Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Three:i

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter of *Part Three:i*, the nar­ra­tive cen­ters on Nancy’s grad­ual efforts to regain con­trol over her life fol­low­ing a peri­od of loss and tran­si­tion. Encour­aged by Lau­ra to adopt a brisk walk­ing rou­tine for health and weight loss, Nan­cy strug­gles with moti­va­tion and the phys­i­cal demands of the exer­cise. Their dif­fer­ing atti­tudes toward pace and pur­pose high­light Nancy’s ini­tial reluc­tance and Laura’s insis­tence on dis­ci­pline. Mean­while, prepa­ra­tions for Miriam’s wed­ding pro­vide a back­drop of famil­ial activ­i­ty, with Lau­ra empha­siz­ing the sig­nif­i­cance of the event and Miri­am express­ing a more detached, almost weary per­spec­tive.

    The chap­ter also explores Nancy’s inter­nal con­flict about her future liv­ing arrange­ments with Jim Far­rell, reveal­ing her cau­tious con­tem­pla­tion of shared plans and her desire to intro­duce the idea of build­ing a bun­ga­low. This sub­plot under­scores Nancy’s ten­ta­tive steps toward cre­at­ing a new home and life beyond her wid­ow­hood. The detailed descrip­tions of the updat­ed draw­ing room and Jim’s unchanged sit­ting room sym­bol­ize the con­trast­ing states of renew­al and stag­na­tion with­in their lives, reflect­ing deep­er emo­tion­al under­cur­rents.

    Nancy’s encounter with Nora Web­ster and her sis­ter Cather­ine intro­duces themes of social inter­ac­tion and com­mu­ni­ty per­cep­tion. Despite Nora’s empa­thet­ic out­reach, Nan­cy feels alien­at­ed by their assump­tions about her grief, under­scor­ing her need for auton­o­my and respect. The con­ver­sa­tion shifts to prac­ti­cal mat­ters, with Cather­ine offer­ing assis­tance in secur­ing a dress for the wed­ding, which Nan­cy accepts as a means to nav­i­gate social expec­ta­tions. This inter­ac­tion reveals Nancy’s bal­anc­ing act between vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty and resilience as she nego­ti­ates her place with­in her com­mu­ni­ty.

    Con­clud­ing the chap­ter, Nancy’s proac­tive step to con­tact Miss Met­calfe at Switzers in Dublin, facil­i­tat­ed by the con­nec­tion through Catherine’s friend Marie Bar­ry, marks a moment of agency and hope. This deci­sion sig­ni­fies Nancy’s will­ing­ness to engage with new oppor­tu­ni­ties and embrace change, despite lin­ger­ing uncer­tain­ties. Through­out the chap­ter, the inter­play of per­son­al deter­mi­na­tion, social dynam­ics, and impend­ing life events cre­ates a tex­tured por­tray­al of Nancy’s jour­ney toward renew­al and accep­tance.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Laura encourage Nancy to adopt a healthier lifestyle, and what challenges does Nancy face in following this advice?

      Answer:
      Laura advises Nancy to engage in brisk walking twice a day as a way to lose weight and improve her health, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a fast pace rather than a leisurely stroll. Nancy initially resists, preferring a slower pace and expressing discomfort with the speed Laura demands. Despite agreeing to walk regularly, Nancy struggles with motivation, often turning off her alarm before it rings and allowing herself to drift into half-sleep instead of starting her walk promptly. This illustrates Nancy’s internal conflict between her desire to improve and the inertia or emotional weight she carries, possibly linked to her recent widowhood and the stress surrounding Miriam’s wedding.

      2. What does the interaction between Nancy, Nora Webster, and Catherine reveal about social perceptions of widowhood and community support?

      Answer:
      The encounter highlights the delicate social dynamics surrounding widowhood in the community. While Nancy appreciates that her chip shop has shifted others’ perception of her from a figure of pity to a more independent woman, Nora and Catherine still approach her with a mixture of sympathy and cautious kindness. Nora’s earlier attempt to comfort Nancy by relating their shared experience of loss is remembered as well-intentioned but intrusive. Catherine’s offer to help Nancy find a special outfit for the wedding underscores a community effort to support her, but Nancy feels scrutinized and self-conscious, wishing she had better clothes. This interaction reveals both the support and subtle social pressures widows face, balancing empathy with the desire for privacy and dignity.

