The Fifth SeasonChapter 24: you’re getting the band back together
by Jemisin, N. K.
The chapter begins with the protagonist confronting Tonkee, revealing she knows her true identity as Binof, a former Leadership child from Yumenes. Tonkee, now a geomest, admits she has been tracking the protagonist for decades, initially to protect her but later due to her potential to command obelisks. The tension escalates as the protagonist demands explanations, frustrated by the layers of deception. Tonkee’s past is unveiled—she was disowned by her family for rejecting societal norms and pursuing academia, where she thrived despite conflicts. Her obsession with the obelisks stems from a discovery in the Fulcrum, a secret she believes is crucial to understanding their world.
Tonkee explains that the obelisks move toward orogenes with the skill to control them, hinting at a deeper connection between the protagonist and these mysterious structures. The protagonist is unsettled by the revelation that obelisks were converging near her in Tirimo, suggesting her son might also possess this ability. Tonkee’s research, conducted with a network of scholars, reveals patterns in the obelisks’ movements, tying them to orogenic potential. The protagonist’s anger gives way to reluctant curiosity as Tonkee emphasizes the importance of their findings, though the protagonist remains wary of her motives and the implications of her own role in this larger mystery.
The chapter delves into Tonkee’s backstory, detailing her transformation from Binof, a disgraced Leadership heir, to Tonkee, a self-made scholar. Her family’s rejection forced her to adopt a new identity, but she found purpose in studying the obelisks and challenging academic conventions. Her partnership with other researchers underscores the collaborative effort to uncover the obelisks’ secrets, which she believes are tied to a catastrophic event in the past. The protagonist, though skeptical, begins to see Tonkee as more than a manipulative figure—a dedicated scholar driven by a genuine desire to understand the world’s hidden truths.
As the confrontation winds down, the protagonist acknowledges the inevitability of confronting her own secrets, including her past with Hoa, who watches the exchange silently. The chapter ends with a sense of impending revelation, as Tonkee’s discoveries about the obelisks and their connection to orogenes hint at a larger, unresolved conflict. The protagonist’s exhaustion and frustration are palpable, but the chapter leaves room for the possibility of collaboration, as both characters recognize the weight of the knowledge they now share. The stage is set for further exploration of the obelisks’ role in the world’s upheaval.
FAQs
1. What revelation does the protagonist have about Tonkee, and how does Tonkee react to this realization?
Answer:
The protagonist suddenly recognizes that Tonkee is actually Binof, a former Leadership child from Yumenes who had scammed her way into the Fulcrum years ago. This realization comes when the protagonist confronts Tonkee with the names “Binof” and “Leadership,” causing Tonkee to flinch and step back in horror. Tonkee admits she didn’t think the protagonist would remember her and explains that she hasn’t been following the protagonist by coincidence—she has been tracking her for years with the help of her wealthy family. The confrontation reveals Tonkee’s true identity and her long-standing obsession with the obelisks and their connection to orogenes like the protagonist.
2. How does Tonkee explain her life after being disowned by her family, and what has been her primary focus of study?
Answer:
Tonkee explains that her family disowned her quietly after she rejected the Leadership’s expectations—both by pursuing a non-traditional profession (geomest) and by transitioning genders, which disrupted arranged marriages. She thrived at the Seventh University under her new identity, despite conflicts with scholars. Her life’s work has been studying the obelisks, particularly the socket discovered in the Fulcrum, which she believes is their origin point. She reveals that this obsession began in childhood and has driven her to track orogenes capable of commanding obelisks, including the protagonist, whom she sees as pivotal to understanding the obelisks’ secrets.
Answer:
Tonkee reveals that the obelisks move and converge near orogenes with the potential to command them. She notes that even in Tirimo, two obelisks were drawn toward the protagonist or another skilled orogene nearby. This behavior suggests a latent connection between orogenes and the obelisks, which Tonkee believes is tied to the socket in the Fulcrum—the obelisks’ origin point. This is significant for the protagonist because it implies she may possess a rare ability to control these powerful artifacts, a secret that could have major implications for her survival and the broader conflicts in the Stillness.
