Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    THE WEEKEND JULIA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter opens with Julia ques­tion­ing her attrac­tion to Camp­bell, a man she describes as an “ass­hole,” while her sis­ter Izzy is engrossed in a roman­tic movie. Their ban­ter reveals Juli­a’s inter­nal con­flict about her feel­ings for Camp­bell, as well as her pro­fes­sion­al dilem­ma regard­ing a high-stakes legal deci­sion involv­ing Anna Fitzger­ald. Izzy teas­es Julia about her poor taste in men, sug­gest­ing it might be hered­i­tary, while Julia admits she finds it easy to recon­nect with Camp­bell despite their com­pli­cat­ed his­to­ry. The sis­ters’ play­ful yet point­ed exchange high­lights Juli­a’s emo­tion­al tur­moil.

    Juli­a’s pro­fes­sion­al and per­son­al lives col­lide as she pre­pares for a crit­i­cal hear­ing that will deter­mine Anna’s future. She con­fess­es to Izzy that her attrac­tion to Camp­bell feels like lazi­ness, as they already know each oth­er so well. Izzy offers crude but prac­ti­cal advice, urg­ing Julia to either act on her feel­ings or move on. The con­ver­sa­tion shifts to Camp­bel­l’s super­fi­cial charm, with Izzy com­par­ing him to “marzi­pan frost­ing on a sar­dine.” Their dia­logue under­scores Juli­a’s strug­gle to rec­on­cile her log­i­cal objec­tions with her lin­ger­ing emo­tions for Camp­bell.

    The ten­sion esca­lates when Camp­bell unex­pect­ed­ly arrives at Juli­a’s home, using a plea bar­gain offer as lever­age to per­suade her to join him for din­ner. Their wit­ty back-and-forth reveals their deep famil­iar­i­ty, with Camp­bell accu­rate­ly pre­dict­ing Juli­a’s curios­i­ty will out­weigh her reluc­tance. Izzy, amused by their dynam­ic, eggs Julia on, fur­ther com­pli­cat­ing her resolve. Camp­bel­l’s con­fi­dent per­sis­tence and Juli­a’s reluc­tant com­pli­ance set the stage for a charged inter­ac­tion, blend­ing pro­fes­sion­al stakes with per­son­al his­to­ry.

    The chap­ter con­cludes with Julia and Camp­bell at a mari­na, where he coax­es her to relax by remov­ing her shoes and embrac­ing the moment. Julia remains guard­ed, but Camp­bel­l’s charm and the nos­tal­gic sum­mer set­ting begin to soft­en her resis­tance. Their exchange hints at unre­solved feel­ings, with Julia reluc­tant­ly admit­ting Camp­bell knows her too well. The scene cap­tures the push-and-pull of their rela­tion­ship, leav­ing Julia torn between her pro­fes­sion­al bound­aries and her unde­ni­able con­nec­tion to Camp­bell.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Julia’s internal conflict about Campbell Alexander reflect her professional and personal struggles?

      Answer:
      Julia’s conflicted feelings about Campbell reveal the tension between her professional responsibilities and personal history. As a guardian ad litem preparing for Anna Fitzgerald’s hearing, Julia must remain objective, yet she’s distracted by her unresolved attraction to Campbell, her ex-lover. She questions whether she likes him “because he’s an asshole or in spite of it,” highlighting her self-awareness about his flaws. This mirrors her professional dilemma—she knows any decision she makes will “ruin [Anna’s] life,” yet she must proceed. The chapter shows how past relationships can complicate present duties, blurring boundaries between work and personal life.

      2. Analyze the significance of movie references in the sisters’ dialogue. What do they reveal about their relationship?

      Answer:
      The references to The Way We Were and Izzy’s “Movies You Cannot Click Past” list (Pretty Woman, Ghost, Dirty Dancing) serve as a shorthand for the sisters’ bond. When Julia quotes the film’s iconic line (“See ya, Katie”), Izzy playfully throws a pillow—a moment of levity amid Julia’s stress. Later, Campbell mirrors this exchange, impressing Izzy and suggesting he understands Julia’s world. These pop-culture-laden interactions reveal their shared history and humor: Izzy uses movies to deflect Julia’s anxiety, while Julia teases her about stereotypes (“gay men’s stereotype”). The references underscore how their relationship balances sarcasm and support.

