Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    WEDNESDAY ANNA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter opens with Anna reflect­ing on her fam­i­ly’s pho­to col­lec­tion, which serves as a visu­al time­line of their lives. She notes the dis­par­i­ty in the num­ber of pho­tos of her­self com­pared to her sib­lings, Jesse and Kate, hint­ing at her per­ceived invis­i­bil­i­ty with­in the fam­i­ly. The pho­tos evoke bit­ter­sweet emo­tions, sym­bol­iz­ing moments of hap­pi­ness and impor­tance, yet also high­light­ing the gaps in her own doc­u­ment­ed child­hood. This intro­spec­tion sets the tone for Anna’s feel­ings of iso­la­tion and unre­solved famil­ial dynam­ics.

    Anna’s father calls to check on her while her moth­er stays at the hos­pi­tal with Kate, who is heav­i­ly med­icat­ed. Their con­ver­sa­tion is brief and strained, under­scor­ing the fam­i­ly’s pre­oc­cu­pa­tion with Kate’s ill­ness. Anna imag­ines her father’s life as a fire­fight­er, a metaphor for the con­stant crises he man­ages, both pro­fes­sion­al­ly and per­son­al­ly. This moment pro­pels her to leave the house, seek­ing solace or dis­trac­tion, fur­ther empha­siz­ing her emo­tion­al tur­moil and desire for auton­o­my.

    The nar­ra­tive shifts to Anna’s mus­ings on how her iden­ti­ty is shaped by her sis­ter’s ill­ness. She com­pares her­self to a class­mate who gained sym­pa­thy after being diag­nosed with a dis­ease, ques­tion­ing whether peo­ple treat her kind­ly out of gen­uine regard or pity. This leads her to doubt her own char­ac­ter, won­der­ing if her actions are inher­ent­ly flawed or mere­ly a prod­uct of her cir­cum­stances. Her exis­ten­tial ques­tion­ing reveals deep-seat­ed inse­cu­ri­ties and a long­ing for nor­mal­cy.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Anna and her broth­er Jesse in a car, where she attempts to smoke a cig­a­rette for the first time, a rebel­lious act that ends in comedic fail­ure. Their ban­ter masks deep­er ten­sions, as Anna grap­ples with her deci­sion to vis­it Kate at the hos­pi­tal. Jesse’s cryp­tic advice about the “drag­on guard­ing the cave” hints at their moth­er’s pro­tec­tive pres­ence, com­pli­cat­ing Anna’s desire to see her sis­ter. The sib­lings’ inter­ac­tion blends humor and poignan­cy, cap­tur­ing Anna’s inter­nal con­flict and the com­plex bond they share.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does the family photo collection serve as a metaphor for Anna’s feelings about her place in the family?

      Answer:
      The photo collection represents both the passage of time and Anna’s perceived marginalization within her family. While there are numerous photos of Jesse and Kate at various life stages, Anna notes there are far fewer of her, jumping “from infant to about ten years old in one fell swoop.” This visual gap symbolizes her sense of being overlooked, as she speculates whether her parents “forgot” or were “sick and tired of keeping a catalog of life.” The photos also carry emotional weight—they signify moments when someone was deemed important enough to document. Anna’s absence from many photos underscores her feelings of being secondary to her siblings, particularly Kate, whose illness dominates family attention.

      2. Analyze the significance of Anna’s interaction with Jesse in the car. What does this scene reveal about their relationship and Anna’s emotional state?

      Answer:
      The car scene reveals Jesse’s role as both a provocateur and an unlikely source of support for Anna. His teasing yet permissive attitude—letting her try a cigarette despite knowing she’ll struggle—reflects their complex dynamic. While Jesse mocks her (“Nice try”), he also intuitively understands her need to rebel and distract herself from Kate’s hospitalization. His question, “Have you thought about the dragon guarding the cave?” shows he grasps her desire to see Kate despite the complications. Their banter masks deeper care: Jesse ultimately offers to help her navigate the hospital visit, suggesting a protective instinct beneath his sarcastic exterior. Anna’s willingness to engage in risky behavior (smoking) with Jesse hints at her search for identity outside her “sick sister” narrative.

      3. How does the anecdote about Jimmy Stredboe connect to Anna’s broader reflection on identity and perception?

      Answer:
      Jimmy Stredboe’s story parallels Anna’s musings on how tragedy alters public perception. Before his MS diagnosis, Jimmy was ostracized as a “loser”; afterward, he received sympathy and kindness. Anna recognizes a similar dynamic in her own life—being “the girl with the sick sister” has shielded her from criticism and guaranteed her preferential treatment. This realization unsettles her, as she questions whether her personality (“rude or ugly or stupid”) is excused due to her circumstances. The anecdote underscores her existential dilemma: without Kate’s illness defining her, who would she be? It also critiques how society reduces individuals to simplistic narratives (victim/outcast) rather than seeing their multifaceted identities.

