On the Way

In the chapter titled “On the Way” from Edwin Arlington Robinson’s *The Three Taverns*, an imaginative dialogue unfolds between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, set in Philadelphia, 1794. This conversation occurs in a speculative manner, not tied to a specific real-life event but rather illustrative of the complex and climactic political tensions that would later culminate in the infamous duel between Hamilton and Burr in 1804. The dialogue vividly characterizes both historical figures, drawing on their intelligence, wit, and the rivalry that defined their relationship.

Burr opens the conversation with a tone of forewarning, subtly reminding Hamilton of the precarious nature of political power and the impending challenges both from within the United States and abroad. He half-jokingly, half-seriously refers to the duo as kings by the wayside, implying the transient nature of their influence and the looming shadow of George Washington.

Hamilton replies with gratitude for Burr’s concern, yet swiftly pivots to philosophical reflections on leadership, the weight of responsibility, and the fleeting admiration of the public. He acknowledges the unique burden and isolation of true leadership, which he sees embodied in Washington – a man not merely of action but of profound vision for the young nation.

The conversation delves deeper into the dynamics of power, ambition, and legacy, with Burr questioning the sustainability of their ideals and Hamilton defending the integrity and foresight of their contributions to nation-building. Hamilton’s remarks on Washington reveal a mix of reverence and a sober realization of the challenges of governance and the cultivation of a national identity.

Burr, ever strategic and probing, challenges Hamilton’s convictions and visions, suggesting that both of them are part of a larger, unpredictable political game, one that could see their fortunes reversed or undone by the evolving desires and demands of the republic.

As the discussion concludes, there is a palpable sense of both men contemplating their fates and legacies, with Burr hinting at the unpredictable winds of political change and Hamilton musing on a return to New York, to rebuild and redefine his life beyond the direct reins of power.

The chapter captures not only the historical and political context of its time but also offers a deep, personal insight into the thoughts and motivations of two of America’s most enigmatic founding fathers. It vividly portrays the blend of camaraderie, rivalry, and the philosophical divides that would eventually lead to tragedy and the solidification of their places in American history.