Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    WEDNESDAY ANNA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter opens with Anna reflect­ing on her fam­i­ly’s pho­to shelf, a visu­al time­line of their lives. She notes the dis­par­i­ty in the num­ber of pho­tos of her­self com­pared to her sib­lings, Jesse and Kate, hint­ing at her feel­ings of being over­looked. The pho­tos evoke a sense of nos­tal­gia and long­ing, as Anna con­tem­plates the unspo­ken mes­sages they carry—love, atten­tion, and the pas­sage of time. Her father calls to check on her while her moth­er stays at the hos­pi­tal with Kate, reveal­ing the fam­i­ly’s ongo­ing strug­gle with Kate’s ill­ness. Anna’s inter­nal mono­logue under­scores her iso­la­tion and the emo­tion­al weight of her sis­ter’s con­di­tion.

    Anna’s thoughts shift to her iden­ti­ty as “the girl with the sick sis­ter,” pon­der­ing how her life might dif­fer if Kate were healthy. She ques­tions whether peo­ple treat her kind­ly out of gen­uine affec­tion or pity, and won­ders if her true per­son­al­i­ty is over­shad­owed by her cir­cum­stances. This intro­spec­tion leads her to doubt her own char­ac­ter, as she con­sid­ers whether her actions are influ­enced by her sis­ter’s ill­ness or reflect her inher­ent nature. The nar­ra­tive cap­tures Anna’s exis­ten­tial cri­sis and her desire to break free from the labels imposed by her fam­i­ly’s sit­u­a­tion.

    The chap­ter then fol­lows Anna as she joins her broth­er Jesse in his car, where their ban­ter reveals their com­plex rela­tion­ship. Jesse’s non­cha­lant atti­tude con­trasts with Anna’s ten­sion, as she attempts to smoke a cig­a­rette for the first time, a moment that blends humor and vul­ner­a­bil­i­ty. Their inter­ac­tion high­lights Jesse’s role as both a pro­tec­tor and a provo­ca­teur, while Anna’s failed attempt at smok­ing sym­bol­izes her strug­gle to assert her inde­pen­dence. The scene ends with Jesse dri­ving Anna to the hos­pi­tal, where she hopes to see Kate but fears her moth­er’s inter­fer­ence.

    In the final sec­tion, Anna recalls a child­hood mem­o­ry of prac­tic­ing head­stands with Kate, a bit­ter­sweet moment that under­scores their bond. The mem­o­ry con­trasts with the present real­i­ty of Kate’s ill­ness and Anna’s con­flict­ed emo­tions about her role in her sis­ter’s life. Jesse’s reas­sur­ance that Anna isn’t “doing the wrong thing” hints at the moral ambi­gu­i­ty of her deci­sions. The chap­ter clos­es with Anna’s unre­solved ten­sion, as she grap­ples with love, guilt, and the desire for auton­o­my in the shad­ow of her sis­ter’s suf­fer­ing.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does the family photo collection reflect Anna’s feelings of neglect and isolation?

      Answer:
      The family photo shelf serves as a visual metaphor for Anna’s perceived marginalization within her family. While there are numerous pictures of Jesse and Kate at various life stages, Anna notes her own photos jump “from infant to about ten years old in one fell swoop.” This gap symbolizes her emotional experience of being overlooked, as she speculates whether her parents “were sick and tired of keeping a catalog of life” or simply “forgot.” The photos represent more than memories—they’re tangible proof of care and attention that Anna feels she lacked. Her observation that “a photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch” underscores how she interprets this photographic absence as emotional neglect.

      2. Analyze the significance of Anna’s cigarette experiment with Jesse. What does this reveal about their relationship and Anna’s emotional state?

      Answer:
      Anna’s request to smoke serves as both a rebellion against her “good girl” image and a bid for connection with her brother. Jesse’s initial amusement (“You want a cigarette?”) and subsequent teasing instruction reveal their complex dynamic—he simultaneously enables and mocks her attempt at transgression. The physical struggle with the cigarette mirrors Anna’s internal turmoil, as the coughing fit becomes a visceral manifestation of her emotional suffocation. Jesse’s final comment (“you’re not doing the wrong thing”) suggests he recognizes her deeper existential crisis beyond the surface-level rebellion. This interaction highlights how Jesse serves as both a flawed mentor and the only family member who engages with Anna’s authentic self, even through destructive behaviors.

      3. Compare how illness affects social perception in Jimmy Stredboe’s case versus Anna’s experience. What does this reveal about societal attitudes toward illness?

