Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Insurgent
    Adventure FictionScience FictionYoung Adult

    Insurgent

    by Veronica, Roth
    “Insurgent” by Veronica Roth is the second installment in the Divergent trilogy, a dystopian young adult series set in a post-apocalyptic Chicago. The novel follows protagonist Tris Prior as she navigates the aftermath of a faction-based society’s collapse, grappling with grief, identity, and loyalty. Amidst escalating conflict, Tris and her allies uncover dark secrets about their world while facing moral dilemmas and personal betrayals. The story explores themes of revolution, societal control, and the consequences of choices. As a sequel to the bestselling “Divergent,” “Insurgent” expands the series’ dystopian framework and sets the stage for the trilogy’s conclusion.
    PreviousNext
    Insurgent

    Chapter Seventeen

    by Veronica, Roth

    The chap­ter opens with Tobias recount­ing how Cara, Will’s old­er sis­ter and an Eru­dite, helped loy­al Daunt­less escape dur­ing the attack. She led them to a fire escape, allow­ing them to regroup and ambush the Daunt­less trai­tors, who were unpre­pared for the resis­tance. The trai­tors fled, believ­ing only the Diver­gent were con­scious. This rev­e­la­tion high­lights Cara’s unex­pect­ed alliance and the strate­gic turn­ing point for the loy­al Daunt­less.

    Tris dis­cov­ers a strange met­al disc embed­ded in her shoul­der, which she painful­ly removes using a knife. The disc has a nee­dle attached and leaves blue dye under her skin, sug­gest­ing an injec­tion of unknown pur­pose. She spec­u­lates it’s not lethal, as the attack­ers could have killed them out­right. This moment under­scores the mys­tery of the Erudite’s motives and the unset­tling nature of the injec­tion.

    Uri­ah enters the restroom, notic­ing Tris’s injury and the removed nee­dle. Their con­ver­sa­tion shifts to the after­math of the attack, with Uri­ah reveal­ing Eric is alive but under inter­ro­ga­tion by Can­dor. Tris and Uri­ah puz­zle over the Erudite’s actions, ques­tion­ing why they tar­get­ed the Diver­gent when Jea­nine already con­trols an army. Tris the­o­rizes Jea­nine seeks con­trol, pos­si­bly plan­ning anoth­er sim­u­la­tion to elim­i­nate resis­tance.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Uri­ah ask­ing Tris to keep his Diver­gence a secret, fear­ing Shauna’s reac­tion. Tris agrees, high­light­ing the ongo­ing stig­ma around Diver­gence. Their dis­cus­sion rein­forces the themes of trust and fear with­in the fac­tion sys­tem, while leav­ing the pur­pose of the injec­tions and Jeanine’s plans unre­solved, set­ting the stage for fur­ther con­flict.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. What strategic advantage did Cara provide to the loyal Dauntless during the attack, and why was this significant?

      Answer:
      Cara provided a critical strategic advantage by leading a group of loyal Dauntless, including Tobias, to an unsealed fire escape on a higher level of the building. This allowed them to evade the Dauntless traitors who had clustered around the elevator banks. By splitting into four groups and storming the stairwells simultaneously, they surrounded the traitors, who were unprepared for such resistance. This was significant because the traitors assumed only the Divergent were conscious, making their retreat inevitable. Cara’s quick thinking and knowledge of the building’s layout turned the tide in favor of the loyalists.

      2. Analyze the implications of the injection Tris discovers in her arm. What does this reveal about Jeanine’s broader plans?

      Answer:
      The injection Tris finds—a metal disc with a needle and blue dye—suggests Jeanine is deploying a new method of control rather than outright killing. Unlike the previous simulation serum, this injection seems designed for an unknown purpose, possibly to identify or manipulate the Divergent. Tris speculates Jeanine wants control over society, not annihilation, as each faction serves a functional role. The injection may precede another simulation, ensuring compliance or elimination of resisters. This reveals Jeanine’s calculated approach: she seeks to dominate the population systematically, targeting the Divergent as threats to her authority.

