Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    TUESDAY ANNA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter intro­duces Anna, a teenag­er who often fan­ta­sizes about belong­ing to a dif­fer­ent fam­i­ly due to her phys­i­cal dis­sim­i­lar­i­ty from her par­ents and sib­lings. She humor­ous­ly imag­ines her “real” par­ents whisk­ing her away to a lux­u­ri­ous life, yet admits the first per­son she’d share this fan­ta­sy with is her sis­ter Kate. The nar­ra­tive quick­ly shifts to reveal Kate’s seri­ous health condition—she under­goes fre­quent dial­y­sis due to fail­ing kid­neys, a sit­u­a­tion where Anna plays a sup­port­ive role, keep­ing Kate enter­tained dur­ing her treat­ments. The sis­ters share a close bond, with Anna act­ing as Kate’s “eyes and ears” dur­ing her med­ical rou­tines.

    The chap­ter delves into the com­plex­i­ties of Anna’s role as a poten­tial kid­ney donor for Kate. Anna reflects on the risks and long-term con­se­quences of kid­ney dona­tion, con­trast­ing it with minor med­ical pro­ce­dures. While she acknowl­edges the grav­i­ty of the surgery, she also rec­og­nizes the self­less­ness involved in sav­ing Kate’s life. This inter­nal con­flict is jux­ta­posed with a light­heart­ed moment where their moth­er shares a pam­phlet about kid­ney trans­plants, spark­ing a macabre yet humor­ous exchange about the logis­tics of hav­ing three kid­neys.

    Ten­sion esca­lates when Vern Stack­house, a local sher­iff, arrives to serve legal papers to Anna’s moth­er. The doc­u­ments reveal Anna’s peti­tion for med­ical eman­ci­pa­tion, seek­ing to pre­vent fur­ther med­ical pro­ce­dures for Kate’s ben­e­fit. The rev­e­la­tion shocks the fam­i­ly, with Anna feel­ing a mix of guilt and relief as Kate sud­den­ly expe­ri­ences pain, divert­ing their moth­er’s atten­tion. Anna’s emo­tion­al tur­moil is pal­pa­ble as she flees the room, unable to face the con­se­quences of her actions.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Anna seek­ing refuge in the mater­ni­ty ward, a stark con­trast to the chaos she left behind. The jux­ta­po­si­tion of new life with her fam­i­ly’s med­ical strug­gles under­scores the chap­ter’s themes of sac­ri­fice, iden­ti­ty, and moral ambi­gu­i­ty. Anna’s actions, though dras­tic, high­light her desire for auton­o­my amid a life­time of being defined by her sis­ter’s ill­ness. The unre­solved ten­sion leaves read­ers ques­tion­ing the eth­i­cal and emo­tion­al ram­i­fi­ca­tions of her deci­sion.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. What is Anna’s initial fantasy about her family situation, and what does this reveal about her feelings of belonging?

      Answer:
      Anna pretends she is “just passing through” her current family on her way to her “real” one, imagining her true parents might be nearby, ready to whisk her away to a life of luxury. This fantasy reveals her deep-seated feelings of being an outsider in her own family, as she notes her siblings resemble their parents while she feels like a “collection of recessive genes.” Despite this, her immediate thought of calling Kate to share her imagined good fortune shows her complex bond with her sister—simultaneously feeling disconnected from her family yet deeply attached to Kate.

      2. How does the chapter illustrate the physical and emotional dynamics of Kate’s medical condition and its impact on Anna?

      Answer:
      Kate’s dialysis sessions are described as lengthy and boring, requiring Anna to act as her “eyes and ears” during treatments. The chapter highlights the sisters’ close relationship through their games and shared moments, but also foreshadows tension with the discussion of kidney transplants. Anna’s internal monologue about the risks of kidney donation (anesthesia complications, recovery time, long-term health effects) contrasts sharply with her mother’s casual tone about the procedure, emphasizing Anna’s unspoken anxiety about being pressured into medical sacrifice for Kate’s benefit.

