Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Three:iii

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter, Jim’s grow­ing rela­tion­ship with Nan­cy is explored against the back­drop of social expec­ta­tions and per­son­al hes­i­ta­tions. After spend­ing a day togeth­er in Dublin, Jim con­tem­plates mak­ing their engage­ment pub­lic, hop­ing it would com­pel them to for­mal­ize their com­mit­ment. Nan­cy, how­ev­er, insists on care­ful plan­ning, mind­ful of not over­shad­ow­ing Miriam’s upcom­ing wed­ding. Jim’s impa­tience con­trasts with Nancy’s cau­tion, reflect­ing their dif­fer­ing approach­es to the future. Despite the delay, Jim finds him­self increas­ing­ly drawn to the idea of mar­riage, his dreams becom­ing more vivid as he envi­sions a life with Nan­cy.

    The jour­ney to Dublin marks a turn­ing point for Jim, as he appre­ci­ates Nancy’s pres­ence more deeply. Unlike his usu­al soli­tary dri­ves, Nancy’s com­pa­ny brings an ease and inter­est to their con­ver­sa­tions, even in moments of silence. Jim notices the gen­uine engage­ment in her voice and the way she shares her con­cerns, which endears her fur­ther to him. This grow­ing affec­tion high­lights Jim’s shift from enjoy­ing soli­tude to valu­ing com­pan­ion­ship, set­ting the emo­tion­al tone for their evolv­ing rela­tion­ship.

    Mean­while, the local pub envi­ron­ment pro­vides a con­trast­ing social land­scape where Jim finds cama­raderie and dis­trac­tion. Char­ac­ters like Andy and Shane Nolan offer live­ly sports dis­cus­sions and per­son­al anec­dotes, enrich­ing the com­mu­nal atmos­phere. These inter­ac­tions reveal Jim’s inte­gra­tion into the com­mu­ni­ty and his appre­ci­a­tion for famil­iar rou­tines, even as his pri­vate life stirs with new pos­si­bil­i­ties. The pub serves as a space where Jim bal­ances his inter­nal reflec­tions with exter­nal social con­nec­tions.

    Jim’s dis­cre­tion about his engage­ment under­scores his cau­tious nature and respect for pri­va­cy. Despite trust­ing Colette, he refrains from shar­ing his plans, wary of gos­sip and the con­se­quences of pre­ma­ture dis­clo­sure. This restraint is root­ed in lessons from his father about the impor­tance of silence in his role as a bar­man. The chap­ter clos­es with sub­tle hints of Jim’s ner­vous­ness and excite­ment, as he nav­i­gates the com­plex­i­ties of love, secre­cy, and social expec­ta­tions, poised between antic­i­pa­tion and restraint.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Jim’s attitude towards engagement and marriage evolve throughout the chapter?

      Answer:
      At the beginning of the chapter, Jim is somewhat impatient about the timing of his engagement to Nancy, hoping to hasten the announcement and wedding. He almost wishes someone would spot them together to force them into going public. His impatience is prompted by Nancy mentioning a wedding planned for next spring, which he thinks is too far away. Despite wanting to be settled by Christmas, he recognizes that Nancy wants to plan carefully, especially to avoid overshadowing Miriam’s wedding. Over the course of the chapter, Jim’s feelings deepen as he dreams about marriage and enjoys Nancy’s company, showing a growing emotional connection and readiness for commitment, even as he respects Nancy’s desire for careful planning.

      2. What role do the conversations and interactions in the pub play in the narrative?

      Answer:
      The pub serves as a social hub where Jim interacts with local characters like Andy and Shane Nolan, which contrasts with his private thoughts about marriage. These interactions provide insight into the community’s daily life and interests, particularly through detailed sports commentary and family discussions. The pub also highlights Jim’s reserved nature—he listens more than he speaks and follows his father’s advice to keep personal matters private. The conversations offer a backdrop that grounds Jim’s personal story within a broader social context, showing how he balances his private desires with public roles and responsibilities.

