Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story

    Plain Truth: A Novel

    by

    Picoult, Jodi

    Jodi Picoult’s Plain Truth (2000) is a legal drama and cultural exploration set in Pennsylvania’s Amish community. The novel centers on Katie Fisher, an unmarried Amish teenager accused of murdering her newborn after the infant’s body is discovered on her family’s farm. Ellie Hathaway, a disillusioned defense attorney, takes on Katie’s case and must live among the Amish as part of bail conditions. The story examines clashes between modern justice and Amish traditions, themes of secrecy, faith, and maternal bonds. Picoult weaves courtroom tension with insights into Amish life, culminating in revelations about the infant’s death and Katie’s hidden trauma. The novel is noted for its research into Plain Sect culture and moral ambiguity.

    PreviousNext
    Plain Truth: A Novel

    EIGHT

    by

    Picoult, Jodi

    The chap­ter opens with Ellie reflect­ing on her favorite spot at the Fish­er farm—the milk room—where she works on her lap­top amidst the cool, clean envi­ron­ment. Her soli­tude is inter­rupt­ed when Leda, her excom­mu­ni­cat­ed aunt, vis­its after ten days. Their ban­ter reveals Ellie’s adjust­ment to farm life, marked by humor­ous mishaps, while Leda teas­es her about the stark con­trast between her legal career and rur­al real­i­ties. The con­ver­sa­tion shifts to Katie’s recent clean bill of health from the doc­tor, though Ellie remains con­cerned about her men­tal state, hint­ing at unre­solved trau­ma.

    Ellie con­fides in Leda about her plans to involve a psy­chi­a­trist, sus­pect­ing Katie might have repressed mem­o­ries of a sex­u­al assault, giv­en her denial of the preg­nan­cy and birth. Leda defends Samuel, Katie’s Amish beau, but Ellie dis­miss­es the idea that he’s the father, sug­gest­ing the per­pe­tra­tor could still be some­one with­in the com­mu­ni­ty. Ten­sion ris­es as Ellie press­es Leda for with­held infor­ma­tion, frus­trat­ed by the lack of trans­paren­cy in Katie’s case. Leda’s dis­com­fort sig­nals a deep­er secret, fore­shad­ow­ing a rev­e­la­tion.

    The truth emerges: Katie has been secret­ly vis­it­ing her excom­mu­ni­cat­ed broth­er, Jacob, at a uni­ver­si­ty once a month, with her mother’s tac­it approval but her father’s vehe­ment dis­ap­proval. Ellie is furi­ous at this omis­sion, real­iz­ing it could be cru­cial to Katie’s defense. Leda explains that Jacob left the Amish com­mu­ni­ty to pur­sue edu­ca­tion, lead­ing Aaron to dis­own him, while Sarah covert­ly main­tains ties through Katie. This famil­ial rift under­scores the ten­sion between Amish tra­di­tions and per­son­al desires.

    The chap­ter clos­es with Ellie grap­pling with the impli­ca­tions of this dis­cov­ery, as the mechan­i­cal hum of the milk tank’s stir­rer punc­tu­ates the con­ver­sa­tion. The rev­e­la­tion of Jacob’s exis­tence and Katie’s clan­des­tine vis­its adds com­plex­i­ty to Ellie’s defense strat­e­gy, sug­gest­ing Katie’s expo­sure to the out­side world may hold clues to the baby’s con­cep­tion. The scene under­scores themes of secre­cy, famil­ial loy­al­ty, and the clash between insu­lar tra­di­tions and exter­nal influ­ences.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. What is Ellie’s favorite place on the Fisher farm, and why does she prefer it?

      Answer:
      Ellie’s favorite place is the milk room because it stays cool thanks to the bulk refrigeration tank, even during the hottest times of the day. She describes it as smelling like ice cream and winter, with clean white walls and a spotless floor, making it an ideal place to sit and think. Additionally, she uses this space to work on her laptop once the inverter has charged its batteries, appreciating the quiet and comfort it provides amidst her challenging circumstances on the farm.

      2. How does Leda explain her delayed visit to Ellie, and what does this reveal about their relationship?

      Answer:
      Leda explains that she waited to visit Ellie to give her time to adjust to life on the farm, suggesting that if she had come sooner, Ellie might have tried to escape by hiding in her car. This reveals a playful yet understanding dynamic between them, where Leda knows Ellie well enough to anticipate her reactions. Their banter and shared humor indicate a close, trusting relationship, as Leda feels comfortable teasing Ellie about her initial reluctance to stay, while Ellie openly complains about the hardships she’s faced.

      3. What significant revelation does Leda share about Katie’s monthly trips, and how does this impact Ellie’s understanding of the case?

      Answer:
      Leda reveals that Katie secretly visits her excommunicated brother, Jacob, at the university in State College once a month, with Sarah’s knowledge but without Aaron’s approval. This shocks Ellie, as it suggests Katie has more contact with the “English” world than previously assumed. This information is crucial for Ellie’s defense strategy, as it opens up new possibilities about how Katie might have become pregnant—potentially through interactions outside the Amish community—and highlights the family’s hidden dynamics and secrets.

      4. Why does Ellie consider bringing a psychiatrist to evaluate Katie, and what does this suggest about her defense approach?

      Answer:
      Ellie considers a psychiatric evaluation because Katie continues to deny not only the pregnancy and birth but also the conception of the baby. Ellie suspects Katie might have been raped and could be repressing traumatic memories, which could explain her behavior and provide an emotional motive for the alleged crime. This approach shows Ellie’s thoroughness in building a defense that accounts for psychological factors, aiming to uncover the truth behind Katie’s actions while ensuring she receives appropriate mental health support.

