In Chapter 22, Phoebe drives the Mercedes to the Breakers alone, reflecting on the nature of happiness as she passes grand mansions and the preparations for a wedding that is about to be called off. She grapples with the concept of fulfillment, questioning what a person lacks when they seemingly have everything. As she approaches the altar, it becomes evident that she carries a difficult truth: Lila will not be showing up for her wedding to Gary.

When Phoebe speaks to Gary, she conveys the news gently, recognizing the stoicism in his response. Gary nods in resignation, embodying a sense of emotional defeat. Phoebe feels the weight of her words as she announces to the crowd that “Lila and Gary will not be getting married today,” rehearsing the act of speaking hard truths aloud. The guests murmur, some puzzled by the expense of their attendance for a non-event. Meanwhile, Lila is described as being at the hotel, preparing to leave for Canada, adding a mysterious layer to her absence.

Once the crowd disperses, Phoebe and Matt find each other. Their interaction signifies an emotional reckoning. Phoebe asserts her decision not to return to St. Louis, revealing her desire to leave Matt and embrace her own dreams. She wishes to live in a nineteenth-century mansion and write, expressing intention rather than resignation. As they navigate their feelings, Matt responds with concern and gentle humor about their academic lives, highlighting the bittersweet nature of their conversation.

Despite the gravity of the situation, there is a moment of levity when Phoebe opens a bottle of champagne, prompting a toast. They share a bittersweet joy in this impromptu celebration, finding comfort in the taste of good champagne and a shared connection amidst the change. As they toast to Matt’s emotional vulnerability, Phoebe recognizes a new sense of self and the small changes that make a big difference in life. She relishes the moment, a blend of sorrow, liberation, and the bittersweet taste of possibility.