      3. How does Uriah’s request for Tris to keep his Divergence secret reflect the societal tensions in their world?

      Answer:
      Uriah’s request highlights the pervasive fear and stigma surrounding Divergence. Despite being allies, Shauna (and others) might view him differently if they knew, underscoring how deeply Jeanine’s propaganda has influenced perceptions. This mirrors broader societal tensions where Divergents are hunted as destabilizing forces. Uriah’s concern about losing trust shows how fear fractures relationships, even among friends. The moment also reinforces Tris’s isolation as a known Divergent, emphasizing the psychological toll of being both a target and a symbol of resistance.

      4. Evaluate the significance of the Candor’s decision to treat Eric medically. What does this reveal about their faction’s values?

      Answer:
      The Candor’s choice to provide Eric medical treatment, despite his role as an antagonist, reflects their commitment to justice and ethical consistency. Kang’s insistence on interrogating Eric privately (“honorable treatment of prisoners”) underscores their belief in due process, even for enemies. This contrasts with Dauntless impulsiveness or Erudite ruthlessness, showcasing Candor’s rigid moral code. However, Tris and Uriah’s scorn (“disturbing the peace or whatever”) hints at friction between pragmatic survival and ideological purity—a tension central to the factions’ clash.

      5. What does Tris’s physical state (injured jaw, fingernail marks) symbolize about her role in the conflict?

      Answer:
      Tris’s visible injuries—swollen jaw from Eric’s gun and self-inflicted wounds from removing the needle—symbolize her dual struggle against external oppression and internal resilience. The jaw injury represents violence from enemies (Eric/Erudite), while the fingernail marks signify her painful, determined resistance (“gritting my teeth”). Her reflection (“disgusting”) mirrors her emotional scars, yet she persists. Physically marked but unbroken, Tris embodies the cost of defiance and the relentless burden of leadership in a war where her body and mind are battlegrounds.

    Quotes

    • 1. “The Dauntless traitors were not prepared for that much resistance. They thought everyone but the Divergent was unconscious, so they ran.”

      This quote highlights a key tactical turning point in the chapter, where the loyal Dauntless outmaneuver the traitors. It underscores the theme of underestimated resilience and the strategic advantage of surprise in conflict.

      2. “Jeanine doesn’t want to kill everyone. She knows that would be illogical. Without each faction, society doesn’t function, because each faction trains its members for particular jobs. What she wants is control.”

      This passage reveals the antagonist’s calculated motives—prioritizing systemic control over mindless destruction. It crystallizes the core ideological conflict of the series: order vs. autonomy, and the manipulation of societal structures for power.

      3. “She must be planning another simulation. Same thing as before, but this time, she wants to make sure that everyone is either under its influence or dead.”

      A chilling hypothesis about the antagonist’s next move, this quote foreshadows escalating stakes. It ties the physical conflict (the injections) to the broader thematic struggle against psychological domination.

      4. “Not like Tobias, who is almost shy when he smiles, like he is surprised you bothered to look at him in the first place.”

      Amidst the chaos, this introspective observation about Tobias contrasts his vulnerability with Uriah’s confidence. It humanizes the characters during tense moments, reinforcing the emotional core of the narrative.

      5. “Don’t tell anyone I’m Divergent. Shauna’s my friend, and I don’t want her to suddenly become afraid of me.”

      This plea from Uriah encapsulates the stigma and fear surrounding Divergence. It personalizes the broader societal conflict, showing how prejudice fractures even close relationships.

    Quotes

    1. “The Dauntless traitors were not prepared for that much resistance. They thought everyone but the Divergent was unconscious, so they ran.”

    This quote highlights a key tactical turning point in the chapter, where the loyal Dauntless outmaneuver the traitors. It underscores the theme of underestimated resilience and the strategic advantage of surprise in conflict.

    2. “Jeanine doesn’t want to kill everyone. She knows that would be illogical. Without each faction, society doesn’t function, because each faction trains its members for particular jobs. What she wants is control.”

    This passage reveals the antagonist’s calculated motives—prioritizing systemic control over mindless destruction. It crystallizes the core ideological conflict of the series: order vs. autonomy, and the manipulation of societal structures for power.