      5. How does the chapter illustrate the tension between Amish traditions and external influences, particularly through the characters of Leda and Jacob?

      Answer:
      The chapter highlights this tension through Leda and Jacob, both of whom were excommunicated for pursuing lives outside Amish norms—Leda for unspecified reasons and Jacob for continuing his education. Their excommunication reflects the strict boundaries of the Amish community, yet their ongoing connections to the family (Katie’s visits to Jacob, Leda’s involvement in the case) show that these boundaries are sometimes permeable. This tension underscores the broader conflict between tradition and change, as well as the personal costs of choosing a path different from the community’s expectations.

    Quotes

    • 1. “According to the ME, that baby wasn’t stillborn, Leda.” […] “According to the prosecutor, Katie killed the baby. I don’t believe that either.”

      This exchange highlights the central tension of the chapter - the conflicting narratives about the baby’s death. Ellie presents the medical examiner’s factual findings while Leda voices her emotional disbelief, foreshadowing the moral complexity of Katie’s case.

      2. “I’m beginning to wonder if she might have been raped.”

      A pivotal moment where Ellie articulates her growing suspicion about Katie’s possible trauma. This quote represents a key turning point in the legal strategy and psychological understanding of the case.

      3. “Once a month she goes to State College on the train. To the university. […] Her brother.”

      This revelation exposes a hidden dimension of Katie’s life and family dynamics. The quote is significant as it introduces Jacob’s existence and the Fisher family’s secret division, which may hold clues to Katie’s situation.

      4. “Aaron took the high road, and said if Jacob left the church, he wouldn’t be his son any longer. His name isn’t mentioned in the house.”

      This quote powerfully illustrates the strict Amish family structure and the consequences of breaking religious rules. It provides crucial context for understanding the family’s dynamics and potential sources of stress for Katie.

    Quotes

    1. “According to the ME, that baby wasn’t stillborn, Leda.” […] “According to the prosecutor, Katie killed the baby. I don’t believe that either.”

    This exchange highlights the central tension of the chapter - the conflicting narratives about the baby’s death. Ellie presents the medical examiner’s factual findings while Leda voices her emotional disbelief, foreshadowing the moral complexity of Katie’s case.

    2. “I’m beginning to wonder if she might have been raped.”

    A pivotal moment where Ellie articulates her growing suspicion about Katie’s possible trauma. This quote represents a key turning point in the legal strategy and psychological understanding of the case.

    3. “Once a month she goes to State College on the train. To the university. […] Her brother.”

    This revelation exposes a hidden dimension of Katie’s life and family dynamics. The quote is significant as it introduces Jacob’s existence and the Fisher family’s secret division, which may hold clues to Katie’s situation.

    4. “Aaron took the high road, and said if Jacob left the church, he wouldn’t be his son any longer. His name isn’t mentioned in the house.”

    This quote powerfully illustrates the strict Amish family structure and the consequences of breaking religious rules. It provides crucial context for understanding the family’s dynamics and potential sources of stress for Katie.

    FAQs

    1. What is Ellie’s favorite place on the Fisher farm, and why does she prefer it?

    Answer:
    Ellie’s favorite place is the milk room because it stays cool thanks to the bulk refrigeration tank, even during the hottest times of the day. She describes it as smelling like ice cream and winter, with clean white walls and a spotless floor, making it an ideal place to sit and think. Additionally, she uses this space to work on her laptop once the inverter has charged its batteries, appreciating the quiet and comfort it provides amidst her challenging circumstances on the farm.

    2. How does Leda explain her delayed visit to Ellie, and what does this reveal about their relationship?

    Answer:
    Leda explains that she waited to visit Ellie to give her time to adjust to life on the farm, suggesting that if she had come sooner, Ellie might have tried to escape by hiding in her car. This reveals a playful yet understanding dynamic between them, where Leda knows Ellie well enough to anticipate her reactions. Their banter and shared humor indicate a close, trusting relationship, as Leda feels comfortable teasing Ellie about her initial reluctance to stay, while Ellie openly complains about the hardships she’s faced.

    3. What significant revelation does Leda share about Katie’s monthly trips, and how does this impact Ellie’s understanding of the case?

    Answer:
    Leda reveals that Katie secretly visits her excommunicated brother, Jacob, at the university in State College once a month, with Sarah’s knowledge but without Aaron’s approval. This shocks Ellie, as it suggests Katie has more contact with the “English” world than previously assumed. This information is crucial for Ellie’s defense strategy, as it opens up new possibilities about how Katie might have become pregnant—potentially through interactions outside the Amish community—and highlights the family’s hidden dynamics and secrets.

    4. Why does Ellie consider bringing a psychiatrist to evaluate Katie, and what does this suggest about her defense approach?

    Answer:
    Ellie considers a psychiatric evaluation because Katie continues to deny not only the pregnancy and birth but also the conception of the baby. Ellie suspects Katie might have been raped and could be repressing traumatic memories, which could explain her behavior and provide an emotional motive for the alleged crime. This approach shows Ellie’s thoroughness in building a defense that accounts for psychological factors, aiming to uncover the truth behind Katie’s actions while ensuring she receives appropriate mental health support.

    5. How does the chapter illustrate the tension between Amish traditions and external influences, particularly through the characters of Leda and Jacob?

    Answer:
    The chapter highlights this tension through Leda and Jacob, both of whom were excommunicated for pursuing lives outside Amish norms—Leda for unspecified reasons and Jacob for continuing his education. Their excommunication reflects the strict boundaries of the Amish community, yet their ongoing connections to the family (Katie’s visits to Jacob, Leda’s involvement in the case) show that these boundaries are sometimes permeable. This tension underscores the broader conflict between tradition and change, as well as the personal costs of choosing a path different from the community’s expectations.

    Note