Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story

    Plain Truth: A Novel

    by

    Picoult, Jodi

    Jodi Picoult’s Plain Truth (2000) is a legal drama and cultural exploration set in Pennsylvania’s Amish community. The novel centers on Katie Fisher, an unmarried Amish teenager accused of murdering her newborn after the infant’s body is discovered on her family’s farm. Ellie Hathaway, a disillusioned defense attorney, takes on Katie’s case and must live among the Amish as part of bail conditions. The story examines clashes between modern justice and Amish traditions, themes of secrecy, faith, and maternal bonds. Picoult weaves courtroom tension with insights into Amish life, culminating in revelations about the infant’s death and Katie’s hidden trauma. The novel is noted for its research into Plain Sect culture and moral ambiguity.

    PreviousNext
    Plain Truth: A Novel

    TWELVE

    by

    Picoult, Jodi

    In this chap­ter, Ellie, the pro­tag­o­nist and lawyer, grap­ples with a moral dilem­ma while research­ing case law in the supe­ri­or court library. She is approached by George Calla­han, the coun­ty attor­ney, who offers a plea bar­gain for her client, Katie—an Amish girl accused of mur­der. George pro­pos­es reduc­ing the charge to manslaugh­ter with a ten-year sen­tence, poten­tial­ly halved with good behav­ior. Ellie express­es con­cern about Katie’s abil­i­ty to sur­vive prison, but George argues it’s a bet­ter alter­na­tive to life impris­on­ment. The exchange high­lights the ten­sion between legal prag­ma­tism and human com­pas­sion, set­ting the stage for Ellie’s dif­fi­cult con­ver­sa­tion with Katie.

    Ellie meets Katie at her home, where the young Amish woman is iron­ing clothes, embody­ing the domes­tic life she may lose. Ellie explains the plea bar­gain, fram­ing it as a way to end the legal ordeal by admit­ting guilt in exchange for a reduced sen­tence. Katie ini­tial­ly reacts with relief at the prospect of clo­sure, but her enthu­si­asm wanes when she real­izes she would still face impris­on­ment. Ellie attempts to dis­suade her by empha­siz­ing the uncer­tain­ty of tri­al out­comes and the harsh real­i­ties of prison, but Katie’s cul­tur­al upbring­ing pre­dis­pos­es her to accept respon­si­bil­i­ty and pun­ish­ment with­out resis­tance.

    The chap­ter delves deep­er into Katie’s world­view as she ques­tions Ellie about the like­li­hood of acquit­tal. Ellie, usu­al­ly con­fi­dent in her legal strate­gies, admits she can­not guar­an­tee an acquit­tal due to the rushed prepa­ra­tion of their defense. Katie’s deci­sion to accept the plea bar­gain reflects her Amish val­ues of humil­i­ty and accep­tance, con­trast­ing sharply with Ellie’s adver­sar­i­al legal mind­set. Ellie, torn between her pro­fes­sion­al duty and per­son­al con­cern, tries one last time to dis­suade Katie by arrang­ing a tour of the prison, hop­ing the stark real­i­ty will change her mind.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Ellie tak­ing Katie to the State Cor­rec­tion­al Insti­tu­tion at Muncy for a first­hand look at prison life. The impos­ing envi­ron­ment, marked by barred doors and a reg­i­ment­ed din­ing hall, is a stark con­trast to Katie’s peace­ful Amish com­mu­ni­ty. Ellie’s inten­tion is to shock Katie into recon­sid­er­ing the plea bar­gain, but the chap­ter leaves their reac­tions unre­solved. This scene under­scores the clash between Katie’s cul­tur­al inno­cence and the bru­tal real­i­ty of the jus­tice sys­tem, leav­ing read­ers to pon­der whether Katie will main­tain her resolve or recon­sid­er her deci­sion after wit­ness­ing the harsh con­di­tions of incar­cer­a­tion.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. What plea bargain does the county attorney offer Katie, and what are its terms?

