Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Long Island
    Historical FictionLiterary Fiction

    Long Island

    by Tóibín, Colm
    Long Island by Colm Tóibín is a sequel to his 2009 novel Brooklyn, continuing the story of Eilis Lacey two decades later. Now settled in Long Island with her husband Tony and their children, Eilis faces personal upheaval when she discovers Tony has fathered a child with another woman. She returns to her hometown in Ireland, confronting past relationships and seeking solace. The novel explores themes of identity, belonging, and the complexities of love and family across two countries.
    Next
    Long Island

    Part One:i

    by Tóibín, Colm

    The chap­ter opens with Francesca inform­ing Eilis about a per­sis­tent Irish vis­i­tor who has been ask­ing for her specif­i­cal­ly, spark­ing curios­i­ty and unease. Their con­ver­sa­tion reveals under­ly­ing ten­sion as Eilis con­tem­plates the impli­ca­tions of this stranger’s inter­est. Francesca’s sharp wit and per­cep­tive­ness con­trast with Eilis’s appre­hen­sive mood. As dai­ly life unfolds with fam­i­ly mem­bers arriv­ing home, Eilis is caught between the mun­dane rhythm of her house­hold and the loom­ing pres­ence of an unknown man whose inten­tions remain unclear.

    When the vis­i­tor final­ly appears at the door, his aggres­sive demeanor and point­ed accu­sa­tions imme­di­ate­ly unset­tle Eilis. He claims that Tony, her hus­band, has fathered a child with anoth­er woman, threat­en­ing to deliv­er the new­born to Eilis’s home. His words are laced with hos­til­i­ty and pos­ses­sive­ness, reflect­ing a deeply per­son­al griev­ance. Eilis sens­es the man’s sin­cer­i­ty and stub­born­ness, rec­og­niz­ing traits famil­iar from her Irish back­ground, and real­izes the poten­tial dan­ger of his threats in the qui­et neigh­bor­hood.

    Eilis wres­tles with the dis­turb­ing real­i­ty of the sit­u­a­tion, imag­in­ing the vul­ner­a­ble woman car­ry­ing Tony’s child and the pos­si­bil­i­ty of a baby being aban­doned at her doorstep. The visitor’s deter­mi­na­tion and the qui­et set­ting ampli­fy her fear, as she con­tem­plates what such an act would mean for her fam­i­ly and her­self. Her inter­nal con­flict deep­ens as she con­sid­ers the social and cul­tur­al dif­fer­ences between her past in Ire­land and her present life, high­light­ing her iso­la­tion and the com­plex­i­ty of her predica­ment.

    The chap­ter clos­es with Eilis reflect­ing on her lone­li­ness and the absence of trust­ed con­fi­dantes. Mem­o­ries of her late sis­ter Rose, who once pro­vid­ed guid­ance dur­ing crises, empha­size her cur­rent vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty. With her moth­er in Ire­land and her sis­ters-in-law tied to dif­fer­ent cul­tur­al expec­ta­tions, Eilis feels the weight of the sit­u­a­tion press­ing down on her. This moment under­scores the pro­found uncer­tain­ty she faces, caught between past loy­al­ties and present chal­lenges in a for­eign land.

    Down­load Free PDF

    FAQs

    • 1. What is the nature of the visitor’s message to Eilis, and how does it affect her emotionally and mentally?

      Answer:
      The visitor delivers a threatening and unsettling message to Eilis regarding a pregnancy caused by her husband Tony’s infidelity. He claims he is married to the pregnant woman and asserts that the child is not Tony’s, threatening to bring the baby to Eilis’s home once it is born. This confrontation leaves Eilis feeling shocked, fearful, and isolated. She experiences a mix of disbelief, anxiety, and a deep sense of vulnerability as she contemplates the implications of the threat—both the possibility of a baby being abandoned on her doorstep and the unknown woman who will be seeking support from Tony. The visitor’s aggressive tone and determined demeanor convince her that the threat is serious, intensifying her emotional turmoil.

      2. How does the chapter illustrate cultural differences in dealing with issues of infidelity and pregnancy between Ireland and the new setting?

      Answer:
      The chapter contrasts traditional Irish cultural responses to infidelity and pregnancy with the more anonymous, perhaps harsher realities in the current setting. Eilis reflects that in Ireland, a man discovering his wife’s unfaithfulness and pregnancy would not allow the child to remain in the household and community figures like priests or doctors would intervene to prevent abandonment. However, here in the quiet cul-de-sac, the visitor’s threat to leave the baby on Eilis’s doorstep could realistically be carried out without detection. This highlights a cultural dissonance: Ireland’s close-knit community and social structures versus the isolation and anonymity of the new environment, which complicates Eilis’s ability to respond and seek help.

