Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    WEDNESDAY JULIA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter opens with Juli­a’s frus­tra­tion as her sis­ter Iso­bel reor­ga­nizes her apart­ment, high­light­ing their con­trast­ing personalities—Julia’s rebel­lious past ver­sus her cur­rent con­ven­tion­al life, and Iso­bel’s cre­ative, metic­u­lous nature. Their tense dynam­ic esca­lates when Julia cru­el­ly ref­er­ences Iso­bel’s recent breakup, caus­ing her sis­ter to retreat in tears. Despite their bick­er­ing, Juli­a’s pro­tec­tive instincts emerge as she com­forts Iso­bel, reveal­ing their deep, if com­pli­cat­ed, bond. The sis­ters rec­on­cile with humor, under­scor­ing their abil­i­ty to nav­i­gate con­flicts through shared his­to­ry and wit.

    Juli­a’s pro­fes­sion­al life inter­rupts the per­son­al dra­ma when Judge DeSal­vo calls, ask­ing her to serve as a guardian ad litem for a 13-year-old girl, Anna, seek­ing med­ical eman­ci­pa­tion. Though ini­tial­ly hes­i­tant, Julia agrees, hint­ing at unre­solved per­son­al stakes in the case. The urgency of the sit­u­a­tion con­trasts with the calm exte­ri­or of Anna’s well-kept home, where Julia meets the wary pre­teen. Anna’s cau­tious demeanor and cryp­tic men­tion of “Kate” pique Juli­a’s curios­i­ty, set­ting the stage for their fraught but piv­otal rela­tion­ship.

    At the zoo, Julia attempts to con­nect with Anna, who remains guard­ed despite Juli­a’s efforts to cre­ate a relaxed envi­ron­ment. Anna’s brief revelations—her past as a hock­ey goalie and her iso­la­tion from friends—hint at deep­er strug­gles. Juli­a’s obser­va­tion that Anna avoids let­ting her team down sub­tly mir­rors the girl’s broad­er sense of respon­si­bil­i­ty, pos­si­bly tied to her fam­i­ly sit­u­a­tion. The inter­ac­tion under­scores Juli­a’s chal­lenge in break­ing through Anna’s defens­es to under­stand her true moti­va­tions.

    The chap­ter clos­es with Julia reflect­ing on the zebras’ sym­bol­ic con­trast to life’s com­plex­i­ties, mir­ror­ing her own role as a medi­a­tor in Anna’s black-and-white legal bat­tle. Anna’s reluc­tance to engage con­trasts with Juli­a’s deter­mi­na­tion to advo­cate for her, fore­shad­ow­ing the emo­tion­al and eth­i­cal com­plex­i­ties ahead. The unre­solved ten­sion between Juli­a’s per­son­al doubts and pro­fes­sion­al duty leaves the read­er antic­i­pat­ing the next steps in their inter­twined jour­neys.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does the relationship dynamic between Julia and her sister Isobel evolve throughout the chapter, and what does this reveal about their personalities?

      Answer:
      The chapter reveals a complex sibling relationship where Julia, despite being the younger twin by three minutes, has historically played the protective role for Isobel. While Isobel appears organized and critical (evidenced by her cleaning Julia’s apartment and criticizing her expired food), Julia shows a more rebellious streak (referenced through her past behavior like shaving her head). Their dynamic shifts when Julia makes a hurtful comment about Isobel’s breakup, showing their emotional vulnerability. Ultimately, Julia comforts Isobel, demonstrating their deep bond despite surface tensions. This interplay reveals Julia as outwardly tough but deeply caring, while Isobel appears perfectionistic yet emotionally sensitive.

      2. What significant ethical dilemma does Julia face when accepting Judge DeSalvo’s case, and how does Anna’s initial reaction reinforce this conflict?

      Answer:
      Julia faces a professional conflict of interest when she learns the opposing attorney in Anna’s emancipation case is Anna’s own mother. This creates an ethical dilemma about whether Julia can objectively advocate for Anna against a parent with legal expertise. Anna’s initial wariness (comparing Julia to a potential kidnapper and carefully examining her credentials) mirrors Julia’s own doubts, showing they both recognize the case’s complexity. Their mutual caution suggests this legal situation requires extraordinary sensitivity, as it involves both professional boundaries and deep family tensions.

