
The Giver of Stars
Chapter 28: Twenty-eight
by Moyes, JojoThe chapter opens with the wedding of Margery and Sven, a joyous occasion held in a small Episcopalian church in Salt Lick. Despite Margery’s initial reluctance to make a public spectacle, Sven insists on a celebration with their friends, the library patrons, and their daughter, Virginia. The reception at Fred’s house is filled with music, dancing, and community warmth, though Margery struggles to reconcile her happiness, confiding in Alice that such joy feels unfamiliar. The event marks a turning point for Margery, who, despite her discomfort in formal attire, embraces the love and support surrounding her.
Following the wedding, Margery and Sven settle into their new life, building a cabin near her original home and adopting a dog. Verna McCullough, who cares for Virginia, begins to reintegrate into the community, while her sister Neeta remains more reclusive. The sisters move into a new cabin, leaving behind their dilapidated family home, which slowly succumbs to nature. This symbolic decay reflects their liberation from their troubled past, as they find stability and purpose in their roles within the growing library community.
Alice and Fred’s marriage follows shortly after Margery’s, marked by quiet happiness and mutual devotion. Alice thrives in her work at the library, her joy evident despite criticism from some townsfolk about her unconventional appearance. Fred adores her unconditionally, and their life together becomes a source of local amusement due to their unabashed affection. Meanwhile, Bennett Van Cleve remarries without fuss, and Alice’s annulment is handled discreetly, allowing her to move forward without scandal.
The chapter concludes with Sophia and William’s departure for Louisville, where Sophia takes a job at the Colored Branch of the public library. Though her absence is deeply felt by the librarians, they take pride in her achievements, framing her letters and photos as reminders of their bond. Kathleen, meanwhile, remains unmarried, focused on her work and uninterested in courtship. The chapter underscores themes of love, community, and personal growth, as each character finds their own path to fulfillment.
FAQs
1. How does Margery’s attitude toward marriage reflect her character development throughout the chapter?
Answer:
Margery’s initial reluctance to marry (“under sufferance”) and her conditions (secrecy, no fuss) showcase her independent, unconventional nature. However, her eventual public wedding in the Episcopalian church—complete with community attendance and a borrowed dress—demonstrates growth in embracing vulnerability and connection. Her admission of feeling “weird to be this happy” reveals a newfound acceptance of joy and emotional intimacy, contrasting with her typically self-reliant demeanor. This arc illustrates how love and community have softened her defenses while still maintaining her core identity (evidenced by her discomfort in formal attire).2. Analyze the symbolic significance of the collapsing Arnott’s Ridge cabin in relation to the McCullough sisters’ storyline.
Answer:
The gradual decay of the McCulloughs’ former home mirrors their liberation from their abusive past. As the cabin is “reclaimed by nature,” the imagery of “shoots and brambles clawing it back to the earth” parallels their emotional healing and the erasure of their father’s toxic legacy. Verna’s weekly town visits and the sisters’ new life in a purpose-built cabin symbolize rebirth, contrasting with the old home’s physical collapse. The detail that they only retrieved a few items (“a jute bag of clothing, two pans”) underscores their deliberate rejection of the past.3. Compare and contrast the marriages of Margery/Sven and Alice/Fred in terms of societal expectations and personal fulfillment.
Answer:
Margery and Sven’s wedding blends compromise (Sven insists on a public ceremony) with subversion (Margery’s breeches, their premarital child). Their celebration, including a hog roast and fiddling, reflects Appalachian communal values. In contrast, Alice and Fred’s union follows more conventional timing (post-annulment) but defies norms through their premarital cohabitation, which the town tacitly accepts. Both couples find deep happiness: Margery through reluctant vulnerability, Alice through unabashed joy (“ridiculously happy”). Their parallel narratives show diverse paths to fulfillment within the same community.4. What role does secondary character Sophia play in the chapter’s exploration of racial and social barriers?
Answer:
Sophia’s move to Louisville highlights systemic limitations: William’s scarce job prospects and flood-damaged housing push them toward an urban Black community (“Professional people”). Her promotion at the Louisville Free Public Library (Colored Branch) underscores talent constrained by segregation, yet her framed photo in Baileyville’s library signifies enduring bonds across racial lines. The disorganized shelves after her departure humorously yet pointedly emphasize her irreplaceable role, suggesting that true integration’s loss diminishes the community.5. How does the chapter use domestic spaces—homes, the library, and the church—to illustrate themes of transformation?
Answer:
Domestic spaces anchor the characters’ evolution: Margery’s library steps (where she processes happiness) and the new cabin (built with a working WC) represent progress. Fred’s house becomes a site of joyous rebellion against Puritanical norms through Alice’s laughter. The church, though traditional, hosts Margery’s unconventional wedding, repurposing institutions for personal growth. Even the decaying Arnott’s Ridge cabin serves as a counterpoint, its ruin symbolizing the characters’ shedding of oppressive histories. These spaces collectively map emotional and social change.
Quotes
1. “From the body of the loved one’s simple, sweetly colored flesh, which our animal instincts urge us to desire, there springs not only the wonder of a new bodily life, but also the enlargement of the horizon of human sympathy and the glow of spiritual understanding which one could never have attained alone.”
This opening epigraph by Dr. Marie Stopes sets the thematic tone for the chapter, connecting physical love with emotional and spiritual growth. It foreshadows the transformative relationships explored in the chapter, particularly Margery and Sven’s marriage.
2. “Feels kind of weird to be this happy,” she said, and it was the most unsettled Alice had ever seen her.”
Margery’s vulnerable admission to Alice during her wedding reception reveals her character growth - the fiercely independent woman unaccustomed to joy finally allowing herself happiness. This moment marks a pivotal emotional turning point in her personal journey.
3. “The rest of it stunk of our daddy,” Verna said, and never spoke of it again.”
Verna’s blunt explanation for abandoning her childhood home powerfully conveys the lasting trauma of abuse and the sisters’ quiet reclamation of their lives. This brief statement carries significant weight about generational healing and new beginnings.
4. “He was married to the most beautiful woman in the world, and every night after they had each finished work, and put away the dishes side by side, he made sure to pay homage.”
Fred’s devotion to Alice illustrates the chapter’s theme of love as redemption and mutual respect. Their domestic bliss contrasts sharply with Alice’s previous oppressive marriage, showing how love can transform lives.
5. “Though it had to be said, the shelves were never quite as well organized again.”
This humorous yet poignant observation about Sophia’s departure underscores how each librarian brought unique gifts to their community. It subtly celebrates diversity while acknowledging the irreplaceable nature of individual contributions.