      3. Analyze how Jim’s relationship with Nancy influences his self-perception and social behavior.

      Answer:
      Jim’s relationship with Nancy brings a renewed sense of purpose and emotional engagement. Before, he enjoyed solitary drives to Dublin and was comfortable being alone, but with Nancy, he experiences companionship that makes silence feel natural rather than awkward. Her engaging conversation and evident enthusiasm make him appreciate deeper connection. Socially, he becomes more self-conscious, as seen when he blushes talking to Nancy on the phone and worries about who might know about their relationship. This new dynamic challenges his usual reserved demeanor, prompting him to consider sharing personal information more openly, though he ultimately respects his father’s advice to maintain discretion.

      4. What significance does the advice from Jim’s father hold in the context of the chapter?

      Answer:
      Jim’s father’s advice about not talking too much as a barman symbolizes a broader theme of discretion and privacy. It serves as a guiding principle for Jim, who values trust but remains cautious about sharing his engagement news. This advice reflects the social expectations and norms of the community, where personal information can quickly spread and affect one’s reputation. It also underscores Jim’s internal conflict between wanting to confide in someone like Colette and the need to keep his private life guarded. The advice reinforces Jim’s character as thoughtful and prudent, aware of the consequences of gossip.

      5. How does the chapter explore the theme of timing and planning in relationships?

      Answer:
      Timing and planning are central to Jim and Nancy’s engagement discussions. Nancy emphasizes the need to plan the wedding carefully, particularly to avoid overshadowing Miriam’s wedding, indicating respect for family dynamics and social propriety. Jim’s desire to expedite the engagement and marriage contrasts with Nancy’s cautious approach, illustrating the tension between impulse and prudence. This theme reflects the complexities of relationships, where personal desires must be balanced with external considerations. The chapter shows that successful relationships often require negotiation and patience, acknowledging that important life events are rarely spontaneous but thoughtfully orchestrated.

    Quotes

    • 1. “When Jim dropped Nancy at her car at the railway station in Gorey after their day in Dublin, he almost hoped that they would be spotted by someone who would spread the news that would have forced them into the open. They could then have announced their engagement.”

      This quote captures Jim’s internal conflict and longing for openness about his relationship, highlighting the tension between private desires and social constraints that frame much of the chapter’s emotional undercurrent.

      2. “‘Why don’t we get engaged now and get married in October?’ ‘We need to plan.’ ‘Plan what?’ ‘The wedding. And you know we can’t draw attention away from Miriam’s.’”

      This exchange reveals the careful negotiation and postponement around the engagement and wedding, emphasizing the theme of timing, social appearances, and the influence of family dynamics on personal decisions.

      3. “Nancy could also be silent, he noticed, but there was no strain in the car when she didn’t talk. When she did begin a conversation, however, what she said was interesting… But it was the tone of her voice and how engaged she became when she spoke, that he loved most.”

      Here, the author insightfully portrays the evolving intimacy between Jim and Nancy, showing how connection transcends mere words and is found in presence and engagement, deepening the reader’s understanding of their relationship.

      4. “If he ever felt an urge to tell anybody anything, he was to stop and say nothing. No one appreciated a barman who talked too much. In his pub, his father added, he would learn much more than he needed to know and his job was to keep it all to himself.”

      This passage illuminates Jim’s ingrained sense of discretion and privacy, which shapes his cautious approach to sharing personal news, thereby underscoring the themes of secrecy and social roles in the chapter.

      5. “‘There was never going to be a goal. Anyone who expected a goal from Mick Scallan knows nothing. But there are eejits everywhere and why should this town be free of them?’”

      This colorful commentary on a local sports event, delivered by Andy, adds texture and local color to the narrative, reflecting community life and serving as a contrast to Jim’s personal contemplations, grounding the chapter in its social setting.

    Quotes

    1. “When Jim dropped Nancy at her car at the railway station in Gorey after their day in Dublin, he almost hoped that they would be spotted by someone who would spread the news that would have forced them into the open. They could then have announced their engagement.”

    This quote captures Jim’s internal conflict and longing for openness about his relationship, highlighting the tension between private desires and social constraints that frame much of the chapter’s emotional undercurrent.

    2. “‘Why don’t we get engaged now and get married in October?’ ‘We need to plan.’ ‘Plan what?’ ‘The wedding. And you know we can’t draw attention away from Miriam’s.’”

    This exchange reveals the careful negotiation and postponement around the engagement and wedding, emphasizing the theme of timing, social appearances, and the influence of family dynamics on personal decisions.