4. How does the protagonist’s emotional state evolve during the confrontation with Tonkee, and what does this reveal about her character?
Answer:
Initially, the protagonist is furious and accusatory, slamming her hands on the table and demanding explanations. However, as Tonkee shares her story and motivations, the protagonist’s anger wanes into weary resignation. She recognizes that Tonkee’s secrets are just one layer of the larger web of deception she faces (including Hoa’s unrevealed truths). This shift highlights the protagonist’s emotional exhaustion and pragmatism—she cannot sustain outrage amid so many revelations. It also underscores her resilience; she prioritizes understanding over vengeance, even when betrayed.
5. What unresolved tension is hinted at between the protagonist and Hoa, and how does it relate to the chapter’s themes of secrecy and trust?
Answer:
The chapter repeatedly notes that the protagonist still needs to confront Hoa, who stands guard warily during her argument with Tonkee. This unresolved tension suggests Hoa is hiding his own secrets, mirroring Tonkee’s deception. The protagonist’s awareness that “all the secrets are coming out, including yours” underscores the chapter’s theme of fractured trust and the inevitability of hidden truths surfacing. Hoa’s guarded posture implies their upcoming confrontation will further test loyalties, emphasizing how survival in the Stillness requires navigating layers of deception—even among allies.
Quotes
1. “‘I didn’t think you remembered,’ she says, in a small voice.”
This moment reveals the emotional weight of Tonkee/Binof’s hidden identity and her long-standing connection to the protagonist. It marks a turning point where past secrets begin unraveling, showing how deeply their histories are intertwined.
2. “‘History is always relevant.’ Tonkee, Binof, or whoever she is, steps away from the wall, a pleading look on her face.”
This statement encapsulates Tonkee’s worldview and the chapter’s theme of inescapable pasts. It highlights the tension between personal history and present identity that drives both characters’ conflicts.
3. “‘It’s where they built them.’ Binof-Tonkee comes forward quickly, her face alight. ‘The socket in the Fulcrum. That’s where the obelisks come from. And it’s also where everything went wrong.’”
This revelation about the obelisks’ origin represents a major plot development and world-building insight. It connects personal histories to the larger mysteries of the Stillness, showing how past technological secrets continue to shape the present.
4. “‘I died to get away from them, and yet I didn’t shake you.’”
This powerful statement summarizes the protagonist’s futile attempts to escape her past. It underscores the chapter’s theme of inescapable connections and the cost of survival in this world.
5. “‘The triangulation lines were pretty clear. Tirimo was the center…’”
This unfinished thought introduces a chilling realization about the obelisks’ behavior and their connection to orogenes. It sets up future revelations while demonstrating how Tonkee’s research has uncovered dangerous truths about the world’s mechanics.
Quotes
1. “‘I didn’t think you remembered,’ she says, in a small voice.”
This moment reveals the emotional weight of Tonkee/Binof’s hidden identity and her long-standing connection to the protagonist. It marks a turning point where past secrets begin unraveling, showing how deeply their histories are intertwined.
2. “‘History is always relevant.’ Tonkee, Binof, or whoever she is, steps away from the wall, a pleading look on her face.”
This statement encapsulates Tonkee’s worldview and the chapter’s theme of inescapable pasts. It highlights the tension between personal history and present identity that drives both characters’ conflicts.
3. “‘It’s where they built them.’ Binof-Tonkee comes forward quickly, her face alight. ‘The socket in the Fulcrum. That’s where the obelisks come from. And it’s also where everything went wrong.’”
This revelation about the obelisks’ origin represents a major plot development and world-building insight. It connects personal histories to the larger mysteries of the Stillness, showing how past technological secrets continue to shape the present.
4. “‘I died to get away from them, and yet I didn’t shake you.’”
This powerful statement summarizes the protagonist’s futile attempts to escape her past. It underscores the chapter’s theme of inescapable connections and the cost of survival in this world.
5. “‘The triangulation lines were pretty clear. Tirimo was the center…’”
This unfinished thought introduces a chilling realization about the obelisks’ behavior and their connection to orogenes. It sets up future revelations while demonstrating how Tonkee’s research has uncovered dangerous truths about the world’s mechanics.
