Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Four:ii

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter, Eilis engages in a sub­tle yet reveal­ing con­ver­sa­tion with her moth­er about appear­ance and soci­etal expec­ta­tions, par­tic­u­lar­ly focus­ing on the choice of dress­es and hats for an upcom­ing wed­ding. Her mother’s ini­tial cri­tiques give way to a rare com­pli­ment, sug­gest­ing a com­plex rela­tion­ship marked by unspo­ken emo­tions and restrained affec­tion. The dia­logue high­lights the ten­sion between per­son­al pref­er­ence and com­mu­ni­ty scruti­ny, reflect­ing the pres­sures Eilis faces as she nav­i­gates her iden­ti­ty and pre­sen­ta­tion with­in a close-knit envi­ron­ment.

    Upon arriv­ing at the cathe­dral grounds, Eilis encoun­ters famil­iar faces and expe­ri­ences an under­cur­rent of social judg­ment and restrained warmth. Inter­ac­tions with acquain­tances, includ­ing Nan­cy and a woman who knew her sis­ter, Rose, under­score the community’s col­lec­tive mem­o­ry and expec­ta­tions. The pres­ence of Jim Far­rell, who arrives alone and main­tains a cau­tious dis­tance, intro­duces an ele­ment of unre­solved ten­sion and shared his­to­ry, fur­ther com­pli­cat­ed by the watch­ful eyes of those around them.

    As the wed­ding cer­e­mo­ny unfolds, Eilis’s thoughts drift to her past, par­tic­u­lar­ly to Jim and the emo­tion­al com­plex­i­ties sur­round­ing their part­ing. She reflects on the lone­li­ness of her ear­ly days in Amer­i­ca and the nar­ra­tive she has con­struct­ed about her jour­ney and rela­tion­ships. The con­trast between her pri­vate real­i­ties and the sto­ries cir­cu­lat­ed by Tony’s broth­ers reveals the dis­so­nance between pub­lic per­cep­tion and per­son­al truth, illus­trat­ing the chal­lenges of rec­on­cil­ing dif­fer­ent facets of her life.

    The chap­ter clos­es with Eilis’s con­tin­ued intro­spec­tion dur­ing the mass, con­tem­plat­ing her con­nec­tion to home and the peo­ple she left behind. Her silence on cer­tain mat­ters, such as Jim’s exis­tence and the true nature of her rela­tion­ship with Tony, points to the unre­solved emo­tion­al under­cur­rents shap­ing her expe­ri­ence. This nuanced por­tray­al empha­sizes themes of iden­ti­ty, belong­ing, and the com­plex­i­ties inher­ent in bal­anc­ing per­son­al his­to­ry with soci­etal expec­ta­tions.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Eilis’s mother express her concerns about Eilis’s outfit, and what does this reveal about their relationship?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s mother critiques the blue dress by saying, “Blue is not your colour,” and suggests that the yellow dress might suit her better, especially if paired with a black jacket and pillbox hat. This interaction reveals a protective and opinionated side of her mother, who cares deeply about Eilis’s appearance and how she is perceived by others. Though initially critical, her mother ultimately offers a kind compliment, saying Eilis “could wear anything and look marvellous,” which Eilis recognizes as the first kind thing since her return. This moment highlights the complexity of their relationship—marked by underlying care amidst tension—and shows the mother’s desire to guide Eilis through social expectations in their community.

      2. What significance does the cathedral wedding setting hold for Eilis, and how does it affect her reflections during the ceremony?

      Answer:
      The cathedral wedding setting brings Eilis face-to-face with her past and community, including people she knows and memories of those who have passed, such as George Sheridan. Seeing the bride and her brother who resemble their late father evokes the absence felt by Nancy and others, making George’s death starkly present. The formal religious setting also contrasts with Eilis’s internal emotional state; while prayers are said, she is distracted by thoughts of Jim Farrell and her complex feelings about her life choices, relationships, and the story she tells others about her migration. The cathedral thus acts as a physical and symbolic space where Eilis confronts themes of loss, belonging, and identity.