    3. “Nancy could also be silent, he noticed, but there was no strain in the car when she didn’t talk. When she did begin a conversation, however, what she said was interesting… But it was the tone of her voice and how engaged she became when she spoke, that he loved most.”

    Here, the author insightfully portrays the evolving intimacy between Jim and Nancy, showing how connection transcends mere words and is found in presence and engagement, deepening the reader’s understanding of their relationship.

    4. “If he ever felt an urge to tell anybody anything, he was to stop and say nothing. No one appreciated a barman who talked too much. In his pub, his father added, he would learn much more than he needed to know and his job was to keep it all to himself.”

    This passage illuminates Jim’s ingrained sense of discretion and privacy, which shapes his cautious approach to sharing personal news, thereby underscoring the themes of secrecy and social roles in the chapter.

    5. “‘There was never going to be a goal. Anyone who expected a goal from Mick Scallan knows nothing. But there are eejits everywhere and why should this town be free of them?’”

    This colorful commentary on a local sports event, delivered by Andy, adds texture and local color to the narrative, reflecting community life and serving as a contrast to Jim’s personal contemplations, grounding the chapter in its social setting.

    FAQs

    1. How does Jim’s attitude towards engagement and marriage evolve throughout the chapter?

    Answer:
    At the beginning of the chapter, Jim is somewhat impatient about the timing of his engagement to Nancy, hoping to hasten the announcement and wedding. He almost wishes someone would spot them together to force them into going public. His impatience is prompted by Nancy mentioning a wedding planned for next spring, which he thinks is too far away. Despite wanting to be settled by Christmas, he recognizes that Nancy wants to plan carefully, especially to avoid overshadowing Miriam’s wedding. Over the course of the chapter, Jim’s feelings deepen as he dreams about marriage and enjoys Nancy’s company, showing a growing emotional connection and readiness for commitment, even as he respects Nancy’s desire for careful planning.

    2. What role do the conversations and interactions in the pub play in the narrative?

    Answer:
    The pub serves as a social hub where Jim interacts with local characters like Andy and Shane Nolan, which contrasts with his private thoughts about marriage. These interactions provide insight into the community’s daily life and interests, particularly through detailed sports commentary and family discussions. The pub also highlights Jim’s reserved nature—he listens more than he speaks and follows his father’s advice to keep personal matters private. The conversations offer a backdrop that grounds Jim’s personal story within a broader social context, showing how he balances his private desires with public roles and responsibilities.

    3. Analyze how Jim’s relationship with Nancy influences his self-perception and social behavior.

    Answer:
    Jim’s relationship with Nancy brings a renewed sense of purpose and emotional engagement. Before, he enjoyed solitary drives to Dublin and was comfortable being alone, but with Nancy, he experiences companionship that makes silence feel natural rather than awkward. Her engaging conversation and evident enthusiasm make him appreciate deeper connection. Socially, he becomes more self-conscious, as seen when he blushes talking to Nancy on the phone and worries about who might know about their relationship. This new dynamic challenges his usual reserved demeanor, prompting him to consider sharing personal information more openly, though he ultimately respects his father’s advice to maintain discretion.

    4. What significance does the advice from Jim’s father hold in the context of the chapter?

    Answer:
    Jim’s father’s advice about not talking too much as a barman symbolizes a broader theme of discretion and privacy. It serves as a guiding principle for Jim, who values trust but remains cautious about sharing his engagement news. This advice reflects the social expectations and norms of the community, where personal information can quickly spread and affect one’s reputation. It also underscores Jim’s internal conflict between wanting to confide in someone like Colette and the need to keep his private life guarded. The advice reinforces Jim’s character as thoughtful and prudent, aware of the consequences of gossip.

    5. How does the chapter explore the theme of timing and planning in relationships?

    Answer:
    Timing and planning are central to Jim and Nancy’s engagement discussions. Nancy emphasizes the need to plan the wedding carefully, particularly to avoid overshadowing Miriam’s wedding, indicating respect for family dynamics and social propriety. Jim’s desire to expedite the engagement and marriage contrasts with Nancy’s cautious approach, illustrating the tension between impulse and prudence. This theme reflects the complexities of relationships, where personal desires must be balanced with external considerations. The chapter shows that successful relationships often require negotiation and patience, acknowledging that important life events are rarely spontaneous but thoughtfully orchestrated.

    Note