Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Six:iii

    by Tóibín, Colm

    The chap­ter opens with a qui­et moment between Eilis and Jim, as he lies awake beside her, hes­i­tant to dis­turb her sleep. Jim reflects on their recent inter­ac­tions and the unspo­ken ques­tions about their relationship’s future. Despite his desire to clar­i­fy their sit­u­a­tion, he choos­es to wait until Eilis is ready to speak. Their shared morn­ing is marked by gen­tle teas­ing and an inti­mate domes­tic­i­ty, reveal­ing a ten­ta­tive but grow­ing close­ness. The sun­ny weath­er con­trasts with Jim’s inter­nal uncer­tain­ty about how and when their rela­tion­ship will be defined, espe­cial­ly with exter­nal pres­sures loom­ing.

    As they share break­fast and plan to vis­it the near­by strand, their con­ver­sa­tion reveals sub­tle ten­sions and hopes. Eilis’s sug­ges­tion to swim togeth­er evokes mem­o­ries and a sense of renew­al, while Jim’s admis­sion of no longer know­ing how to swim sym­bol­izes his emo­tion­al vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty. Their walk along the coast, choos­ing a qui­et and seclud­ed path, under­scores their desire for pri­va­cy and a fresh start. The nat­ur­al set­ting acts as a back­drop to their evolv­ing con­nec­tion, blend­ing moments of light­heart­ed­ness with deep­er, unspo­ken con­cerns.

    The nar­ra­tive shifts briefly to Jim’s encounter with Jack Lacey and his broth­ers at the pub, where old ten­sions resur­face. Jack’s insin­u­a­tions about Jim and Eilis’s past rela­tion­ship intro­duce an ele­ment of social pres­sure and poten­tial con­flict. Jim’s calm dis­missal and his request to Shane to keep Jack at bay high­light his deter­mi­na­tion to pro­tect his rela­tion­ship with Eilis. This episode under­scores the chal­lenges they face not only in their per­son­al dynam­ics but also with­in the community’s watch­ful eyes.

    Return­ing to Eilis and Jim’s inter­ac­tion, Eilis reveals com­pli­ca­tions in her per­son­al life that affect their future togeth­er. She dis­clos­es her inten­tion to leave her mar­riage to Tony and her respon­si­bil­i­ties towards her chil­dren, indi­cat­ing that her sit­u­a­tion is com­plex and unre­solved. Their walk along the shore becomes a metaphor for nav­i­gat­ing uncer­tain emo­tion­al ter­rain, as Jim lis­tens care­ful­ly, sens­ing that patience and under­stand­ing will be cru­cial. The chap­ter clos­es on this note of cau­tious hope, with both char­ac­ters con­fronting the real­i­ties that will shape their next steps.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Jim’s behavior while Eilis is asleep reflect his feelings and the tension in their relationship at this point in the chapter?

      Answer:
      Jim’s behavior—lying still beside Eilis so as not to wake her—reflects a sense of tenderness and hesitation. He is careful and considerate, indicating his affection and the delicacy of their current situation. His internal thoughts about asking Eilis if she wants to be with him reveal underlying tension and uncertainty. Despite wanting clarity, he chooses to wait until she is awake, showing respect for her and the complexity of their relationship. This moment also highlights Jim’s cautious hopefulness and the emotional restraint that characterizes their interactions.

      2. What significance does the setting by the sea and the act of swimming hold in the development of Jim and Eilis’s relationship in this chapter?

      Answer:
      The sea setting symbolizes both renewal and vulnerability. Eilis’s observation that the water used to be beautiful at the end of summer but might be imagined suggests a reflection on change and nostalgia. Their decision to swim together, despite the cold water, is a metaphor for confronting discomfort and embracing new experiences. Jim’s admission that he hasn’t swum since a previous time with Eilis and others points to a past that still influences him. Swimming together acts as a bonding moment, representing a tentative step toward intimacy and shared memories, reinforcing the evolving closeness between them.

