Header Image
    Cover of Buttered Side Down
    Fiction

    Buttered Side Down

    by

    Part XI opens with a del­i­cate blend of the per­son­al and pro­fes­sion­al, cap­tur­ing a day in Mary Louise’s life when inspi­ra­tion feels far away. Her hair needs wash­ing, but what she real­ly wants is clarity—a fresh idea for a sto­ry that refus­es to move for­ward. The small task of hair care, often triv­i­al­ized, becomes a reflec­tion of her emo­tion­al state. There’s no back­yard to enjoy the sun, no porch to rest on—just the roof of her New York build­ing, where she heads with pars­ley in hand. The act feels almost rit­u­al­is­tic, an effort to recon­nect with some­thing more root­ed than city pave­ment. Here, sun­light meets soli­tude, and a stranger unex­pect­ed­ly breaks both.

    The man who appears is ragged, smart-mouthed, and unim­pressed by her qui­et rit­u­al. His sar­casm clash­es with her sin­cer­i­ty, yet some­thing about Mary Louise’s demeanor unset­tles his cyn­i­cism. Their con­ver­sa­tion shifts between light teas­ing and sharp insights, grad­u­al­ly peel­ing back the lay­ers of Mary Louise’s aspi­ra­tions. She speaks not of dreams, but of plans—clear steps from Escan­a­ba to mag­a­zine bylines, from class­room to man­u­script. Her voice doesn’t trem­ble with doubt, only exhaus­tion from the weight of unac­knowl­edged effort. He notices this, and his tone soft­ens. He doesn’t mock her ambi­tion; instead, he chal­lenges her to recon­sid­er where her real mate­r­i­al lies.

    Mary Louise lis­tens, not because she needs advice, but because the roof, the sun, and the com­pa­ny offer a rare moment of still­ness. His suggestion—that she write not what she thinks peo­ple want but what only she can offer—sticks. He points toward her past, her home, and the rhythms of coun­try life as a reser­voir she has yet to ful­ly draw from. She nods, per­haps not ful­ly con­vinced, but open to the idea that authen­tic­i­ty is more com­pelling than inven­tion. For her, that means turn­ing away from gener­ic tales and toward what she knows best: rur­al voic­es, qui­et morn­ings, small tri­umphs, and hair washed in kitchen basins. This shift, how­ev­er sub­tle, feels like a break­through.

    The encounter doesn’t end with a dra­mat­ic rev­e­la­tion, but some­thing in Mary Louise clicks back into place. The man’s off­hand remarks and prob­ing curios­i­ty spark a real­iza­tion: rejec­tion doesn’t mean misdirection—it might sim­ply mean mis­align­ment. She has been try­ing to fit into a mold that doesn’t match her mate­r­i­al. Instead of chas­ing after sleek urban sto­ries, she could share the warmth of fire­wood morn­ings, the cadence of a small-town Sun­day, or the qui­et pow­er of women wash­ing their hair in bor­rowed sun­shine. Her writ­ing, like her life, doesn’t need to imitate—it needs to reveal.

    Back in her apart­ment, she approach­es her desk with a dif­fer­ent resolve. Her character—the life­less man in her manuscript—might be set aside for now. Instead, she begins a new sto­ry, one about a girl with pars­ley in her hands, sun­light in her hair, and some­thing to say. The voice she writes with is her own. Each word reflects some­thing truer than before. The scene on the roof doesn’t dis­ap­pear; it set­tles into her mem­o­ry like a seed, one that may bloom lat­er in pages not yet writ­ten.

    As evening falls, the city con­tin­ues its buzz, unaware of Mary Louise’s qui­et break­through. Her world hasn’t changed vis­i­bly, but some­thing inside has shift­ed. She still faces rejec­tions, bills, and uncer­tain­ty, but now they are matched with direc­tion. Some­times, growth is not about grand suc­cess, but about choos­ing to stay. To stay in the room, in the work, in the dis­com­fort of per­sis­tence. Mary Louise, now a lit­tle more cer­tain, writes not because she’s sure of her­self, but because writ­ing is how she sur­vives. And sur­vival, in a city that for­gets peo­ple too eas­i­ly, is its own small tri­umph.

    Quotes

    FAQs

    Note