      4. What contrasting imagery does the author use to depict Kate and Anna’s childhood, and what effect does this create?

      Answer:
      The author contrasts Kate’s “pixie” grace with Anna’s physical clumsiness to highlight their divergent roles in the family. Kate is described with delicate, almost ethereal imagery (“noodle arms and legs,” “spider walking a wall”), reinforcing her fragility due to illness. Anna, meanwhile, defies gravity “with a thud,” a humorous yet poignant metaphor for her perceived lack of finesse. This dichotomy extends to their photos: Kate’s images document her transformation (e.g., “with hair and all bald”), while Anna’s sparse photos suggest an unchroniched existence. The contrast emphasizes Kate’s centrality in the family narrative and Anna’s struggle to carve out space as more than just a supporting character in Kate’s story.

      5. Evaluate the chapter’s exploration of guilt and moral ambiguity through Anna’s internal monologue.

      Answer:
      Anna’s guilt manifests in her conflicted actions and thoughts. She seeks reassurance from Jesse (“I’m not doing the right thing”), revealing her unease about her decisions regarding Kate. Her cigarette experiment—a fleeting rebellion—symbolizes her attempt to assert control amid powerlessness, yet it also reflects self-punishment (the physical discomfort mirrors her emotional turmoil). The chapter subtly frames her moral ambiguity: she resents the pity tied to Kate’s illness but also relies on it for identity. Her observation that “no one would ever have the guts to tell me [I’m rotten] to my face” suggests she suspects her actions may be selfish but feels trapped by societal expectations. This tension invites readers to consider whether Anna’s choices stem from malice or from an understandable need for autonomy.

    Quotes

    • 1. “A photo says, You were happy, and I wanted to catch that. A photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch.”

      This poignant reflection on family photos captures Anna’s sense of being overlooked as the third child. It reveals her deeper longing for validation and the unspoken hierarchy of attention in her family.

      2. “From the moment I was born, I have been the girl with the sick sister. All my life bank tellers have given me extra lollipops; principals have known me by name. No one is ever outright mean to me.”

      This quote exposes the complex identity Anna has developed as “the healthy sibling” in a family focused on illness. It highlights how her entire personality and social interactions are filtered through her sister’s condition.

      3. “Maybe I’m a pretty rotten person, not that anyone would ever have the guts to tell me this to my face. Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice because it could be the circumstances of my life that make me that way.”

      This vulnerable introspection shows Anna questioning whether her personality is authentic or shaped by others’ pity. It represents a key moment of self-doubt about her motivations and character.

      4. “Anna,” he says, “you’re not doing the wrong thing.” […] “I’m not doing the right thing, either,” I point out.”

      This tense exchange with Jesse encapsulates the moral ambiguity at the heart of Anna’s dilemma regarding her sister. The brief dialogue powerfully conveys the gray area between right and wrong in difficult family decisions.

      5. “There’s really no way to explain why I need to know that she’s okay, at least now, even though I have taken steps that will put an end to that.”

      This paradoxical statement reveals Anna’s internal conflict - her simultaneous desire to protect her sister Kate while being complicit in actions that may harm her. It’s a crucial moment exposing the complexity of sibling love under extraordinary circumstances.

    Quotes

    1. “A photo says, You were happy, and I wanted to catch that. A photo says, You were so important to me that I put down everything else to come watch.”

    This poignant reflection on family photos captures Anna’s sense of being overlooked as the third child. It reveals her deeper longing for validation and the unspoken hierarchy of attention in her family.

    2. “From the moment I was born, I have been the girl with the sick sister. All my life bank tellers have given me extra lollipops; principals have known me by name. No one is ever outright mean to me.”

    This quote exposes the complex identity Anna has developed as “the healthy sibling” in a family focused on illness. It highlights how her entire personality and social interactions are filtered through her sister’s condition.

    3. “Maybe I’m a pretty rotten person, not that anyone would ever have the guts to tell me this to my face. Maybe everyone thinks I’m rude or ugly or stupid but they have to be nice because it could be the circumstances of my life that make me that way.”

    This vulnerable introspection shows Anna questioning whether her personality is authentic or shaped by others’ pity. It represents a key moment of self-doubt about her motivations and character.

