Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    WEDNESDAY ANNA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter opens with Anna’s mor­bid reflec­tions on her own hypo­thet­i­cal funer­al, imag­in­ing sparse atten­dance and min­i­mal impact. She con­trasts this with her sis­ter Kate’s future funer­al, which she envi­sions as a crowd­ed, high-pro­file event due to Kate’s bat­tle with can­cer. Anna’s mus­ings reveal her feel­ings of invis­i­bil­i­ty and resent­ment, as well as her deep aware­ness of Kate’s cen­tral role in their fam­i­ly dynam­ics. The scene shifts abrupt­ly to a cour­t­house, where Anna meets with Judge DeSal­vo to dis­cuss her peti­tion for med­ical eman­ci­pa­tion, cre­at­ing a jar­ring tran­si­tion that mir­rors Anna’s emo­tion­al tur­moil.

    In the cour­t­house scene, Judge DeSalvo’s infor­mal demeanor—wearing flip-flops and offer­ing Anna a Coke—initially puts her at ease. Their con­ver­sa­tion takes a sci­en­tif­ic turn when the judge men­tions how Coke can dis­solve a baby tooth, which Anna inter­nal­izes as a metaphor for her own emo­tion­al dis­so­lu­tion. The judge probes Anna’s con­flict­ing state­ments about her desire to drop the law­suit against her par­ents, high­light­ing the ten­sion between her moth­er’s claims and her lawyer’s posi­tion. This con­fronta­tion forces Anna to artic­u­late her true feel­ings about being a per­pet­u­al med­ical donor for Kate.

    Anna’s emo­tion­al break­down comes when she notices the judge drink­ing apple juice, trig­ger­ing a vivid mem­o­ry of a prank she and Kate played on a nurse. This bit­ter­sweet rec­ol­lec­tion under­scores the com­plex­i­ty of Anna’s rela­tion­ship with her sister—simultaneously resent­ful yet deeply con­nect­ed. Her tears reveal the unbear­able pres­sure of being expect­ed to con­tin­u­al­ly sac­ri­fice her body for Kate’s sur­vival. The judge, rec­og­niz­ing Anna’s dis­tress, pro­pos­es appoint­ing a guardian ad litem to assess her best inter­ests, cre­at­ing a tem­po­rary reprieve from the imme­di­ate legal pres­sure.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Anna’s moth­er enter­ing the room, inter­rupt­ed by Anna’s lawyer before she can reach her daugh­ter. Judge DeSal­vo for­mal­izes his deci­sion to appoint a guardian, set­ting up a two-week eval­u­a­tion peri­od. Anna’s moth­er’s unspo­ken con­cern about Kate’s time­line hints at the urgent med­ical con­text hang­ing over the legal pro­ceed­ings. The chap­ter mas­ter­ful­ly inter­twines Anna’s inter­nal strug­gles with the exter­nal legal bat­tle, paint­ing a poignant pic­ture of a teenag­er fight­ing for bod­i­ly auton­o­my while grap­pling with guilt, love, and fam­i­ly loy­al­ty.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Anna imagine her funeral compared to her sister Kate’s, and what does this reveal about their family dynamics?

      Answer:
      Anna envisions her funeral as a small, sparsely attended event with only immediate family and a few others present, while she predicts Kate’s funeral will be overflowing with mourners, media attention, and community support. This stark contrast highlights the family’s focus on Kate’s illness and the emotional resources directed toward her. Anna’s imagined scenario suggests she feels overlooked and secondary in the family hierarchy, reinforcing the theme of sibling sacrifice and unequal attention that permeates the chapter.

      2. What symbolic significance does the Judge’s anecdote about a baby tooth dissolving in Coke hold in the context of Anna’s emotional state?

      Answer:
      The Judge’s story about carbonic acid dissolving a tooth mirrors Anna’s internal erosion—both physically (through repeated medical procedures) and emotionally (through the weight of her sister’s illness). The imagery foreshadows Anna’s breakdown later in the scene, where she cries, “I can’t give a kidney to my sister. I just can’t.” Like the tooth, Anna feels herself disappearing under familial and medical pressures, symbolizing her diminishing sense of autonomy and identity.

      3. Analyze the significance of Anna’s reaction to the apple juice can during her meeting with Judge DeSalvo. How does this memory reveal her relationship with Kate?

      Answer:
      When Anna sees the Judge drinking apple juice, she recalls a prank where Kate pretended to drink urine (apple juice) to shock a nurse. This memory showcases their shared dark humor and bond through adversity. The spontaneous laughter they shared—now contrasted with Anna’s sudden tears—underscores how Kate’s illness has shifted from manageable challenges to unbearable burdens. The recollection also reveals Anna’s grief for the lighthearted relationship they once had, now overshadowed by medical trauma.

      Answer:
      The Judge appoints a guardian ad litem because Anna’s stated desires (to drop the lawsuit) conflict with her actions (hiring a lawyer). This move acknowledges the murky territory of medical emancipation cases involving minors. By seeking an independent advocate, the Judge recognizes that Anna’s parents may be too emotionally invested in Kate’s survival to objectively represent Anna’s best interests, while also questioning whether Anna fully grasps the consequences of her decisions amid family pressure.

      5. How does the chapter use contrasting imagery (e.g., funerals, medical procedures, childhood pranks) to explore themes of autonomy and sacrifice?

      Answer:
      The juxtaposition of grim funerals with darkly comic hospital pranks illustrates the tension between life’s fragility and the resilience of human connection. Anna’s vivid funeral fantasies contrast with the sterile reality of courtrooms and medical procedures, emphasizing her struggle to assert control over her body and future. Meanwhile, the shift from shared laughter with Kate to solitary tears in court traces her journey from willing participant to reluctant donor, framing organ donation not as heroism but as an erosion of self.

