Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    PreviousNext
    Long Island

    Part One:v

    by Tóibín, Colm

    In this chap­ter of *Part One:v*, Eilis grap­ples with the lin­ger­ing unease brought on by a recent vis­i­tor, whose pres­ence unset­tles her in sub­tle but per­sis­tent ways. Mean­while, Tony remains ret­i­cent about his and his moth­er’s plans, prompt­ing Eilis to attempt coax­ing him into con­ver­sa­tion dur­ing their walks. Despite her grow­ing curios­i­ty and the temp­ta­tion to con­fide in Frank about the baby and poten­tial adop­tion, she choos­es silence, valu­ing the pos­si­bil­i­ty of gain­ing more infor­ma­tion lat­er. Their inter­ac­tions, filled with light­heart­ed sto­ries and obser­va­tions, cre­ate an illu­sion of a per­fect mar­ried cou­ple to any onlook­er.

    Eilis’s con­nec­tion to her past and fam­i­ly is explored through her inter­ac­tions at work and at home. She brings a cam­era to cap­ture moments of her col­leagues and work­place, intend­ing to share these glimpses of her life with her moth­er. Their cor­re­spon­dence reveals a deep sense of long­ing and dis­tance, as it has been over twen­ty years since they last met. The poignant absence of Eilis’s moth­er from her children’s lives under­scores the emo­tion­al cost of sep­a­ra­tion. Addi­tion­al­ly, the unex­pect­ed vis­it from Lena offers a glimpse of sup­port and sol­i­dar­i­ty with­in Eilis’s com­mu­ni­ty, empha­siz­ing the impor­tance of dis­cre­tion and the shared shock over the baby.

    The chap­ter also touch­es on Eilis’s com­plex his­to­ry in Ennis­cor­thy, revealed through a let­ter from her moth­er list­ing acquain­tances who have asked about her. Notably absent is Jim Far­rell, a sig­nif­i­cant fig­ure from Eilis’s past with whom she shared a secret romance. This omis­sion stirs mem­o­ries and high­lights the secre­cy sur­round­ing her mar­riage to Tony, which she has kept hid­den even from close friends and fam­i­ly. The chap­ter cap­tures Eilis’s inter­nal con­flict as she rec­on­ciles her past with her present life in Brook­lyn.

    Final­ly, the nar­ra­tive shifts to a reflec­tive moment as Eilis decides to vis­it Jones Beach, recall­ing ear­li­er sum­mers spent there with Tony and their friends. These mem­o­ries evoke a sense of warmth and com­mu­ni­ty, con­trast­ing with the cur­rent uncer­tain­ties she faces. The depic­tion of Tony’s devo­tion and the per­cep­tion of their mar­riage as a roman­tic ide­al among their peers adds depth to their rela­tion­ship. The chap­ter clos­es with a cel­e­bra­tion of love and des­tiny, rein­forc­ing the under­ly­ing themes of con­nec­tion, secre­cy, and the com­plex­i­ties of per­son­al his­to­ry.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Eilis’s relationship with Tony reflect the themes of secrecy and uncertainty in this chapter?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s relationship with Tony is marked by a significant degree of secrecy and uncertainty, which underscores the chapter’s themes. Tony does not reveal the plans he and his mother have, leaving Eilis guessing and somewhat anxious. Despite this, they maintain the appearance of a perfect married couple, which adds a layer of complexity to their interactions. Moreover, Eilis withholds information about the baby and the possibility of adoption, fearing she may need Frank’s help later. This mutual withholding of information creates an atmosphere of ambiguity and tension in their relationship, reflecting the broader theme of hidden truths and unspoken worries that permeate the chapter.

      2. What role does Eilis’s connection to her past in Ireland play in this chapter, particularly regarding her mother and Jim Farrell?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s connection to her past in Ireland is poignantly illustrated through her correspondence with her mother and the absence of Jim Farrell’s name in the letters. Her mother’s letters list acquaintances from Enniscorthy, highlighting a community life that Eilis is distanced from. The omission of Jim Farrell, with whom Eilis had a secret romance and who was unaware of her marriage to Tony, symbolizes unresolved aspects of her past. This silence reflects Eilis’s internal conflict and the sacrifices she has made by emigrating and starting a new life in America. It also illustrates her emotional divide between past and present, emphasizing themes of memory, identity, and the complexity of personal history.

