Lord Foul’s Bane
Chapter 15: Fifteen: The Great Challenge
by Donaldson, Stephen R.The chapter opens with Thomas Covenant in a state of emotional and physical exhaustion, gazing out his window as Bannor arrives to escort him to a Lords’ meeting. Covenant, visibly drained, questions Bannor’s distrust, to which the Bloodguard responds with stoic indifference, emphasizing their self-sufficiency. Covenant’s sarcastic retort and weary demeanor highlight his internal struggle and alienation. The tension between them underscores Covenant’s isolation in the Land, even as he begrudgingly follows Bannor to the Close, where he reunites with Foamfollower, who expresses relief at Covenant’s presence despite their banter.
Upon entering the Close, Covenant finds a somber assembly of Lords, Bloodguard, and spectators. High Lord Prothall, appearing aged and weary, formally offers Covenant the High Lordship, citing his possession of white gold as justification. Covenant refuses, dismissing the idea as impractical, and Prothall reluctantly resumes leadership, accepting the burden of the Land’s fate. The Lords then discuss their next steps, with Osondrea proposing an escort for Foamfollower to return to his people, but the Giant insists on staying to aid their cause, demonstrating his loyalty and foresight.
The council shifts to strategic planning, with Warmark Garth reporting on the dissemination of warnings and preparations for war. Osondrea emphasizes the urgency of sending messengers to Seareach while analyzing the ominous signs Covenant encountered, such as the three-winged bird and the bloodied moon. Her conclusion—that Drool Rockworm has already found his bane—hints at escalating threats. The chapter captures the growing tension and the collective resolve of the Lords and their allies as they brace for impending conflict.
Throughout the chapter, Covenant’s internal conflict and reluctant role in the Land’s fate remain central. His interactions with Bannor and Foamfollower reveal his defensive cynicism, while the Lords’ deliberations highlight the gravity of their situation. The narrative builds toward a climax, with Prothall’s leadership tested and the group’s unity forged in the face of uncertainty. The chapter ends on a note of foreboding, setting the stage for the challenges ahead.
FAQs
1. How does Bannor’s attitude toward Thomas Covenant reflect the Bloodguard’s broader philosophy?
Answer:
Bannor’s interaction with Covenant reveals the Bloodguard’s stoic self-sufficiency and distrust of external power sources. When Covenant accuses Bannor of distrust, the Bloodguard responds, “We have no use for white gold,” framing it as a “knowledge-weapon” (p. 1). This reflects their core belief in innate capability—they “suffice” without relying on tools or magic. Their dedication to pure service (protecting the Lords through intrinsic strength rather than weapons) contrasts with Covenant’s reliance on the white gold ring, highlighting a thematic tension between external power and inner discipline.2. Analyze the significance of Prothall’s offer to surrender the High Lordship to Covenant. What does this reveal about leadership in the Land?
Answer:
Prothall’s offer demonstrates the Lords’ humility and their belief in Covenant’s potential role as a savior. By citing the custom of surrendering leadership when “the trial of these times is too great” (p. 2), Prothall acknowledges his perceived inadequacy against Lord Foul’s threat while testing Covenant’s willingness to engage with the Land’s plight. Covenant’s refusal (“It isn’t that easy”) underscores his internal conflict—he resists responsibility despite bearing the white gold. The scene also reveals the Lords’ collective leadership model, as Mhoram and Osondrea reaffirm Prothall’s position, valuing stability over individual doubt.3. How does Foamfollower’s decision to stay with the Lords instead of returning to Seareach reflect his character and the Giants’ values?
Answer:
Foamfollower prioritizes active solidarity over self-preservation, rejecting Osondrea’s proposed escort with the Bhrathair proverb about losing one’s head to hesitation (p. 3). His choice to “assist whatever course [the Lords] undertake” exemplifies Giantish loyalty and courage. The Giants’ wandering heritage (referenced in his speech) informs their adaptability and commitment to allies. His insistence on contributing despite his people’s peril also contrasts with Covenant’s reluctance, reinforcing the theme of communal responsibility versus isolation.4. What strategic preparations does Garth report, and how do they address the looming threat?
Answer:
Garth’s measures combine immediate action and long-term planning: lighting Furls Fire as a warning beacon, deploying scouts to monitor Grimmerdhore and Andelain, and preparing Revelstone for siege (p. 4). His system of relayed warnings ensures rapid dissemination of information, while the 1,300 warriors at work show proactive defense. The 20 ready Eoman (military units) balance readiness with resource allocation. These steps reflect the Lords’ pragmatic approach—prioritizing communication, reconnaissance, and fortification against an enemy whose exact movements remain unknown.5. Interpret Osondrea’s analysis of the omens (e.g., the three-winged bird). What might these signs foreshadow?
Answer:
Osondrea connects disparate phenomena—storms, the maimed bird, Wraiths’ attacks, and the bloodied moon—to Drool Rockworm’s awakening power (p. 4). The three-winged bird symbolizes unnatural corruption, while the moon’s bloodying suggests cosmic disruption. Her abrupt cutoff (“Drool has already found his bane-”) implies these signs herald a weapon or ally for the enemy (possibly the Illearth Stone). This analysis underscores the chapter’s tension: the Land’s destabilization mirrors Covenant’s inner turmoil, with both natural and political orders under threat.
Quotes
1. ““We are the Bloodguard. We have no use for white gold.” […] “It is a knowledge- a weapon. We have no use for weapons.” […] “We”- Bannor paused as if searching the language of the Land for a word to match his thought- “suffice.””
This exchange between Covenant and Bannor highlights the Bloodguard’s philosophy of self-reliance and their rejection of external power sources like Covenant’s white gold. It introduces a key cultural distinction in the Land’s factions.
2. ““Rock and root, the trial of these times is too great for me. Ur-Lord Thomas Covenant, you are permitted to claim the High Lordship if you wish.” […] “You know I don’t want it.” “Yet I ask you to accept it. You bear the white gold.” “Forget it. It isn’t that easy.””
This tense dialogue between Prothall and Covenant reveals the political pressure on Covenant as ringbearer, while showing his resistance to leadership roles. It’s a pivotal moment where Covenant’s unwillingness to fully engage with the Land’s struggles becomes clear.
3. ““I believe that the best service which I can do for my people is to assist whatever course you undertake. Please permit me to join you.” […] “Peril or plight, the Giants of Seareach strengthen us, and we cannot sing our gratitude enough.””
Foamfollower’s declaration of loyalty and Prothall’s response demonstrate the deep bonds between the Giants and Lords. This exchange showcases the theme of unity against impending threats, contrasting with Covenant’s isolation.
4. ““He who waits for the sword to fall upon his neck will surely lose his head.’ I believe that the best service which I can do for my people is to assist whatever course you undertake.””
Foamfollower’s quote from the Bhrathair encapsulates the chapter’s sense of urgency and the proactive stance needed against looming threats. It serves as both wisdom and call to action for the council.