challenge Tris (“What are you doing here?”) but quickly defer when learning she saved David, even allowing her to speak with Tobias despite rules against prisoner communication. This contrasts sharply with their harsh treatment of Tobias (gun threats, enforced silence). The dynamic reveals a tiered system of respect: 1) Heroes like Tris who protect authority figures (David) gain privileges, 2) Rebels like Tobias lose basic dignities, and 3) Guards like Shelly rigidly enforce these hierarchies. The exception made for Tris shows how personal connections to power (saving the leader) can temporarily override rules, highlighting the society’s transactional nature.4. What is the significance of Tobias’s repeated internal question “What did I do?” and how does it develop the novel’s themes?
Answer:
This haunting refrain appears twice—first when Tobias learns of the injuries, then after Tris’s revelations—marking his escalating guilt. It underscores the theme of moral accountability in rebellion, questioning whether ignorance excuses complicity. His physical participation (helping the attackers) clashes with his lack of true knowledge (not knowing about the poison), mirroring larger questions about collective responsibility in violent movements. The question also personalizes the theme of unintended consequences, as Tobias never intended harm to Uriah or David. This introspection makes him a foil to Nita’s ends-justify-means philosophy, emphasizing the novel’s exploration of ethical boundaries in resistance.5. How does the chapter use physical barriers as metaphors for the deteriorating relationship between Tris and Tobias?
Answer:
Three key physical barriers symbolize their emotional rift: 1) The guard who initially separates them represents Tobias’s choices alienating Tris, 2) The space Tris maintains during their conversation (“not that close”) mirrors her emotional distance, and 3) Her folded arms create a “wall” between them, emphasizing her anger and betrayal. Even eye contact—something Tobias normally craves—becomes painful as it “takes him apart.” These barriers contrast with their usual closeness, showing how Tobias’s trust in Nita has damaged their foundational trust. The tied hands also symbolize his helplessness to fix what’s broken, foreshadowing potential irreparable damage to their relationship.
Quotes
1. “If I did well, why do I feel sick to my stomach?”
This quote captures Tobias’s internal conflict after participating in the attack. Despite receiving approval from Rafi, he feels deep unease about his actions, foreshadowing the moral reckoning to come.
2. “I know of nothing that shakes people up as much as lost lives.”
A profound observation about human nature and the gravity of violence. This line reveals Tobias’s growing realization that their actions may have had deadly consequences.
3. “Tris was right. Nita was lying.”
This pivotal moment shows Tobias confronting the truth about the mission’s deception. The simple, stark admission carries significant emotional weight as he realizes he’s been manipulated.
4. “It’s strange how a word, a phrase, a sentence, can feel like a blow to the head.”
This beautifully crafted line describes Tobias’s visceral reaction to learning about Uriah’s condition. It powerfully conveys how information can have physical impact.
5. “I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to look at you the same way again.”
Tris’s devastating statement represents the emotional climax of the chapter. This quote marks a potential breaking point in their relationship due to Tobias’s choices and their consequences.