      3. How does Lena’s visit to Eilis contribute to the development of the chapter’s themes of friendship and support?

      Answer:
      Lena’s visit to Eilis is a significant moment that highlights themes of friendship, solidarity, and discreet support. Lena offers practical help, emotional comfort, and confidentiality, especially regarding the delicate situation of the baby. Her willingness to assist, despite the risk of gossip or investigation from others like Francesca or Enzo, shows the strength of female friendship and community bonds. This visit contrasts with the isolation Eilis might feel due to the secrecy surrounding her life and adds a layer of warmth and trust. Lena’s gesture reassures Eilis that she is not alone, reinforcing the importance of support systems in times of personal crisis.

      4. Analyze how the chapter uses setting and imagery, such as the descriptions of Jones Beach and the weather, to reflect Eilis’s emotional state.

      Answer:
      The chapter’s descriptions of setting and imagery, particularly of Jones Beach and the blustery late May weather, serve as metaphors for Eilis’s emotional landscape. The chilly wind and raked light evoke a sense of melancholy and tension, mirroring Eilis’s internal conflict and uncertainty about her future. The comparison of the weather to Ireland, specifically Wexford, suggests nostalgia and a lingering connection to her homeland. The beach, once a place of joyful social gatherings and romance with Tony and friends, now feels different, perhaps tinged with loss or change. This use of setting deepens the reader’s understanding of Eilis’s mixed feelings—caught between past happiness and present challenges.

      5. Considering Eilis’s secret marriage and the hidden aspects of her life, what might this chapter suggest about the challenges faced by immigrants balancing old and new identities?

      Answer:
      This chapter highlights the complex challenges immigrants face in balancing their old and new identities through Eilis’s secret marriage and the concealment of significant aspects of her life. Eilis’s reluctance to share her marriage with her mother and her omission of Jim Farrell from her mother’s letter list illustrate the emotional and social divides immigrants often endure. They must navigate loyalty to their origins while adapting to new cultural and personal realities, sometimes leading to secrecy and isolation. The chapter suggests that this balancing act can create internal conflict and a sense of fragmentation, as immigrants strive to reconcile their past with their present, often sacrificing openness to maintain stability or protect loved ones.

    Quotes

    • 1. “Anyone seeing them, she thought, would believe they were the perfect married couple.”

      This quote highlights the outward appearance of Eilis and Tony’s relationship, emphasizing the contrast between public perception and private uncertainty. It captures a key tension in the chapter about appearances versus hidden realities.

      2. “I came over to say that if you need anything I am ready to help. Anything. If you need money or advice, or just need to talk.”

      Lena’s offer of support to Eilis reflects themes of friendship, community, and discreet solidarity within their social environment. It underscores the importance of trust and quiet assistance amid difficult personal circumstances.

      3. “It was strange to be reminded of what had happened by the absence of Jim Farrell’s name on a list of people in the town, some of whom she barely remembered.”

      This passage reveals Eilis’s internal conflict and the unresolved past she carries, illustrating how memories and omissions can evoke feelings of loss and secrecy. It also introduces a significant backstory element that shapes her present.

      4. “‘He is a devoted husband,’ Lena said. ‘If I get half of that from Enzo, I will be content.’”

      This statement encapsulates the ideal of marital devotion as seen through the eyes of Eilis’s friend, contrasting it with other relationships and reinforcing the theme of love, commitment, and the aspirations tied to marriage.

      5. “‘And getting married secretly! You must have been so happy!’ another said. ‘It makes me believe in love at first sight.’”

      This quote captures the romantic idealism surrounding Eilis and Tony’s secret marriage, highlighting how their story inspires hope and belief in love’s instantaneous power among their peers. It serves as a poignant reflection on love’s role in their lives.

    Quotes

    1. “Anyone seeing them, she thought, would believe they were the perfect married couple.”

    This quote highlights the outward appearance of Eilis and Tony’s relationship, emphasizing the contrast between public perception and private uncertainty. It captures a key tension in the chapter about appearances versus hidden realities.

    2. “I came over to say that if you need anything I am ready to help. Anything. If you need money or advice, or just need to talk.”

    Lena’s offer of support to Eilis reflects themes of friendship, community, and discreet solidarity within their social environment. It underscores the importance of trust and quiet assistance amid difficult personal circumstances.

    3. “It was strange to be reminded of what had happened by the absence of Jim Farrell’s name on a list of people in the town, some of whom she barely remembered.”