      3. Analyze the interaction between Jim and Jack at the pub. What does this reveal about the social dynamics and potential conflicts surrounding Jim and Eilis’s relationship?

      Answer:
      The interaction reveals underlying tensions and social pressures within their community. Jack’s drunken insinuations about Jim and Eilis’s past and possible future attempts to rekindle their relationship introduce an element of threat and rivalry. Jack’s offer to “help out” is a veiled warning or challenge, implying he might interfere or manipulate the situation. Jim’s calm dismissal and request to keep Jack away highlight his desire to avoid conflict and protect the fragile progress with Eilis. This scene illustrates how external forces and local gossip could complicate personal relationships, emphasizing the social scrutiny they face.

      4. How does Eilis’s revelation about her marriage and complicated situation contribute to the chapter’s themes of uncertainty and change?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s disclosure about not wanting to stay married to Tony, but having complications, introduces a layer of personal struggle and ambiguity. It underscores the theme of uncertainty—her future is unclear, and she must navigate difficult decisions. This revelation adds emotional complexity to her relationship with Jim, as it tempers hope with realism and caution. The fact that she is returning home to manage family responsibilities further emphasizes the challenges of balancing personal desires with obligations. This contributes to the chapter’s overall exploration of change, the difficulty of moving forward, and the interplay between past and present.

      5. What role does the motif of time play in this chapter, particularly in relation to Jim and Eilis’s plans and conversations?

      Answer:
      Time is a recurring motif that underscores the tension between past, present, and future. Jim’s thoughts about the timing of their next encounter and the need to clarify their relationship reflect the pressure of making decisions within limited time frames. Eilis’s plans to return home and the mention of specific timeframes (such as the beginning of September and her travel next week) emphasize the urgency and temporality of their situation. The motif of time highlights the characters’ awareness that their circumstances are transitional and that choices made now will shape their futures. It also reflects the emotional pacing of their relationship, caught between hesitation and the need for resolution.

    Quotes

    • 1. “He had, since the Montrose Hotel, been imagining their next encounter when he could ask Eilis, plainly, if she wanted to be with him.”

      This quote captures Jim’s internal anticipation and the emotional tension underlying his relationship with Eilis. It reflects his desire for clarity and commitment, setting the emotional tone for the chapter.

      2. “‘Those underpants will have to go,’ she said.”

      A seemingly small, playful moment that subtly signals Eilis’s intention to continue their relationship. It conveys intimacy and familiarity, hinting at future plans without explicit declaration.

      3. “‘Water under the bridge, Jack. Water under the bridge.’”

      Jim’s response to Jack’s provocation about past relationships reveals his attempts to move forward and avoid conflict. This phrase encapsulates the theme of letting go of the past to focus on the present.

      4. “‘I got news from home and it made me realise that I don’t want to stay married to Tony. But there are complications and I need to let you know about them.’”

      This moment is a key turning point in the chapter, revealing Eilis’s personal struggles and complications that affect her relationship with Jim. It introduces tension and complexity into the narrative.

      5. “‘I’m going back next week on the same flight as the children if I can change my ticket. I need to get them both settled, Rosella at university and Larry back at his high school. I also have to return to work and get everything back to normal as s’”

      This quote highlights Eilis’s responsibilities and the practical challenges she faces, grounding her character in real-life concerns and illustrating the balance between personal desires and obligations.

    Quotes

    1. “He had, since the Montrose Hotel, been imagining their next encounter when he could ask Eilis, plainly, if she wanted to be with him.”

    This quote captures Jim’s internal anticipation and the emotional tension underlying his relationship with Eilis. It reflects his desire for clarity and commitment, setting the emotional tone for the chapter.

    2. “‘Those underpants will have to go,’ she said.”

    A seemingly small, playful moment that subtly signals Eilis’s intention to continue their relationship. It conveys intimacy and familiarity, hinting at future plans without explicit declaration.

    3. “‘Water under the bridge, Jack. Water under the bridge.’”