      Answer:
      The county attorney, George Callahan, offers Katie a plea bargain where she can plead guilty to manslaughter instead of first-degree murder. In exchange, her sentence would be reduced from life imprisonment to ten years, with the possibility of parole after five or six years for good behavior. This deal would allow Katie to avoid a trial and accept responsibility for her actions while receiving a shorter prison sentence. However, Ellie expresses concern about whether Katie, as an Amish girl, would be able to survive in prison even for this reduced term.

      2. How does Katie’s Amish background influence her reaction to the plea bargain?

      Answer:
      Katie’s Amish upbringing plays a significant role in her willingness to accept the plea bargain. The Amish value humility, acceptance of consequences, and avoiding conflict, which makes the idea of admitting wrongdoing and accepting punishment appealing to her. Unlike many defendants who might hold out for acquittal, Katie sees the plea as a way to bring the situation to a quick resolution. Ellie notes that Amish culture discourages seeking “the best” outcome if it comes at someone else’s expense, which contrasts with the typical legal strategy of fighting for full acquittal.

      3. Why does Ellie take Katie to visit the prison before accepting the plea deal?

      Answer:
      Ellie takes Katie to the State Correctional Institution at Muncy to show her the harsh reality of prison life. She wants Katie to understand what she would be facing—a environment filled with “bad people” and strict confinement—before making a final decision. Ellie fears that Katie, coming from a sheltered Amish community, doesn’t fully grasp how difficult prison would be for her. The tour includes the dining hall and control booth, where the barred door slamming shut visibly unsettles Katie, emphasizing the intimidating nature of the facility.

      Answer:
      Ellie typically encourages clients to reject plea bargains and fight for acquittal at trial, confident in her ability to win cases. However, with Katie, she is more hesitant. The abbreviated preparation time for the new defense and Katie’s unique cultural background make the outcome less certain. Ellie also feels a personal concern for Katie’s well-being, advising her as a friend rather than just a lawyer. This emotional investment and the case’s complexities lead Ellie to present the plea option more neutrally, despite her usual preference for trials.

      5. What internal conflict does Ellie experience regarding Katie’s decision?

      Answer:
      Ellie struggles between her professional duty as a lawyer and her personal concern for Katie. Professionally, she must present the plea bargain objectively, but personally, she believes prison would be devastating for Katie. She worries that Katie’s cultural upbringing—emphasizing acceptance of punishment—may lead her to make a choice without fully understanding the consequences. Ellie’s conflict is evident when she warns Katie about the dangers of prison, stating it’s full of “bad people,” and questions whether the plea is truly the right path, despite her obligation to honor Katie’s wishes.

    Quotes

    • 1. “She’s got a better chance of making it through five years than fifty.”

      This quote from prosecutor George Callahan captures the central dilemma of the plea bargain - whether to accept a reduced sentence or risk a lifetime in prison. It represents the pragmatic legal perspective contrasting with Ellie’s emotional concern for Katie’s wellbeing.

      2. “An Amishman took what he was given-he didn’t hold out for the best, because that would only come at someone else’s expense, someone who didn’t get the best.”

      This insight from Ellie explains Katie’s cultural perspective and why she might accept the plea deal. It highlights the fundamental conflict between Amish values of acceptance and the adversarial nature of the legal system.

      3. “I think I can get you acquitted. I hope I can get you acquitted. But Katie… I can’t give you my word.”

      This pivotal moment shows Ellie’s professional honesty and the painful limitations of legal defense. It marks a turning point where Katie must make her decision without absolute certainty of the trial’s outcome.

      4. “You don’t know what prison is like. It’s not only full of English people-it’s full of bad people. I don’t think this is the way to go.”

      Ellie’s warning as a friend rather than a lawyer reveals her deep concern for Katie’s welfare. This quote underscores the cultural and personal dangers Katie would face in prison, beyond just the legal consequences.

      5. “The barred door slammed shut behind Katie and made her draw in her breath.”

      This visceral moment during the prison tour symbolizes the harsh reality of incarceration. It serves as a powerful foreshadowing of what Katie’s future might hold if she accepts the plea deal.

    Quotes

    1. “She’s got a better chance of making it through five years than fifty.”