FAQs
1. What revelation does the protagonist have about Tonkee, and how does Tonkee react to this realization?
Answer:
The protagonist suddenly recognizes that Tonkee is actually Binof, a former Leadership child from Yumenes who had scammed her way into the Fulcrum years ago. This realization comes when the protagonist confronts Tonkee with the names “Binof” and “Leadership,” causing Tonkee to flinch and step back in horror. Tonkee admits she didn’t think the protagonist would remember her and explains that she hasn’t been following the protagonist by coincidence—she has been tracking her for years with the help of her wealthy family. The confrontation reveals Tonkee’s true identity and her long-standing obsession with the obelisks and their connection to orogenes like the protagonist.
2. How does Tonkee explain her life after being disowned by her family, and what has been her primary focus of study?
Answer:
Tonkee explains that her family disowned her quietly after she rejected the Leadership’s expectations—both by pursuing a non-traditional profession (geomest) and by transitioning genders, which disrupted arranged marriages. She thrived at the Seventh University under her new identity, despite conflicts with scholars. Her life’s work has been studying the obelisks, particularly the socket discovered in the Fulcrum, which she believes is their origin point. She reveals that this obsession began in childhood and has driven her to track orogenes capable of commanding obelisks, including the protagonist, whom she sees as pivotal to understanding the obelisks’ secrets.
Answer:
Tonkee reveals that the obelisks move and converge near orogenes with the potential to command them. She notes that even in Tirimo, two obelisks were drawn toward the protagonist or another skilled orogene nearby. This behavior suggests a latent connection between orogenes and the obelisks, which Tonkee believes is tied to the socket in the Fulcrum—the obelisks’ origin point. This is significant for the protagonist because it implies she may possess a rare ability to control these powerful artifacts, a secret that could have major implications for her survival and the broader conflicts in the Stillness.
4. How does the protagonist’s emotional state evolve during the confrontation with Tonkee, and what does this reveal about her character?
Answer:
Initially, the protagonist is furious and accusatory, slamming her hands on the table and demanding explanations. However, as Tonkee shares her story and motivations, the protagonist’s anger wanes into weary resignation. She recognizes that Tonkee’s secrets are just one layer of the larger web of deception she faces (including Hoa’s unrevealed truths). This shift highlights the protagonist’s emotional exhaustion and pragmatism—she cannot sustain outrage amid so many revelations. It also underscores her resilience; she prioritizes understanding over vengeance, even when betrayed.
5. What unresolved tension is hinted at between the protagonist and Hoa, and how does it relate to the chapter’s themes of secrecy and trust?
Answer:
The chapter repeatedly notes that the protagonist still needs to confront Hoa, who stands guard warily during her argument with Tonkee. This unresolved tension suggests Hoa is hiding his own secrets, mirroring Tonkee’s deception. The protagonist’s awareness that “all the secrets are coming out, including yours” underscores the chapter’s theme of fractured trust and the inevitability of hidden truths surfacing. Hoa’s guarded posture implies their upcoming confrontation will further test loyalties, emphasizing how survival in the Stillness requires navigating layers of deception—even among allies.
The Fifth SeasonChapter 24: you’re getting the band back together
by Jemisin, N. K.
FAQs
1. What revelation does the protagonist have about Tonkee, and how does Tonkee react to this realization?
Answer:
The protagonist suddenly recognizes that Tonkee is actually Binof, a former Leadership child from Yumenes who had scammed her way into the Fulcrum years ago. This realization comes when the protagonist confronts Tonkee with the names “Binof” and “Leadership,” causing Tonkee to flinch and step back in horror. Tonkee admits she didn’t think the protagonist would remember her and explains that she hasn’t been following the protagonist by coincidence—she has been tracking her for years with the help of her wealthy family. The confrontation reveals Tonkee’s true identity and her long-standing obsession with the obelisks and their connection to orogenes like the protagonist.
