Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Two:iii

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter, Jim Far­rell, the pub own­er, notices a famil­iar fig­ure, Eilis Lacey, who seems to avoid his gaze, stir­ring a mix of recog­ni­tion and uncer­tain­ty. The nar­ra­tive reveals Jim’s con­nec­tions with local patrons, includ­ing Eilis’s moth­er and Mar­tin, who fre­quents the bar but remains dis­tant. The dynam­ics with­in the pub are high­light­ed through Jim’s obser­va­tions of the staff, par­tic­u­lar­ly Andy, a young and some­what cheeky bar­man whose pres­ence brings a new crowd, con­trast­ing with Jim’s more tra­di­tion­al approach to man­ag­ing the estab­lish­ment.

    Jim reflects on the his­to­ry and atmos­phere of the pub, which has remained large­ly unchanged since his grandfather’s time. Despite con­sid­er­ing mod­ern­iza­tion, he chose to pre­serve its old-fash­ioned charm, which appeals to a loy­al clien­tele, includ­ing local teach­ers and long­time patrons. The recent addi­tion of a back space has attract­ed younger sports enthu­si­asts, sub­tly trans­form­ing the pub’s social envi­ron­ment. Jim’s rou­tine includes tak­ing Thurs­days off to trav­el to Dublin but return­ing to main­tain his con­nec­tion with the pub and its com­mu­ni­ty.

    The chap­ter also delves into Jim’s per­son­al life, par­tic­u­lar­ly his inter­ac­tions with Colette, Shane’s wife, who vis­its him upstairs to encour­age him to find com­pan­ion­ship. Their con­ver­sa­tions reveal Jim’s lone­li­ness and reluc­tance to pur­sue new rela­tion­ships, com­pound­ed by his age and demand­ing work sched­ule. Colette’s per­sis­tent yet gen­tle prod­ding cul­mi­nates in her sug­gest­ing a poten­tial part­ner, a woman Jim has known all his life but nev­er con­sid­ered roman­ti­cal­ly, high­light­ing themes of missed oppor­tu­ni­ties and the com­plex­i­ties of human con­nec­tion.

    Ulti­mate­ly, the chap­ter paints a vivid pic­ture of Jim’s world—a blend of tra­di­tion, change, and per­son­al intro­spec­tion. It bal­ances the social rhythms of the pub with inti­mate moments of vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty, illus­trat­ing Jim’s strug­gle between hold­ing onto the past and embrac­ing the pos­si­bil­i­ty of new begin­nings. The sub­tle ten­sion between famil­iar­i­ty and change under­scores the emo­tion­al under­cur­rents that dri­ve the nar­ra­tive for­ward.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Jim perceive the changes in the clientele and atmosphere of the pub since he took it over from his father?

      Answer:
      Jim notices a gradual shift in the pub’s clientele and atmosphere over time. Initially, the pub was a quiet, traditional establishment with a steady trade, especially busy on weekends, reflecting its long history since the 1920s. With societal changes such as women beginning to frequent bars in the late 1960s, some pubs modernized by adding lounges, but Jim did not follow this trend. Instead, his pub retained its old-fashioned character. The clientele evolved to include local teachers during the week and a loyal group of regulars who guarded their space near the front door. More recently, the opening of a previously unused space at the back has attracted younger sports enthusiasts, friends of the new barman Andy, indicating a diversification but also a tension between tradition and change.

      2. What tensions arise between Jim and the new barman Andy, and what do these reveal about Jim’s character and management style?

      Answer:
      Jim experiences tension with Andy, the new young barman, primarily because Andy is impatient, cheeky, and behaves as though he is in charge, which Jim resents. Jim dislikes being told what to do, reflecting his need to maintain authority in his pub. However, he acknowledges Andy’s reliability with keys and cash, showing a pragmatic side. This dynamic reveals Jim’s struggle to adapt to new management styles and younger staff attitudes. It also highlights his desire for respect and control in his long-standing role, juxtaposed with the need to accommodate new customers and employees who bring fresh energy and crowds.

      3. Analyze the significance of Colette’s role in Jim’s life as depicted in the chapter. How does her interaction with Jim reflect broader themes in the narrative?