      3. How does Campbell’s manipulation of Julia during their marina encounter illustrate his character and their dynamic?

      Answer:
      Campbell’s tactics—luring Julia with the plea bargain, then insisting she remove her sneakers to “relax”—show his calculated charm. He exploits her curiosity and control tendencies (“Rule number one… we talk about the trial”), knowing she’ll prioritize Anna’s case over her discomfort. His comparison of her to a Victorian-era woman (“I’m not going to attack you because I see your ankle”) mixes teasing with persuasion, highlighting their combative yet intimate dynamic. Julia’s eventual compliance (“When he smiles at me, I’m lost”) reveals her vulnerability, contrasting her professional authority. This scene encapsulates their push-pull relationship: Campbell disarms Julia by appealing to both her duty and buried affection.

      4. What thematic role does Izzy play in this chapter, particularly in her advice about relationships?

      Answer:
      Izzy serves as both comic relief and a voice of hard-won wisdom. Her blunt suggestions (“Why don’t you just screw him and get it out of your system?”) contrast with insightful observations about love’s irrationality (“your body’s got the IQ of a fruit fly”). She calls out Julia’s pattern of attraction to “jerks,” framing it as hereditary humorously (“Maybe it’s hereditary”), yet underscores a deeper truth about emotional baggage. Her remark that Campbell is “marzipan frosting on a sardine” critiques superficial attraction, aligning with the chapter’s exploration of past vs. present desires. Izzy’s interplay with Julia—mocking yet supportive—mirrors the novel’s broader tension between cynicism and hope.

      5. How does the chapter use sensory details (e.g., grass, martinis) to contrast Julia’s emotional states?

      Answer:
      The marina scene’s sensory imagery—bare feet on grass, “honey-colored decks tanning in the late sun”—evokes fleeting summer nostalgia, temporarily easing Julia’s stress. Campbell’s “Carpe diem” prompt contrasts sharply with her earlier martini at the bar, which she drinks “straight bitter alcohol,” associating it with disappointment. The grass symbolizes natural, unguarded connection (mirroring her momentary surrender to Campbell), while the martini reflects her defensive solitude. These details map her shifting emotions: the cold, controlled professionalism of the courtroom vs. the warmth of personal history. The juxtaposition highlights Julia’s struggle to reconcile duty with desire.

    Quotes

    • 1. “DO YOU THINK I LIKE CAMPBELL because he’s an asshole,” I ask my sister, “or in spite of it?”

      This opening quote immediately establishes Julia’s conflicted feelings about Campbell Alexander, setting up the central tension of the chapter - her struggle between professional duty and personal attraction. The blunt self-awareness makes it particularly memorable.

      2. “The problem, you know, is that you never forget your first one. And even if your brain’s smart about it, your body’s got the IQ of a fruit fly.”

      Izzy’s observation captures the chapter’s exploration of lingering attraction and the disconnect between logic and desire. The vivid “fruit fly” metaphor makes this both insightful and humorous.

      3. “It’s just so easy with him, Iz. It’s like we’re picking up where we left off. I already know everything I need to about him and he already knows everything he needs to about me. Can you fall for someone because you’re lazy?”

      This quote reveals Julia’s vulnerability and the dangerous comfort of familiar relationships. The paradoxical question about lazy love encapsulates the chapter’s examination of why we return to complicated past relationships.

      4. “Summertime, I think, is a collective unconscious. We all remember the notes that made up the song of the ice cream man; we all know what it feels like to brand our thighs on a playground slide that’s heated up like a knife in a fire…”

      This poetic reflection represents a key turning point where Julia begins to let her guard down. The vivid sensory details create a shared nostalgia that contrasts with her earlier tension, showing Campbell’s effect on her.

      5. “When he smiles at me, I’m lost.”

      This simple, powerful closing line captures Julia’s ultimate surrender to her feelings despite her resistance. The brevity makes it impactful, serving as the emotional climax of the chapter’s will-they-won’t-they tension.

    Quotes

    1. “DO YOU THINK I LIKE CAMPBELL because he’s an asshole,” I ask my sister, “or in spite of it?”

    This opening quote immediately establishes Julia’s conflicted feelings about Campbell Alexander, setting up the central tension of the chapter - her struggle between professional duty and personal attraction. The blunt self-awareness makes it particularly memorable.

    2. “The problem, you know, is that you never forget your first one. And even if your brain’s smart about it, your body’s got the IQ of a fruit fly.”

    Izzy’s observation captures the chapter’s exploration of lingering attraction and the disconnect between logic and desire. The vivid “fruit fly” metaphor makes this both insightful and humorous.

    3. “It’s just so easy with him, Iz. It’s like we’re picking up where we left off. I already know everything I need to about him and he already knows everything he needs to about me. Can you fall for someone because you’re lazy?”