      3. What role does Francesca, Eilis’s mother-in-law, play in the chapter, and how does her character influence the story?

      Answer:
      Francesca serves as a subtle but insightful presence in the chapter. She informs Eilis about the visitor’s repeated attempts to find her and hints at his intentions without revealing too much, demonstrating her intelligence and sly sense of humor. Francesca’s awareness of the visitor and her decision to tell Eilis that he is looking for her prepares Eilis for the confrontation and adds a layer of foreshadowing. Her character embodies a sharp, pragmatic perspective on the situation, contrasting with Eilis’s initial disbelief and vulnerability. Francesca’s actions help build tension and provide the reader with a sense of the social dynamics and potential conflicts within the household.

      4. In what ways does Eilis’s internal conflict and isolation manifest throughout the chapter?

      Answer:
      Eilis’s internal conflict and isolation are evident in her reactions to the visitor and her subsequent reflections. She feels unable to confide in her mother, who is far away in Ireland without modern communication means, and hesitates to share with her sisters-in-law, who come from different cultural backgrounds. The memory of her deceased elder sister Rose as a source of strength during crises underscores Eilis’s current loneliness. Her inability to find immediate support exacerbates her fear and confusion. She also struggles with contradictory feelings—resentment towards the unknown pregnant woman, fear of the visitor’s threats, and anxiety about her husband’s betrayal—highlighting her emotional turmoil and sense of being trapped in a difficult situation.

      5. How might Eilis apply practical strategies to manage the threat posed by the visitor and the situation with her husband?

      Answer:
      Eilis could begin by seeking support from trusted individuals within her community or workplace to avoid isolation. Although she cannot rely on her mother or sisters-in-law fully, confiding in a close friend or a professional counselor could provide emotional relief and advice. She might also consider discussing the threat with her husband Tony to understand his perspective and to address the infidelity directly. Legally, she could document the visitor’s threats and consider contacting authorities if the threats escalate. Practically, securing her home and preparing for any potential incidents involving the baby might help her regain a sense of control. Overall, proactive communication and seeking external support would be vital strategies to manage the complex emotional and practical challenges she faces.

    Quotes

    • 1. “‘That Irishman has been here again,’ Francesca said, sitting down at the kitchen table. ‘He has come to every house, but it’s you he’s looking for. I told him you would be home soon.’”

      This quote sets the tense and mysterious tone of the chapter, introducing the arrival of a determined man seeking Eilis. It highlights the looming conflict and the sense of intrusion into Eilis’s life, marking the beginning of the chapter’s central confrontation.

      2. “‘He fixed everything in our house,’ he went on, pointing a finger at her. ‘He even did a bit more than was in the estimate. Indeed, he came back regularly when he knew that the woman of the house would be there and I would not. And his plumbing is so good that she is to have a baby in August.’”

      This statement reveals the crux of the conflict: an accusation of infidelity and impending consequences. It is pivotal because it exposes the tension between the characters and the disruptive secret that threatens the family’s stability.

      3. “‘So as soon as this little bastard is born, I am transporting it here. And if you are not at home, then I will hand it to that other woman. And if there’s no one at all in any of the houses you people own, I’ll leave it right here on your doorstep.’”

      This threatening declaration underscores the seriousness of the man’s intent and his willingness to escalate the situation. It encapsulates the chapter’s themes of betrayal, intimidation, and the precarious position of Eilis and her family.

      4. “She had known men like this in Ireland. Should one of them discover that their wife had been unfaithful and was pregnant as a result, they would not have the baby in the house.”

      This reflection provides cultural context and insight into Eilis’s mindset, contrasting Irish social norms with her current circumstances. It conveys her understanding of the man’s character and the gravity of the situation from her perspective.

      5. “Somewhere, not far away, there was a woman pregnant with Tony’s child. Eilis did not know why she presumed that the woman was Irish too… Suddenly, the image of this woman alone with a baby coming to look for support from Tony frightened her even more than the image of a baby being left on her doorstep.”

      This passage captures Eilis’s emotional turmoil and fear about the unknown woman and the future consequences of Tony’s infidelity. It highlights the chapter’s emotional core—her anxiety, isolation, and the complex implications of the situation she faces.

    Quotes

    1. “‘That Irishman has been here again,’ Francesca said, sitting down at the kitchen table. ‘He has come to every house, but it’s you he’s looking for. I told him you would be home soon.’”

    This quote sets the tense and mysterious tone of the chapter, introducing the arrival of a determined man seeking Eilis. It highlights the looming conflict and the sense of intrusion into Eilis’s life, marking the beginning of the chapter’s central confrontation.

    2. “‘He fixed everything in our house,’ he went on, pointing a finger at her. ‘He even did a bit more than was in the estimate. Indeed, he came back regularly when he knew that the woman of the house would be there and I would not. And his plumbing is so good that she is to have a baby in August.’”

    This statement reveals the crux of the conflict: an accusation of infidelity and impending consequences. It is pivotal because it exposes the tension between the characters and the disruptive secret that threatens the family’s stability.

