Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of Never Let Me Go
    DystopianFictionLiterary FictionPhilosophicalScience Fiction

    Never Let Me Go

    by Ishiguro, Kazuo
    Kazuo Ishiguro’s “Never Let Me Go” is a poignant dystopian novel exploring themes of identity, mortality, and the ethics of human cloning. The story follows Kathy H., a caregiver reflecting on her childhood at Hailsham, an isolated English boarding school where students are raised to become organ donors. As Kathy reconnects with her friends Ruth and Tommy, they confront their predetermined fate and the fleeting nature of their existence. Ishiguro’s restrained prose and subtle world-building underscore the novel’s meditation on love, loss, and what it means to be human. A haunting and thought-provoking work, it challenges readers to consider the moral implications of scientific advancement.
    PreviousNext
    Never Let Me Go

    Chapter 9: Nine

    by Ishiguro, Kazuo

    The chap­ter begins with Kathy reflect­ing on a con­ver­sa­tion in the Art Room, where Cyn­thia E. casu­al­ly men­tions that Kathy is the “nat­ur­al suc­ces­sor” to Ruth in Tom­my’s life. This remark unset­tles Kathy, as it sug­gests an out­side per­spec­tive on her rela­tion­ship with Tom­my, com­pli­cat­ing her feel­ings. Around the same time, Han­nah points out Tom­my sit­ting alone, fur­ther fuel­ing Kathy’s con­fu­sion about the assump­tions cir­cu­lat­ing among their peers. These inter­ac­tions dis­rupt Kathy’s pre­vi­ous plans to pur­sue a phys­i­cal rela­tion­ship with Har­ry, as she becomes pre­oc­cu­pied with the idea of being Tom­my’s next part­ner.

    Kathy’s ini­tial resolve to be with Har­ry wavers as the “nat­ur­al suc­ces­sor” notion takes hold. She recalls her care­ful prepa­ra­tions to approach Har­ry but now finds her­self avoid­ing him, mak­ing excus­es when­ev­er they meet. Lat­er, she reflects on this peri­od with regret, real­iz­ing Har­ry might not have even been inter­est­ed, and her behav­ior could have seemed absurd. The chap­ter then shifts to a poignant encounter years lat­er, where Kathy briefly meets Har­ry at a recov­ery cen­ter after a dona­tion. The inter­ac­tion is bit­ter­sweet, as Har­ry doesn’t rec­og­nize her, leav­ing Kathy with a sense of grat­i­tude for his past decen­cy.

    The nar­ra­tive returns to Kathy’s youth, describ­ing the sum­mer trend of shar­ing Walk­mans among friends in the fields. These moments of com­mu­nal music lis­ten­ing cre­ate a sense of cama­raderie, con­trast­ing with the under­ly­ing ten­sion in Kathy’s per­son­al life. Dur­ing one such ses­sion, Ruth approach­es Kathy with a request: she wants to reunite with Tom­my and asks Kathy to medi­ate. Ruth admits she trusts only Kathy to com­mu­ni­cate her sin­cere inten­tions to Tom­my, empha­siz­ing their shared his­to­ry and Kathy’s unique influ­ence over him.

    Kathy agrees to help, though she is sur­prised by Ruth’s sud­den change of heart. The chap­ter ends with Ruth out­lin­ing her desire for a fresh start with Tom­my, acknowl­edg­ing their past mis­takes. Kathy, though con­flict­ed, reas­sures Ruth of her sup­port, set­ting the stage for the emo­tion­al com­plex­i­ties to come. The chap­ter cap­tures the del­i­cate dynam­ics of friend­ship, loy­al­ty, and unspo­ken desires among the char­ac­ters at Hail­sham.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Kathy’s perception of herself as Tommy’s “natural successor” influence her actions with Harry?

      Answer:
      The idea of being Tommy’s “natural successor” creates significant internal conflict for Kathy, disrupting her plans with Harry. Initially, she had carefully prepared to have sex with Harry, believing he would be a considerate and suitable partner. However, after Cynthia E. and Hannah indirectly suggest that Kathy is the obvious next partner for Tommy, Kathy becomes confused and begins avoiding intimacy with Harry. She starts making excuses and whispering reasons to delay their encounter, which she later realizes might have seemed absurd from Harry’s perspective. This shift highlights how external perceptions can deeply influence personal decisions, even when they contradict one’s original intentions.