2. How does Tonkee explain her life after being disowned by her family, and what has been her primary focus of study?
Answer:
Tonkee explains that her family disowned her quietly after she rejected the Leadership’s expectations—both by pursuing a non-traditional profession (geomest) and by transitioning genders, which disrupted arranged marriages. She thrived at the Seventh University under her new identity, despite conflicts with scholars. Her life’s work has been studying the obelisks, particularly the socket discovered in the Fulcrum, which she believes is their origin point. She reveals that this obsession began in childhood and has driven her to track orogenes capable of commanding obelisks, including the protagonist, whom she sees as pivotal to understanding the obelisks’ secrets.
Answer:
Tonkee reveals that the obelisks move and converge near orogenes with the potential to command them. She notes that even in Tirimo, two obelisks were drawn toward the protagonist or another skilled orogene nearby. This behavior suggests a latent connection between orogenes and the obelisks, which Tonkee believes is tied to the socket in the Fulcrum—the obelisks’ origin point. This is significant for the protagonist because it implies she may possess a rare ability to control these powerful artifacts, a secret that could have major implications for her survival and the broader conflicts in the Stillness.
4. How does the protagonist’s emotional state evolve during the confrontation with Tonkee, and what does this reveal about her character?
Answer:
Initially, the protagonist is furious and accusatory, slamming her hands on the table and demanding explanations. However, as Tonkee shares her story and motivations, the protagonist’s anger wanes into weary resignation. She recognizes that Tonkee’s secrets are just one layer of the larger web of deception she faces (including Hoa’s unrevealed truths). This shift highlights the protagonist’s emotional exhaustion and pragmatism—she cannot sustain outrage amid so many revelations. It also underscores her resilience; she prioritizes understanding over vengeance, even when betrayed.
5. What unresolved tension is hinted at between the protagonist and Hoa, and how does it relate to the chapter’s themes of secrecy and trust?
Answer:
The chapter repeatedly notes that the protagonist still needs to confront Hoa, who stands guard warily during her argument with Tonkee. This unresolved tension suggests Hoa is hiding his own secrets, mirroring Tonkee’s deception. The protagonist’s awareness that “all the secrets are coming out, including yours” underscores the chapter’s theme of fractured trust and the inevitability of hidden truths surfacing. Hoa’s guarded posture implies their upcoming confrontation will further test loyalties, emphasizing how survival in the Stillness requires navigating layers of deception—even among allies.
Quotes
1. “‘I didn’t think you remembered,’ she says, in a small voice.”
This moment reveals the emotional weight of Tonkee/Binof’s hidden identity and her long-standing connection to the protagonist. It marks a turning point where past secrets begin unraveling, showing how deeply their histories are intertwined.
2. “‘History is always relevant.’ Tonkee, Binof, or whoever she is, steps away from the wall, a pleading look on her face.”
This statement encapsulates Tonkee’s worldview and the chapter’s theme of inescapable pasts. It highlights the tension between personal history and present identity that drives both characters’ conflicts.
3. “‘It’s where they built them.’ Binof-Tonkee comes forward quickly, her face alight. ‘The socket in the Fulcrum. That’s where the obelisks come from. And it’s also where everything went wrong.’”
This revelation about the obelisks’ origin represents a major plot development and world-building insight. It connects personal histories to the larger mysteries of the Stillness, showing how past technological secrets continue to shape the present.
4. “‘I died to get away from them, and yet I didn’t shake you.’”
This powerful statement summarizes the protagonist’s futile attempts to escape her past. It underscores the chapter’s theme of inescapable connections and the cost of survival in this world.
5. “‘The triangulation lines were pretty clear. Tirimo was the center…’”
This unfinished thought introduces a chilling realization about the obelisks’ behavior and their connection to orogenes. It sets up future revelations while demonstrating how Tonkee’s research has uncovered dangerous truths about the world’s mechanics.
Quotes
1. “‘I didn’t think you remembered,’ she says, in a small voice.”
This moment reveals the emotional weight of Tonkee/Binof’s hidden identity and her long-standing connection to the protagonist. It marks a turning point where past secrets begin unraveling, showing how deeply their histories are intertwined.
2. “‘History is always relevant.’ Tonkee, Binof, or whoever she is, steps away from the wall, a pleading look on her face.”
