Header Image
    Cover of Buttered Side Down
    Fiction

    Buttered Side Down

    by

    Part VI opens with Effie Bauer stand­ing con­fi­dent­ly behind the per­fume counter, her poise shaped by years of self-dis­ci­pline and hard-earned exper­tise in depart­ment store pres­tige. She knows how to match a fra­grance to a customer’s per­son­al­i­ty, just as she has learned to tai­lor her own com­po­sure to a life lived solo. Though admired for her pol­ished man­ners and taste­ful fash­ion, she often walks home to a qui­et apart­ment, where silence greets her more faith­ful­ly than any com­pan­ion. Years of watch­ing oth­ers build homes while she mas­tered inven­to­ry sheets and cus­tomer rap­port have cre­at­ed a space inside her that suc­cess can­not quite fill. Yet Effie, known for her firm hand­shake and brisk pro­fes­sion­al­ism, nev­er speaks of this vacan­cy. Instead, she buries it beneath rou­tine, appoint­ments, and the crisp rus­tle of shop­ping bags.

    Din­ner with Gabe I. Marks becomes her one inter­rup­tion, a twice-month­ly pause where laugh­ter has no dead­line. Gabe, a man of sim­ple habits and good humor, has long admired Effie not just for her appear­ance but for her steadi­ness and unspo­ken kind­ness. He pro­pos­es with a ner­vous chuck­le dur­ing their twen­ty-fifth shared meal, offer­ing her a life with few­er silks but more shared cof­fee morn­ings. Effie declines with grace, her voice steady as she lists log­i­cal concerns—bills, habits, age, and the loss of auton­o­my. But log­ic, how­ev­er sound, can­not com­plete­ly qui­et the unex­pect­ed echo left behind by the offer. That night, the shad­ows in her apart­ment feel longer, her mir­ror reflec­tion more dis­tant.

    Typhoid finds her in late autumn, weak­en­ing the woman known for nev­er miss­ing a shift. Her co-work­ers speak of her with hushed con­cern, sur­prised by how much her absence shifts the store’s rhythm. Dur­ing recov­ery, days blur into one anoth­er, and with each spoon­ful of broth, the dri­ve that once pri­or­i­tized secu­ri­ty over sen­ti­ment begins to dis­solve. Ill­ness has a way of soft­en­ing cer­tain­ty, of show­ing how qui­et can become lone­li­ness and how inde­pen­dence might some­times be anoth­er word for iso­la­tion. Gabe vis­its reg­u­lar­ly, bring­ing books, flow­ers, and a gen­tle smile that asks noth­ing in return. Each vis­it tight­ens a thread Effie hadn’t known was loose.

    When health returns, Effie no longer sees life sole­ly through the lens of effi­cien­cy and self-preser­va­tion. Gabe, now more famil­iar than any cowork­er or neigh­bor, repeats his pro­pos­al not with fan­fare but with the same warmth that had nursed her through fatigue. This time, her hes­i­ta­tion gives way to a nod, small and delib­er­ate. She no longer views accep­tance as sur­ren­der but as a deci­sion to stop with­hold­ing joy from her­self. In choos­ing com­pan­ion­ship, she embraces the bal­ance between auton­o­my and vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty. A life with Gabe might include less finan­cial cush­ion, but it promis­es a warmth she’d nev­er allowed her­self to need before.

    Return­ing to the per­fume counter, Effie’s steps car­ry less urgency but more con­tent­ment. Her cowork­ers notice the change—not in what she wears, but how she wears it. There’s a soft­ness now in her tone, a flick­er of antic­i­pa­tion in her con­ver­sa­tions, espe­cial­ly when plan­ning hol­i­days or breaks. Gabe doesn’t sweep her off into a sto­ry­book future. Instead, he becomes a chap­ter in the life she’s already built—a chap­ter filled with break­fast rit­u­als, warm evenings, and the knowl­edge that some­one waits for her at home.

    This sto­ry del­i­cate­ly chal­lenges the notion that ful­fill­ment must arrive ear­ly or fol­low a pre­dictable script. It speaks for the qui­et women—those whose lives are not trag­ic but qui­et­ly incom­plete, shaped by prac­ti­cal­i­ty and qui­et resilience. Effie’s jour­ney is not about res­cue, but about permission—giving her­self room to want more, even after years of not need­ing it. Her accep­tance of Gabe’s love isn’t dra­mat­ic; it’s rea­son­able, slow, and deeply brave. It hon­ors the idea that per­son­al hap­pi­ness is a goal not bound by age or soci­etal time­lines.

    Many work­ing women, espe­cial­ly those who’ve put careers first, will find some­thing per­son­al in Effie’s reflec­tion. The sto­ry doesn’t ask them to choose between suc­cess and com­pan­ion­ship, but reminds them both are valid, and some­times even com­pat­i­ble. Life rarely offers per­fect tim­ing, but it does pro­vide moments where hearts, once guard­ed, may be safe­ly opened again. Effie’s sto­ry is not one of giv­ing in, but of final­ly let­ting some­thing good in. Through her, we’re remind­ed that the but­tered side of life isn’t always about what gets dropped, but what still remains warm after it lands.

    Quotes

    FAQs

    Note