Search Jump: Comments
    Chapter Index
    Back to Story
    Cover of My Sister’s Keeper
    LiteraryLiterary FictionRelationshipYoung Adult

    My Sister’s Keeper

    by Picoult, Jodie
    “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodie Picoult follows 13-year-old Anna Fitzgerald, who was conceived as a genetic match to donate organs and blood to her older sister Kate, who suffers from leukemia. When Anna is asked to donate a kidney, she sues her parents for medical emancipation, challenging the ethical boundaries of family obligation and bodily autonomy. The novel explores themes of sacrifice, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of love through multiple perspectives. Picoult’s narrative delves into the emotional and legal turmoil faced by the Fitzgerald family, raising profound questions about medical ethics and personal choice. The story is inspired by the real-life case of Anissa and Marissa Ayala.
    PreviousNext
    My Sister’s Keeper

    TUESDAY ANNA

    by Picoult, Jodie

    The chap­ter intro­duces Anna, a teenag­er who often fan­ta­sizes about belong­ing to a dif­fer­ent fam­i­ly, feel­ing like an out­sider among her par­ents and sib­lings. She humor­ous­ly imag­ines her “real” par­ents whisk­ing her away to a lux­u­ri­ous life, yet admits the first per­son she’d share the news with is her sis­ter Kate. The nar­ra­tive quick­ly shifts to reveal Kate’s seri­ous health condition—she under­goes fre­quent dial­y­sis due to kid­ney fail­ure. Anna describes the mun­dane yet inti­mate moments dur­ing Kate’s treat­ments, where she acts as Kate’s eyes and ears, play­ing games or observ­ing their sur­round­ings to dis­tract her sis­ter from the monot­o­ny of the pro­ce­dure.

    The fam­i­ly dynam­ic becomes more com­plex as Anna’s moth­er dis­cuss­es kid­ney trans­plan­ta­tion, casu­al­ly men­tion­ing that Anna’s kid­ney could be a poten­tial match for Kate. Anna inter­nal­ly grap­ples with the risks and long-term con­se­quences of kid­ney dona­tion, con­trast­ing it with minor med­ical pro­ce­dures. Her con­flict­ed feel­ings high­light the moral and emo­tion­al weight of her poten­tial sac­ri­fice. The ten­sion esca­lates when Vern Stack­house, a fam­i­ly acquain­tance and sher­iff, arrives unex­pect­ed­ly to serve legal papers, dis­rupt­ing the already frag­ile atmos­phere in the hos­pi­tal room.

    The doc­u­ments reveal a shock­ing devel­op­ment: Anna is peti­tion­ing for med­ical eman­ci­pa­tion, seek­ing the right to make her own med­ical deci­sions and refus­ing fur­ther treat­ments for Kate’s ben­e­fit. The rev­e­la­tion stuns Anna’s moth­er, who is caught between her two daughters—one in phys­i­cal pain and the oth­er in emo­tion­al tur­moil. Anna’s guilt and relief are pal­pa­ble as she observes her moth­er’s dis­tress and Kate’s sud­den med­ical cri­sis, which momen­tar­i­ly diverts atten­tion from the legal bomb­shell.

    The chap­ter ends with Anna flee­ing the room, seek­ing refuge in an unlike­ly place—the mater­ni­ty ward—where she con­trasts the joy of new life with the chaos of her own fam­i­ly’s strug­gles. The jux­ta­po­si­tion under­scores her iso­la­tion and the weight of her deci­sion, leav­ing the read­er to pon­der the eth­i­cal and emo­tion­al com­plex­i­ties of her sit­u­a­tion. The abrupt end­ing hints at the unre­solved ten­sion and the dif­fi­cult choic­es Anna must face in the chap­ters to come.

    Down­load PDF Sum­ma­ry

    FAQs

    • 1. How does Anna’s perception of her family dynamic differ from reality, and what does this reveal about her emotional state?

      Answer:
      Anna humorously describes herself as “a collection of recessive genes” compared to her siblings who resemble their parents, revealing her feelings of being an outsider in her own family. She fantasizes about discovering her “real” parents who would whisk her away to a luxurious life, yet notes she’d immediately call her sister Kate to share the news. This contradiction shows Anna’s deep bond with Kate despite her familial alienation. The passage highlights Anna’s adolescent identity struggles and her complex emotional landscape—yearning for escape while being fundamentally connected to her sister.