      Answer:
      Colette serves as a subtle catalyst in Jim’s personal life, encouraging him to consider companionship despite his resistance. Her visits upstairs, under the guise of passing through, gradually shift conversations toward Jim’s bachelor status and prospects for marriage. This interaction reflects themes of loneliness, social expectation, and the passage of time. Colette’s tactful and persistent encouragement contrasts with Jim’s defensive and somewhat resigned attitude, illustrating his isolation and reluctance to change. Her role symbolizes the community’s subtle pressures and hopes for Jim’s personal happiness, emphasizing the human need for connection amid the routines of life.

      4. What does the chapter suggest about Jim’s feelings toward Eilis Lacey, and how does this encounter contribute to the development of his character?

      Answer:
      Jim’s reaction to seeing Eilis Lacey is marked by a mixture of recognition, uncertainty, and a hint of emotional restraint. He wants to confirm it is truly her but is cautious, noting her avoidance of his gaze. This moment suggests unresolved feelings or curiosity but also a distance that has grown between them. The encounter adds depth to Jim’s character by revealing a past connection that still lingers in his mind, highlighting themes of memory, missed opportunities, and emotional complexity. It underscores Jim’s reflective nature and perhaps a sense of what might have been, enriching the narrative with personal history and nuance.

      5. Considering the chapter’s depiction of the pub and its social environment, how might the pub serve as a microcosm of the broader community and social changes?

      Answer:
      The pub functions as a microcosm of the town’s social fabric and its evolving dynamics. It reflects traditional values through its longstanding physical setting and older clientele, while simultaneously adapting to new social trends, such as the inclusion of women patrons and younger sports enthusiasts. The tensions between old and new, authority and youth, and personal relationships mirror wider societal shifts. The pub is a communal space where social hierarchies, friendships, and conflicts play out, making it a focal point for understanding the community’s identity, changes, and challenges. Through this setting, the chapter explores themes of continuity, change, and the negotiation of social roles.

    Quotes

    • 1. “He was almost certain that she had seen him because she had suddenly turned her face away as if to avoid his gaze, but not before he had caught a glimpse of her.”

      This quote captures the moment of recognition and emotional tension between Jim and Eilis Lacey, setting the tone for the chapter’s exploration of past relationships and unspoken feelings.

      2. “‘Who would have me? I’m nearly fifty years old. And how would I meet anyone? I’m in the bar until midnight five or six nights a week.’”

      Here, Jim expresses his loneliness and resignation, reflecting the chapter’s theme of isolation and the difficulty of finding companionship later in life.

      3. “‘You see, there isn’t anyone,’ he said.”

      This succinct statement underscores Jim’s deep sense of solitude and the emotional barrier he has constructed, which is central to understanding his character’s internal conflict.

      4. “‘Jim Farrell, look at you! You are handsome, you are kind, you are hard-working. She is a good person and you are lonely.’”

      This quote is significant as it reveals Colette’s attempt to encourage Jim towards hope and change, highlighting the chapter’s tension between despair and the possibility of new beginnings.

      5. “‘I have never heard anyone say a bad word about her. Her children are grown up. She really is lovely, Jim. She has a lovely smile. And she’s had a very hard time.’”

      This passage adds depth to the proposal Colette makes, emphasizing empathy and understanding as key to overcoming loneliness, and it frames the potential for healing through connection.

    Quotes

    1. “He was almost certain that she had seen him because she had suddenly turned her face away as if to avoid his gaze, but not before he had caught a glimpse of her.”

    This quote captures the moment of recognition and emotional tension between Jim and Eilis Lacey, setting the tone for the chapter’s exploration of past relationships and unspoken feelings.

    2. “‘Who would have me? I’m nearly fifty years old. And how would I meet anyone? I’m in the bar until midnight five or six nights a week.’”

    Here, Jim expresses his loneliness and resignation, reflecting the chapter’s theme of isolation and the difficulty of finding companionship later in life.

    3. “‘You see, there isn’t anyone,’ he said.”

    This succinct statement underscores Jim’s deep sense of solitude and the emotional barrier he has constructed, which is central to understanding his character’s internal conflict.

