LETTER–To W. M. Thackeray

In this letter to W. M. Thackeray, the author navigates the nuances of praising the works of a departed novelist, where the usual constraints of criticism—such as envy or the potential for flattery—are absent, making it easier to commend wholeheartedly. Thackeray is celebrated for his versatility and unmatched excellence in literature, noted for his unique blend of humor, pathos, and keen observation of life. Unlike contemporaries who approached writing with the methodical dedication of a desk job, Thackeray’s work is likened to the inspired moments of the Scholar Gipsy, transcending mere profession to reflect life’s full spectrum.

Critics who label Thackeray as cynical, focusing merely on society’s sordid aspects, fail to grasp the broader scope of his satire, which is an indictment not of his perspective but of life itself. Such viewpoints overlook his ability to create multifaceted characters, both flawed and virtuous, illustrating his profound understanding of human nature. Thackeray’s portrayal of women, often criticized for being either too idealized or too flawed, in truth, captures the genuine complexities and dualities of their character, challenging the notion that he couldn’t depict “good women” convincingly.

Moreover, Thackeray’s reflective interludes within his narratives prompt readers toward deeper contemplation on life and human conduct, much like the Greek Chorus, enriching the storytelling with philosophical musings that elevate his prose to the poetic. The author of the letter defends these digressions as one of Thackeray’s most endearing qualities, suggesting that his ability to intertwine narrative with reflection contributes significantly to the richness and depth of his work.

Thackeray’s lasting impact is encapsulated in the emotional resonance of his works, with scenes and characters that linger “forever echoing in the heart and present in the memory.” His legacy is that of a companion and comforter through the reader’s journey, offering both solace and celebration of the human condition. The letter thus serves not only as an homage to Thackeray’s literary achievements but also as a meditation on the enduring power of his storytelling, affirming his position as a titan of English literature without rival.