      Answer:
      The “Petition for Medical Emancipation” serves as the chapter’s climax, revealing Anna’s covert legal action to gain control over her medical decisions and refuse further treatment for Kate. The shock of this moment is heightened by Vern’s discomfort and the family’s confusion. Anna’s visceral reaction (“all the blood leaves my body”) and Kate’s sudden pain create a dramatic tension, forcing their mother to choose between attending to Kate’s immediate crisis and confronting Anna. This scene crystallizes the ethical dilemma: Anna’s desire for bodily autonomy versus her family’s expectation of self-sacrifice.

      4. How does the author use contrasting imagery to underscore Anna’s emotional state during the confrontation with her mother?

      Answer:
      The chapter employs stark contrasts to mirror Anna’s turmoil. The sterile hospital setting clashes with the violent metaphor of Anna feeling “like a fist in my gut.” Her mother is described as a fragile “soap bubble” torn between her daughters, while Anna’s relief at Kate’s pain—a morally ambiguous reaction—highlights her desperation. The final image of her mother frantically pressing the nurse’s call button “as if it’s the trigger to a bomb” parallels Anna’s own sense that her legal action has detonated the family’s fragile equilibrium.

      5. Why might Anna flee to the maternity ward, and what symbolic meaning does this location hold in the context of her conflict?

      Answer:
      Anna’s choice to hide in the maternity ward is deeply ironic: it represents new life and familial bonds, while she is actively severing her role as Kate’s medical lifeline. The overheard phone call about a “perfect” newborn contrasts with Anna’s fraught relationship with her own body and its commodification for Kate’s survival. This setting underscores her desire to reclaim autonomy over her physical self, much like the newborns who belong wholly to themselves. It also hints at future themes of creation versus sacrifice, as Anna seeks refuge where life begins rather than where it might be prolonged through her suffering.

    Quotes

    • 1. “I USED TO PRETEND that I was just passing through this family on my way to my real one… The thing is, the first person I’d have called to crow over my new fortune would be Kate.”

      This opening quote establishes Anna’s complex feelings of alienation within her family and her deep, conflicted bond with her sister Kate. It introduces the central tension between Anna’s desire for independence and her love for Kate.

      2. “When she is tied to the bed, I am her eyes and her ears.”

      This poignant statement captures Anna’s role as Kate’s companion and proxy during medical treatments. It illustrates both the intimacy of their relationship and the burden Anna carries in being Kate’s connection to the world.

      3. “Kidney donation is considered relatively safe surgery… Then again, when you get a wart removed or a cavity drilled, the only person who benefits in the long run is yourself.”

      This passage reveals Anna’s internal conflict about organ donation, contrasting medical risks with moral obligation. It highlights the novel’s central ethical dilemma through Anna’s practical yet conflicted perspective.

      4. “PETITION FOR MEDICAL EMANCIPATION… That she not be required to undergo any more treatment for the benefit of her sister, Kate.”

      This pivotal moment represents the chapter’s climax and the novel’s central conflict. The legal document’s stark language makes concrete Anna’s rebellion against being used as a medical resource for Kate.

      5. “My sister’s in pain, and I’m relieved. What does that say about me?”

      This raw confession reveals Anna’s profound guilt and emotional complexity. It captures the moral ambiguity at the heart of the story - how love and resentment can coexist in impossible situations.

    Quotes

    1. “I USED TO PRETEND that I was just passing through this family on my way to my real one… The thing is, the first person I’d have called to crow over my new fortune would be Kate.”

    This opening quote establishes Anna’s complex feelings of alienation within her family and her deep, conflicted bond with her sister Kate. It introduces the central tension between Anna’s desire for independence and her love for Kate.

    2. “When she is tied to the bed, I am her eyes and her ears.”

    This poignant statement captures Anna’s role as Kate’s companion and proxy during medical treatments. It illustrates both the intimacy of their relationship and the burden Anna carries in being Kate’s connection to the world.

