The Priory of the Orange Tree
Fifty-Six
by Shannon, SamanthaIn this chapter, Loth is occupied with drafting urgent missives to the Virtues Council about an impending threat, a task made slightly easier by Seyton Combe’s return to power. Sabran joins him, bearing a letter from High Princess Ermuna of Mentendon, who demands justice for Lady Truyde’s execution and blames Sabran for the abduction of Doctor Niclays Roos by pirates. Sabran reflects on her delayed pardon for Roos, acknowledging her mistake, while Loth remains skeptical of the alchemist’s character. The tension between duty and remorse is palpable as they discuss the political ramifications of Ermuna’s demands.
Sabran reveals that Ermuna has agreed to search the Library of Ostendeur for records on Empress Mokwo, a crucial step in addressing the looming threat. Their conversation takes a personal turn when Loth shares Igrain Crest’s shocking revelation: Sabran’s mother may have had an affair with Captain Gian Harlowe, casting doubt on Sabran’s legitimacy as queen. Sabran reacts with a mix of resignation and defiance, recognizing Crest’s manipulation but also acknowledging the possible truth. Loth attempts to comfort her, emphasizing that Prince Wilstan could still be her father, but Sabran’s introspection hints at deeper emotional turmoil.
The chapter delves into Sabran’s internal conflict as she contemplates appointing Roslain as the new Duchess of Justice, despite Loth’s reservations about Roslain’s innocence in recent events. Sabran’s resolve to punish Crest contrasts with her tempered mercy toward Roslain, reflecting her struggle to balance justice and compassion. Their discussion is interrupted by Lady Nelda Stillwater, who reaffirms her loyalty and pleads for Roslain’s mercy. Sabran’s measured response underscores her growing political acumen, even as she grapples with personal betrayals.
The chapter closes with the arrival of Margret and Eadaz in Summerport, signaling new developments. Loth and Sabran’s dynamic is highlighted as they navigate trust and forgiveness, particularly in their dealings with Seyton Combe. Sabran offers Loth the chance to retaliate against Combe for past wrongs, but Loth chooses mercy, embodying the virtues he holds dear. The chapter masterfully intertwines political intrigue with personal revelations, setting the stage for further conflict and resolution in the narrative.
FAQs
1. What significant revelation does Igrain Crest share about Queen Mother Rosarian, and how does Sabran react to this news?
Answer:
Igrain Crest reveals that Queen Mother Rosarian committed adultery with Captain Gian Harlowe, potentially making Sabran a bastard rather than the legitimate heir of Prince Wilstan. Crest claims this was her motivation for arranging Rosarian’s death—to mold Sabran into a more “virtuous” (i.e., obedient) queen. Sabran responds with a mix of resignation and quiet acknowledgment, stating, “Part of me has always known,” referencing her parents’ cold private relationship. While shaken, she remains composed, thanking Loth for his honesty and refocusing on her duties, suggesting she is grappling with the implications internally.2. Analyze the political tensions between Sabran and High Princess Ermuna as revealed in their correspondence. What key issues strain their relationship?
Answer:
Two major issues strain their relationship: (1) Ermuna demands justice for Lady Truyde’s unlawful execution, which Sabran can only offer through Igrain Crest’s execution, and (2) Ermuna blames Sabran for Doctor Niclays Roos’s abduction by pirates due to her delayed pardon. Despite these tensions, Ermuna cooperates by searching the Library of Ostendeur for records about Empress Mokwo, highlighting the fragile alliance between their nations. The conflict underscores Sabran’s precarious position as a ruler balancing justice, mercy, and diplomatic pragmatism.3. How does Sabran’s perspective on mercy and justice evolve in this chapter, particularly regarding Roslain Crest?
Answer:
Sabran demonstrates a hardening stance on mercy, stating, “too much of it makes a fool,” as she plans to execute Igrain Crest for treason. However, she shows nuance in considering Roslain’s fate, acknowledging Combe’s belief that Roslain acted to save Sabran’s life (evidenced by her broken fingers). Sabran insists Roslain will be “judged fairly,” balancing her earlier ruthlessness with a measured approach to loyalty. This reflects her growth from a queen who once relied on Ead’s counsel for mercy to one who now asserts her own judgment amid political crises.4. What does Loth’s internal monologue about Sabran’s relationships reveal about her character and emotional conflicts?
Answer:
Loth wonders whether Sabran truly loved her late husband, Lievelyn, or if her marriage was political while her heart belonged to Ead. His musings—”Had Sabran been in love with Lievelyn and turned to Ead for comfort after his death?“—highlight Sabran’s complex emotional landscape as a ruler whose personal desires often clash with public duty. This introspection humanizes Sabran, suggesting her actions (like delaying Roos’s pardon) may stem from unresolved grief or love, adding depth to her decisions.5. Evaluate the significance of Lady Nelda Stillwater’s loyalty declaration and its impact on the power dynamics in Sabran’s court.
Answer:
Stillwater’s pledge of loyalty—”You have always had my loyalty”—after her release from the Dearn Tower reinforces Sabran’s authority amid Igrain Crest’s betrayal. As Duchess of Courage, her support helps legitimize Sabran’s rule, countering the destabilization caused by Crest’s faction. Her plea for mercy for Roslain also tests Sabran’s judgment, illustrating how courtiers navigate loyalty and familial ties. This moment underscores the delicate balance of power Sabran must maintain to unify her court against external threats like the Nameless One.
Quotes
1. “The only justice I can offer for Truyde is the head of Igrain Crest. As for Roos … I should have relented a long time ago.”
This quote captures Queen Sabran’s internal conflict between her desire for justice and her regret over past decisions. It reveals her growing self-awareness and the weight of leadership as she reflects on her handling of Niclays Roos’ pardon.
2. “So, I may be a bastard. […] Part of me has always known. Mother and Father were loving in public, but cold in private.”
A pivotal moment where Sabran confronts the shocking revelation about her potential illegitimacy. This quote shows her composed acceptance of a truth that could undermine her royal authority, while revealing deeper family tensions beneath the surface.
3. “A more obedient queen. A manikin to be manipulated.”
Sabran’s sharp retort about Igrain Crest’s intentions highlights the central theme of manipulation versus autonomy in leadership. This metaphor powerfully conveys how she rejects being controlled, asserting her independence despite Crest’s attempts to shape her.
4. “Certain is a dangerous word, but I am as sure as I can be that everything he does, he does for the crown—and for the queen who wears it. Strangely, I trust him.”
Loth’s nuanced statement about Seyton Combe reflects the chapter’s exploration of trust and forgiveness in politics. His willingness to trust despite past betrayals demonstrates the complex moral calculations required in governance.
5. “The Knight of Courage teaches mercy and forgiveness. I choose to take heed.”
This philosophical statement by Loth represents a key turning point in the narrative, as characters grapple with justice versus mercy. It underscores the book’s recurring theme of virtuous leadership and the conscious choice to embrace compassion.