    4. “‘Jim Farrell, look at you! You are handsome, you are kind, you are hard-working. She is a good person and you are lonely.’”

    This quote is significant as it reveals Colette’s attempt to encourage Jim towards hope and change, highlighting the chapter’s tension between despair and the possibility of new beginnings.

    5. “‘I have never heard anyone say a bad word about her. Her children are grown up. She really is lovely, Jim. She has a lovely smile. And she’s had a very hard time.’”

    This passage adds depth to the proposal Colette makes, emphasizing empathy and understanding as key to overcoming loneliness, and it frames the potential for healing through connection.

    FAQs

    1. How does Jim perceive the changes in the clientele and atmosphere of the pub since he took it over from his father?

    Answer:
    Jim notices a gradual shift in the pub’s clientele and atmosphere over time. Initially, the pub was a quiet, traditional establishment with a steady trade, especially busy on weekends, reflecting its long history since the 1920s. With societal changes such as women beginning to frequent bars in the late 1960s, some pubs modernized by adding lounges, but Jim did not follow this trend. Instead, his pub retained its old-fashioned character. The clientele evolved to include local teachers during the week and a loyal group of regulars who guarded their space near the front door. More recently, the opening of a previously unused space at the back has attracted younger sports enthusiasts, friends of the new barman Andy, indicating a diversification but also a tension between tradition and change.

    2. What tensions arise between Jim and the new barman Andy, and what do these reveal about Jim’s character and management style?

    Answer:
    Jim experiences tension with Andy, the new young barman, primarily because Andy is impatient, cheeky, and behaves as though he is in charge, which Jim resents. Jim dislikes being told what to do, reflecting his need to maintain authority in his pub. However, he acknowledges Andy’s reliability with keys and cash, showing a pragmatic side. This dynamic reveals Jim’s struggle to adapt to new management styles and younger staff attitudes. It also highlights his desire for respect and control in his long-standing role, juxtaposed with the need to accommodate new customers and employees who bring fresh energy and crowds.

    3. Analyze the significance of Colette’s role in Jim’s life as depicted in the chapter. How does her interaction with Jim reflect broader themes in the narrative?

    Answer:
    Colette serves as a subtle catalyst in Jim’s personal life, encouraging him to consider companionship despite his resistance. Her visits upstairs, under the guise of passing through, gradually shift conversations toward Jim’s bachelor status and prospects for marriage. This interaction reflects themes of loneliness, social expectation, and the passage of time. Colette’s tactful and persistent encouragement contrasts with Jim’s defensive and somewhat resigned attitude, illustrating his isolation and reluctance to change. Her role symbolizes the community’s subtle pressures and hopes for Jim’s personal happiness, emphasizing the human need for connection amid the routines of life.

    4. What does the chapter suggest about Jim’s feelings toward Eilis Lacey, and how does this encounter contribute to the development of his character?

    Answer:
    Jim’s reaction to seeing Eilis Lacey is marked by a mixture of recognition, uncertainty, and a hint of emotional restraint. He wants to confirm it is truly her but is cautious, noting her avoidance of his gaze. This moment suggests unresolved feelings or curiosity but also a distance that has grown between them. The encounter adds depth to Jim’s character by revealing a past connection that still lingers in his mind, highlighting themes of memory, missed opportunities, and emotional complexity. It underscores Jim’s reflective nature and perhaps a sense of what might have been, enriching the narrative with personal history and nuance.

    5. Considering the chapter’s depiction of the pub and its social environment, how might the pub serve as a microcosm of the broader community and social changes?

    Answer:
    The pub functions as a microcosm of the town’s social fabric and its evolving dynamics. It reflects traditional values through its longstanding physical setting and older clientele, while simultaneously adapting to new social trends, such as the inclusion of women patrons and younger sports enthusiasts. The tensions between old and new, authority and youth, and personal relationships mirror wider societal shifts. The pub is a communal space where social hierarchies, friendships, and conflicts play out, making it a focal point for understanding the community’s identity, changes, and challenges. Through this setting, the chapter explores themes of continuity, change, and the negotiation of social roles.

    Note