      2. What role does gossip and outsider perspectives play in shaping Kathy’s understanding of her relationships?

      Answer:
      Gossip and outsider perspectives significantly impact Kathy’s self-perception and decisions. Cynthia E.’s offhand remark about Kathy being Tommy’s “natural successor” carries weight because Cynthia is perceptive and detached from their social circle. Similarly, Hannah’s pointed observation about Tommy sitting alone reinforces the idea that others see Kathy as logically next in line for Tommy. These external viewpoints create doubt in Kathy’s mind, making her question her plans with Harry and reconsider her feelings for Tommy. The chapter illustrates how social narratives can intrude on personal agency, even when they aren’t explicitly confrontational.

      3. Analyze the significance of the Walkman-sharing ritual at Hailsham. What does it reveal about the students’ social dynamics?

      Answer:
      The Walkman-sharing ritual symbolizes the students’ desire for connection and shared experiences despite their limited resources. By passing a single headset among a group, they create a collective way to enjoy music, fostering camaraderie and inclusion. The practice also reflects their adaptability and creativity in finding joy within constraints. The guardians’ mild disapproval (citing ear infections) contrasts with the students’ enthusiasm, emphasizing a subtle tension between institutional rules and student culture. This ritual becomes a cherished memory for Kathy, highlighting how small, communal moments can define an era in their lives.

      4. How does Ruth’s request for Kathy’s help in reuniting with Tommy reflect their friendship and Ruth’s character?

      Answer:
      Ruth’s request demonstrates both her vulnerability and her strategic awareness of social dynamics. By confiding exclusively in Kathy—her most trusted friend—she acknowledges Kathy’s unique ability to communicate with Tommy. Ruth’s phrasing (“You’ve always had this way with him”) suggests she recognizes Kathy’s historical closeness to Tommy, even as she seeks to reclaim him for herself. Her admission that they’ve both acted foolishly (“We’re about evens now”) shows a rare moment of self-reflection. However, her focus on “scoring” points (like mocking Tommy’s fling with Martha H.) also reveals her competitive streak, underscoring the complexity of their relationships.

      5. Contrast Kathy’s encounter with Harry at the recovery center with her earlier memories of him. What does this reveal about her emotional growth?

      Answer:
      Kathy’s later encounter with Harry reveals her matured perspective and regret. In their youth, she saw Harry as a pragmatic choice for her first sexual experience, but her plans were derailed by social pressures. Years later, meeting him in a weakened post-donation state, she feels gratitude for his past decency and wishes she could care for him. This moment highlights her empathy and nostalgia, contrasting with her earlier self-absorption. Her realization that Harry might not even remember her underscores the fleeting nature of their adolescent interactions and her own growth beyond Hailsham’s social games.

    Quotes

    • 1. “‘And Tommy. I knew it wouldn’t last with Ruth. Well, I suppose you’re the natural successor.’”

      This throwaway remark by Cynthia E. sparks Kathy’s internal conflict about her relationship with Tommy. It represents the social pressures and unspoken expectations at Hailsham, where relationships are closely observed and analyzed by peers.

      2. “I just let it go, though, and Cynthia, who wasn’t trying to make any big point, said nothing else about it.”

      This shows Kathy’s tendency to internalize social observations while maintaining outward composure. It highlights the subtle yet powerful ways gossip and perception influence the students’ lives at Hailsham.

      3. “I think he would have been considerate and gentle, and have understood what I was wanting from him.”

      Kathy’s reflection on Harry reveals her thoughtful approach to relationships and sexuality. This quote demonstrates the students’ careful navigation of intimacy in their controlled environment.

      4. “The craze was for several people to sit on the grass around a single Walkman, passing the headset around… it created a really good feeling.”

      This description of shared music listening captures a rare moment of communal joy and connection among the students. It serves as a poignant contrast to the darker realities of their existence.

      5. “‘I want me and Tommy to get back together again. Kathy, will you help?’”

      Ruth’s request marks a turning point in the chapter and the relationships between the three main characters. It sets in motion the complex emotional dynamics that will continue to unfold.

    Quotes

    1. “‘And Tommy. I knew it wouldn’t last with Ruth. Well, I suppose you’re the natural successor.’”

    This throwaway remark by Cynthia E. sparks Kathy’s internal conflict about her relationship with Tommy. It represents the social pressures and unspoken expectations at Hailsham, where relationships are closely observed and analyzed by peers.