      Answer:
      Both cases demonstrate how illness reshapes social perception, but with crucial differences. Jimmy transitions from being seen as a “total loser” to receiving compassion after his MS diagnosis, showing how illness can erase previous social stigma. Anna, however, has always been “the girl with the sick sister,” never knowing an identity separate from illness. Her observation that “no one is ever outright mean to me” reveals the isolating pity that accompanies her perpetual association with tragedy. While Jimmy gains acceptance, Anna questions whether her entire personality might be a performance shaped by others’ lowered expectations (“Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice”). This contrast exposes how society uses illness as a lens that distorts authentic relationships.

      4. How does the headstand memory with Kate serve as a metaphor for their sisterly relationship?

      Answer:
      The headstand training memory encapsulates the physical and emotional imbalance between the sisters. Kate’s graceful form (“delicate as a spider walking a wall”) contrasts with Anna’s “thud” of defiance against gravity, mirroring how Kate’s illness naturally commands attention while Anna must work harder to be noticed. Anna’s complaint about her head shape during the exercise reflects her constant self-comparison to Kate. The shared activity—attempting a world record—symbolizes their childhood bond, but the differing execution hints at the underlying tension. The blood rushing to their heads (“cheeks went hard as plums”) foreshadows the emotional pressure that will later define their relationship, making this innocent memory poignantly ironic in retrospect.

      5. Evaluate the significance of fire imagery throughout the chapter. How does it connect the various characters and themes?

      Answer:
      Fire emerges as a multifaceted symbol linking family roles and emotional states. The father literally fights fires professionally, yet fails to extinguish the metaphorical fires in his family. Anna imagines his fire station door “yawning like Aladdin’s cave,” suggesting both danger and potential salvation. Jesse’s cigarette fire represents both rebellion and connection, a small controlled burn that contrasts with the larger emotional infernos. When Anna says smoking is “like licking a barbecue,” she conflates the physical sensation with nostalgic family memories, revealing how pain and comfort intertwine. This imagery network ultimately portrays the family as simultaneously creating and combating their own destruction, with each member playing different roles in the cycle of damage and rescue.

    Quotes

    • 1. “A photo says, You were happy, and I wanted to catch that. A photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch.”

      This poignant reflection on family photos captures Anna’s feelings of being overlooked as the third child. It reveals her deep longing for validation and connection, setting the tone for her emotional journey in the chapter.

      2. “From the moment I was born, I have been the girl with the sick sister. All my life bank tellers have given me extra lollipops; principals have known me by name. No one is ever outright mean to me.”

      This quote highlights Anna’s complex relationship with her identity as Kate’s sister. It shows how her sister’s illness has shaped her entire existence and raises questions about how she would be perceived without this defining context.

      3. “Maybe I’m a pretty rotten person, not that anyone would ever have the guts to tell me this to my face. Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice because it could be the circumstances of my life that make me that way.”

      This vulnerable moment reveals Anna’s deep self-doubt and the psychological impact of living in Kate’s shadow. It shows her questioning whether people’s kindness is genuine or just pity, a key emotional conflict in the story.

      4. “I’m not doing the right thing, either,” I point out.”

      This brief but powerful exchange with Jesse captures Anna’s moral dilemma about her decisions regarding Kate. It represents a turning point where she acknowledges the complexity of her situation rather than seeing it in black-and-white terms.

      5. “We were eleven and fourteen, and we were training for the Guinness Book of World Records. Surely there had never been two sisters who did simultaneous headstands for so long that their cheeks went hard as plums and their eyes saw nothing but red.”

      This nostalgic memory illustrates the bond Anna once shared with Kate before illness dominated their relationship. It serves as a bittersweet contrast to their current situation and shows what Anna stands to lose.

    Quotes

    1. “A photo says, You were happy, and I wanted to catch that. A photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch.”

    This poignant reflection on family photos captures Anna’s feelings of being overlooked as the third child. It reveals her deep longing for validation and connection, setting the tone for her emotional journey in the chapter.

    2. “From the moment I was born, I have been the girl with the sick sister. All my life bank tellers have given me extra lollipops; principals have known me by name. No one is ever outright mean to me.”

    This quote highlights Anna’s complex relationship with her identity as Kate’s sister. It shows how her sister’s illness has shaped her entire existence and raises questions about how she would be perceived without this defining context.

    3. “Maybe I’m a pretty rotten person, not that anyone would ever have the guts to tell me this to my face. Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice because it could be the circumstances of my life that make me that way.”