    This quote reveals Julia’s vulnerability and the dangerous comfort of familiar relationships. The paradoxical question about lazy love encapsulates the chapter’s examination of why we return to complicated past relationships.

    4. “Summertime, I think, is a collective unconscious. We all remember the notes that made up the song of the ice cream man; we all know what it feels like to brand our thighs on a playground slide that’s heated up like a knife in a fire…”

    This poetic reflection represents a key turning point where Julia begins to let her guard down. The vivid sensory details create a shared nostalgia that contrasts with her earlier tension, showing Campbell’s effect on her.

    5. “When he smiles at me, I’m lost.”

    This simple, powerful closing line captures Julia’s ultimate surrender to her feelings despite her resistance. The brevity makes it impactful, serving as the emotional climax of the chapter’s will-they-won’t-they tension.

    FAQs

    1. How does Julia’s internal conflict about Campbell Alexander reflect her professional and personal struggles?

    Answer:
    Julia’s conflicted feelings about Campbell reveal the tension between her professional responsibilities and personal history. As a guardian ad litem preparing for Anna Fitzgerald’s hearing, Julia must remain objective, yet she’s distracted by her unresolved attraction to Campbell, her ex-lover. She questions whether she likes him “because he’s an asshole or in spite of it,” highlighting her self-awareness about his flaws. This mirrors her professional dilemma—she knows any decision she makes will “ruin [Anna’s] life,” yet she must proceed. The chapter shows how past relationships can complicate present duties, blurring boundaries between work and personal life.

    2. Analyze the significance of movie references in the sisters’ dialogue. What do they reveal about their relationship?

    Answer:
    The references to The Way We Were and Izzy’s “Movies You Cannot Click Past” list (Pretty Woman, Ghost, Dirty Dancing) serve as a shorthand for the sisters’ bond. When Julia quotes the film’s iconic line (“See ya, Katie”), Izzy playfully throws a pillow—a moment of levity amid Julia’s stress. Later, Campbell mirrors this exchange, impressing Izzy and suggesting he understands Julia’s world. These pop-culture-laden interactions reveal their shared history and humor: Izzy uses movies to deflect Julia’s anxiety, while Julia teases her about stereotypes (“gay men’s stereotype”). The references underscore how their relationship balances sarcasm and support.

    3. How does Campbell’s manipulation of Julia during their marina encounter illustrate his character and their dynamic?

    Answer:
    Campbell’s tactics—luring Julia with the plea bargain, then insisting she remove her sneakers to “relax”—show his calculated charm. He exploits her curiosity and control tendencies (“Rule number one… we talk about the trial”), knowing she’ll prioritize Anna’s case over her discomfort. His comparison of her to a Victorian-era woman (“I’m not going to attack you because I see your ankle”) mixes teasing with persuasion, highlighting their combative yet intimate dynamic. Julia’s eventual compliance (“When he smiles at me, I’m lost”) reveals her vulnerability, contrasting her professional authority. This scene encapsulates their push-pull relationship: Campbell disarms Julia by appealing to both her duty and buried affection.

    4. What thematic role does Izzy play in this chapter, particularly in her advice about relationships?

    Answer:
    Izzy serves as both comic relief and a voice of hard-won wisdom. Her blunt suggestions (“Why don’t you just screw him and get it out of your system?”) contrast with insightful observations about love’s irrationality (“your body’s got the IQ of a fruit fly”). She calls out Julia’s pattern of attraction to “jerks,” framing it as hereditary humorously (“Maybe it’s hereditary”), yet underscores a deeper truth about emotional baggage. Her remark that Campbell is “marzipan frosting on a sardine” critiques superficial attraction, aligning with the chapter’s exploration of past vs. present desires. Izzy’s interplay with Julia—mocking yet supportive—mirrors the novel’s broader tension between cynicism and hope.

    5. How does the chapter use sensory details (e.g., grass, martinis) to contrast Julia’s emotional states?

    Answer:
    The marina scene’s sensory imagery—bare feet on grass, “honey-colored decks tanning in the late sun”—evokes fleeting summer nostalgia, temporarily easing Julia’s stress. Campbell’s “Carpe diem” prompt contrasts sharply with her earlier martini at the bar, which she drinks “straight bitter alcohol,” associating it with disappointment. The grass symbolizes natural, unguarded connection (mirroring her momentary surrender to Campbell), while the martini reflects her defensive solitude. These details map her shifting emotions: the cold, controlled professionalism of the courtroom vs. the warmth of personal history. The juxtaposition highlights Julia’s struggle to reconcile duty with desire.

    Note