
Allegiant
Chapter Twenty-Five
by Roth, VeronicaTobias and Tris meet Nita in a hotel lobby for a secretive midnight rendezvous. Nita is visibly upset that Tobias brought Tris, accusing him of breaking his promise to protect her. Tris sharply points out that Nita manipulated Tobias by appealing to his protective instincts, which unsettles him as he realizes he may have been deceived. Nita defends her actions, insisting she was trying to prevent Tris from being arrested for knowing classified information, and reluctantly agrees to let Tris join their mission.
The trio proceeds to a laboratory deep within the compound, where the atmosphere is tense and clandestine. They meet Reggie, Nita’s ally, who is also genetically damaged (GD). Reggie shows them a series of disturbing historical images depicting suffering and war, suggesting the Bureau has hidden the truth about past conflicts. The photographs, showing outdated weapons and atrocities, imply that genetically pure people were responsible for ancient wars, contradicting the Bureau’s narrative. Tobias and Tris are visibly shaken by the graphic evidence.
Nita and Reggie argue that the Bureau is not just misinformed but actively harmful, citing their involvement in the attack simulation that led to the Abnegation massacre. Tris struggles to reconcile this with her belief that the Bureau means well, while Tobias questions their motives, pointing out the inconsistency in the Bureau supposedly valuing genetically pure individuals yet aiding in their destruction. Tris recalls Evelyn’s claim that the Divergent were most common among the factionless, not Abnegation, adding another layer of doubt.
The chapter culminates in a revelation of the Bureau’s darker role in the factions’ conflicts, leaving Tobias and Tris to grapple with the implications. Nita’s revolutionary fervor becomes more pronounced as she accuses the Bureau of enabling violence. The encounter forces Tobias and Tris to confront the possibility that their trust in the Bureau is misplaced, setting the stage for a deeper exploration of truth and betrayal in the chapters to come.
FAQs
1. What was Nita’s initial reaction to seeing Tris with Tobias, and what does this reveal about her motives?
Answer:
Nita’s face tightened “like she just tasted something bitter” when she saw Tris with Tobias, indicating her displeasure at Tris’s presence. This reaction suggests Nita had intended to keep Tris unaware of their plans, possibly to protect her from danger or to maintain control over the information being shared. Nita later explains that knowing certain truths could lead to Tris’s arrest, implying her motives might be protective. However, Tris interprets Nita’s earlier statement to Tobias about “protecting her” as manipulation, highlighting the tension between Nita’s stated intentions and her methods.2. How does the chapter portray the theme of deception, and which characters demonstrate it?
Answer:
The chapter explores deception through multiple characters. Tobias reflects on his own tendency to lie rather than face difficult truths, admitting he might have “welcomed the chance to deceive” Tris. Nita is accused of manipulating Tobias by framing secrecy as protection. Meanwhile, the Bureau’s alleged cover-up of historical wars and their collaboration with Jeanine represents institutional deception. These layers of dishonesty create a climate of distrust, with even well-intentioned characters like Nita and Tobias struggling with ethical boundaries between protection and manipulation.3. What evidence does Reggie present to challenge the Bureau’s official history, and why is it significant?
Answer:
Reggie shows grayscale photographs of historical suffering, including malnourished children and mass graves, which appear outdated compared to Purity War technology. He points to an antique gun in one image, arguing it predates genetic manipulation, proving genetically “pure” people waged wars long before the Bureau’s narrative begins. This evidence undermines the Bureau’s claim that genetic damage caused societal collapse, suggesting instead that violence is inherent to humanity regardless of genetic status. The disturbing images create an emotional appeal that complements the logical argument about historical inaccuracy.4. How does Tris respond to the revelations about the Bureau’s actions, and what does this reveal about her character?
Answer:
Initially, Tris maintains a calm facade (“still water”) despite the horrific images, but subtle quivers in her expression betray her shock. She attempts to rationalize the Bureau’s deception as well-intentioned misinformation rather than malice, showing her inclination toward fairness and reluctance to condemn without proof. However, when confronted with evidence of the Bureau supplying Jeanine with attack serums, her defensive reaction (“talking too fast, nervous”) reveals cognitive dissonance—she struggles to reconcile these actions with her emerging trust in the Bureau. This highlights her analytical nature and emotional resilience.5. What contradiction arises regarding the Bureau’s treatment of the Divergent/Abnegation, and how do characters attempt to resolve it?
Answer:
Tobias points out a paradox: if the Bureau values genetically pure individuals (Divergent) enough to send someone to save them, why would they help Jeanine destroy Abnegation (supposedly Divergent-heavy)? Tris resolves this by citing Evelyn’s claim that the factionless actually had the most Divergent, implying Jeanine’s data was flawed. This debate underscores the characters’ struggle to interpret the Bureau’s inconsistent actions—protecting Divergent while enabling their massacre—which either suggests bureaucratic incompetence or hidden motives not yet revealed in the chapter.
Quotes
1. “I can usually rely on myself to see a person’s ulterior motives, or to invent them in my mind, but I was so used to my desire to protect Tris, especially after almost losing her, that I didn’t even think twice.”
This quote reveals Tobias’s internal conflict about his protective instincts toward Tris, showing how his emotional attachment may have clouded his judgment. It marks a moment of self-awareness about his own vulnerabilities.
2. “People are isolated, starving. They know only what they’re taught, they see only the information that’s made available to them. And who controls all that? The government.”
Nita’s powerful statement encapsulates the chapter’s central theme of government manipulation and information control. This quote represents the revolutionary perspective being presented to Tris and Tobias about the Bureau’s true nature.
3. “When the Abnegation wanted to reveal the great truth of their world sooner than they were supposed to…the Bureau was all too happy to provide [Jeanine] with an incredibly advanced simulation serum.”
This shocking revelation connects the Bureau directly to the events in Chicago, showing their complicity in the attack on Abnegation. It serves as a key turning point in the chapter’s argument against the Bureau’s morality.
4. “Jeanine was wrong. Evelyn said so. The highest proportion of Divergent was among the factionless, not Abnegation.”
Tris’s interjection challenges previous assumptions about genetic purity distribution, hinting at deeper layers of deception. This quote shows characters grappling with conflicting information about their world’s fundamental truths.