      3. Analyze how the preparations for Miriam’s wedding affect the characters’ emotions and interactions.

      Answer:
      Miriam’s wedding serves as a focal point of tension and anticipation. Miriam herself appears detached and somewhat overwhelmed, describing the event as “just a day” and expressing a wish for it to be over quickly, indicating her anxiety or ambivalence. Laura, in contrast, views the wedding as the most important day of Miriam’s life and tries to impress upon her its significance. Nancy’s attention is divided between practical concerns like walking for weight loss and the wedding arrangements. The wedding preparations also influence social interactions, as seen in Nancy’s worry about appearances and the opinions of others. This dynamic reveals the varied emotional responses to significant life events and how they can create both connection and strain among family members.

      4. How does Nancy’s consideration of future living arrangements reflect her hopes and uncertainties about her relationship with Jim Farrell?

      Answer:
      Nancy’s thoughts about where she and Jim might live after marriage reveal her cautious optimism and underlying uncertainty. She recognizes that Jim likely assumes she will move in with him above the pub, a traditional and practical choice. However, Nancy entertains the idea of building a bungalow, reflecting her desire for independence and perhaps a fresh start. She contemplates whether to share her plans about the bungalow and the site for sale at Lucas Park with Jim, hoping he might support or even initiate the idea. This internal deliberation illustrates Nancy’s balancing act between conforming to expected roles and pursuing her own aspirations, highlighting the complexities of negotiating future life paths within relationships.

      5. What role does social status and appearance play in Nancy’s interactions and self-perception throughout the chapter?

      Answer:
      Social status and appearance are significant undercurrents in Nancy’s experiences. She is acutely aware of how others perceive her, especially in the context of the upcoming wedding and her recent widowhood. Nancy worries about her clothing, fearing judgment if she appears poorly dressed, especially when encountering Nora and Catherine, who are noted as well-dressed and elegant. The fact that Nancy’s chip shop success has changed how people look at her—less as a sorrowful widow and more as a capable businesswoman—also affects her self-image. The emphasis on attire, social visits, and the drawing room’s decoration all point to a desire for respectability and acceptance, illustrating how social appearance influences identity and interpersonal dynamics in the community.

    Quotes

    • 1. “‘Don’t just stroll,’ Laura said. ‘That won’t help. A brisk walk twice a day. That’s what they recommend.’”

      This quote introduces a key theme of proactive self-care and determination, underscoring the importance of deliberate effort rather than passive action. It sets the stage for Nancy’s journey toward change and reflects the practical advice guiding her transformation.

      2. “‘It’s your wedding,’ Laura replied. ‘It is the most important day of your life.’”

      Here, the chapter highlights the emotional weight and significance of Miriam’s wedding, emphasizing how pivotal life events can bring both anticipation and pressure. This statement contrasts Miriam’s ambivalence, illustrating differing perspectives on what moments truly matter.

      3. “‘I know what you are going through. Maurice was the same age as George when he died and we were married the same number of years.’”

      This poignant moment captures the shared grief and isolation experienced by widows, while also revealing Nancy’s reluctance to be pitied or presumed understood. It deepens the emotional texture of the chapter and reflects on human connection in times of sorrow.

      4. “‘It’s a special day,’ Nora said. ‘I think you should do what Catherine suggests.’”

      This quote reflects the community’s supportive, sometimes intrusive, role in Nancy’s life, illustrating how social networks influence personal decisions. It conveys the tension between Nancy’s desire for independence and the practical help offered by others.

      5. “‘Any friend of Marie’s is a friend of mine.’”

      This concluding line from the chapter symbolizes the power of connection and endorsement within social circles. It marks a turning point where Nancy gains access to new opportunities through trust and recommendation, hinting at potential positive developments ahead.

    Quotes

    1. “‘Don’t just stroll,’ Laura said. ‘That won’t help. A brisk walk twice a day. That’s what they recommend.’”

    This quote introduces a key theme of proactive self-care and determination, underscoring the importance of deliberate effort rather than passive action. It sets the stage for Nancy’s journey toward change and reflects the practical advice guiding her transformation.

    2. “‘It’s your wedding,’ Laura replied. ‘It is the most important day of your life.’”

    Here, the chapter highlights the emotional weight and significance of Miriam’s wedding, emphasizing how pivotal life events can bring both anticipation and pressure. This statement contrasts Miriam’s ambivalence, illustrating differing perspectives on what moments truly matter.

    3. “‘I know what you are going through. Maurice was the same age as George when he died and we were married the same number of years.’”

