A Court of Thorns and Roses
Chapter 17
by Maas, Sarah J.In Chapter 17, the protagonist awakens abruptly from a disturbing nightmare filled with ominous visions and a sense of foreboding. The dream’s imagery, including the Suriel’s bone-fingers and a faceless woman demanding her name, sets a tone of unease and hints at deeper, unseen threats. As she regains her composure, she hears unusual sounds—shouts and screams—from the manor’s front hall, prompting her to investigate. Her instinct to understand what is happening drives her to leave her room, revealing her growing concern about the safety and mysteries surrounding her surroundings.
Upon reaching the hall, she witnesses a harrowing scene: Tamlin carrying a severely wounded faerie, whose injuries are devastating and graphic. The faerie, almost as large as Tamlin, is bleeding profusely from the stumps where his wings once were, torn off in a brutal act. The scene underscores the violence inflicted by an unknown enemy, and Tamlin’s urgent commands to tend to the injured highlight the severity of the attack. The description of the faerie’s injuries, with jagged wounds and raw tissue, emphasizes the cruelty of the assault and the high stakes involved.
The chapter reveals that the attacker, a mysterious female figure, has not merely injured but has deliberately ripped off the faerie’s wings, leaving him in a state of shock and imminent danger of death. Tamlin’s attempt to treat the wounds with magic is thwarted, as he admits that he cannot heal such major damage anymore. The scene intensifies as the faerie’s condition deteriorates rapidly, blood flowing uncontrollably and his life hanging by a thread. The protagonist’s empathetic response, holding the faerie’s hand and trying to comfort him, underscores her growing awareness of the violence and peril that permeate their world.
By the chapter’s end, the grim reality becomes clear: the faerie’s injuries are fatal without immediate intervention. The sense of impending death is palpable, with Tamlin recognizing that the wounds won’t clot and that the faerie is unlikely to survive. The protagonist’s attempt to reassure the dying faerie, despite the bleak circumstances, highlights her compassion amid a brutal and uncertain environment. The chapter leaves a lingering sense of dread, emphasizing the dangerous forces at play and the devastating consequences of the unseen enemy’s ruthless attack.
FAQs
-
1. Question 1
What are the key events that occur in Chapter 17, and how do they reveal the stakes and the danger faced by the characters?
Answer:
In Chapter 17, the protagonist wakes suddenly from a nightmare and hears shouts and screams from the front hall of the manor. She discovers Tamlin rushing in with a severely injured faerie who has been brutally mutilated—his wings have been torn off in a jagged, bloody manner. This scene reveals the imminent danger and violence in their world, emphasizing the threat posed by the mysterious “she” who is responsible for the attack. The faerie’s suffering and Tamlin’s urgent actions highlight the high stakes, as they are dealing with a powerful, malevolent force capable of such brutal damage, underscoring the peril that looms over them and the importance of uncovering the enemy’s identity.2. Question 2
Describe the nature of the injuries inflicted on the faerie and what they symbolize about the antagonist’s methods and intentions.
Answer:
The faerie’s injuries are severe and disturbing—they have had their wings ripped off in jagged, uneven cuts, as if sawed away bit by bit. Blood gushes from the black stumps on his back, and the wounds are raw and jagged, indicating a deliberate, brutal mutilation rather than a simple attack. These injuries symbolize the malicious intent and cruelty of the antagonist, who does not merely defeat her victims but destroys an essential part of their identity and freedom—wings symbolize flight, freedom, and power. The violence inflicted reflects her ruthless desire to dominate and torment, emphasizing her capacity for sadistic harm and the threat she poses to others.3. Question 3
How does the chapter illustrate the themes of vulnerability and helplessness, and what does this suggest about the characters’ emotional states?
Answer:
The chapter vividly depicts vulnerability through the faerie’s injuries, as his wings—an integral part of his being—are forcibly taken, leaving him weak, in shock, and on the brink of death. The protagonist’s efforts to hold him down and stop his thrashing reveal a moment of helplessness, as she cannot undo the damage or save him outright. Tamlin’s inability to use magic for major injuries and Lucien’s visceral reaction—vomiting and backing away—further emphasize the characters’ powerlessness in the face of such brutality. These scenes evoke feelings of despair, fear, and helplessness, illustrating how trauma and violence can strip characters of their strength and agency, heightening the emotional stakes of the story.4. Question 4
What might the act of ripping off the faerie’s wings represent metaphorically within the context of the story’s themes?
Answer:
Metaphorically, ripping off the faerie’s wings represents the destruction of freedom, identity, and autonomy. Wings are a symbol of flight, escape, and self-determination, and their removal signifies a brutal attempt to strip the victim of these qualities. Within the broader themes of the story, this act underscores the cruelty and control exerted by the antagonist—she not only physically harms her victims but also aims to break their spirits and sense of self. It highlights the theme of powerlessness against malevolent forces and the devastating impact of violence designed to dominate and dehumanize.5. Question 5
Based on the chapter, how might the characters’ experiences with violence influence their future actions and relationships?
Answer:
The characters’ direct encounters with violence, especially the brutal mutilation of the faerie, are likely to deepen their sense of vulnerability and urgency. Witnessing such cruelty can foster a desire for justice or revenge, motivating them to uncover and confront the antagonist. It may also strengthen their bonds, as they rely on each other for support and survival amid trauma. Conversely, such experiences could lead to feelings of helplessness or fear, potentially causing emotional withdrawal or cautiousness in their interactions. Overall, these traumatic events will shape their future decisions—prompting them to seek safety, justice, and perhaps vengeance, while also testing their resilience and capacity for trust.
Quotes
1. “She took my wings.”
This haunting refrain underscores the brutal violence inflicted upon the faerie, symbolizing a profound loss and the cruelty of the antagonist. It highlights the chapter’s central theme of pain and helplessness, setting the tone for the scene’s intense emotional impact.
2. “Blood oozed from the black velvety stumps on the faerie’s back. The wounds were jagged—cartilage and tissue severed in what looked like uneven cuts. As if she’d sawed off his wings bit by bit.”
This vivid description emphasizes the brutality of the injury, illustrating the extent of the violence and the merciless power of the antagonist. It deepens the reader’s understanding of the faerie’s suffering and the stakes involved.
3. “It was instinct, or mercy, or desperation, perhaps, to grab the faerie’s upper arms and shove him down again, pinning him to the table as gently as I could.”
This quote reveals the narrator’s compassion and internal conflict—her instinctive desire to help clashes with the brutal reality of the injuries. It highlights her empathetic response amidst chaos.
4. “Tamlin swallowed hard. ‘No. Not for major damage. Once, but not any longer.’”
This moment exposes the limitations of magic and hints at a shift in the narrative’s understanding of what can be healed. It marks a key turning point, illustrating the harsh reality that some wounds are beyond immediate remedy.
5. “It will be all right,” I said, and hoped he couldn’t smell lies the way that I could.”
This closing line encapsulates the chapter’s poignant tone—an attempt at reassurance in the face of impending death—highlighting themes of hope and the human (or faerie) instinct to comfort even when the outcome is grim.