    This vulnerable moment reveals Anna’s deep self-doubt and the psychological impact of living in Kate’s shadow. It shows her questioning whether people’s kindness is genuine or just pity, a key emotional conflict in the story.

    4. “I’m not doing the right thing, either,” I point out.”

    This brief but powerful exchange with Jesse captures Anna’s moral dilemma about her decisions regarding Kate. It represents a turning point where she acknowledges the complexity of her situation rather than seeing it in black-and-white terms.

    5. “We were eleven and fourteen, and we were training for the Guinness Book of World Records. Surely there had never been two sisters who did simultaneous headstands for so long that their cheeks went hard as plums and their eyes saw nothing but red.”

    This nostalgic memory illustrates the bond Anna once shared with Kate before illness dominated their relationship. It serves as a bittersweet contrast to their current situation and shows what Anna stands to lose.

    FAQs

    1. How does the family photo collection reflect Anna’s feelings of neglect and isolation?

    Answer:
    The family photo shelf serves as a visual metaphor for Anna’s perceived marginalization within her family. While there are numerous pictures of Jesse and Kate at various life stages, Anna notes her own photos jump “from infant to about ten years old in one fell swoop.” This gap symbolizes her emotional experience of being overlooked, as she speculates whether her parents “were sick and tired of keeping a catalog of life” or simply “forgot.” The photos represent more than memories—they’re tangible proof of care and attention that Anna feels she lacked. Her observation that “a photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch” underscores how she interprets this photographic absence as emotional neglect.

    2. Analyze the significance of Anna’s cigarette experiment with Jesse. What does this reveal about their relationship and Anna’s emotional state?

    Answer:
    Anna’s request to smoke serves as both a rebellion against her “good girl” image and a bid for connection with her brother. Jesse’s initial amusement (“You want a cigarette?”) and subsequent teasing instruction reveal their complex dynamic—he simultaneously enables and mocks her attempt at transgression. The physical struggle with the cigarette mirrors Anna’s internal turmoil, as the coughing fit becomes a visceral manifestation of her emotional suffocation. Jesse’s final comment (“you’re not doing the wrong thing”) suggests he recognizes her deeper existential crisis beyond the surface-level rebellion. This interaction highlights how Jesse serves as both a flawed mentor and the only family member who engages with Anna’s authentic self, even through destructive behaviors.

    3. Compare how illness affects social perception in Jimmy Stredboe’s case versus Anna’s experience. What does this reveal about societal attitudes toward illness?

    Answer:
    Both cases demonstrate how illness reshapes social perception, but with crucial differences. Jimmy transitions from being seen as a “total loser” to receiving compassion after his MS diagnosis, showing how illness can erase previous social stigma. Anna, however, has always been “the girl with the sick sister,” never knowing an identity separate from illness. Her observation that “no one is ever outright mean to me” reveals the isolating pity that accompanies her perpetual association with tragedy. While Jimmy gains acceptance, Anna questions whether her entire personality might be a performance shaped by others’ lowered expectations (“Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice”). This contrast exposes how society uses illness as a lens that distorts authentic relationships.

    4. How does the headstand memory with Kate serve as a metaphor for their sisterly relationship?

    Answer:
    The headstand training memory encapsulates the physical and emotional imbalance between the sisters. Kate’s graceful form (“delicate as a spider walking a wall”) contrasts with Anna’s “thud” of defiance against gravity, mirroring how Kate’s illness naturally commands attention while Anna must work harder to be noticed. Anna’s complaint about her head shape during the exercise reflects her constant self-comparison to Kate. The shared activity—attempting a world record—symbolizes their childhood bond, but the differing execution hints at the underlying tension. The blood rushing to their heads (“cheeks went hard as plums”) foreshadows the emotional pressure that will later define their relationship, making this innocent memory poignantly ironic in retrospect.

    5. Evaluate the significance of fire imagery throughout the chapter. How does it connect the various characters and themes?

    Answer:
    Fire emerges as a multifaceted symbol linking family roles and emotional states. The father literally fights fires professionally, yet fails to extinguish the metaphorical fires in his family. Anna imagines his fire station door “yawning like Aladdin’s cave,” suggesting both danger and potential salvation. Jesse’s cigarette fire represents both rebellion and connection, a small controlled burn that contrasts with the larger emotional infernos. When Anna says smoking is “like licking a barbecue,” she conflates the physical sensation with nostalgic family memories, revealing how pain and comfort intertwine. This imagery network ultimately portrays the family as simultaneously creating and combating their own destruction, with each member playing different roles in the cycle of damage and rescue.

    Note