    3. “Kidney donation is considered relatively safe surgery… Then again, when you get a wart removed or a cavity drilled, the only person who benefits in the long run is yourself.”

    This passage reveals Anna’s internal conflict about organ donation, contrasting medical risks with moral obligation. It highlights the novel’s central ethical dilemma through Anna’s practical yet conflicted perspective.

    4. “PETITION FOR MEDICAL EMANCIPATION… That she not be required to undergo any more treatment for the benefit of her sister, Kate.”

    This pivotal moment represents the chapter’s climax and the novel’s central conflict. The legal document’s stark language makes concrete Anna’s rebellion against being used as a medical resource for Kate.

    5. “My sister’s in pain, and I’m relieved. What does that say about me?”

    This raw confession reveals Anna’s profound guilt and emotional complexity. It captures the moral ambiguity at the heart of the story - how love and resentment can coexist in impossible situations.

    FAQs

    1. What is Anna’s initial fantasy about her family situation, and what does this reveal about her feelings of belonging?

    Answer:
    Anna pretends she is “just passing through” her current family on her way to her “real” one, imagining her true parents might be nearby, ready to whisk her away to a life of luxury. This fantasy reveals her deep-seated feelings of being an outsider in her own family, as she notes her siblings resemble their parents while she feels like a “collection of recessive genes.” Despite this, her immediate thought of calling Kate to share her imagined good fortune shows her complex bond with her sister—simultaneously feeling disconnected from her family yet deeply attached to Kate.

    2. How does the chapter illustrate the physical and emotional dynamics of Kate’s medical condition and its impact on Anna?

    Answer:
    Kate’s dialysis sessions are described as lengthy and boring, requiring Anna to act as her “eyes and ears” during treatments. The chapter highlights the sisters’ close relationship through their games and shared moments, but also foreshadows tension with the discussion of kidney transplants. Anna’s internal monologue about the risks of kidney donation (anesthesia complications, recovery time, long-term health effects) contrasts sharply with her mother’s casual tone about the procedure, emphasizing Anna’s unspoken anxiety about being pressured into medical sacrifice for Kate’s benefit.

    Answer:
    The “Petition for Medical Emancipation” serves as the chapter’s climax, revealing Anna’s covert legal action to gain control over her medical decisions and refuse further treatment for Kate. The shock of this moment is heightened by Vern’s discomfort and the family’s confusion. Anna’s visceral reaction (“all the blood leaves my body”) and Kate’s sudden pain create a dramatic tension, forcing their mother to choose between attending to Kate’s immediate crisis and confronting Anna. This scene crystallizes the ethical dilemma: Anna’s desire for bodily autonomy versus her family’s expectation of self-sacrifice.

    4. How does the author use contrasting imagery to underscore Anna’s emotional state during the confrontation with her mother?

    Answer:
    The chapter employs stark contrasts to mirror Anna’s turmoil. The sterile hospital setting clashes with the violent metaphor of Anna feeling “like a fist in my gut.” Her mother is described as a fragile “soap bubble” torn between her daughters, while Anna’s relief at Kate’s pain—a morally ambiguous reaction—highlights her desperation. The final image of her mother frantically pressing the nurse’s call button “as if it’s the trigger to a bomb” parallels Anna’s own sense that her legal action has detonated the family’s fragile equilibrium.

    5. Why might Anna flee to the maternity ward, and what symbolic meaning does this location hold in the context of her conflict?

    Answer:
    Anna’s choice to hide in the maternity ward is deeply ironic: it represents new life and familial bonds, while she is actively severing her role as Kate’s medical lifeline. The overheard phone call about a “perfect” newborn contrasts with Anna’s fraught relationship with her own body and its commodification for Kate’s survival. This setting underscores her desire to reclaim autonomy over her physical self, much like the newborns who belong wholly to themselves. It also hints at future themes of creation versus sacrifice, as Anna seeks refuge where life begins rather than where it might be prolonged through her suffering.

    Note