      3. Analyze how Eilis’s internal conflict about Jim Farrell and Tony is portrayed in this chapter. What does this reveal about her emotional state?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s internal conflict is portrayed through her lingering thoughts about Jim walking away without looking back and her reflections on the story she tells about Tony and her move to America. She imagines a conversation with Jim that never happened, revealing unresolved feelings and a sense of what might have been. At the same time, she accepts the narrative about Tony’s love crafted by his brothers, knowing it is not entirely true but choosing not to confront it. This duality reveals Eilis’s emotional complexity: she is caught between past and present, longing and acceptance, and the pressure to conform to simplified stories about her life. Her emotional state is one of quiet turmoil and guarded reflection.

      4. How does the chapter explore the theme of social perception and community judgment? Provide examples from the text.

      Answer:
      The theme of social perception and community judgment is evident in the mother’s concern about “the whole town” looking at Eilis and having opinions about her dress and appearance. This highlights the weight of communal scrutiny in their environment. At the cathedral, Eilis is greeted by acquaintances who comment on her mother’s health and her sister Rose’s elegance, reinforcing the importance of reputation and family legacy. Eilis also notices Jim Farrell’s solitary presence and is aware that “everyone here must know some version of what had happened between them,” suggesting the pervasive nature of gossip and social surveillance. These examples demonstrate how individuals navigate social expectations and the impact of public opinion on personal identity.

      5. If you were advising Eilis on how to reconcile her past experiences with her present life, what strategies might you suggest based on the chapter’s insights?

      Answer:
      Based on the chapter, advising Eilis would involve encouraging her to openly acknowledge her complex feelings rather than suppress them. Strategies might include seeking honest conversations with those involved, such as Jim or Tony, to clarify unresolved emotions and reduce internal conflict. Emphasizing self-compassion and recognizing that her life story is multifaceted—not just the simplified versions told by others—could help her embrace her identity more fully. Additionally, finding ways to balance her private reflections with public expectations, perhaps by setting boundaries around what she shares, may ease the pressure of community judgment. Ultimately, fostering a sense of agency over her narrative could empower her to integrate past and present in a healthy way.

    Quotes

    • 1. “‘The whole town will be looking at you. And they will all have an opinion.’”

      This quote captures the social pressure and scrutiny Eilis faces from her community, highlighting the theme of judgment and expectation that permeates her experience. It sets the tone for the chapter’s exploration of personal identity versus public perception.

      2. “‘I think you could wear anything and look marvellous. You always do.’”

      This is a rare moment of maternal kindness and affirmation that reveals the complex relationship between Eilis and her mother. It underscores a subtle encouragement amid the mother’s otherwise critical stance, adding emotional depth to the narrative.

      3. “As the bride was accompanied up the aisle by her brother, Eilis… was amazed at how much they both looked like their father… George was so good-humoured, so solid and decent… And now he was absent.”

      This passage poignantly reflects on loss and absence within family dynamics, emphasizing the emotional weight of the wedding setting. It also contrasts public celebration with private grief, enriching the chapter’s themes of memory and mourning.

      4. “If he had glanced behind, even for one second, he would have seen her standing on the lane, looking after him, wondering why he did not turn.”

      This introspective moment reveals Eilis’s lingering feelings and the unresolved tension between her and Jim Farrell. It captures the chapter’s undercurrent of longing and missed connection, highlighting her internal struggle.

      5. “‘It was a whirlwind,’ Enzo added. ‘Tony was a miserable bachelor one day and the next was a happy married man.’”

      This quote illustrates the mythologizing of Eilis’s life story by those around her, contrasting with her own more complicated and private reality. It explores themes of narrative control and the simplification of personal history within family and community discourse.

    Quotes

    1. “‘The whole town will be looking at you. And they will all have an opinion.’”

    This quote captures the social pressure and scrutiny Eilis faces from her community, highlighting the theme of judgment and expectation that permeates her experience. It sets the tone for the chapter’s exploration of personal identity versus public perception.

    2. “‘I think you could wear anything and look marvellous. You always do.’”

    This is a rare moment of maternal kindness and affirmation that reveals the complex relationship between Eilis and her mother. It underscores a subtle encouragement amid the mother’s otherwise critical stance, adding emotional depth to the narrative.

    3. “As the bride was accompanied up the aisle by her brother, Eilis… was amazed at how much they both looked like their father… George was so good-humoured, so solid and decent… And now he was absent.”

