
Insurgent
Chapter Ten
by Veronica, RothThe chapter opens with Tris, the protagonist, exhausted and in need of a shower after enduring physical strain. She enters a crowded bathroom where factionless women are bathing, highlighting the lack of privacy in their current circumstances. Susan, a former Abnegation member, offers her a towel for modesty, and their conversation reveals the strained yet caring dynamic between them. Tris reflects on how their lives have diverged from the peaceful future they once imagined, hinting at her guilt for leaving Abnegation and the upheaval caused by faction conflicts.
As Tris and Susan continue their conversation, Susan mentions a safe house for Abnegation refugees, emphasizing the ongoing displacement caused by the Erudite’s aggression. Tris encourages Susan to join her faction, prioritizing their needs over her own. The shared moment of bathing from a sink underscores their resilience and adaptability in dire conditions. Their dialogue touches on regret and missed opportunities, revealing the emotional toll of their fractured society and the personal sacrifices they’ve made.
After leaving the bathroom, Tris observes factionless members preparing to paint coded messages on billboards, a clever communication strategy devised by Evelyn, a former Erudite turned factionless leader. Evelyn’s pride in her plan mirrors the arrogance Tris associates with Erudite. Their exchange takes a dramatic turn when Evelyn reveals that Tris’s father was originally from Erudite, a shocking revelation that challenges Tris’s understanding of her family history. This disclosure adds depth to her father’s hatred for Erudite, suggesting a personal vendetta.
The chapter concludes with Tris confronting Evelyn, accusing her of manipulating Tobias and reopening old wounds. Tris’s sharp intuition and defiance shine through as she refuses to be swayed by Evelyn’s tactics. The tension between them underscores the broader power struggles within the factionless community. Tris’s determination to protect Tobias and her growing distrust of Evelyn set the stage for further conflict, highlighting her evolving role as a leader and her resilience in the face of betrayal and manipulation.
FAQs
1. How does the bathroom scene between Tris and Susan reveal the lingering effects of their Abnegation upbringing despite their current circumstances?
Answer:
The bathroom interaction showcases how both characters still carry Abnegation values despite leaving the faction. Susan maintains faction etiquette by asking “How are you?” even though Tris recognizes it’s perfunctory (noting “faction rules dictate that she does”). Their mutual towel-holding demonstrates self-sacrifice—Susan provides privacy first, then Tris endures arm pain to return the favor. Susan’s comment about their imagined future (“have our kids walk to the bus stop together”) reveals persistent Abnegation ideals about community. Even their clothing choices reflect faction roots: Susan buttons her collar to her throat, maintaining modesty, while Tris notices this represents “the Abnegation modesty to the point of discomfort.”2. Analyze how Evelyn’s revelation about Tris’s father being former Erudite serves both plot development and character insight.
Answer:
This bombshell revelation advances the plot by: 1) Explaining Marcus’s vehement hatred of Erudite as personal rather than ideological (“his hatred… must have been personal”), 2) Creating new tension between Tris and Jeanine by revealing their fathers’ childhood connection, and 3) Foreshadowing potential revelations about Tris’s divergence. For character insight, it: 1) Forces Tris to reinterpret her father’s silence about his past (“He never talked about his family”), 2) Highlights Evelyn’s manipulative tendencies by timing this sensitive disclosure, and 3) Deepens Tris’s identity crisis as she processes another layer of her father’s hidden life. The absurd mental image of Marcus and Jeanine sharing books underscores how this disrupts Tris’s understanding of faction divisions.3. What strategic purpose does Evelyn’s billboard coding system serve, and how does her presentation of it reveal her leadership style?
Answer:
The billboard system uses personal details (“so-and-so’s favorite color… childhood pet”) to create factionless communication codes that outsiders can’t decipher. This demonstrates strategic thinking by: 1) Utilizing public spaces covertly, 2) Leveraging intimate factionless knowledge for security, and 3) Establishing organized resistance networks. Evelyn’s presentation—casually mentioning it then shrugging (“She is anything but nonchalant”)—reveals her leadership as calculated and image-conscious. Her visible pride mirrors Jeanine’s expression when showcasing serums, suggesting similar authoritarian tendencies. By sharing this with Tris specifically, Evelyn strategically displays competence while testing Tris’s reaction to factionless ingenuity, revealing her manipulative approach to gaining influence.4. Compare how Tris and Susan each cope with their disrupted faction identities in this chapter.
Answer:
Tris copes through defiance and dark humor—mocking Evelyn’s Erudite past (“Guess you couldn’t keep up with academia”) and immediately calling out manipulation (“Yes, you did” when Evelyn feigns apology). Susan adapts through service, offering to stay with Tris despite wanting to join Abnegation refugees (“Unless you need my help”). While Tris confronts uncomfortable truths head-on (the revelation about her father), Susan avoids conflict, changing subjects when emotions surface (“I’m done. Can you hand me that towel?”). Their differences highlight how Dauntless and Abnegation conditioning shape coping mechanisms—Tris’s directness versus Susan’s avoidance—while showing both still struggle with faction identity loss.
Quotes
1. “This is a situation I never thought we would be in together… Bathing from the sink of an abandoned building, on the run from the Erudite.”
This quote captures the stark contrast between the characters’ former lives and their current reality of survival, highlighting the dramatic societal collapse and their unexpected alliance in adversity.
2. “I thought we would live near each other… Go to social events together. Have our kids walk to the bus stop together.”
Susan’s lament reveals the profound loss of normalcy and the broken social fabric of their world, while also showing the personal cost of the protagonist’s faction choice.
3. “Your father was born in Erudite… Your father and Jeanine used to play together as children.”
This shocking revelation about the protagonist’s father recontextualizes his character and motivations, suggesting his anti-Erudite stance may have been deeply personal rather than purely ideological.
4. “Except: His hatred of Erudite was so vehement it must have been personal.”
This internal realization marks a turning point in the protagonist’s understanding of her father and the faction conflicts, suggesting hidden histories and personal betrayals behind the political strife.
5. “I’m not stupid… I can see that you’re trying to use him.”
This defiant statement shows the protagonist’s growing political awareness and willingness to confront manipulation, setting up future conflicts with Evelyn and the factionless leadership.