    Jim’s response to Jack’s provocation about past relationships reveals his attempts to move forward and avoid conflict. This phrase encapsulates the theme of letting go of the past to focus on the present.

    4. “‘I got news from home and it made me realise that I don’t want to stay married to Tony. But there are complications and I need to let you know about them.’”

    This moment is a key turning point in the chapter, revealing Eilis’s personal struggles and complications that affect her relationship with Jim. It introduces tension and complexity into the narrative.

    5. “‘I’m going back next week on the same flight as the children if I can change my ticket. I need to get them both settled, Rosella at university and Larry back at his high school. I also have to return to work and get everything back to normal as s’”

    This quote highlights Eilis’s responsibilities and the practical challenges she faces, grounding her character in real-life concerns and illustrating the balance between personal desires and obligations.

    FAQs

    1. How does Jim’s behavior while Eilis is asleep reflect his feelings and the tension in their relationship at this point in the chapter?

    Answer:
    Jim’s behavior—lying still beside Eilis so as not to wake her—reflects a sense of tenderness and hesitation. He is careful and considerate, indicating his affection and the delicacy of their current situation. His internal thoughts about asking Eilis if she wants to be with him reveal underlying tension and uncertainty. Despite wanting clarity, he chooses to wait until she is awake, showing respect for her and the complexity of their relationship. This moment also highlights Jim’s cautious hopefulness and the emotional restraint that characterizes their interactions.

    2. What significance does the setting by the sea and the act of swimming hold in the development of Jim and Eilis’s relationship in this chapter?

    Answer:
    The sea setting symbolizes both renewal and vulnerability. Eilis’s observation that the water used to be beautiful at the end of summer but might be imagined suggests a reflection on change and nostalgia. Their decision to swim together, despite the cold water, is a metaphor for confronting discomfort and embracing new experiences. Jim’s admission that he hasn’t swum since a previous time with Eilis and others points to a past that still influences him. Swimming together acts as a bonding moment, representing a tentative step toward intimacy and shared memories, reinforcing the evolving closeness between them.

    3. Analyze the interaction between Jim and Jack at the pub. What does this reveal about the social dynamics and potential conflicts surrounding Jim and Eilis’s relationship?

    Answer:
    The interaction reveals underlying tensions and social pressures within their community. Jack’s drunken insinuations about Jim and Eilis’s past and possible future attempts to rekindle their relationship introduce an element of threat and rivalry. Jack’s offer to “help out” is a veiled warning or challenge, implying he might interfere or manipulate the situation. Jim’s calm dismissal and request to keep Jack away highlight his desire to avoid conflict and protect the fragile progress with Eilis. This scene illustrates how external forces and local gossip could complicate personal relationships, emphasizing the social scrutiny they face.

    4. How does Eilis’s revelation about her marriage and complicated situation contribute to the chapter’s themes of uncertainty and change?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s disclosure about not wanting to stay married to Tony, but having complications, introduces a layer of personal struggle and ambiguity. It underscores the theme of uncertainty—her future is unclear, and she must navigate difficult decisions. This revelation adds emotional complexity to her relationship with Jim, as it tempers hope with realism and caution. The fact that she is returning home to manage family responsibilities further emphasizes the challenges of balancing personal desires with obligations. This contributes to the chapter’s overall exploration of change, the difficulty of moving forward, and the interplay between past and present.

    5. What role does the motif of time play in this chapter, particularly in relation to Jim and Eilis’s plans and conversations?

    Answer:
    Time is a recurring motif that underscores the tension between past, present, and future. Jim’s thoughts about the timing of their next encounter and the need to clarify their relationship reflect the pressure of making decisions within limited time frames. Eilis’s plans to return home and the mention of specific timeframes (such as the beginning of September and her travel next week) emphasize the urgency and temporality of their situation. The motif of time highlights the characters’ awareness that their circumstances are transitional and that choices made now will shape their futures. It also reflects the emotional pacing of their relationship, caught between hesitation and the need for resolution.

    Note