    3. “She must be planning another simulation. Same thing as before, but this time, she wants to make sure that everyone is either under its influence or dead.”

    A chilling hypothesis about the antagonist’s next move, this quote foreshadows escalating stakes. It ties the physical conflict (the injections) to the broader thematic struggle against psychological domination.

    4. “Not like Tobias, who is almost shy when he smiles, like he is surprised you bothered to look at him in the first place.”

    Amidst the chaos, this introspective observation about Tobias contrasts his vulnerability with Uriah’s confidence. It humanizes the characters during tense moments, reinforcing the emotional core of the narrative.

    5. “Don’t tell anyone I’m Divergent. Shauna’s my friend, and I don’t want her to suddenly become afraid of me.”

    This plea from Uriah encapsulates the stigma and fear surrounding Divergence. It personalizes the broader societal conflict, showing how prejudice fractures even close relationships.

    FAQs

    1. What strategic advantage did Cara provide to the loyal Dauntless during the attack, and why was this significant?

    Answer:
    Cara provided a critical strategic advantage by leading a group of loyal Dauntless, including Tobias, to an unsealed fire escape on a higher level of the building. This allowed them to evade the Dauntless traitors who had clustered around the elevator banks. By splitting into four groups and storming the stairwells simultaneously, they surrounded the traitors, who were unprepared for such resistance. This was significant because the traitors assumed only the Divergent were conscious, making their retreat inevitable. Cara’s quick thinking and knowledge of the building’s layout turned the tide in favor of the loyalists.

    2. Analyze the implications of the injection Tris discovers in her arm. What does this reveal about Jeanine’s broader plans?

    Answer:
    The injection Tris finds—a metal disc with a needle and blue dye—suggests Jeanine is deploying a new method of control rather than outright killing. Unlike the previous simulation serum, this injection seems designed for an unknown purpose, possibly to identify or manipulate the Divergent. Tris speculates Jeanine wants control over society, not annihilation, as each faction serves a functional role. The injection may precede another simulation, ensuring compliance or elimination of resisters. This reveals Jeanine’s calculated approach: she seeks to dominate the population systematically, targeting the Divergent as threats to her authority.

    3. How does Uriah’s request for Tris to keep his Divergence secret reflect the societal tensions in their world?

    Answer:
    Uriah’s request highlights the pervasive fear and stigma surrounding Divergence. Despite being allies, Shauna (and others) might view him differently if they knew, underscoring how deeply Jeanine’s propaganda has influenced perceptions. This mirrors broader societal tensions where Divergents are hunted as destabilizing forces. Uriah’s concern about losing trust shows how fear fractures relationships, even among friends. The moment also reinforces Tris’s isolation as a known Divergent, emphasizing the psychological toll of being both a target and a symbol of resistance.

    4. Evaluate the significance of the Candor’s decision to treat Eric medically. What does this reveal about their faction’s values?

    Answer:
    The Candor’s choice to provide Eric medical treatment, despite his role as an antagonist, reflects their commitment to justice and ethical consistency. Kang’s insistence on interrogating Eric privately (“honorable treatment of prisoners”) underscores their belief in due process, even for enemies. This contrasts with Dauntless impulsiveness or Erudite ruthlessness, showcasing Candor’s rigid moral code. However, Tris and Uriah’s scorn (“disturbing the peace or whatever”) hints at friction between pragmatic survival and ideological purity—a tension central to the factions’ clash.

    5. What does Tris’s physical state (injured jaw, fingernail marks) symbolize about her role in the conflict?

    Answer:
    Tris’s visible injuries—swollen jaw from Eric’s gun and self-inflicted wounds from removing the needle—symbolize her dual struggle against external oppression and internal resilience. The jaw injury represents violence from enemies (Eric/Erudite), while the fingernail marks signify her painful, determined resistance (“gritting my teeth”). Her reflection (“disgusting”) mirrors her emotional scars, yet she persists. Physically marked but unbroken, Tris embodies the cost of defiance and the relentless burden of leadership in a war where her body and mind are battlegrounds.

    Note