    2. “I just let it go, though, and Cynthia, who wasn’t trying to make any big point, said nothing else about it.”

    This shows Kathy’s tendency to internalize social observations while maintaining outward composure. It highlights the subtle yet powerful ways gossip and perception influence the students’ lives at Hailsham.

    3. “I think he would have been considerate and gentle, and have understood what I was wanting from him.”

    Kathy’s reflection on Harry reveals her thoughtful approach to relationships and sexuality. This quote demonstrates the students’ careful navigation of intimacy in their controlled environment.

    4. “The craze was for several people to sit on the grass around a single Walkman, passing the headset around… it created a really good feeling.”

    This description of shared music listening captures a rare moment of communal joy and connection among the students. It serves as a poignant contrast to the darker realities of their existence.

    5. “‘I want me and Tommy to get back together again. Kathy, will you help?’”

    Ruth’s request marks a turning point in the chapter and the relationships between the three main characters. It sets in motion the complex emotional dynamics that will continue to unfold.

    FAQs

    1. How does Kathy’s perception of herself as Tommy’s “natural successor” influence her actions with Harry?

    Answer:
    The idea of being Tommy’s “natural successor” creates significant internal conflict for Kathy, disrupting her plans with Harry. Initially, she had carefully prepared to have sex with Harry, believing he would be a considerate and suitable partner. However, after Cynthia E. and Hannah indirectly suggest that Kathy is the obvious next partner for Tommy, Kathy becomes confused and begins avoiding intimacy with Harry. She starts making excuses and whispering reasons to delay their encounter, which she later realizes might have seemed absurd from Harry’s perspective. This shift highlights how external perceptions can deeply influence personal decisions, even when they contradict one’s original intentions.

    2. What role does gossip and outsider perspectives play in shaping Kathy’s understanding of her relationships?

    Answer:
    Gossip and outsider perspectives significantly impact Kathy’s self-perception and decisions. Cynthia E.’s offhand remark about Kathy being Tommy’s “natural successor” carries weight because Cynthia is perceptive and detached from their social circle. Similarly, Hannah’s pointed observation about Tommy sitting alone reinforces the idea that others see Kathy as logically next in line for Tommy. These external viewpoints create doubt in Kathy’s mind, making her question her plans with Harry and reconsider her feelings for Tommy. The chapter illustrates how social narratives can intrude on personal agency, even when they aren’t explicitly confrontational.

    3. Analyze the significance of the Walkman-sharing ritual at Hailsham. What does it reveal about the students’ social dynamics?

    Answer:
    The Walkman-sharing ritual symbolizes the students’ desire for connection and shared experiences despite their limited resources. By passing a single headset among a group, they create a collective way to enjoy music, fostering camaraderie and inclusion. The practice also reflects their adaptability and creativity in finding joy within constraints. The guardians’ mild disapproval (citing ear infections) contrasts with the students’ enthusiasm, emphasizing a subtle tension between institutional rules and student culture. This ritual becomes a cherished memory for Kathy, highlighting how small, communal moments can define an era in their lives.

    4. How does Ruth’s request for Kathy’s help in reuniting with Tommy reflect their friendship and Ruth’s character?

    Answer:
    Ruth’s request demonstrates both her vulnerability and her strategic awareness of social dynamics. By confiding exclusively in Kathy—her most trusted friend—she acknowledges Kathy’s unique ability to communicate with Tommy. Ruth’s phrasing (“You’ve always had this way with him”) suggests she recognizes Kathy’s historical closeness to Tommy, even as she seeks to reclaim him for herself. Her admission that they’ve both acted foolishly (“We’re about evens now”) shows a rare moment of self-reflection. However, her focus on “scoring” points (like mocking Tommy’s fling with Martha H.) also reveals her competitive streak, underscoring the complexity of their relationships.

    5. Contrast Kathy’s encounter with Harry at the recovery center with her earlier memories of him. What does this reveal about her emotional growth?

    Answer:
    Kathy’s later encounter with Harry reveals her matured perspective and regret. In their youth, she saw Harry as a pragmatic choice for her first sexual experience, but her plans were derailed by social pressures. Years later, meeting him in a weakened post-donation state, she feels gratitude for his past decency and wishes she could care for him. This moment highlights her empathy and nostalgia, contrasting with her earlier self-absorption. Her realization that Harry might not even remember her underscores the fleeting nature of their adolescent interactions and her own growth beyond Hailsham’s social games.

    Note