      2. Analyze the symbolic significance of the kidney transplant pamphlet scene. How does it foreshadow conflict?

      Answer:
      The pamphlet discussion about kidney retention (“they don’t take out the old kidney”) becomes a metaphor for Anna’s unresolved emotional burdens. Kate’s macabre joke about a coroner finding “three kidneys” darkly hints at the physical and emotional toll of medical procedures, while the mother’s optimistic rebuttal reflects the family’s denial of transplant risks. This scene foreshadows the lawsuit revelation by contrasting the mother’s clinical detachment with Anna’s silent awareness of the pamphlet’s grim details—mirroring their later clash over Anna’s bodily autonomy. The kidney becomes a symbol of both connection and coercion.

      3. How does the author use Vern Stackhouse’s appearance to structurally heighten the chapter’s tension?

      Answer:
      Vern’s arrival shifts the chapter from medical routine to legal crisis through deliberate pacing. His awkward demeanor (“face like a soufflé”) and incomplete sentences create unease before the lawsuit’s reveal. As a family friend serving legal papers, he embodies the collision between personal relationships and institutional forces. The abrupt transition from kidney discussion to legal action mirrors Anna’s emotional whiplash. Vern’s hasty exit leaves the confrontation unresolved, forcing the reader to sit with the family’s shock—a technique that amplifies the scene’s dramatic weight and Anna’s subsequent flight.

      4. Evaluate Anna’s reaction to Kate’s medical emergency in the final scene. What does this reveal about their relationship?

      Answer:
      When Kate cries out in pain during the lawsuit confrontation, Anna admits feeling “relieved” that the focus shifts away from her—a brutally honest moment revealing their relationship’s complexity. This reaction underscores Anna’s resentment over always prioritizing Kate’s needs, yet her earlier fantasies confirm genuine love. The scene’s staging (Kate possibly watching Anna through her hair) suggests Kate may be manipulating the situation, hinting at their codependent dynamic. Anna’s flight to the maternity ward—a space symbolizing new beginnings—contrasts sharply with Kate’s dialysis, emphasizing her desire to escape the cycle of medical crisis.

      Answer:
      Technical terms like “Mahhukar catheter” and “medical emancipation” frame Anna’s body as a contested site. The detached description of dialysis (blood leaving/returning) mirrors Anna’s emotional extraction from family decisions. Legal phrases like “not in her best interests” ironically echo the ethical language used to justify her prior donations. By juxtaposing medical risks (1 in 3,000 chance of death) with legal demands, the text forces readers to weigh biological sacrifice against personal autonomy. The sterile jargon makes Anna’s visceral reactions (“cheeks on fire”) more poignant, highlighting how institutions reduce personal trauma to clinical or legal terms.

    Quotes

    • 1. “I USED TO PRETEND that I was just passing through this family on my way to my real one… The thing is, the first person I’d have called to crow over my new fortune would be Kate.”

      This opening quote establishes Anna’s complex feelings of alienation within her family and her deep bond with Kate, setting up the central tension between her desire for autonomy and her love for her sister.

      2. “When she is tied to the bed, I am her eyes and her ears.”

      This poignant statement captures Anna’s role as Kate’s companion and helper during medical treatments, illustrating both the intimacy and burden of their relationship.

      3. “Kidney donation is considered relatively safe surgery, but if you ask me, the writer must have been comparing it to something like a heart-lung transplant… Then again, when you get a wart removed or a cavity drilled, the only person who benefits in the long run is yourself.”

      This passage reveals Anna’s internal conflict about the kidney donation, contrasting the significant risks she faces with the selfless nature of helping Kate.

      4. “PETITION FOR MEDICAL EMANCIPATION… That she not be required to undergo any more treatment for the benefit of her sister, Kate.”

      This legal language marks the chapter’s dramatic turning point, as Anna’s secret lawsuit is revealed, challenging the family’s established dynamic of prioritizing Kate’s medical needs.

      5. “My sister’s in pain, and I’m relieved. What does that say about me?”

      This raw confession exposes Anna’s guilt and conflicting emotions, highlighting the moral complexity of her decision to seek independence from her family’s medical crisis.

    Quotes

    1. “I USED TO PRETEND that I was just passing through this family on my way to my real one… The thing is, the first person I’d have called to crow over my new fortune would be Kate.”

    This opening quote establishes Anna’s complex feelings of alienation within her family and her deep bond with Kate, setting up the central tension between her desire for autonomy and her love for her sister.

