Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part Two:iii

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter, Jim, the pub own­er, notices a famil­iar figure—Eilis Lacey—who appears to avoid his gaze, stir­ring a mix of recog­ni­tion and uncer­tain­ty in him. The pub, a long­stand­ing fam­i­ly estab­lish­ment, serves as a back­drop for Jim’s reflec­tions on past rela­tion­ships and present social dynam­ics. Reg­u­lar patrons and acquain­tances, includ­ing Mar­tin and Mrs Lacey, form a sub­tle net­work around him, high­light­ing changes in their inter­ac­tions since Eilis’s depar­ture. Jim’s obser­va­tions reveal his yearn­ing for con­nec­tion amidst the rou­tine of his bar work and the shift­ing com­mu­ni­ty around him.

    The pub itself embod­ies tra­di­tion and change; it remains large­ly untouched since Jim’s grandfather’s time, pre­serv­ing old wood­work and its orig­i­nal char­ac­ter. Yet, it adapts grad­u­al­ly as new groups, like young sports enthu­si­asts brought in by the new bar­man Andy, begin to fre­quent the space, blend­ing old and new social cur­rents. Jim bal­ances the demands of run­ning the pub with the chal­lenges posed by Andy’s youth­ful ener­gy and assertive­ness, reflect­ing ten­sions between main­tain­ing order and embrac­ing change with­in the estab­lish­ment.

    Jim’s per­son­al life is marked by soli­tude and unful­filled desires, as illus­trat­ed by his inter­ac­tions with Colette, Shane’s wife. Her vis­its are tinged with sub­tle encour­age­ment for Jim to seek com­pan­ion­ship and move beyond his bach­e­lor­hood, despite his skep­ti­cism and self-doubt. Their con­ver­sa­tions reveal the emo­tion­al under­cur­rents in Jim’s life, includ­ing his aware­ness of lost oppor­tu­ni­ties for love and the soci­etal expec­ta­tions sur­round­ing mar­riage and rela­tion­ships in their com­mu­ni­ty.

    Ulti­mate­ly, Colette pro­pos­es a poten­tial match for Jim, sug­gest­ing some­one he has known all his life but nev­er con­sid­ered roman­ti­cal­ly. This sug­ges­tion opens a win­dow for hope and recon­sid­er­a­tion, as Colette high­lights the qual­i­ties that make Jim a wor­thy part­ner and the hard­ships the woman has endured. The chap­ter clos­es on this ten­ta­tive pos­si­bil­i­ty, empha­siz­ing themes of lone­li­ness, the pas­sage of time, and the qui­et hope for renew­al with­in famil­iar sur­round­ings.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Jim’s relationship with Eilis Lacey and her family reflect the social dynamics in the town as portrayed in the chapter?

      Answer:
      Jim’s relationship with Eilis Lacey and her family illustrates a complex web of social connections and unspoken tensions within the town. Jim recognizes Eilis and suspects she has seen him but she avoids his gaze, indicating a strained or awkward history. While Jim knows her mother and often sees her, their interactions have shifted from avoidance to polite friendliness, reflecting a gradual social thaw. Martin, Eilis’s brother, frequents the bar but remains distant, showing how personal relationships intertwine with public social spaces. This dynamic highlights themes of community familiarity, personal histories, and the subtle ways people navigate past relationships in a small town environment.

      2. What are the challenges Jim faces managing the pub, particularly with the new barman Andy, and what do these challenges reveal about changes in the community?

      Answer:
      Jim faces challenges balancing tradition and change in running the pub. Andy, the young barman, brings a new, younger crowd and is described as impatient and cheeky, which Jim struggles to accept. Andy’s involvement in multiple sports and refusal to work weekends disrupts the established patterns. Jim resents Andy’s assertiveness, especially when Andy acts as if he is in charge. These challenges reveal a generational shift in the community and changing social habits. Jim’s pub, rooted in family history and traditional clientele, is adapting to new influences and demographics, reflecting broader social changes in the town.

      3. How does the chapter portray Jim’s personal life and emotional state, particularly in relation to his bachelorhood and interactions with Colette?