    This passage reveals Eilis’s internal conflict and the unresolved past she carries, illustrating how memories and omissions can evoke feelings of loss and secrecy. It also introduces a significant backstory element that shapes her present.

    4. “‘He is a devoted husband,’ Lena said. ‘If I get half of that from Enzo, I will be content.’”

    This statement encapsulates the ideal of marital devotion as seen through the eyes of Eilis’s friend, contrasting it with other relationships and reinforcing the theme of love, commitment, and the aspirations tied to marriage.

    5. “‘And getting married secretly! You must have been so happy!’ another said. ‘It makes me believe in love at first sight.’”

    This quote captures the romantic idealism surrounding Eilis and Tony’s secret marriage, highlighting how their story inspires hope and belief in love’s instantaneous power among their peers. It serves as a poignant reflection on love’s role in their lives.

    FAQs

    1. How does Eilis’s relationship with Tony reflect the themes of secrecy and uncertainty in this chapter?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s relationship with Tony is marked by a significant degree of secrecy and uncertainty, which underscores the chapter’s themes. Tony does not reveal the plans he and his mother have, leaving Eilis guessing and somewhat anxious. Despite this, they maintain the appearance of a perfect married couple, which adds a layer of complexity to their interactions. Moreover, Eilis withholds information about the baby and the possibility of adoption, fearing she may need Frank’s help later. This mutual withholding of information creates an atmosphere of ambiguity and tension in their relationship, reflecting the broader theme of hidden truths and unspoken worries that permeate the chapter.

    2. What role does Eilis’s connection to her past in Ireland play in this chapter, particularly regarding her mother and Jim Farrell?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s connection to her past in Ireland is poignantly illustrated through her correspondence with her mother and the absence of Jim Farrell’s name in the letters. Her mother’s letters list acquaintances from Enniscorthy, highlighting a community life that Eilis is distanced from. The omission of Jim Farrell, with whom Eilis had a secret romance and who was unaware of her marriage to Tony, symbolizes unresolved aspects of her past. This silence reflects Eilis’s internal conflict and the sacrifices she has made by emigrating and starting a new life in America. It also illustrates her emotional divide between past and present, emphasizing themes of memory, identity, and the complexity of personal history.

    3. How does Lena’s visit to Eilis contribute to the development of the chapter’s themes of friendship and support?

    Answer:
    Lena’s visit to Eilis is a significant moment that highlights themes of friendship, solidarity, and discreet support. Lena offers practical help, emotional comfort, and confidentiality, especially regarding the delicate situation of the baby. Her willingness to assist, despite the risk of gossip or investigation from others like Francesca or Enzo, shows the strength of female friendship and community bonds. This visit contrasts with the isolation Eilis might feel due to the secrecy surrounding her life and adds a layer of warmth and trust. Lena’s gesture reassures Eilis that she is not alone, reinforcing the importance of support systems in times of personal crisis.

    4. Analyze how the chapter uses setting and imagery, such as the descriptions of Jones Beach and the weather, to reflect Eilis’s emotional state.

    Answer:
    The chapter’s descriptions of setting and imagery, particularly of Jones Beach and the blustery late May weather, serve as metaphors for Eilis’s emotional landscape. The chilly wind and raked light evoke a sense of melancholy and tension, mirroring Eilis’s internal conflict and uncertainty about her future. The comparison of the weather to Ireland, specifically Wexford, suggests nostalgia and a lingering connection to her homeland. The beach, once a place of joyful social gatherings and romance with Tony and friends, now feels different, perhaps tinged with loss or change. This use of setting deepens the reader’s understanding of Eilis’s mixed feelings—caught between past happiness and present challenges.

    5. Considering Eilis’s secret marriage and the hidden aspects of her life, what might this chapter suggest about the challenges faced by immigrants balancing old and new identities?

    Answer:
    This chapter highlights the complex challenges immigrants face in balancing their old and new identities through Eilis’s secret marriage and the concealment of significant aspects of her life. Eilis’s reluctance to share her marriage with her mother and her omission of Jim Farrell from her mother’s letter list illustrate the emotional and social divides immigrants often endure. They must navigate loyalty to their origins while adapting to new cultural and personal realities, sometimes leading to secrecy and isolation. The chapter suggests that this balancing act can create internal conflict and a sense of fragmentation, as immigrants strive to reconcile their past with their present, often sacrificing openness to maintain stability or protect loved ones.

    Note