      3. Analyze how the zoo setting functions symbolically in Julia’s interactions with Anna. Why might this environment be less effective with Anna than with Julia’s previous cases?

      Answer:
      The zoo represents Julia’s usual strategy of creating relaxed environments where children open up naturally, symbolized by her appreciation of zebras’ black-and-white simplicity. However, this backfires with Anna because: 1) As a teenager, Anna is more guarded than younger children Julia typically works with; 2) Anna’s legal emancipation case requires direct conversation rather than indirect disclosure; and 3) The zoo’s playful atmosphere contrasts with the gravity of Anna’s situation. The naked mole rat hiding in its cave becomes an unintentional metaphor for Anna’s reluctance to engage, showing Julia’s misjudgment in selecting this setting.

      4. How does the chapter use contrasting imagery to establish Julia’s dual roles in her personal and professional life?

      Answer:
      The chapter contrasts Julia’s rebellious past (combat boots, shaved head) with her current conventional appearance required for her legal work, showing her professional persona. Similarly, her apartment’s personified appliances (“Sylvia the oven”) reveal a whimsical personal side that clashes with Isobel’s practicality. This duality extends to her role as both a caretaker (comforting Isobel) and a legal advocate (meeting Anna). The zebra imagery particularly encapsulates this tension - while Julia admires their black-and-white clarity, her own life and cases exist in moral gray areas, especially when handling Anna’s complex family situation.

      5. What foreshadowing exists in the chapter about potential challenges in Julia’s handling of Anna’s case?

      Answer:
      Several elements foreshadow challenges: 1) Julia’s immediate thought “God, I can’t do this” upon learning the attorney’s identity suggests unresolved personal issues; 2) The Fitzgerald house’s deceptively normal appearance contrasts with the expected “family in crisis,” hinting at hidden complexities; 3) Anna’s concern about Kate’s absence introduces an unknown variable in the family dynamic; 4) Julia’s admission that Anna “has already managed to surprise me” indicates she may underestimate the case’s difficulties. Most significantly, Julia’s closing thought - “What I don’t tell my sister is that I’m talking about me” - suggests she identifies too personally with Anna’s situation, potentially compromising her professional objectivity.

    Quotes

    • 1. “AFTER TWO HOURS OF LIVING with my sister again, I’m finding it hard to believe we ever comfortably shared a womb.”

      This opening line perfectly captures the complex sibling dynamic between Julia and Isobel, setting the tone for their strained yet deeply connected relationship. The visceral imagery contrasts their current tension with their biological bond.

      2. “I’m her nuclear bomb: when there’s something upsetting her, I go in and lay waste to it, whether that’s one of our six older brothers teasing her or the evil Janet, who decided she wasn’t gay after seven years into a committed relationship with Izzy.”

      This quote reveals Julia’s protective nature toward her sister despite their differences, showing how their roles have evolved from childhood to adulthood while maintaining the core dynamic of Julia as Isobel’s defender.

      This biting commentary on Julia’s profession demonstrates her cynical worldview while explaining the important role she plays in children’s lives. The sarcastic aside about lawyers reveals her character’s sharp wit.

      4. “They’d be one of the few things that would fit if we were lucky enough to live in a world that’s black or white.”

      Julia’s observation about zebras serves as a metaphor for her work and life, highlighting her frustration with moral complexities and her longing for clear-cut solutions - a theme that becomes central to her case with Anna.

      5. “The older you get, the less the coach forgives you if you miss a game. I don’t like letting a whole team down.”

      Anna’s response about hockey subtly reveals her central conflict - feeling responsible for others’ wellbeing at her own expense. This foreshadows the ethical dilemma at the heart of her legal case.

    Quotes

    1. “AFTER TWO HOURS OF LIVING with my sister again, I’m finding it hard to believe we ever comfortably shared a womb.”

    This opening line perfectly captures the complex sibling dynamic between Julia and Isobel, setting the tone for their strained yet deeply connected relationship. The visceral imagery contrasts their current tension with their biological bond.

    2. “I’m her nuclear bomb: when there’s something upsetting her, I go in and lay waste to it, whether that’s one of our six older brothers teasing her or the evil Janet, who decided she wasn’t gay after seven years into a committed relationship with Izzy.”

    This quote reveals Julia’s protective nature toward her sister despite their differences, showing how their roles have evolved from childhood to adulthood while maintaining the core dynamic of Julia as Isobel’s defender.