    2. “When she is tied to the bed, I am her eyes and her ears.”

    This poignant statement captures Anna’s role as Kate’s companion and helper during medical treatments, illustrating both the intimacy and burden of their relationship.

    3. “Kidney donation is considered relatively safe surgery, but if you ask me, the writer must have been comparing it to something like a heart-lung transplant… Then again, when you get a wart removed or a cavity drilled, the only person who benefits in the long run is yourself.”

    This passage reveals Anna’s internal conflict about the kidney donation, contrasting the significant risks she faces with the selfless nature of helping Kate.

    4. “PETITION FOR MEDICAL EMANCIPATION… That she not be required to undergo any more treatment for the benefit of her sister, Kate.”

    This legal language marks the chapter’s dramatic turning point, as Anna’s secret lawsuit is revealed, challenging the family’s established dynamic of prioritizing Kate’s medical needs.

    5. “My sister’s in pain, and I’m relieved. What does that say about me?”

    This raw confession exposes Anna’s guilt and conflicting emotions, highlighting the moral complexity of her decision to seek independence from her family’s medical crisis.

    FAQs

    1. How does Anna’s perception of her family dynamic differ from reality, and what does this reveal about her emotional state?

    Answer:
    Anna humorously describes herself as “a collection of recessive genes” compared to her siblings who resemble their parents, revealing her feelings of being an outsider in her own family. She fantasizes about discovering her “real” parents who would whisk her away to a luxurious life, yet notes she’d immediately call her sister Kate to share the news. This contradiction shows Anna’s deep bond with Kate despite her familial alienation. The passage highlights Anna’s adolescent identity struggles and her complex emotional landscape—yearning for escape while being fundamentally connected to her sister.

    2. Analyze the symbolic significance of the kidney transplant pamphlet scene. How does it foreshadow conflict?

    Answer:
    The pamphlet discussion about kidney retention (“they don’t take out the old kidney”) becomes a metaphor for Anna’s unresolved emotional burdens. Kate’s macabre joke about a coroner finding “three kidneys” darkly hints at the physical and emotional toll of medical procedures, while the mother’s optimistic rebuttal reflects the family’s denial of transplant risks. This scene foreshadows the lawsuit revelation by contrasting the mother’s clinical detachment with Anna’s silent awareness of the pamphlet’s grim details—mirroring their later clash over Anna’s bodily autonomy. The kidney becomes a symbol of both connection and coercion.

    3. How does the author use Vern Stackhouse’s appearance to structurally heighten the chapter’s tension?

    Answer:
    Vern’s arrival shifts the chapter from medical routine to legal crisis through deliberate pacing. His awkward demeanor (“face like a soufflé”) and incomplete sentences create unease before the lawsuit’s reveal. As a family friend serving legal papers, he embodies the collision between personal relationships and institutional forces. The abrupt transition from kidney discussion to legal action mirrors Anna’s emotional whiplash. Vern’s hasty exit leaves the confrontation unresolved, forcing the reader to sit with the family’s shock—a technique that amplifies the scene’s dramatic weight and Anna’s subsequent flight.

    4. Evaluate Anna’s reaction to Kate’s medical emergency in the final scene. What does this reveal about their relationship?

    Answer:
    When Kate cries out in pain during the lawsuit confrontation, Anna admits feeling “relieved” that the focus shifts away from her—a brutally honest moment revealing their relationship’s complexity. This reaction underscores Anna’s resentment over always prioritizing Kate’s needs, yet her earlier fantasies confirm genuine love. The scene’s staging (Kate possibly watching Anna through her hair) suggests Kate may be manipulating the situation, hinting at their codependent dynamic. Anna’s flight to the maternity ward—a space symbolizing new beginnings—contrasts sharply with Kate’s dialysis, emphasizing her desire to escape the cycle of medical crisis.

    Answer:
    Technical terms like “Mahhukar catheter” and “medical emancipation” frame Anna’s body as a contested site. The detached description of dialysis (blood leaving/returning) mirrors Anna’s emotional extraction from family decisions. Legal phrases like “not in her best interests” ironically echo the ethical language used to justify her prior donations. By juxtaposing medical risks (1 in 3,000 chance of death) with legal demands, the text forces readers to weigh biological sacrifice against personal autonomy. The sterile jargon makes Anna’s visceral reactions (“cheeks on fire”) more poignant, highlighting how institutions reduce personal trauma to clinical or legal terms.

    Note