    3. “‘So as soon as this little bastard is born, I am transporting it here. And if you are not at home, then I will hand it to that other woman. And if there’s no one at all in any of the houses you people own, I’ll leave it right here on your doorstep.’”

    This threatening declaration underscores the seriousness of the man’s intent and his willingness to escalate the situation. It encapsulates the chapter’s themes of betrayal, intimidation, and the precarious position of Eilis and her family.

    4. “She had known men like this in Ireland. Should one of them discover that their wife had been unfaithful and was pregnant as a result, they would not have the baby in the house.”

    This reflection provides cultural context and insight into Eilis’s mindset, contrasting Irish social norms with her current circumstances. It conveys her understanding of the man’s character and the gravity of the situation from her perspective.

    5. “Somewhere, not far away, there was a woman pregnant with Tony’s child. Eilis did not know why she presumed that the woman was Irish too… Suddenly, the image of this woman alone with a baby coming to look for support from Tony frightened her even more than the image of a baby being left on her doorstep.”

    This passage captures Eilis’s emotional turmoil and fear about the unknown woman and the future consequences of Tony’s infidelity. It highlights the chapter’s emotional core—her anxiety, isolation, and the complex implications of the situation she faces.

    FAQs

    1. What is the nature of the visitor’s message to Eilis, and how does it affect her emotionally and mentally?

    Answer:
    The visitor delivers a threatening and unsettling message to Eilis regarding a pregnancy caused by her husband Tony’s infidelity. He claims he is married to the pregnant woman and asserts that the child is not Tony’s, threatening to bring the baby to Eilis’s home once it is born. This confrontation leaves Eilis feeling shocked, fearful, and isolated. She experiences a mix of disbelief, anxiety, and a deep sense of vulnerability as she contemplates the implications of the threat—both the possibility of a baby being abandoned on her doorstep and the unknown woman who will be seeking support from Tony. The visitor’s aggressive tone and determined demeanor convince her that the threat is serious, intensifying her emotional turmoil.

    2. How does the chapter illustrate cultural differences in dealing with issues of infidelity and pregnancy between Ireland and the new setting?

    Answer:
    The chapter contrasts traditional Irish cultural responses to infidelity and pregnancy with the more anonymous, perhaps harsher realities in the current setting. Eilis reflects that in Ireland, a man discovering his wife’s unfaithfulness and pregnancy would not allow the child to remain in the household and community figures like priests or doctors would intervene to prevent abandonment. However, here in the quiet cul-de-sac, the visitor’s threat to leave the baby on Eilis’s doorstep could realistically be carried out without detection. This highlights a cultural dissonance: Ireland’s close-knit community and social structures versus the isolation and anonymity of the new environment, which complicates Eilis’s ability to respond and seek help.

    3. What role does Francesca, Eilis’s mother-in-law, play in the chapter, and how does her character influence the story?

    Answer:
    Francesca serves as a subtle but insightful presence in the chapter. She informs Eilis about the visitor’s repeated attempts to find her and hints at his intentions without revealing too much, demonstrating her intelligence and sly sense of humor. Francesca’s awareness of the visitor and her decision to tell Eilis that he is looking for her prepares Eilis for the confrontation and adds a layer of foreshadowing. Her character embodies a sharp, pragmatic perspective on the situation, contrasting with Eilis’s initial disbelief and vulnerability. Francesca’s actions help build tension and provide the reader with a sense of the social dynamics and potential conflicts within the household.

    4. In what ways does Eilis’s internal conflict and isolation manifest throughout the chapter?

    Answer:
    Eilis’s internal conflict and isolation are evident in her reactions to the visitor and her subsequent reflections. She feels unable to confide in her mother, who is far away in Ireland without modern communication means, and hesitates to share with her sisters-in-law, who come from different cultural backgrounds. The memory of her deceased elder sister Rose as a source of strength during crises underscores Eilis’s current loneliness. Her inability to find immediate support exacerbates her fear and confusion. She also struggles with contradictory feelings—resentment towards the unknown pregnant woman, fear of the visitor’s threats, and anxiety about her husband’s betrayal—highlighting her emotional turmoil and sense of being trapped in a difficult situation.

    5. How might Eilis apply practical strategies to manage the threat posed by the visitor and the situation with her husband?

    Answer:
    Eilis could begin by seeking support from trusted individuals within her community or workplace to avoid isolation. Although she cannot rely on her mother or sisters-in-law fully, confiding in a close friend or a professional counselor could provide emotional relief and advice. She might also consider discussing the threat with her husband Tony to understand his perspective and to address the infidelity directly. Legally, she could document the visitor’s threats and consider contacting authorities if the threats escalate. Practically, securing her home and preparing for any potential incidents involving the baby might help her regain a sense of control. Overall, proactive communication and seeking external support would be vital strategies to manage the complex emotional and practical challenges she faces.

    Note