    4. “Anna,” he says, “you’re not doing the wrong thing.” […] “I’m not doing the right thing, either,” I point out.”

    This tense exchange with Jesse encapsulates the moral ambiguity at the heart of Anna’s dilemma regarding her sister. The brief dialogue powerfully conveys the gray area between right and wrong in difficult family decisions.

    5. “There’s really no way to explain why I need to know that she’s okay, at least now, even though I have taken steps that will put an end to that.”

    This paradoxical statement reveals Anna’s internal conflict - her simultaneous desire to protect her sister Kate while being complicit in actions that may harm her. It’s a crucial moment exposing the complexity of sibling love under extraordinary circumstances.

    FAQs

    1. How does the family photo collection serve as a metaphor for Anna’s feelings about her place in the family?

    Answer:
    The photo collection represents both the passage of time and Anna’s perceived marginalization within her family. While there are numerous photos of Jesse and Kate at various life stages, Anna notes there are far fewer of her, jumping “from infant to about ten years old in one fell swoop.” This visual gap symbolizes her sense of being overlooked, as she speculates whether her parents “forgot” or were “sick and tired of keeping a catalog of life.” The photos also carry emotional weight—they signify moments when someone was deemed important enough to document. Anna’s absence from many photos underscores her feelings of being secondary to her siblings, particularly Kate, whose illness dominates family attention.

    2. Analyze the significance of Anna’s interaction with Jesse in the car. What does this scene reveal about their relationship and Anna’s emotional state?

    Answer:
    The car scene reveals Jesse’s role as both a provocateur and an unlikely source of support for Anna. His teasing yet permissive attitude—letting her try a cigarette despite knowing she’ll struggle—reflects their complex dynamic. While Jesse mocks her (“Nice try”), he also intuitively understands her need to rebel and distract herself from Kate’s hospitalization. His question, “Have you thought about the dragon guarding the cave?” shows he grasps her desire to see Kate despite the complications. Their banter masks deeper care: Jesse ultimately offers to help her navigate the hospital visit, suggesting a protective instinct beneath his sarcastic exterior. Anna’s willingness to engage in risky behavior (smoking) with Jesse hints at her search for identity outside her “sick sister” narrative.

    3. How does the anecdote about Jimmy Stredboe connect to Anna’s broader reflection on identity and perception?

    Answer:
    Jimmy Stredboe’s story parallels Anna’s musings on how tragedy alters public perception. Before his MS diagnosis, Jimmy was ostracized as a “loser”; afterward, he received sympathy and kindness. Anna recognizes a similar dynamic in her own life—being “the girl with the sick sister” has shielded her from criticism and guaranteed her preferential treatment. This realization unsettles her, as she questions whether her personality (“rude or ugly or stupid”) is excused due to her circumstances. The anecdote underscores her existential dilemma: without Kate’s illness defining her, who would she be? It also critiques how society reduces individuals to simplistic narratives (victim/outcast) rather than seeing their multifaceted identities.

    4. What contrasting imagery does the author use to depict Kate and Anna’s childhood, and what effect does this create?

    Answer:
    The author contrasts Kate’s “pixie” grace with Anna’s physical clumsiness to highlight their divergent roles in the family. Kate is described with delicate, almost ethereal imagery (“noodle arms and legs,” “spider walking a wall”), reinforcing her fragility due to illness. Anna, meanwhile, defies gravity “with a thud,” a humorous yet poignant metaphor for her perceived lack of finesse. This dichotomy extends to their photos: Kate’s images document her transformation (e.g., “with hair and all bald”), while Anna’s sparse photos suggest an unchroniched existence. The contrast emphasizes Kate’s centrality in the family narrative and Anna’s struggle to carve out space as more than just a supporting character in Kate’s story.

    5. Evaluate the chapter’s exploration of guilt and moral ambiguity through Anna’s internal monologue.

    Answer:
    Anna’s guilt manifests in her conflicted actions and thoughts. She seeks reassurance from Jesse (“I’m not doing the right thing”), revealing her unease about her decisions regarding Kate. Her cigarette experiment—a fleeting rebellion—symbolizes her attempt to assert control amid powerlessness, yet it also reflects self-punishment (the physical discomfort mirrors her emotional turmoil). The chapter subtly frames her moral ambiguity: she resents the pity tied to Kate’s illness but also relies on it for identity. Her observation that “no one would ever have the guts to tell me [I’m rotten] to my face” suggests she suspects her actions may be selfish but feels trapped by societal expectations. This tension invites readers to consider whether Anna’s choices stem from malice or from an understandable need for autonomy.

    Note