    This quote from prosecutor George Callahan captures the central dilemma of the plea bargain - whether to accept a reduced sentence or risk a lifetime in prison. It represents the pragmatic legal perspective contrasting with Ellie’s emotional concern for Katie’s wellbeing.

    2. “An Amishman took what he was given-he didn’t hold out for the best, because that would only come at someone else’s expense, someone who didn’t get the best.”

    This insight from Ellie explains Katie’s cultural perspective and why she might accept the plea deal. It highlights the fundamental conflict between Amish values of acceptance and the adversarial nature of the legal system.

    3. “I think I can get you acquitted. I hope I can get you acquitted. But Katie… I can’t give you my word.”

    This pivotal moment shows Ellie’s professional honesty and the painful limitations of legal defense. It marks a turning point where Katie must make her decision without absolute certainty of the trial’s outcome.

    4. “You don’t know what prison is like. It’s not only full of English people-it’s full of bad people. I don’t think this is the way to go.”

    Ellie’s warning as a friend rather than a lawyer reveals her deep concern for Katie’s welfare. This quote underscores the cultural and personal dangers Katie would face in prison, beyond just the legal consequences.

    5. “The barred door slammed shut behind Katie and made her draw in her breath.”

    This visceral moment during the prison tour symbolizes the harsh reality of incarceration. It serves as a powerful foreshadowing of what Katie’s future might hold if she accepts the plea deal.

    FAQs

    1. What plea bargain does the county attorney offer Katie, and what are its terms?

    Answer:
    The county attorney, George Callahan, offers Katie a plea bargain where she can plead guilty to manslaughter instead of first-degree murder. In exchange, her sentence would be reduced from life imprisonment to ten years, with the possibility of parole after five or six years for good behavior. This deal would allow Katie to avoid a trial and accept responsibility for her actions while receiving a shorter prison sentence. However, Ellie expresses concern about whether Katie, as an Amish girl, would be able to survive in prison even for this reduced term.

    2. How does Katie’s Amish background influence her reaction to the plea bargain?

    Answer:
    Katie’s Amish upbringing plays a significant role in her willingness to accept the plea bargain. The Amish value humility, acceptance of consequences, and avoiding conflict, which makes the idea of admitting wrongdoing and accepting punishment appealing to her. Unlike many defendants who might hold out for acquittal, Katie sees the plea as a way to bring the situation to a quick resolution. Ellie notes that Amish culture discourages seeking “the best” outcome if it comes at someone else’s expense, which contrasts with the typical legal strategy of fighting for full acquittal.

    3. Why does Ellie take Katie to visit the prison before accepting the plea deal?

    Answer:
    Ellie takes Katie to the State Correctional Institution at Muncy to show her the harsh reality of prison life. She wants Katie to understand what she would be facing—a environment filled with “bad people” and strict confinement—before making a final decision. Ellie fears that Katie, coming from a sheltered Amish community, doesn’t fully grasp how difficult prison would be for her. The tour includes the dining hall and control booth, where the barred door slamming shut visibly unsettles Katie, emphasizing the intimidating nature of the facility.

    Answer:
    Ellie typically encourages clients to reject plea bargains and fight for acquittal at trial, confident in her ability to win cases. However, with Katie, she is more hesitant. The abbreviated preparation time for the new defense and Katie’s unique cultural background make the outcome less certain. Ellie also feels a personal concern for Katie’s well-being, advising her as a friend rather than just a lawyer. This emotional investment and the case’s complexities lead Ellie to present the plea option more neutrally, despite her usual preference for trials.

    5. What internal conflict does Ellie experience regarding Katie’s decision?

    Answer:
    Ellie struggles between her professional duty as a lawyer and her personal concern for Katie. Professionally, she must present the plea bargain objectively, but personally, she believes prison would be devastating for Katie. She worries that Katie’s cultural upbringing—emphasizing acceptance of punishment—may lead her to make a choice without fully understanding the consequences. Ellie’s conflict is evident when she warns Katie about the dangers of prison, stating it’s full of “bad people,” and questions whether the plea is truly the right path, despite her obligation to honor Katie’s wishes.

    Note