    This biting commentary on Julia’s profession demonstrates her cynical worldview while explaining the important role she plays in children’s lives. The sarcastic aside about lawyers reveals her character’s sharp wit.

    4. “They’d be one of the few things that would fit if we were lucky enough to live in a world that’s black or white.”

    Julia’s observation about zebras serves as a metaphor for her work and life, highlighting her frustration with moral complexities and her longing for clear-cut solutions - a theme that becomes central to her case with Anna.

    5. “The older you get, the less the coach forgives you if you miss a game. I don’t like letting a whole team down.”

    Anna’s response about hockey subtly reveals her central conflict - feeling responsible for others’ wellbeing at her own expense. This foreshadows the ethical dilemma at the heart of her legal case.

    FAQs

    1. How does the relationship dynamic between Julia and her sister Isobel evolve throughout the chapter, and what does this reveal about their personalities?

    Answer:
    The chapter reveals a complex sibling relationship where Julia, despite being the younger twin by three minutes, has historically played the protective role for Isobel. While Isobel appears organized and critical (evidenced by her cleaning Julia’s apartment and criticizing her expired food), Julia shows a more rebellious streak (referenced through her past behavior like shaving her head). Their dynamic shifts when Julia makes a hurtful comment about Isobel’s breakup, showing their emotional vulnerability. Ultimately, Julia comforts Isobel, demonstrating their deep bond despite surface tensions. This interplay reveals Julia as outwardly tough but deeply caring, while Isobel appears perfectionistic yet emotionally sensitive.

    2. What significant ethical dilemma does Julia face when accepting Judge DeSalvo’s case, and how does Anna’s initial reaction reinforce this conflict?

    Answer:
    Julia faces a professional conflict of interest when she learns the opposing attorney in Anna’s emancipation case is Anna’s own mother. This creates an ethical dilemma about whether Julia can objectively advocate for Anna against a parent with legal expertise. Anna’s initial wariness (comparing Julia to a potential kidnapper and carefully examining her credentials) mirrors Julia’s own doubts, showing they both recognize the case’s complexity. Their mutual caution suggests this legal situation requires extraordinary sensitivity, as it involves both professional boundaries and deep family tensions.

    3. Analyze how the zoo setting functions symbolically in Julia’s interactions with Anna. Why might this environment be less effective with Anna than with Julia’s previous cases?

    Answer:
    The zoo represents Julia’s usual strategy of creating relaxed environments where children open up naturally, symbolized by her appreciation of zebras’ black-and-white simplicity. However, this backfires with Anna because: 1) As a teenager, Anna is more guarded than younger children Julia typically works with; 2) Anna’s legal emancipation case requires direct conversation rather than indirect disclosure; and 3) The zoo’s playful atmosphere contrasts with the gravity of Anna’s situation. The naked mole rat hiding in its cave becomes an unintentional metaphor for Anna’s reluctance to engage, showing Julia’s misjudgment in selecting this setting.

    4. How does the chapter use contrasting imagery to establish Julia’s dual roles in her personal and professional life?

    Answer:
    The chapter contrasts Julia’s rebellious past (combat boots, shaved head) with her current conventional appearance required for her legal work, showing her professional persona. Similarly, her apartment’s personified appliances (“Sylvia the oven”) reveal a whimsical personal side that clashes with Isobel’s practicality. This duality extends to her role as both a caretaker (comforting Isobel) and a legal advocate (meeting Anna). The zebra imagery particularly encapsulates this tension - while Julia admires their black-and-white clarity, her own life and cases exist in moral gray areas, especially when handling Anna’s complex family situation.

    5. What foreshadowing exists in the chapter about potential challenges in Julia’s handling of Anna’s case?

    Answer:
    Several elements foreshadow challenges: 1) Julia’s immediate thought “God, I can’t do this” upon learning the attorney’s identity suggests unresolved personal issues; 2) The Fitzgerald house’s deceptively normal appearance contrasts with the expected “family in crisis,” hinting at hidden complexities; 3) Anna’s concern about Kate’s absence introduces an unknown variable in the family dynamic; 4) Julia’s admission that Anna “has already managed to surprise me” indicates she may underestimate the case’s difficulties. Most significantly, Julia’s closing thought - “What I don’t tell my sister is that I’m talking about me” - suggests she identifies too personally with Anna’s situation, potentially compromising her professional objectivity.

    Note