This statement encapsulates Tonkee’s worldview and the chapter’s theme of inescapable pasts. It highlights the tension between personal history and present identity that drives both characters’ conflicts.
3. “‘It’s where they built them.’ Binof-Tonkee comes forward quickly, her face alight. ‘The socket in the Fulcrum. That’s where the obelisks come from. And it’s also where everything went wrong.’”
This revelation about the obelisks’ origin represents a major plot development and world-building insight. It connects personal histories to the larger mysteries of the Stillness, showing how past technological secrets continue to shape the present.
4. “‘I died to get away from them, and yet I didn’t shake you.’”
This powerful statement summarizes the protagonist’s futile attempts to escape her past. It underscores the chapter’s theme of inescapable connections and the cost of survival in this world.
5. “‘The triangulation lines were pretty clear. Tirimo was the center…’”
This unfinished thought introduces a chilling realization about the obelisks’ behavior and their connection to orogenes. It sets up future revelations while demonstrating how Tonkee’s research has uncovered dangerous truths about the world’s mechanics.
FAQs
1. What revelation does the protagonist have about Tonkee, and how does Tonkee react to this realization?
Answer:
The protagonist suddenly recognizes that Tonkee is actually Binof, a former Leadership child from Yumenes who had scammed her way into the Fulcrum years ago. This realization comes when the protagonist confronts Tonkee with the names “Binof” and “Leadership,” causing Tonkee to flinch and step back in horror. Tonkee admits she didn’t think the protagonist would remember her and explains that she hasn’t been following the protagonist by coincidence—she has been tracking her for years with the help of her wealthy family. The confrontation reveals Tonkee’s true identity and her long-standing obsession with the obelisks and their connection to orogenes like the protagonist.
2. How does Tonkee explain her life after being disowned by her family, and what has been her primary focus of study?
Answer:
Tonkee explains that her family disowned her quietly after she rejected the Leadership’s expectations—both by pursuing a non-traditional profession (geomest) and by transitioning genders, which disrupted arranged marriages. She thrived at the Seventh University under her new identity, despite conflicts with scholars. Her life’s work has been studying the obelisks, particularly the socket discovered in the Fulcrum, which she believes is their origin point. She reveals that this obsession began in childhood and has driven her to track orogenes capable of commanding obelisks, including the protagonist, whom she sees as pivotal to understanding the obelisks’ secrets.
Answer:
Tonkee reveals that the obelisks move and converge near orogenes with the potential to command them. She notes that even in Tirimo, two obelisks were drawn toward the protagonist or another skilled orogene nearby. This behavior suggests a latent connection between orogenes and the obelisks, which Tonkee believes is tied to the socket in the Fulcrum—the obelisks’ origin point. This is significant for the protagonist because it implies she may possess a rare ability to control these powerful artifacts, a secret that could have major implications for her survival and the broader conflicts in the Stillness.
4. How does the protagonist’s emotional state evolve during the confrontation with Tonkee, and what does this reveal about her character?
Answer:
Initially, the protagonist is furious and accusatory, slamming her hands on the table and demanding explanations. However, as Tonkee shares her story and motivations, the protagonist’s anger wanes into weary resignation. She recognizes that Tonkee’s secrets are just one layer of the larger web of deception she faces (including Hoa’s unrevealed truths). This shift highlights the protagonist’s emotional exhaustion and pragmatism—she cannot sustain outrage amid so many revelations. It also underscores her resilience; she prioritizes understanding over vengeance, even when betrayed.
5. What unresolved tension is hinted at between the protagonist and Hoa, and how does it relate to the chapter’s themes of secrecy and trust?
Answer:
The chapter repeatedly notes that the protagonist still needs to confront Hoa, who stands guard warily during her argument with Tonkee. This unresolved tension suggests Hoa is hiding his own secrets, mirroring Tonkee’s deception. The protagonist’s awareness that “all the secrets are coming out, including yours” underscores the chapter’s theme of fractured trust and the inevitability of hidden truths surfacing. Hoa’s guarded posture implies their upcoming confrontation will further test loyalties, emphasizing how survival in the Stillness requires navigating layers of deception—even among allies.