
Thomas Covenant 8 — The Fatal Revenant
Chapter 17: Part Two — 4. Old Conflicts
by Donaldson, Stephen R.Linden Avery, wielding the Staff of Law, grapples with the aftermath of a mysterious stranger’s annihilation of the Demondim horde. Her companions—Liand, Stave, the Ramen, and the disturbed Anele—react with varying degrees of confusion and apprehension. Stave reveals that the stranger waits outside Revelstone’s gates, neither eating nor sleeping, beside an inexplicably enduring fire. Linden’s mind races with possibilities, but the Masters of the Land refuse to engage with the stranger, citing uncertainty about his power and motives. Stave hints at undisclosed concerns, deepening Linden’s suspicion that the Masters are withholding critical information.
Determined to act, Linden delegates tasks to her allies, urging Liand and the Ramen to prepare for an impending journey while she seeks clarity. She instructs Stave to share her revelations about Roger Covenant and the croyel with the Humbled, despite the potential repercussions. As her companions disperse, Linden paces restlessly, torn between the need to strategize and her urgency to confront the stranger. She fears her enemies—Roger, the croyel, and Lord Foul’s other minions—are already advancing their schemes, and the stranger’s presence could signify either a new threat or an unforeseen ally.
Stave returns after informing the Humbled, revealing their guarded reaction to Linden’s account. The Masters, unable to conceal their thoughts like Stave, suspect her intent to confront the stranger and resent her secrecy about the Mandoubt. Linden probes Stave’s reluctance to discuss the stranger or the Mandoubt, but he deflects, citing unconfirmed speculations. His evasiveness fuels her frustration, yet she refrains from pressing further, recognizing the need for patience.
As the fire in her hearth dims, mirroring the growing cold outside Revelstone, Linden steels herself for the challenges ahead. The Humbled’s presence at her door underscores the Masters’ distrust, but she remains resolved to uncover the truth. The chapter closes with Linden poised on the brink of action, her mind racing with unanswered questions about the stranger’s identity, the Mandoubt’s role, and the looming dangers threatening the Land. Her determination to defy passive acceptance sets the stage for her next decisive move.
FAQs
1. Comprehension Question
What is Linden’s immediate reaction to learning about the stranger outside Revelstone’s gates, and how does she prepare herself emotionally for potential challenges?
Answer:
Linden reacts with a mix of dread and curiosity when she learns about the mysterious stranger who destroyed the Demondim horde. She instinctively draws Earthpower from the Staff of Law to counteract her fear, showing her reliance on its strength. Emotionally, she forces herself to assess her companions’ reactions—Liand’s confusion, Stave’s stoicism, and Anele’s withdrawal—before shifting into a decisive mindset. She organizes her allies, delegating tasks to the Ramen and Liand while reserving time to think. Her pacing with the Staff reveals both her restlessness and her determination to act, though she recognizes the need to wait for Stave before confronting the stranger.
2. Analytical Question
How does the chapter portray the tension between Linden’s urgency to act and the constraints imposed by the Masters of Revelstone?
Answer:
The chapter highlights a key conflict: Linden’s drive to confront threats (like the stranger or her hidden foes) clashes with the Masters’ restrictive policies. They forbid passage through Revelstone’s gates and withhold information, leaving her dependent on Stave for communication. This tension escalates when the Humbled monitor her movements, symbolizing institutional distrust. Meanwhile, Linden’s internal monologue reveals her fear that delays will advantage her enemies. The Masters’ caution—rooted in uncertainty about the stranger’s power—contrasts with Linden’s proactive stance, emphasizing the broader theme of authority versus individual agency in the face of crisis.
3. Critical Thinking Question
Evaluate the significance of the “fire that does not need to be fed” in the context of the Land’s mysteries and Linden’s past experiences.
Answer:
The unnatural fire beside the stranger evokes deeper mysteries of the Land, recalling Linden’s prior encounters with beings like the Theomach or the Insequent. Its unending burn suggests supernatural power, possibly linking to forces beyond Linden’s knowledge—such as the Elohim or even time manipulation. This detail also mirrors her earlier vision of a motionless figure by a fire, hinting at foreshadowing or cyclical events. The fire’s symbolism (warmth vs. danger) reflects Linden’s dilemma: Is the stranger an ally like the Mandoubt or a threat like the croyel? The ambiguity underscores the Land’s capacity to defy her understanding.
4. Application Question
If you were in Linden’s position, how would you address the Masters’ secrecy about the Mandoubt and the stranger, given their distrust of outsiders?
Answer:
To navigate the Masters’ secrecy, I would leverage Stave’s unique position as a bridge between Linden and his kin. First, I’d press him for clearer explanations, emphasizing shared goals (e.g., protecting Revelstone). Next, I’d propose a controlled encounter with the stranger under the Humbled’s supervision, framing it as reconnaissance rather than defiance. To address the Mandoubt’s secrecy, I’d highlight her past aid as evidence that withholding information risks missing vital alliances. Finally, I’d appeal to the Masters’ duty to the Land’s survival, arguing that collaboration outweighs rigid control—a tactic Linden begins to employ by sharing truths about Roger and the croyel.
5. Thematic Question
How does the chapter develop the theme of uncertainty, both in Linden’s decisions and the broader conflicts of the Land?
Answer:
Uncertainty pervades the chapter, shaping character actions and plot progression. Linden grapples with incomplete knowledge—about the stranger’s identity, the Masters’ motives, and her foes’ plans—which forces her to make decisions amid doubt (e.g., delaying Liand’s questions). The Masters, too, are paralyzed by their uncertainty about the stranger’s power, reflecting a broader crisis of leadership. Even Stave withholds speculation, fearing error. This theme mirrors the Land’s instability, where ancient powers (like the Demondim’s sudden demise) defy prediction. The chapter suggests that in such a world, adaptability—embodied by Linden’s restless pacing—may be as vital as strength.
Quotes
1. “The Earth was vast, and inhabited by beings and powers which she had never encountered. The Land’s present as well as its past held mysteries.”
This quote captures Linden’s realization of the unknown forces at work in the Land, emphasizing the depth of its hidden dangers and allies. It reflects the chapter’s theme of uncertainty and the limits of her understanding.
2. “They are the Masters of the Land.”
Stave’s terse response highlights the Haruchai’s stoic nature and their rigid adherence to their role, underscoring the cultural and ideological barriers Linden faces in dealing with them. This moment reveals the tension between her urgency and their caution.
3. “Like the Mandoubt and the stranger are entwined in my thoughts. I speculate concerning them, but my imaginings are unconfirmed.”
Stave’s hesitation to share his suspicions reflects the chapter’s atmosphere of secrecy and withheld knowledge. This quote underscores the theme of uncertainty and the strategic withholding of critical information.
4. “She had let too much time pass. Surely her foes had already formed new plans and started to carry them out?”
Linden’s internal monologue here reveals her mounting anxiety and urgency, a key emotional turning point in the chapter. It underscores the pressure she feels to act despite incomplete information.
5. “They conclude that you propose to confront the stranger who has brought an end to the Demondim. This they conceive in part because it is your way to leave no obstacle unchallenged.”
This quote encapsulates the Masters’ perception of Linden’s character and foreshadows her impending confrontation with the mysterious stranger. It highlights the clash between her proactive nature and their cautious approach.