    This poignant moment captures the shared grief and isolation experienced by widows, while also revealing Nancy’s reluctance to be pitied or presumed understood. It deepens the emotional texture of the chapter and reflects on human connection in times of sorrow.

    4. “‘It’s a special day,’ Nora said. ‘I think you should do what Catherine suggests.’”

    This quote reflects the community’s supportive, sometimes intrusive, role in Nancy’s life, illustrating how social networks influence personal decisions. It conveys the tension between Nancy’s desire for independence and the practical help offered by others.

    5. “‘Any friend of Marie’s is a friend of mine.’”

    This concluding line from the chapter symbolizes the power of connection and endorsement within social circles. It marks a turning point where Nancy gains access to new opportunities through trust and recommendation, hinting at potential positive developments ahead.

    FAQs

    1. How does Laura encourage Nancy to adopt a healthier lifestyle, and what challenges does Nancy face in following this advice?

    Answer:
    Laura advises Nancy to engage in brisk walking twice a day as a way to lose weight and improve her health, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a fast pace rather than a leisurely stroll. Nancy initially resists, preferring a slower pace and expressing discomfort with the speed Laura demands. Despite agreeing to walk regularly, Nancy struggles with motivation, often turning off her alarm before it rings and allowing herself to drift into half-sleep instead of starting her walk promptly. This illustrates Nancy’s internal conflict between her desire to improve and the inertia or emotional weight she carries, possibly linked to her recent widowhood and the stress surrounding Miriam’s wedding.

    2. What does the interaction between Nancy, Nora Webster, and Catherine reveal about social perceptions of widowhood and community support?

    Answer:
    The encounter highlights the delicate social dynamics surrounding widowhood in the community. While Nancy appreciates that her chip shop has shifted others’ perception of her from a figure of pity to a more independent woman, Nora and Catherine still approach her with a mixture of sympathy and cautious kindness. Nora’s earlier attempt to comfort Nancy by relating their shared experience of loss is remembered as well-intentioned but intrusive. Catherine’s offer to help Nancy find a special outfit for the wedding underscores a community effort to support her, but Nancy feels scrutinized and self-conscious, wishing she had better clothes. This interaction reveals both the support and subtle social pressures widows face, balancing empathy with the desire for privacy and dignity.

    3. Analyze how the preparations for Miriam’s wedding affect the characters’ emotions and interactions.

    Answer:
    Miriam’s wedding serves as a focal point of tension and anticipation. Miriam herself appears detached and somewhat overwhelmed, describing the event as “just a day” and expressing a wish for it to be over quickly, indicating her anxiety or ambivalence. Laura, in contrast, views the wedding as the most important day of Miriam’s life and tries to impress upon her its significance. Nancy’s attention is divided between practical concerns like walking for weight loss and the wedding arrangements. The wedding preparations also influence social interactions, as seen in Nancy’s worry about appearances and the opinions of others. This dynamic reveals the varied emotional responses to significant life events and how they can create both connection and strain among family members.

    4. How does Nancy’s consideration of future living arrangements reflect her hopes and uncertainties about her relationship with Jim Farrell?

    Answer:
    Nancy’s thoughts about where she and Jim might live after marriage reveal her cautious optimism and underlying uncertainty. She recognizes that Jim likely assumes she will move in with him above the pub, a traditional and practical choice. However, Nancy entertains the idea of building a bungalow, reflecting her desire for independence and perhaps a fresh start. She contemplates whether to share her plans about the bungalow and the site for sale at Lucas Park with Jim, hoping he might support or even initiate the idea. This internal deliberation illustrates Nancy’s balancing act between conforming to expected roles and pursuing her own aspirations, highlighting the complexities of negotiating future life paths within relationships.

    5. What role does social status and appearance play in Nancy’s interactions and self-perception throughout the chapter?

    Answer:
    Social status and appearance are significant undercurrents in Nancy’s experiences. She is acutely aware of how others perceive her, especially in the context of the upcoming wedding and her recent widowhood. Nancy worries about her clothing, fearing judgment if she appears poorly dressed, especially when encountering Nora and Catherine, who are noted as well-dressed and elegant. The fact that Nancy’s chip shop success has changed how people look at her—less as a sorrowful widow and more as a capable businesswoman—also affects her self-image. The emphasis on attire, social visits, and the drawing room’s decoration all point to a desire for respectability and acceptance, illustrating how social appearance influences identity and interpersonal dynamics in the community.

    Note