      Answer:
      Jim’s personal life is portrayed as lonely and marked by unfulfilled desires for companionship. Despite being nearly fifty and working late nights, he remains single, a fact Colette gently but persistently addresses. Their interactions reveal Jim’s guardedness and resignation; he dismisses the possibility of finding a partner and is defensive about past failed relationships. Colette’s role is somewhat maternal or matchmaking, trying to encourage Jim without direct confrontation, even suggesting a potential match. This portrayal emphasizes themes of isolation, social expectations around marriage, and the subtle pressures to conform to community norms regarding partnership.

      4. Analyze the significance of the suggestion Colette makes about a potential partner for Jim. What does this reveal about social attitudes and personal histories in the community?

      Answer:
      Colette’s suggestion of a specific woman as a potential partner for Jim is significant because it highlights the community’s interconnectedness and the weight of personal histories. Jim’s immediate reaction—that he has known the woman all his life and that neither showed interest before—underscores how past experiences shape present attitudes. Colette’s insistence that they are now older and wiser and that Jim is a good man reveals a hopeful, pragmatic approach to companionship common in close-knit communities. This exchange reveals social attitudes that value familiarity and practicality over romantic idealism and reflects the community’s collective involvement in personal matters, often blurring boundaries between private and public life.

      5. Considering Jim’s reflections and experiences throughout the chapter, how might his story illustrate broader themes of change and continuity within the town?

      Answer:
      Jim’s story encapsulates broader themes of change and continuity by juxtaposing his adherence to tradition with the evolving social landscape around him. The pub, inherited from his grandfather and unchanged since the 1920s, symbolizes continuity and the weight of family legacy. However, the changing clientele, introduction of new spaces in the pub, and the arrival of younger patrons through Andy represent social change and modernization. Jim’s personal life, marked by loneliness and resistance to change, mirrors the town’s gradual transformation. His internal conflict between holding onto the past and adapting to new realities reflects the tension many individuals face in communities undergoing cultural shifts.

    Quotes

    • 1. “Jim wanted to call in her direction, loud enough to make her look over so that he could be sure it really was Eilis Lacey. He was almost certain that she had seen him because she had suddenly turned her face away as if to avoid his gaze, but not before he had caught a glimpse of her.”

      This quote captures Jim’s internal conflict and the tension surrounding his recognition of Eilis Lacey, highlighting themes of memory, avoidance, and uncertain reconnection early in the chapter.

      2. “‘Who would have me? I’m nearly fifty years old. And how would I meet anyone? I’m in the bar until midnight five or six nights a week.’”

      Here, Jim expresses his loneliness and self-doubt, emphasizing the emotional isolation that defines much of his character’s experience and setting the stage for the chapter’s exploration of companionship and hope.

      3. “‘You see, there isn’t anyone,’ he said.”

      This succinct statement crystallizes Jim’s resignation about his bachelor status, underscoring the chapter’s underlying theme of longing for connection amidst a life constrained by circumstance and routine.

      4. “‘Jim Farrell, look at you! You are handsome, you are kind, you are hard-working. She is a good person and you are lonely.’”

      This encouraging affirmation from Colette represents a pivotal moment, offering a hopeful perspective on Jim’s prospects for love and companionship, and reflects the chapter’s movement toward possible change in Jim’s life.

      5. “‘I have never heard anyone say a bad word about her. Her children are grown up. She really is lovely, Jim. She has a lovely smile. And she’s had a very hard time.’”

      This quote highlights the character of the woman Colette suggests for Jim, emphasizing themes of resilience and kindness, and reinforcing the chapter’s focus on community, empathy, and the possibility of new beginnings.

    Quotes

    1. “Jim wanted to call in her direction, loud enough to make her look over so that he could be sure it really was Eilis Lacey. He was almost certain that she had seen him because she had suddenly turned her face away as if to avoid his gaze, but not before he had caught a glimpse of her.”

    This quote captures Jim’s internal conflict and the tension surrounding his recognition of Eilis Lacey, highlighting themes of memory, avoidance, and uncertain reconnection early in the chapter.

    2. “‘Who would have me? I’m nearly fifty years old. And how would I meet anyone? I’m in the bar until midnight five or six nights a week.’”

    Here, Jim expresses his loneliness and self-doubt, emphasizing the emotional isolation that defines much of his character’s experience and setting the stage for the chapter’s exploration of companionship and hope.

    3. “‘You see, there isn’t anyone,’ he said.”