    Quotes

    • 1. “I DON’T THINK ANYONE WOULD COME, to my funeral. My parents, I guess, and Aunt Zanne and maybe Mr. Ollincott, the social studies teacher.”

      This opening line establishes Anna’s bleak perspective on her own significance, contrasting sharply with her sister Kate’s anticipated funeral. It introduces the theme of sibling comparison and Anna’s feelings of invisibility.

      2. “At Kate’s funeral, everyone will come… They will have to turn mourners away at the cemetery gates.”

      This stark contrast between Anna’s imagined funeral and Kate’s anticipated one highlights the central conflict of the chapter - Anna’s perception of being overshadowed by her sister’s illness and the different ways their lives are valued.

      3. “I can’t give a kidney to my sister. I just can’t.”

      This raw confession to Judge DeSalvo represents the climax of Anna’s emotional struggle, revealing her true feelings about being a donor for Kate despite her earlier claims to want to drop the lawsuit.

      4. “The kidney—that’s just today. Tomorrow it’ll be something else. It’s always something else.”

      This quote powerfully conveys Anna’s sense of being trapped in an endless cycle of medical demands, showing why she’s pursuing legal emancipation despite loving her family.

      5. “Because I love her… I’m sorry. I’m really sorry.”

      This emotional admission reveals the complexity of Anna’s position - her legal action stems from love, not rejection, capturing the painful paradox at the heart of her decision.

    Quotes

    1. “I DON’T THINK ANYONE WOULD COME, to my funeral. My parents, I guess, and Aunt Zanne and maybe Mr. Ollincott, the social studies teacher.”

    This opening line establishes Anna’s bleak perspective on her own significance, contrasting sharply with her sister Kate’s anticipated funeral. It introduces the theme of sibling comparison and Anna’s feelings of invisibility.

    2. “At Kate’s funeral, everyone will come… They will have to turn mourners away at the cemetery gates.”

    This stark contrast between Anna’s imagined funeral and Kate’s anticipated one highlights the central conflict of the chapter - Anna’s perception of being overshadowed by her sister’s illness and the different ways their lives are valued.

    3. “I can’t give a kidney to my sister. I just can’t.”

    This raw confession to Judge DeSalvo represents the climax of Anna’s emotional struggle, revealing her true feelings about being a donor for Kate despite her earlier claims to want to drop the lawsuit.

    4. “The kidney—that’s just today. Tomorrow it’ll be something else. It’s always something else.”

    This quote powerfully conveys Anna’s sense of being trapped in an endless cycle of medical demands, showing why she’s pursuing legal emancipation despite loving her family.

    5. “Because I love her… I’m sorry. I’m really sorry.”

    This emotional admission reveals the complexity of Anna’s position - her legal action stems from love, not rejection, capturing the painful paradox at the heart of her decision.

    FAQs

    1. How does Anna imagine her funeral compared to her sister Kate’s, and what does this reveal about their family dynamics?

    Answer:
    Anna envisions her funeral as a small, sparsely attended event with only immediate family and a few others present, while she predicts Kate’s funeral will be overflowing with mourners, media attention, and community support. This stark contrast highlights the family’s focus on Kate’s illness and the emotional resources directed toward her. Anna’s imagined scenario suggests she feels overlooked and secondary in the family hierarchy, reinforcing the theme of sibling sacrifice and unequal attention that permeates the chapter.

    2. What symbolic significance does the Judge’s anecdote about a baby tooth dissolving in Coke hold in the context of Anna’s emotional state?

    Answer:
    The Judge’s story about carbonic acid dissolving a tooth mirrors Anna’s internal erosion—both physically (through repeated medical procedures) and emotionally (through the weight of her sister’s illness). The imagery foreshadows Anna’s breakdown later in the scene, where she cries, “I can’t give a kidney to my sister. I just can’t.” Like the tooth, Anna feels herself disappearing under familial and medical pressures, symbolizing her diminishing sense of autonomy and identity.

    3. Analyze the significance of Anna’s reaction to the apple juice can during her meeting with Judge DeSalvo. How does this memory reveal her relationship with Kate?

    Answer:
    When Anna sees the Judge drinking apple juice, she recalls a prank where Kate pretended to drink urine (apple juice) to shock a nurse. This memory showcases their shared dark humor and bond through adversity. The spontaneous laughter they shared—now contrasted with Anna’s sudden tears—underscores how Kate’s illness has shifted from manageable challenges to unbearable burdens. The recollection also reveals Anna’s grief for the lighthearted relationship they once had, now overshadowed by medical trauma.

    Answer:
    The Judge appoints a guardian ad litem because Anna’s stated desires (to drop the lawsuit) conflict with her actions (hiring a lawyer). This move acknowledges the murky territory of medical emancipation cases involving minors. By seeking an independent advocate, the Judge recognizes that Anna’s parents may be too emotionally invested in Kate’s survival to objectively represent Anna’s best interests, while also questioning whether Anna fully grasps the consequences of her decisions amid family pressure.

    5. How does the chapter use contrasting imagery (e.g., funerals, medical procedures, childhood pranks) to explore themes of autonomy and sacrifice?

    Answer:
    The juxtaposition of grim funerals with darkly comic hospital pranks illustrates the tension between life’s fragility and the resilience of human connection. Anna’s vivid funeral fantasies contrast with the sterile reality of courtrooms and medical procedures, emphasizing her struggle to assert control over her body and future. Meanwhile, the shift from shared laughter with Kate to solitary tears in court traces her journey from willing participant to reluctant donor, framing organ donation not as heroism but as an erosion of self.

    Note