    This passage poignantly reflects on loss and absence within family dynamics, emphasizing the emotional weight of the wedding setting. It also contrasts public celebration with private grief, enriching the chapter’s themes of memory and mourning.

    4. “If he had glanced behind, even for one second, he would have seen her standing on the lane, looking after him, wondering why he did not turn.”

    This introspective moment reveals Eilis’s lingering feelings and the unresolved tension between her and Jim Farrell. It captures the chapter’s undercurrent of longing and missed connection, highlighting her internal struggle.

    5. “‘It was a whirlwind,’ Enzo added. ‘Tony was a miserable bachelor one day and the next was a happy married man.’”

    This quote illustrates the mythologizing of Eilis’s life story by those around her, contrasting with her own more complicated and private reality. It explores themes of narrative control and the simplification of personal history within family and community discourse.

    FAQs

    1. How does Eilis’s mother express her concerns about Eilis’s outfit, and what does this reveal about their relationship?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s mother critiques the blue dress by saying, “Blue is not your colour,” and suggests that the yellow dress might suit her better, especially if paired with a black jacket and pillbox hat. This interaction reveals a protective and opinionated side of her mother, who cares deeply about Eilis’s appearance and how she is perceived by others. Though initially critical, her mother ultimately offers a kind compliment, saying Eilis “could wear anything and look marvellous,” which Eilis recognizes as the first kind thing since her return. This moment highlights the complexity of their relationship—marked by underlying care amidst tension—and shows the mother’s desire to guide Eilis through social expectations in their community.

    2. What significance does the cathedral wedding setting hold for Eilis, and how does it affect her reflections during the ceremony?

    Answer:
    The cathedral wedding setting brings Eilis face-to-face with her past and community, including people she knows and memories of those who have passed, such as George Sheridan. Seeing the bride and her brother who resemble their late father evokes the absence felt by Nancy and others, making George’s death starkly present. The formal religious setting also contrasts with Eilis’s internal emotional state; while prayers are said, she is distracted by thoughts of Jim Farrell and her complex feelings about her life choices, relationships, and the story she tells others about her migration. The cathedral thus acts as a physical and symbolic space where Eilis confronts themes of loss, belonging, and identity.

    3. Analyze how Eilis’s internal conflict about Jim Farrell and Tony is portrayed in this chapter. What does this reveal about her emotional state?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s internal conflict is portrayed through her lingering thoughts about Jim walking away without looking back and her reflections on the story she tells about Tony and her move to America. She imagines a conversation with Jim that never happened, revealing unresolved feelings and a sense of what might have been. At the same time, she accepts the narrative about Tony’s love crafted by his brothers, knowing it is not entirely true but choosing not to confront it. This duality reveals Eilis’s emotional complexity: she is caught between past and present, longing and acceptance, and the pressure to conform to simplified stories about her life. Her emotional state is one of quiet turmoil and guarded reflection.

    4. How does the chapter explore the theme of social perception and community judgment? Provide examples from the text.

    Answer:
    The theme of social perception and community judgment is evident in the mother’s concern about “the whole town” looking at Eilis and having opinions about her dress and appearance. This highlights the weight of communal scrutiny in their environment. At the cathedral, Eilis is greeted by acquaintances who comment on her mother’s health and her sister Rose’s elegance, reinforcing the importance of reputation and family legacy. Eilis also notices Jim Farrell’s solitary presence and is aware that “everyone here must know some version of what had happened between them,” suggesting the pervasive nature of gossip and social surveillance. These examples demonstrate how individuals navigate social expectations and the impact of public opinion on personal identity.

    5. If you were advising Eilis on how to reconcile her past experiences with her present life, what strategies might you suggest based on the chapter’s insights?

    Answer:
    Based on the chapter, advising Eilis would involve encouraging her to openly acknowledge her complex feelings rather than suppress them. Strategies might include seeking honest conversations with those involved, such as Jim or Tony, to clarify unresolved emotions and reduce internal conflict. Emphasizing self-compassion and recognizing that her life story is multifaceted—not just the simplified versions told by others—could help her embrace her identity more fully. Additionally, finding ways to balance her private reflections with public expectations, perhaps by setting boundaries around what she shares, may ease the pressure of community judgment. Ultimately, fostering a sense of agency over her narrative could empower her to integrate past and present in a healthy way.

    Note