    This succinct statement crystallizes Jim’s resignation about his bachelor status, underscoring the chapter’s underlying theme of longing for connection amidst a life constrained by circumstance and routine.

    4. “‘Jim Farrell, look at you! You are handsome, you are kind, you are hard-working. She is a good person and you are lonely.’”

    This encouraging affirmation from Colette represents a pivotal moment, offering a hopeful perspective on Jim’s prospects for love and companionship, and reflects the chapter’s movement toward possible change in Jim’s life.

    5. “‘I have never heard anyone say a bad word about her. Her children are grown up. She really is lovely, Jim. She has a lovely smile. And she’s had a very hard time.’”

    This quote highlights the character of the woman Colette suggests for Jim, emphasizing themes of resilience and kindness, and reinforcing the chapter’s focus on community, empathy, and the possibility of new beginnings.

    FAQs

    1. How does Jim’s relationship with Eilis Lacey and her family reflect the social dynamics in the town as portrayed in the chapter?

    Answer:
    Jim’s relationship with Eilis Lacey and her family illustrates a complex web of social connections and unspoken tensions within the town. Jim recognizes Eilis and suspects she has seen him but she avoids his gaze, indicating a strained or awkward history. While Jim knows her mother and often sees her, their interactions have shifted from avoidance to polite friendliness, reflecting a gradual social thaw. Martin, Eilis’s brother, frequents the bar but remains distant, showing how personal relationships intertwine with public social spaces. This dynamic highlights themes of community familiarity, personal histories, and the subtle ways people navigate past relationships in a small town environment.

    2. What are the challenges Jim faces managing the pub, particularly with the new barman Andy, and what do these challenges reveal about changes in the community?

    Answer:
    Jim faces challenges balancing tradition and change in running the pub. Andy, the young barman, brings a new, younger crowd and is described as impatient and cheeky, which Jim struggles to accept. Andy’s involvement in multiple sports and refusal to work weekends disrupts the established patterns. Jim resents Andy’s assertiveness, especially when Andy acts as if he is in charge. These challenges reveal a generational shift in the community and changing social habits. Jim’s pub, rooted in family history and traditional clientele, is adapting to new influences and demographics, reflecting broader social changes in the town.

    3. How does the chapter portray Jim’s personal life and emotional state, particularly in relation to his bachelorhood and interactions with Colette?

    Answer:
    Jim’s personal life is portrayed as lonely and marked by unfulfilled desires for companionship. Despite being nearly fifty and working late nights, he remains single, a fact Colette gently but persistently addresses. Their interactions reveal Jim’s guardedness and resignation; he dismisses the possibility of finding a partner and is defensive about past failed relationships. Colette’s role is somewhat maternal or matchmaking, trying to encourage Jim without direct confrontation, even suggesting a potential match. This portrayal emphasizes themes of isolation, social expectations around marriage, and the subtle pressures to conform to community norms regarding partnership.

    4. Analyze the significance of the suggestion Colette makes about a potential partner for Jim. What does this reveal about social attitudes and personal histories in the community?

    Answer:
    Colette’s suggestion of a specific woman as a potential partner for Jim is significant because it highlights the community’s interconnectedness and the weight of personal histories. Jim’s immediate reaction—that he has known the woman all his life and that neither showed interest before—underscores how past experiences shape present attitudes. Colette’s insistence that they are now older and wiser and that Jim is a good man reveals a hopeful, pragmatic approach to companionship common in close-knit communities. This exchange reveals social attitudes that value familiarity and practicality over romantic idealism and reflects the community’s collective involvement in personal matters, often blurring boundaries between private and public life.

    5. Considering Jim’s reflections and experiences throughout the chapter, how might his story illustrate broader themes of change and continuity within the town?

    Answer:
    Jim’s story encapsulates broader themes of change and continuity by juxtaposing his adherence to tradition with the evolving social landscape around him. The pub, inherited from his grandfather and unchanged since the 1920s, symbolizes continuity and the weight of family legacy. However, the changing clientele, introduction of new spaces in the pub, and the arrival of younger patrons through Andy represent social change and modernization. Jim’s personal life, marked by loneliness and resistance to change, mirrors the town’s gradual transformation. His internal conflict between holding onto the past and adapting to new realities reflects the tension many individuals face in communities undergoing cultural shifts.

    Note