I. A Beginning

In “The Shoes of Fortune,” the opening chapter lays a foundation full of wit and reflection on the unique quirks authors possess in their storytelling. Such a start is conscious and self-referential, teasing the potential reaction of readers familiar with Andersen’s style who might anticipate something predictable or repetitive, especially if he drew comparisons between Rome, Naples, and Copenhagen. However, it is precisely within Copenhagen, and more specifically, East Street, that Andersen chooses to anchor this tale, promising a blend of the local with the universal.

The setting transitions to a bustling, somewhat superficial social gathering in a house near the new market, where the intention behind the large gathering is partly to secure future invitations from guests. Amidst this scene, divided between card players and those idly waiting for amusement, the hostess’s attempt to stir entertainment echoes a common societal scenario. The conversation meanders into a debate about the merits of the present times versus the Middle Ages, with Councillor Knap championing the latter era as a pinnacle of interest and poetry, contrasted against the perceived dullness of the contemporary age. This discussion spirals into a collectively spirited defense of the Middle Ages, particularly extolling the reign of King Hans as the peak of nobility and happiness. Such a debate is not merely idle talk but hints at deeper contrasts between nostalgia for the past and the disenchantment with the modern era, cleverly using the microcosm of a social gathering to unfold these themes.

As the narrative unfolds, Andersen deftly weaves in the guests’ increasing engagement with the topic, a contrast to the initially thin stream of conversation that mostly drew from commonplace topics. This shift from superficial social rituals to a passionate exploration of history and values underpins the chapter’s exploration of human nature, society, and the timeless quest for meaning and excitement beyond the immediate confines of one’s existence. Through this lens, Andersen sets the stage for a tale that promises to delve into the complexities of life, ambition, and perhaps, the supernatural, all within the framework of his beloved Copenhagen.